Why was an innocent electrician shot and killed by police ‘in cold blood'?
On July 22, 20 years ago today, electrician Jean Charles de Menezes left his home in Tulse Hill to fix a broken alarm.
Stopping to pick up a copy of Metro, the Brazilian national descended the stairs of Stockwell Tube Station and boarded the next train.
Unbeknownst to him, three officers – named only as Hotel 1, 2 and 3 – sat themselves around him. Moments later, he was shot seven times in the head by police, leaving his body 'unrecognisable'.
His devastated mum Maria has been pushing for prosecutions ever since, saying her son was 'educated and civilised' and 'always respected law and order'.
The family gathered today at a vigil outside the station, saying it is a 'travesty' no police officer has ever been held accountable.
Patricia da Silva Armani, Mr de Menezes' cousin, said: 'He was a completely innocent man. And yet, he was shot in cold blood.
'Nothing can erase the pain of knowing that the life of a hard-working, kind, and honest young man was taken from us out of prejudice and incompetence.
'Jean's memory demands more than words – it demands truth, accountability, and real change. We will not forget. We will not be silent.'
But what happened in those fatal few moments on the Tube, and why have the officers have not faced any disciplinary measures?
They wrongly thought the Jean Charles was part of the previous day's failed second wave of bomb attacks three weeks after the 7/7 terror attacks.
An address in Scotia Road, Tulse Hill, was written on a gym membership card found inside one of the bags where an undetonated bomb was hidden.
Police carried out extensive surveillance in the area, where Jean Charles lived in one of those flats with his two cousins.
As he left to respond to the faulty alarm, officers believed Jean Charles looked like the CCTV images of one of the bombing suspects Osman Hussain.
Cressida Dick, who later became Metropolitan Police Commissioner, ordered Jean Charles be prevented from entering the London Underground.
22 July 2005 Jean Charles de Menezes shot dead by police at Stockwell Tube station 17 July 2006 CPS says no officers will be prosecuted, but Met Police will be tried for breaching health and safety laws 1 November 2007 Met Police found guilty of breaching health and safety laws and fined 22 October 2008 Inquest under way – coroner rules out unlawful killing verdict a month later 12 December 2008 Inquest jury returns open verdict 16 November 2009 Met Police settles damages claim with family 10 June 2015 De Menezes family take legal challenge to European Court of Human Rights 30 March 2016 Family lose challenge over decision not to charge any police officer over the shooting
Officers followed him onto a bus and thought he was acting suspicious once he arrived at Brixton Station and found it was closed due to the previous day's bombings.
Jean Charles boarded the bus again to Stockwell Station, went down to the platform and got on the train.
Firearms officers boarded the train, with varying accounts of whether or not they spoke to the electrician or not.
They had all sat around him, and when Jean Charles stood up, an officer codenamed Hotel 3 grabbed, pinned his arms against his torso and pushed him back into his seat.
It is unclear what happens next. Two officers fired a total of 11 shots between them.
Seven of them landed in Jean Charles's head and his body was left 'unreconisable'.
Police said they had been told to fire directly at suspected suicide bomber's heads – which the Muslim Council of Britain described as a 'shoot-to-kill policy'.
Later investigation found the event had the 'hallmarks of a special forces operation, rather than a police one'.
No officers were prosecuted, but the Metropolitan Police force was fined for breaching health and safety laws. More Trending
Jean Charles's family took the force to the European Court of Human Rights in 2016 over the decision to not charge any officers.
But the family lost the challenge, with the force saying the circumstances around his death 'came at a time of unprecedented terrorist threat to London'.
They have also been subject to numerous public inquiries, and two separate reports by the Independent Police Complaints Commission.
The Met said: 'No officer sets out on duty intent on ending a life. Our sole purpose is the complete opposite – the protection and preservation of life – and we have taken extensive action to address the causes of this tragedy.'
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: 'First-of-its-kind' Eurostar-style train to directly connect UK with Berlin and two more cities
MORE: Husband who stabbed estranged wife in street as she pushed their baby in pram jailed for 28 years
MORE: Fans slam 'atrocious' immersive Elvis Presley show with tickets up to £300
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
25 minutes ago
- BBC News
Jean Charles de Menezes Tube shooting prompts book by ex-officer
A former police officer has written a book he hopes will "put the record straight" over the death of Jean Charles de 27-year-old Brazilian electrician was killed by police outside Stockwell Tube station in south London on 22 July 2005, the day after failed bombing attempts on the city's transport networkFormer Essex Police officer Steve Reynolds had just started a new job at the Independent Police Complaints Commission when the incident took place."First of all, Jean Charles was 100% innocent," he said. "Secondly, notwithstanding that, the two officers who shot him really believed that he was a suicide bomber about to detonate the bomb at any moment."I think it's difficult to perhaps correlate those two extremes but I wanted to articulate that in the book."The Metropolitan Police was fined £175,000 with £385,000 costs over the incident, for breaching health and safety laws. But no officers were prosecuted for the April, the force reiterated its apology to the family, who said it was a "travesty" no officer was held accountable in the 20 years since his de Menezes' cousin, Patricia da Silva Armani, said: "He was a completely innocent man. And yet, he was shot in cold blood."She added that it was "unacceptable that agents of the state can act with impunity". The former officer has been a consultant on a number of documentaries about the incident as well as a drama released on Disney+ in April called Suspect: The Shooting of Jean Charles de book is titled: The Met on Trial."It became clear to me the actual investigation was not being covered in any of those documentaries," he explained."I was also very keen to just set the record straight about what had happened, because there are so many misconceptions about what happened which are still around today."People still think that he was carrying a rucksack, that he was wearing bulky clothing, that he failed to respond to a police challenge, that he ran away... these are some of the misconceptions I wanted to put right." He explained the surveillance team misidentified Mr de Menezes as a suspect after he left his block of flats close to where the suicide bomber actually caused a miscommunication with New Scotland Yard which led the control room to believe a positive identification had taken place, Mr Reynolds incident itself took place two weeks after the 7/7 terror attacks, when 52 people were killed in central Reynolds said: "There were certainly organisational failings but those two officers genuinely believed the person they were confronting was a suicide bomber."They believed once again that this was a suicide bomber, like 7/7, about to detonate his bomb and kill many, many people."You can only imagine how distraught they were... Those two officers are also having their own flashbacks because I'm sure there can't be many days where they don't think about what happened 20 years ago."Earlier this year, the Met Police said he was killed "at a time of unprecedented terrorist threat to London".A spokesperson said the force had been subject to numerous public inquiries, including two separate reports by the Independent Police Complaints Commission (now the Independent Office for Police Conduct)."No officer sets out on duty intent on ending a life. Our sole purpose is the complete opposite – the protection and preservation of life – and we have taken extensive action to address the causes of this tragedy," said the spokesperson. Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Metro
an hour ago
- Metro
'A bus driver killed my daughter but I blame myself because of one decision'
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Scattered around a kitchen in south east London are documents and research notes on the dangers of London buses. On the walls, pictures of 'beautiful' Ada Bicakci cover any spare space. The flat belongs to Nevgul and Bora Bicakci, the parents of nine-year-old Ada, a popular girl obsessed with gymnastics and Taylor Swift, who have dedicate their spare moments find out why their daughter died. Ada, who had just weeks before won the 'kindest gymnast award' at her club, was killed while cycling with her dad and younger brother August 3 last year in Bexleyheath. Bus driver, Martin Asolo-Ogugua, 23, had swerved into the kerb next to her while high on drugs. Her younger brother, who was also taken to hospital, and dad witnessed the whole accident. Ever since, the family's foundations 'have been broken', and their home left with a sense there is something missing. Ada's pictures, toys and artwork all remain, but there is no little girl. The grief in their home is palpable. As she holds onto her husband Bora, Ada's mum Nevgul tells Metro: 'Everyone was her best friend. Her school friends now complain that now she is gone, they are getting into fights more because Ada isn't there to tell them to make up. 'If she ever saw me crying, she would always come up and wipe away my tears. Now, I can't stop them from coming.' Bora tells Metro that the family had taken a route they don't usually take to try to save a bit of time. 'We needed to leave the house but we were all feeling tired that day. I decided we should take shortcut on a route which we rarely take,' he explains. 'I wish I had made another choice.' As the three were riding along, Bora recalls how he could see the bus on the other side of the road begin to drift. 'I then remember the bus's tyres hitting the kerb near us. Then Ada was in my lap,' he says. From that moment, Bora says his memories of what happened next are a little hazy due to the chaos, but he remembers a bypasser called Sam managing to calmly take Ada from her dad's arms and give the little girl first aid. 'I won't forget her,' he said. 'It is hard not be angry at Ada's death, but there were some people who showed how great humanity can be.' At the time of the accident, Ada's mum Nevgul was in a hotel in Surrey with her own mother, who had flown in from Turkey on a visit. Police officers came to the hotel to deliver the devastating news in the lobby her daughter was seriously ill, and probably would not make it. They promised to do their best to get them to King's College Hospital where Ada lay dying from a severe head injury. Nevgul recalls: 'The whole time in the car I was praying we would get their on time.' 'We consider ourselves lucky we got to spend two more days with her. 'I spoke with her, I slept with her, I hugged her. And I know she heard me. She knew I was there.' Ada died two days after the crash, and with her organs donated she went on to help six other people after her death. After the family were able to say a proper goodbye to Ada as she died, all their efforts went into organising her funeral. Around 250 people attended the service, which was a blend with Christian and Muslim traditions – and included some Taylor Swift songs, as they knew how much their daughter loved her. 'Her favourite song ever was Cruel Summer which was played out loud,' Negul explains. 'It was a hard day but it really was a lovely send off.' The criminal investigation into Ada's death went smoothly for the family, but as more details of the driver and previous incidents came to light, the more anger they began to feel. The driver was found to have traces of cannabis in his system at the scene and fell asleep at the wheel. He had been given previous warnings on careless driving. But the specialist police officers which supported the family were 'faultless', they say. Every day is a battle for the family. The couple's younger son asks when he is going to get a new sister, and spends his time playing with Ada's friends at school. Nevgul says: 'It's like he's looking to replace her. He misses his big sister so much.' Now, the family are doing all they can to make sure no other parent has to go through the heartbreak they have. In their search for answers, it was found Asolo-Ogugua was on probation after other Londoners complained about his dangerous driving. Yet he continued to attend his shifts without question, eventually leading to Ada's death. In June Asolo-Ogugua jailed for four years and disqualified from driving for seven years. 'TfL told us he must have 'slipped through their fingers', but this isn't good enough,' says Bora. 'Why was he allowed to drive as normal when he was on probation for dangerous driving? 'It shouldn't take the death of a child to get him off the roads.' Like train drivers, the couple are pushing for Transport for London to test drivers before every shift, and stricter sentencing for those found to have broken the rules. Nevgul adds: 'If necessary precautions had been taken, this never would have happened. 'I feel the sentence was very soft. It shouldn't have been only four years when he took a child's life away.' Bora said: 'We don't want anyone to suffer like we have. A bus knocks down one person ever month. 'TfL need to surrender to the facts.' More Trending Lorna Murphy, TfL's Director of Buses, told Metro: 'Our thoughts remain with the family of Ada Bicakci who was tragically killed in a bus collision last year. 'Following the incident, bus operator Arriva has completed a full investigation into what happened. 'We are now urgently reviewing their investigation to assure the root causes and appropriate corrective actions are being identified and implemented. 'We are committed to being open and transparent and the findings of Arriva's investigation will be shared with all operators so that all necessary changes are put in place.' Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: 'I used a fake profile to hunt my aunt's murderer' MORE: Full list of 10 Brewdog pubs closing 'later this week' MORE: Girl, 9, shot in head 'by motorbike hitman during botched gangland murder'
South Wales Argus
2 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Newport money-laundering family caught with £14k cash
Molly Cook, 23, had £9,800 in her bedroom while her drug-dealing brothers Harry Cook, 30, and Nico Cook, 32, were found with £2,500 and £1,700 respectively. The three siblings from Newport were sentenced at the city's crown court for a number of different offences. Harry Cook, who was jailed for five years and seven months last summer for drug trafficking, admitted possession with intent to supply cocaine, possession of criminal property and possession of cannabis. Nico Cook pleaded guilty to being concerned in the supply of cannabis, possession of criminal property and possession of cannabis. Their sister Molly Cook admitted possession of criminal property and possession of cannabis. Their offences date back more than two years to November 17, 2022. This drew heavy criticism from their barristers over the poor handling of the case by the police and CPS. The judge described the extraordinary delay as "beyond belief". Ruth Smith, prosecuting, said matters started to unravel for the trio when Harry Cook was found with 23 wraps of cocaine in a stolen BMW car on Stockton Road in Newport. He was wearing a £19,000 Rolex at the time. As he was being arrested, he shouted out to a passer-by to tell his brother he had been arrested. Nico Cook was picked up shortly after he was spotted in a Volkswagen car. High value designer gear, cash and a small amount of cannabis were found when police raided the family home on Cumberland Road. Harry Cook has three previous convictions for trafficking class A drugs while Nico Cook was jailed for 40 months in 2017 for possession with intent to supply cocaine. Sol Hartley representing Harry Cook said: 'There is no explanation as to why it has taken so long to bring these matters to court.' He added that his client is due to be released from his current jail sentence on September 2, 2026. Paul Hewitt for Nico Cook told the court the defendant suffers with mental health difficulties. William Bebb representing Molly Cook said she has no previous convictions and runs her own domestic cleaning business. Judge Celia Hughes said: 'The delay in the case is beyond belief.' She told Harry Cook: 'You flaunted your lifestyle.' Harry Cook was jailed for 45 months and Nico Cook sent to prison for 18 weeks. Molly Cook was fined £1,320. All three defendants will also have to pay a victim surcharge. The court ordered the forfeiture and destruction of the drugs.
