Are You Dancing? Showbands, Popular Music and Memory in Ireland: who, exactly, had the postcolonial attitude here?
Author
:
Rebecca S Miller
ISBN-13
:
978-0253072368
Publisher
:
Indianapolis University Press
Guideline Price
:
£27.99
In the course of this excellent account of the
showband
era in
Ireland
– roughly the mid-1950s to the mid-1970s – Rebecca Miller quotes
John Waters
to illustrate what was a common attitude among those alive at the time who disdained the entertainment on offer in the dancehalls.
Waters suggests that the 'imitative' approach of the showbands was the result of a postcolonial mentality, an inherited sense of 'inferiority, fatalism and self-hatred'. It was an attitude expressed more succinctly by
Bob Geldof
in the recent RTÉ series,
Ballroom Blitz
: the showbands were 'crap'.
It might be argued that it is Waters' and Geldof's view that is most suggestive of the postcolonial: the belief that the local must be inferior and that modernity – the good stuff – must be found elsewhere.
Irish popular music has always had the distinctly mixed blessing of a powerful neighbour. The proximity, particularly through the 1960s and into the 1970s, of the rapidly changing and inventive pop and rock scene in Britain could not but highlight the apparent shortcomings of the native offering. In fact, it was Britain that was the exception – popular music elsewhere was often as focused on entertainment, on competent reproduction of covers, and on versatility as the showband scene in Ireland.
READ MORE
Miller, who is American, discovered the showbands long after the fact; when booking a festival of traditional Irish music in New York in 1986, a musician told her he wouldn't be available as he was playing with a showband. She was intrigued, and close to 40 years later this book, the fruit of exhaustive archival research and hundreds of interviews, is an admirable example of the best kind of academic writing: fluent, authoritative, free of either nostalgia or embarrassment – and beautifully illustrated.
[
Ballrooms of romance: 'I wasn't the greatest dancer but when we danced together it was like it was meant to be'
Opens in new window
]
She looks closely at the business side; in a society that was underemployed and lacking in industry, the showband industry was a big fish, even if much of the cash went into, as Eamon Carr puts it 'the biscuit tin', and beyond the reach of the Revenue Commissioners.
She is revealing also about the social background of the musicians and on the ways in which the expectations of the wider society regarding gender roles played out on stage, backstage and on the dancefloor.
Stan Erraught lectures in music at the University of Leeds and is author of Rebel Notes: Popular Music and Conflict in Ireland (Beyond the Pale)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Karl Brophy buys stake in Piers Morgan's growing media group
Karl Brophy , a former journalist who sold his communications business Red Flag Consulting for an estimated €45 million earlier this year, has bought a multimillion euro stake in British broadcaster Piers Morgan's media business. Mr Brophy, a former Daily Mirror reporter who worked with its one-time editor Mr Morgan, is understood to have invested a significant seven-figure sum to buy a minority stake in the British man's Wake Up Productions. Another minority stake in the business is held by Martin Cruddace, a former racing executive and long-time associate of Mr Morgan's who also previously sat on the board of Red Flag. In March, Wake Up bought control of the Piers Morgan Uncensored news and opinion show from Rupert Murdoch's Talk TV, an online venture that broadcasts on YouTube but was previously a linear television channel. READ MORE [ Red Flag Consulting sold with expected €33m payout to founder Karl Brophy Opens in new window ] As part of that deal, Wake Up entered a four-year agreement with Mr Murdoch's News UK to share advertising revenue generated on YouTube by Piers Morgan Uncensored. The popular show presented by Mr Morgan last week passed four million subscribers on the Google-owned platform, where it broadcasts roughly six episodes each week. Recent guests included influencer Jake Paul; Eric Trump, son of US president Donald Trump; and former hip-hop star Kanye West, who now styles himself as Ye. Mr Morgan plans to expand the Uncensored brand in the online broadcasting market, using YouTube as its distribution platform. He told The Irish Times he may try to entice other YouTube stars with big subscriber bases to join the fold under the umbrella of the Uncensored brand. Or, he said, he could launch a stable of Uncensored shows covering different areas, similar to how Gary Lineker's Goalhanger stable of podcasts grew brands such as The Rest is Politics, The Rest is History, The Rest is Football and so on. Mr Morgan said all the content Wake Up produces is aimed at the burgeoning US media market – he has worked in the US on and off for two decades. 'We're in the top three in the world [with Piers Morgan Uncensored] on YouTube for news and opinion. No mean feat in three years,' Mr Morgan said. It is understood Mr Brophy will not join the board of Wake Up, but will contribute to strategy. Mr Morgan and Mr Cruddace were said to be keen to bring on board an investor who could help devise plans to grow the business. Mr Brophy, a former executive at Independent News & Media, founded Red Flag in 2013 with former INM chief Gavin O'Reilly as its chair and swiftly built up the business. Mr Brophy's wife Deirdre Grant runs the Irish division of Red Flag, which also has offices in London, Washington, Brussels and Cape Town. Mr Brophy personally held a 75 per cent stake in the business worth about €33 million when it was sold to US-based Ankura Consulting Group in February.
Irish Times
21 hours ago
- Irish Times
Photographer Ruth Medjber: ‘I spent too much of my early career helping idiot men with theirs'
How agreeable are you? I would say, professionally, I'm very agreeable because when you're a freelancer and you have so many clients on the go at once, I just do what the clients want me to do. That said, in other aspects of my life, my friends and partner would probably say I'm quite determined and stubborn. What is your middle name and what do you think of it? I was named after my godmother, who is my mom's cousin, but they fell out when I was about eight years of age ... I don't use my middle name at all. I even took it off my passport. Where is your favourite place in Ireland? Dollymount Beach. You can walk for five kilometres and not meet anyone, especially on a bit of a horrible day. And then you see the Poolbeg chimneys, the sight of which is a real moment of personal focus every time I'm there. I'm like, there's the lads. I know I'm home and that I can finally relax and breathe. Describe yourself in three words. Persistent. Compassionate. Tired. READ MORE When did you last get angry? In general, I'm not an angry person. I'm angry at injustice more than anything else, and I think we're all in a constant state of anger and disbelief that there isn't enough being done about the genocide that's happening in Gaza. [ Ruth Medjber: 'I don't need a therapist, because I have a camera' Opens in new window ] What have you lost that you would like to have back? I'm quite lucky in that I've never lost an awful lot in my life. I consider the greatest loss to be death, and when my dog died, that was the greatest loss for me. That and my campervan burning down a couple of months ago because of an electrical fault in the dashboard. What's your strongest childhood memory? My dad worked in a camera store and would give me these little plastic 35mm point-and-shoot cameras as Christmas present stocking fillers. I had a pink one when I was about three years of age, and it was my first form of expression, before I could even articulate through language. I still remember taking photographs. I did a series on toilet bowls, then light switches, shoes and other inanimate objects. Randomly enough, I was on eBay a couple of months ago and I found the same type of camera for sale. I have it here with me. I'm going to start trying it out to see if I can reclaim some of that three-year-old energy! Where do you come in your family's birth order, and has this defined you? I've one older brother, who is two years older than me. It's quite nice growing up when there's just the two of you. Our parents gave us a lot of freedom, respect and independence. Because of their trust, I became a very independent child and adult from quite a young age. That helped me build courage for myself as I tried new things and lived in new countries. What do you expect to happen when you die? Realistically, feck-all. If I were thinking fantastically, it'd be great if your spirit lived on, but what if you were trapped on Earth without a body? Or without a dog, a camper van, a beach? I mean, could you imagine never smelling sea air again? [ In pictures: life backstage with Hozier, Arcade Fire, Elton John and more by some of Ireland's top music photographers Opens in new window ] When were you happiest? One of the most recent happiest times took place in 2023. The sun was out, I was with my partner, and I was watching Yusef/Cat Stevens on the Pyramid Stage at Glastonbury. He sang I Love My Dog, which is one of my favourite tunes, and in that moment, I don't think I could have been happier. I was bawling my eyes out. I looked over at my partner. He was just laughing at me, and I was, like, absolutely delighted. Which actor would play you in a biopic about your life? That's a hard one. You don't want to say some amazingly gorgeous celebrity because people will go, what, really?! I'll probably do a Kneecap and see if I can fulfil the role myself. What's your biggest career/personal regret? I spent too much of my early career helping idiot men with theirs. My life would have been different if I had been a little bit more selfish and if I had had better taste in human beings than I did when I was in my 20s. Have you any psychological quirks? If someone on the TV claps their hands, I do the same. If I hear a noise, I repeat it. When I'm home, all the presses and doors have to be closed before I can settle down. In conversation with Tony Clayton-Lea
Irish Times
21 hours ago
- Irish Times
How Silicon Valley became the new Tír na nÓg
What full blooded young lad wouldn't be taken with Niamh of the Golden Hair? Wasn't Oisín only human when he said yes to the beautiful daughter of Manannán Mac Lir, the God of the Sea, particularly as she came with the extra quality of being the queen of Tir na nÓg? Oisín abandoned his mates in Na Fianna and his father Finn Mac Cumhaill – the man who created the Giant's Causeway – for this red-haired stunner, heading for the Land of Eternal Youth. Three hundred years there passed like three and he returned to Ireland, feeling like a young fella, only to find that everyone was dead. When he dismounted his virile horse and touched Irish soil, he transformed into a wizened old man. These Irish legends about the futility of wanting to live forever are thought to be thousands of years old, having been passed down orally for generations before being documented in the 18th century. Obviously, the legends never made it to Silicon Valley, where a movement, based on the notion that death is optional, is sweeping through the glittering halls of the technocracy. An increasing amount of very rich men, having examined the progress of life expectancy of the past two centuries, are bewitched by the idea that we can live forever and that death is a choice more than a certainty. An entire sub-economy of vitamin pills, diets, self-help books, longevity weekends and genetic engineering initiatives have been spawned in this 21st-century version of Tir na nÓg. At the centre of this movement is the modern day Oisín - a man called Bryan Johnson . Like many evangelicals, Johnson's obsession is fascinating and risible in equal measure. His aim is to engineer immortality (or something close to it). In 2021 he publicly launched Blueprint, an obsessive anti-ageing regimen aimed at making his body function decades younger, subjecting himself to a rigorously measured lifestyle, a vegan diet, 100+ pills and supplements a day, strict sleep and exercise schedules, and constant medical tests overseen by a team of doctors. The goal is to reprogramme his body's ageing process and prove that we might be the first generation that 'don't die'. READ MORE [ A tech entrepreneur chases immortality: Bryan Johnson is 46. Soon, he plans to turn 18 Opens in new window ] Johnson is a tech entrepreneur turned longevity-evangelist whose career began in fintech. In 2007 he founded Braintree, a payment processing start-up that powered mobile transactions for online businesses. He then bought Venmo, a small peer-to-peer payments app, for about $26 million, which proved to be a steal. Venmo – not unlike Revolut - was an easy mobile money-transfer app that exploded in popularity, especially among young Americans. By 2013 its growing user base of tens of millions pushed revenue to more than $200 billion in 2021 alone, making it the talk of the digital finance world. Tech giant PayPal, Elon Musk's original company, acquired Braintree and Venmo in 2013 for $800 million. Now enormously wealthy, Johnson set about living forever. He spends a reported $2 million per year of his own money on this quest to stay youthful. The routine has earned him the nickname 'the world's most measured man'. He tracks everything in service of what he calls 'optimal longevity'. He's tried blood plasma transfusions (even using blood from his teenage son) and experimental gene therapies. According to Johnson, his biomarkers now indicate he's ageing more slowly than normal and he claims that each calendar year only ages his body about 7½ months. In recent years as the tech world became wealthier, more self-absorbed and, some might say, deluded, Johnson's pet project has morphed into a fully-fledged 'Don't Die' community. He created a Don't Die app in which users track a daily longevity score and has spawned online forums called Blueprint Discord, now numbering in the tens of thousands. He even hosts Don't Die Summits , day-long events mixing wellness with almost evangelical fervour, driven by the genetic possibility that we can slow down and reverse the DNA triggers for ageing. In early 2024 some 600 attendees paid $249–$599 each to attend a Los Angeles summit featuring biometric tests, complete with its own 'longevity amusement park' of anti-ageing tech demos (VIP tickets at $1,499 included a private dinner with Johnson). At these summits, participants rave together in the morning at 'biohacker dance parties' and test longevity gadgets, such as $500 red-light therapy masks and $125,000 hyperbaric oxygen chambers. It's all designed to build a movement around Johnson's core belief that ageing is a problem to be solved, not a fate to accept. Like any prophet, Johnson is a branding genius and his public profile has skyrocketed. Earlier this year a glossy Netflix documentary, Don't Die: The Man Who Wants to Live Forever, showcased his daily routine, amplifying his message. Johnson is not happening in a vacuum; he is part of a much larger economics of longevity business that is gaining momentum. Globally, anti-ageing and longevity is a multibillion-dollar industry. Anti-ageing products from supplements and skincare to wellness programmes already represent a $70+ billion market. (Colleen Rooney has just launched her own supplements range in Holland & Barrett, along with the ubiquitous Kourtney Kardashian.) The market is projected to double to $141 billion by 2034. We are getting old and will spend to stay healthy and young. There is serious money to be made. [ We hit a second adolescence in our 60s, when beauty isn't skin-deep but 'life-deep' Opens in new window ] Investors in Silicon Valley are bailing into the Don't Die movement. In the past few years longevity biotech startups have sprung up, backed by loads of loot. Tech billionaires believe we can cure ageing at the cellular level. Google's founders have backed Calico Labs (short for the California Life Company) to research life-extension. In 2022, Jeff Bezos (who else?) and other ultra-wealthy punters pitched $3 billion to launch Altos Labs, a company dedicated to cellular reprogramming therapies that hope to reverse ageing. Altos Labs has reported success extending the lifespans of mice via gene therapy. Dozens of other firms, from start-ups to Big Pharma collaborations, are working on anti-ageing drugs, gene edits, stem cell therapies and senolytics (drugs that kill off zombie ageing cells). In 2021 more than $5 billion in venture capital flowed into longevity-related companies. The sector is creating 'unicorn' valuations, For example, a company called Cambrian Bio, which develops drugs to slow age-related diseases, is valued at about $1.8 billion. It is easy to be cynical and cite the Tír na nÓg example underscoring our futile fascination with prolonging life and avoiding death; on the other hand, average life spans have extended quite dramatically over the past century. Admittedly, as we get older, living a bit longer becomes more attractive and the phrase '60 is the new 40″ doesn't seem that weird at my age. Maybe if we can't Live Forever, a tune that will be roared by 60-year-olds at the Oasis gigs in a few weeks' time, our most decorous best bet might be to grow old gracefully. Fat chance.
