HSE apologises after girl immunised during Covid with used needle
Barrister James Cross told Judge Fiona O'Sullivan in the Circuit Civil Court today that Ella Mockler Mulhern, now within six weeks of her 18th birthday, had suffered significantly as a result of the HSE's negligence and breach of duty.
Mr Cross, who appeared with James McSweeney Solicitors, Tallaght, for Ella, said not only had HSE staff administered the wrong vaccination when she attended a vaccination centre in Citywest Hotel in Dublin, in August 2021, a nurse had done so with a needle used already on one of three other people.
Ella's father Niall Mulhern, of Beech Park, Lucan, Co Dublin, told the court in written evidence that the vaccination had been administered without discussion with and the consent of either himself or his daughter.
He said the nurse involved had denied that the first syringe had been used previously but on his further inquiry from the Clinical Lead Nurse, an investigation had been carried out and it had been confirmed the syringe had been used on another person but the nursing staff had been unable to identify on which one of three other people it had been used on.
Mr Cross said Ella had to undergo blood tests and she had to be vaccinated for Hapatitis B. He said at least one of the possible three people who could have been injected with the syringe used on Ella had refused to undergo blood tests and as a result Ella had to undergo a post-exposure antiretroviral therapy course for a month.
Judge O'Sullivan heard this had caused Ella to feel acutely unwell with symptoms of nausea.
She had been upset and distressed by what had happened and had been unable to attend school for almost a month.
Ella had to undergo tests for Hepatitis C and HIV, suffering psychologically as a result and also developing a fear of doctors.
Just under a year later Ella had developed an abscess which had ruptured during her school sports day causing her considerable further distress and which had to be treated with antibiotics. It was not known if this had been due to the treatment she had received in Citywest.
Mr Cross said an initial settlement offer of €11,500 by HSE had been rejected earlier by another judge.
This had been followed by an offer of €16,500 and latterly by an offer of €20,000, expenses and legal costs which Mr Cross said he was recommending to the court.
Judge O'Sullivan, approving of the HSE's final offer, said the injuries associated with what had happened would have had a serious impact on the child and she felt €20,000 compensation was acceptable in the circumstances.
Barrister Seamus Breen, counsel for the HSE, read out an apology on behalf of his client during which he said the defendant accepted responsibility for what had happened and pointing out that Ella was blameless for what had occurred.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
4 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
The sign of common condition that affects thousands of Irish women – and you might notice when brushing your hair
And it could lead to future health problems OVARY AGONY The sign of common condition that affects thousands of Irish women – and you might notice when brushing your hair THERE is a sign of a common condition that affects thousands of Irish women that you might notice when brushing your hair. Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) affects how women's ovaries function, impacting their hormones and menstrual cycles. Advertisement 4 The HSE are urging women to know the signs of a common condition Credit: Getty Images - Getty 4 Polycystic ovary syndrome impacts hormone and periods Credit: Getty Images - Getty 4 It can cause hair loss and weight gain Credit: Getty Images - Getty It can also affect fertility and long-term health, potentially leading to serious health problems. However, these issues can often be managed or improved through lifestyle changes. The condition does not mean that cysts are present on the ovaries. Instead, polycystic ovaries are slightly larger than normal and contain numerous follicles. Follicles are small, fluid-filled sacs that release an egg during ovulation. However, women with PCOS often cannot release eggs regularly, resulting in irregular ovulation — with ovulation occurring at unpredictable times rather than on a monthly basis. The Health Service Executive state that many women have polycystic ovaries without necessarily having PCOS. Ovaries that appear polycystic are also considered normal in teenagers. Advertisement There are six key symptoms to watch for: Irregular periods or no periods at all Excess body or facial hair Weight gain Thinning hair and hair loss (alopecia) Oily skin or acne Difficulty in becoming pregnant The exact cause of PCOS is unknown, but it is thought to have a genetic link and may run in families. Two primary factors may contribute to the condition: insulin resistance and hormone imbalance. I'm living with PCOS and it's a nightmare - I constantly have hairs growing on my neck and chest every day You may be diagnosed with PCOS if you are an adult and meet at least two of the following criteria: Advertisement Irregular, infrequent, or no periods at all Excess hair growth on your face or body, or high levels of testosterone in your blood An ultrasound scan showing polycystic ovaries Currently, there is no cure for PCOS, but its symptoms can be managed. Individuals with PCOS can improve their symptoms and reduce the risk of long-term health issues by making lifestyle changes. There are also medications available to treat symptoms such as excess hair growth, irregular periods, and fertility problems. Although PCOS can contribute to fertility issues, it is still possible to conceive, even if you do not experience regular periods. However, the condition may increase the risk of miscarriage or pregnancy complications, such as diabetes and high blood pressure. Advertisement FUTURE HEALTH RISKS Despite the treatment available, the condition will increase your chances of developing other health problems in the future. These include: type 2 diabetes high blood pressure depression and mood swings high blood pressure and high cholesterol - which can lead to heart disease and stroke sleep apnoea - interrupted breathing during sleep weight gain endometrial cancer (cancer of the womb) - this is more likely if you carry excess weight and have irregular periods FERTILITY WITH PCOS The condition can be a cause of fertility problems but you may still become pregnant even if you do not have periods. It can increase your chance of miscarriage or medical complications, such as diabetes and high blood pressure, during pregnancy. However, there are ways to reduce the risk of complications, including trying to keep a healthy weight. Quitting smoking, eating a healthy, balanced diet and exercising regularly can significantly reduce the risks. Advertisement Fortunately, there are steps you can take to reduce these risks, including maintaining a healthy weight. Quitting smoking, eating a balanced diet, and exercising regularly can significantly improve outcomes.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Radiologist wants to see Kerry cancer bus service ‘replicated across the country'
This is where the Kerry Cancer Support Group (KCSG) and their Healthlink Transport Service comes in. The Kerry group helps provide transport for patients undergoing radiology treatment in both Cork and Limerick, and since these services began they have provided a lifeline to thousands of patients, ensuring they can get to hospital for treatment. Lorraine and her team at the oncology centre have helped support the Limerick Healthlink Transport Service and can see first-hand just how important it is for patients. "It is a lifeline for some patients to be honest, they are coming here from far afield including North Kerry and West Limerick and the bus really helps alleviate the stress of travelling up and down,' said Ms Walsh. "Daily radiation is a huge burden on patients and their families. The delivery of care is often straightforward but getting to it is the challenge,' she said. Having witnessed just how beneficial the service is, Lorraine would love to see it replicated, particularly given the increase in cancer diagnoses especially in younger generations. "Previously you wouldn't have seen bowel, breast or lung cancers in younger people but they are increasing every year,' says Lorraine who adds that, given the need to travel daily for the treatment, it is vital to have support like the bus. "There was a glut of cancer diagnosis after Covid, maybe because patients didn't go hospital or because diagnostic tests were cancelled. It has settled a bit more and more in the younger age category are getting diagnoses 'All radiotherapy centres are in urban areas... It is a huge burden on patients and their families to get to these areas. Treatment can be long, for prostate cancer it can be seven weeks Monday to Friday every single week. It has changed a bit but it can be four weeks every day. 'Services could easily be replicated in other parts of the country especially in Dublin where they reliant on taxes. It would also ease the cost burden to the health service,' she said. "That is my wishlist, to see it everywhere,' she adds. Earlier this week Lorraine and the Kerry Cancer Support Group launched a new vehicle for the Limerick service, replacing the original bus which since 2019 has clocked up nearly 300,000 kilometres helping hundreds of people in the region get to their treatment safely and comfortably. 'The introduction of this new bus is a testament to our shared dedication to compassionate, community-led care, removing barriers to access and easing the physical and emotional burden of travel for patients during an incredibly challenging time.'
Irish Post
2 days ago
- Irish Post
How Riley is changing period care in Ireland and beyond
WHEN Fiona Parfrey speaks about period care, she doesn't mince words. 'We want period products to be treated just like toilet paper; something that's readily available in every bathroom you walk into,' she says. Parfrey is the co-founder of Riley, a rapidly growing Irish startup that's shaking up the period care industry—not just with sustainable products, but with a bold mission to break the silence and shame around menstruation. 'We're aiming to remind people it's a normal bodily function,' she says. 'There's nothing to be ashamed about.' Born and raised in Cork, Parfrey studied marketing at University College Cork. 'I'm a very proud Corkonian,' she laughs. 'I studied marketing and worked in agencies across Dublin and Australia, and then I moved into the startup world in Australia. That's where I kind of fell in love with entrepreneurship.' That love turned into a career. After leaving her job in Australia, Parfrey went backpacking around the world, which sparked her first business idea. 'I realised there was a gap in the market for a travelling backpack that was ergonomically designed to fit the female body,' she says. 'A lot of the backpacks on the market were bulky and hard to carry for women. So I created a backpack that was made using recycled plastic.' The brand, Sundrift, gained traction until the COVID pandemic disrupted the travel industry and forced Parfrey to shift gears. That pivot led to Riley. The idea for Riley wasn't born in a boardroom or a brainstorm session. It happened over wine with a friend. 'The conversation happened quite naturally one evening,' Parfrey says. 'We were talking about how frustrated we were with the period products we had been using our entire lives.' That frustration turned into a revelation. 'We discovered that many mainstream period products are manufactured with up to 24 hormone-disrupting chemicals and covered in plastic,' she says. 'There were so many unnecessary ingredients in the manufacturing process. We felt like surely there's a better way of doing this.' When they couldn't find a cleaner, more sustainable alternative on the Irish market, Parfrey and her co-founders decided to build one themselves. Riley launched in 2021 as an e-commerce subscription service delivering organic, plastic-free period products directly to consumers' doors. 'We knew that when we started to build something clean, it would not only be better for our bodies but better for the planet as well,' Parfrey says. Sustainability isn't a marketing buzzword for Riley; it's a core principle of the business. 'Our applicators on our tampons are made from a bio-based solution, derived from sugarcane,' Parfrey notes. 'And we try to keep the environment in mind in every element of our supply chain.' But it hasn't been easy. 'It's a real journey to make things as sustainable as possible as we grow the business." Riley has since expanded from its consumer-focused model into the corporate space. 'We've started a big corporate offering,' Parfrey says. 'We supply period products to companies so they can stock them in staff bathrooms, just like they stock toilet paper. It's about making period care accessible, visible, and normal.' Parfrey is encouraged by how Ireland has responded to the brand and its mission. 'It's been really refreshing how open people have been, across generations, across genders, to actually talking about this,' she says. 'We've been really pleasantly surprised by the support we've gotten from all types of people.' But she's quick to note that stigma still lingers. 'If you survey young girls in school, 50% of them still feel shame when they're talking about periods. That's a huge problem,' she says. 'We've made progress, but we still have a long way to go.' The issue, she believes, goes far beyond just product accessibility. It's cultural, educational, and deeply gendered. 'Women go through a lot in their lifetime; from periods to childbirth to menopause and everything in between,' Parfrey says. 'It's important not just that women understand what's going on in their bodies, but that men do too.' She's especially passionate about closing the knowledge and research gap in women's health. 'There's been more research and studies on male baldness than there has been on endometriosis. That's shocking.' Riley was launched in 2021 (Photo by Riley) Riley is a proudly Irish company, but built to scale. 'We're an Irish-registered company,' says Parfrey. 'I'm based in Cork; we have a small office here and another in Dublin. My co-founder, Áine, has moved over to London as we try to grow the business in the UK.' That international push is already bearing fruit. 'Our supply chain is set up to serve all of Europe, and we have clients and direct customers all throughout Europe,' Parfrey says. 'We absolutely have global ambitions. The beauty of this business is that periods transcend borders, cultures, and languages. It's such a common thing for women no matter where they come from.' Reflecting on her startup journey, Parfrey encourages others not to wait for perfection. 'Just launch a minimum viable product. Get something to market and learn from your early adopters. If we had waited to launch a perfect product, we still wouldn't be in the market today.' Listening to feedback, she says, has been critical. 'Be close to your customer. Take their feedback on board. We constantly try to improve and make changes as we grow.' 'The more we talk openly about periods, the more we understand each other,' she says. 'And the easier it will be for everyone.' Whether it's tackling sustainability or breaking stigma in boardrooms and classrooms, Riley is charting a new course, one that's not just better for the body, but better for the planet too. See More: Business, Period Care, Startups
