Why TikTok's Viral ‘Caveman Method' Doesn't Work, Explained by Dermatologists
Liz Coulbourn
Overconsumption and multiple-step routines have long dominated skin care conversations, but we've done a 180. This weekend, TikTok creator Tia Zakher went viral discussing her controversial 'Caveman Method," which allegedly is helping in restoring her skin barrier. On the social app, Zakher announced she had given up everything from her beauty routine — even water. The internet was immediately set ablaze, with some questioning whether this method was beneficial and many inquiring about potential long-term skin issues, such as infections and bacterial growth.
Zakher has created numerous videos explaining her decision, stating that she wanted to 'reset her skin barrier.' Some viewers believe she is rage baiting, pretending to not wash her face, while others think she is actually participating in the cold-turkey method — it's raised a lot of questions and concerns.
After she made her viral posts about the 'caveman regimen' — avoiding all skin care products and not washing her face — in April, the TikTok influencer who sparked the movement broke her streak in late May. In a video that quickly gained traction, she revealed she was washing her face for first time in a month, using CeraVe's gentle cleanser. Reactions were mixed: while some praised her for listening to her skin and ending the experiment, other commenters remained skeptical about the authenticity of the change, speculating whether the sponsorship played a role.
Still, fans acknowledged the end of a saga that had sparked widespread debate over skin care minimalism versus modern dermatology. While the 'caveman' era may be over, the controversy it stirred and the questions it raised about the skin care industry are likely to stick around.
Zakher's posts have led to a deep dive into the 'Caveman Method,' and a slew of people are wondering if there's some truth to the myth. To answer all your pressing questions, we chatted with three board-certified dermatologists — Dr. Mona Gohara, MD, Dr. Angela J. Lamb, MD, and Dr. Asmi Berry, DO, FAAD — to find out if there's a world where stopping all forms of skin care, water included, would actually help 'heal your skin barrier.' Check out what they had to say below.
Dr. Angela J. Lamb: It could temporarily help some people whose skin is extremely irritated from overuse of products, as it reduces the chances of chemical irritation and gives the skin a 'break.' However, for the person who is still wearing makeup and working out (which introduces sweat, dirt, bacteria), not cleansing the skin can actually clog pores, worsen acne, and lead to infection, so in these cases it is unlikely to genuinely help the skin barrier long-term.
Dr. Asmi Berry: The 'Caveman Method' isn't backed by science. If you want to reset or strengthen your skin barrier, a better method is to simplify your routine, not abandon it. Stick to a gentle cleanser, a hydrating moisturizer, and a mineral sunscreen. This approach gives your skin the support it needs without overwhelming it.
AJL: Basic necessities include a gentle cleanser that is non-stripping, a hydrating moisturizer, and a non-comedogenic sunscreen with a broad-spectrum SPF of 30 or higher, every morning. One optional add-on treatment includes a serum to address acne, dryness, or pigmentation concerns. You can skip toners, mists, eye creams, use of multiple serums, or heavy-duty exfoliators, unless specifically needed or advised by your regular dermatologist.
AJL: Yes, you can heal your skin barrier by stopping harsh products, such as retinoids, strong acids, and alcohol-based toners. To heal your skin barrier, you also need to moisturize regularly with products that contain barrier-repair ingredients, such as ceramides and fatty acids. Lastly, you should use a gentle cleanser with warm water, avoiding over-washing and hot water. Healing can take 2–6 weeks, depending on how damaged the barrier is.
AB: Without cleansing, dead skin cells, sweat, oils, dirt, and makeup can create an environment where yeast and bacteria thrive, leading to fungal acne or skin infections. Not washing off allergens or irritants can also trigger contact dermatitis, causing redness, itching, and rash.
Dr. Mona Gohara: Water by itself is not bad for the skin. Much of our skin is naturally comprised of water. In fact, our skin barrier has a natural moisturizing factor that Mother Nature gave us — the NMF's job is to attract water and moisture. For the surface of your skin, mixing water with a gentle non-soap cleanser is best to cleanse the skin of impurities, and open the pores, allowing other products such as moisturizers to absorb more easily.
AJL: Less is more. You don't need 15 products to have healthy skin, and you should focus on consistency over time rather than trends. Also, what your skin needs will change over time — what works at 16 may not work at 26. Whatever you do, don't skip sunscreen. UV damage is a major cause of aging and hyperpigmentation, even if you don't see it now.
MG: For a gentle, non-soap cleanser, I recommend using Neutrogena's Hydro Boost Hydrating Gel Cleanser with Hyaluronic Acid, Fragrance Free, as it's gentle on the skin and provides the hydration needed for skin care minimalists – great for daily use. For normal to oily skin, I recommend using Neutrogena's Collagen Bank SPF Moisturizer Broad Spectrum SPF 30. I love this product because it acts as a multitasker, both moisturising and protecting from the sun, perfect for those looking to use as few products as possible. For dry skin, I prefer Neutrogena's Hydro Boost Water Gel with Hyaluronic Acid because it has the moisturizing power of a cream, but absorbs quickly like a gel. But don't forget to use SPF – I recommend Neutrogena's Ultra Sheer Mineral Face Liquid SPF 70 as it's suitable for sensitive skin as well.
$15.00, Amazon
$30.00, Ulta
$23.00, Amazon
$17.00, Amazon
AJL: For a cleanser, I like La Roche-Posay Toleriane Purifying Foaming Cleanser for normal to oily skin. For a moisturizer and for SPF protection, Neutrogena Collagen Bank SPF Moisturizer Broad Spectrum SPF 30 is a wonderful daily sunscreen that can be layered with makeup or other skin care products.
$18.00, Amazon
$30.00, Ulta
AB: 'Cerave Hydrating Cleanser, it's a gentle cleanser packed with ceramides and hyaluronic acid, and gets rid of dirt without leaving your skin feeling tight or dry. La Roche Posay's Toleriane Double Repair Moisturizer, a lightweight, fragrance-free moisturizer with ceramides and prebiotics to support the skin barrier. EltaMD UV Clear SPF 46, a mineral-based, lightweight sunscreen perfect for those with sensitive or acne-prone skin. Bioderma Sensibo H2O micellar water, a quick, gentle way to remove makeup without irritating your skin.
$44.00, Amazon
$18.00, Amazon
$24.00, Amazon
$20.00, Amazon
This story has been updated to include Zakher's post about breaking her caveman method streak.
Originally Appeared on Teen Vogue
Want more style stories from Teen Vogue? Check these out:
Where Did All The Tween Fashion Go?
All the Beauty Products We Spotted at the 2024 Olympics
9 Sunscreens Teen Vogue Editors Swear By for Year-Round Protection
From Rose Water to Eyeliner, An Ode to Middle Eastern & North African Beauty
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Cooked: Celebrated Chef exits new venture after allegedly balking at free food for influencer because she wasn't famous enough
A prominent San Francisco chef threw in the apron at his newly opened cafe after allegedly belittling a TikTok influencer during a tense exchange over her follower count aired out in a viral video. The incident unfolded Wednesday at Kis Cafe in Hayes Valley, when 'micro-influencer' @itskarlabb described how she had pre-arranged a collab with the restaurant's team and showed up early to film content, according to a video she posted to her platform. 3 Influencer @itskarlabb was allegedly belittled by top chef Luke Sung over her supposedly low follower count, leaving her running from his new California restaurant in tears. itskarlabb/tiktok The influencer, known as Karla, claimed that a man — later identified as celebrated James Beard Award-nominated chef and co-owner Luke Sung — questioned her 15,000-follower count and told staff it was a 'mistake' to invite an influencer so small. 'I know they're talking about me, because I can hear them saying 'TikTok, views, followers' ,' she said in a later video, which has racked up more than 20 million views. The influencer said that when she introduced herself, Sung grilled her over whether she had researched the restaurant, a wine bar serving small bites. She insisted she knew the menu and the vibe, but Sung disagreed and began scrolling through her TikTok feed at full volume within earshot, the influencer said. 'After scrolling like, two times, he says to me that he doesn't think my videos are at the level which he wants his restaurant represented,' she recalled. 'It seemed like he was insinuating that my followers would not be able to afford to eat at this restaurant.' 3 Sung couldn't take the heat after the pair's alleged exchange went viral and left his new venture. San Francisco Chronicle via Getty Images Sung then reportedly asked, 'Do you know who I am?' and told Karla he was a two-time James Beard Award finalist and that his daughter is Big Apple vlogger, Isa Sung, who has 600,000 TikTok followers. He also dismissed the influencer's cooking videos she posted to her platform, dissing them as 'homey,' Karla said. The belittling exchange left her in tears, she said. 'I told him I felt disrespected and didn't want to collaborate anymore,' the influencer said. Karla's follower count has since skyrocketed to more than 350,000 since she shared the story on TikTok. The influencer said she wants to 'be an advocate for micro influencers' who don't receive as many handouts. 'You don't need to have a million followers to be respected or feel like you're making a difference,' she said. 3 Kis Cafe, which opened in May, announced that Sung had left as chef and co-owner. FOX By Friday, Kis Cafe's was getting cooked on Yelp, where its rating plunged from four to five stars to just over two stars, and reviews for 'Isa '– a 'pioneering' Cal-French restaurant that Sung previously opened and named after his influencer daughter — grew with haters lambasting the chef for his behavior. Kis Cafe, which opened in May, soon announced that Sung had left as a chef and co-owner, later clarifying he had done so of his 'own accord' and was not technically fired. 'Our chef's behavior was unacceptable, and he is no longer a part of the team,' Kis Cafe wrote in an Instagram post Thursday. The restaurant said it has now temporarily closed to 'restructure.' 'We want to create a space that's welcoming and respectful to everyone. In this instance, we failed to do so,' Kis Cafe said in a statement.
Elle
4 hours ago
- Elle
See the Destiny's Child Reunion at Beyoncé's Final Cowboy Carter Show
THE RUNDOWN On Saturday night, Beyoncé thrilled fans on her final Cowboy Carter tour stop when she invited Kelly Rowland and Michelle Williams on stage to reunite Destiny's Child for the first time in seven years. Fans shared footage from the moment on TikTok, which shows Beyoncé welcoming her colleagues to Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas as their song 'Independent Women' played. The Renaissance singer called out, 'Destiny's Child, bitch!' The famous trio performed a medley that included 'Lose My Breath,' 'Say My Name,' and 'Soldier.' Rowland and Williams also joined Beyoncé for her 2022 song 'Energy,' finishing with her famous 'mute challenge.' As it finished, Beyoncé sang, 'Look around, it's me and my crew. Big energy!' The reunion ended with the massive 2001 hit 'Bootylicious,' before Beyoncé hugged Williams and Rowland and then waved them offstage, telling the crowd, 'Give it up for Destiny's Child!' Beyoncé welcomed a few other guests for her final Cowboy Carter tour stop, including her husband, Jay-Z, and country music star Shaboozey. She and Destiny's Child were last seen together when Beyoncé headlined Coachella in April 2018. The star shared a picture with her friends on stage from the night in which they're all wearing variations on a gold ensemble, including fringed and shimmering gold chaps. In the image, Beyoncé is smiling widely as Williams leans in to give her a kiss on the cheek and they have their arms around one another. The group rose to prominence in the 1990s and originally had four members: Beyoncé Knowles, Kelly Rowland, LaTavia Roberson, and LeToya Luckett. The group transformed into the better known trio including Williams, but then disbanded in 2006. They have remained supportive friends and fans have been hoping to see them reunite for years.
Newsweek
4 hours ago
- Newsweek
Pregnant Woman Goes Into Labor, Then Sees Her Doctor From Hospital Window
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. The dramatic moment when a doctor sprinted across a hospital car park to deliver a baby has gone viral on TikTok, racking up 4.6 million views. The footage, shared by mom-of-four Angelica (@epicangelicanatalie), shows Dr. Christopher Kraft racing against time, as she was already 10cm dilated when he got the call. Angelica, who lives in Houston, Texas, told Newsweek: "Dr. Kraft came in perfectly calm with a 'ready to have a baby?' As if he wasn't just running in July Florida heat." The text layered over the clip states Piece Epic was born five minutes later. Angelica holding her newborn son and her family visiting them in hospital. Angelica holding her newborn son and her family visiting them in hospital. Provided by Angelica According to CDC data, a total of 3,596,017 births occurred in the United States in 2023, down 2 percent from 2022. The general fertility rate also declined 3 percent, falling to 54.5 births per 1,000 females aged 15–44 in 2023. Kraft has been Angelica's doctor for the past five years, but Epic is the first one he has delivered—just over a week ago. She told Newsweek: "The last office visit I had with him I insisted that I did not want him to miss this one! "We timed it perfectly with a very light induction considering I was very far dilated already, and my son was born eight hours later." Before filming the now-viral clip—which has gained almost 557,000 likes—Angelica said a nurse had mentioned how they often see Dr. Kraft running from his office to see patients. Then, like clockwork, they looked out of a third-floor window and saw him doing exactly that. "We found it so caring that he puts in that effort, and funny at the same time," she said. "I'm usually the one with a camera in my hand, but this time my husband Sage was the one who was recording, and his commentary made the video so perfectly wholesome." Indeed, Sage can be heard laughing, saying "he is ready," and complimenting the doctor's pace. Kraft told Newsweek: "While she was in labor, I was seeing patients in my office and monitoring her progress very closely. The nurse had reached out to me and informed me that delivery appeared imminent. "Once I got the word, I rushed from my office down four flights of stairs and ran out the backdoor to the hospital. I needed to get there as quickly as possible to ensure her safety and the safety of her baby, and running was my only option." Angelica requested a Vaginal Birth After Cesarean (VBAC), and Kraft was supportive of her decision. According to the American Pregnancy Association, most studies show that 60–80%—or about 3 to 4 out of every 5 women—who've had a previous C-section can have a successful vaginal birth. However, there are risks, which is why Kraft didn't want to miss a thing. TikTok Reacts So far, the clip has over 3,000 comments - some from parents who recognize Kraft and others sharing their birthing experiences. "My doctor came literally stumbling in. Dude got caught in the curtain got twisted up and fell and popped back up and said it's baby time," said one user. Another wrote: "My doc knew I'd deliver within minutes, we called him and he was half asleep and said "IM ON MY WAY, LOVE YOU BYE" I said "love you too." "With my 2nd the doctor said it would be 2-3 hours until I had to push. Wrong, it was 10 minutes. He came crashing into the room said "whoops" and caught my son one handed," said a third commenter. If you have a family dilemma, let us know via life@ We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
