Can a common denominator unite warring contestant nations at the International Mathematics Olympiad?
All of them from the West Bank, they were only half of a team able to attend the International Mathematics Olympiad, a gathering of the world's brightest young mathematical minds, where medals can offer tickets to any university in the world and launch brilliant careers.
Two of their compatriots from war-ravaged Gaza could not make the journey to Australia and would instead attempt to compete remotely. But this was a marked improvement from last year's event in England, for which no Palestinian could secure a visa in time.
Yet this heartfelt moment at the 66th IMO opening ceremony was followed by one that hinted at the deep divisions – driven by geopolitics and global conflict – which had played out behind closed doors just the day before and which threatened to unravel the oldest and most prestigious competition of young mathematicians.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
The students in the room did not know it, but a jury of delegates from the 114 nations gathered had, the day prior, voted as of the conclusion of the event to lift a suspension applied to Russia's membership after its 2022 full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
The Ukrainian leaders were distraught, the Estonians and other Baltic nations among the outraged. Their talk had already turned to boycott.
Even in the midst of Russia's full-scale invasion, Ukraine boasts an astonishing mathematical achievement. The year the war began, in 2022, Russia was suspended from the IMO and Ukrainian IMO students were evacuated. One among them from war-torn Kharkiv, Ihor Pylaiev, won his second gold medal – with a perfect score and a joint top-ranked position in the world. A number of his compatriots also medalled and, after this achievement, would earn scholarships at Cambridge.
Kyiv was supposed to host last year's maths olympiad. IMO Ukraine team leader Bogdan Rublev said in his country, 'the IMO is a very important event'.
Even as war raged, the Ukrainians remained optimistic that the violence would end and they could host the IMO as planned. But, those hopes were officially dashed when Bath was named Kyiv's replacement.
'It broke our hearts,' Rublev said. 'We had worked hard to prepare and we were excited to welcome the world to our country.'
Fellow Ukrainian representative Anastasiia Venchkovska, who was translating for Rublev on the Sunshine Coast, said Russia's IMO suspension was 'not just about mathematics'.
'Russia is not just a country at war, it is a state that systemically targets education, culture and children,' Venchkovska said. 'That is terrorism.'
'A country that destroys Ukrainian schools and universities should not sit at the same table as those against whom it commits genocide every day.'
The opening ceremony at the Twin Waters Novotel Resort on Monday was well intentioned and, otherwise, good fun. The parade of nations, each with teams of up to six high school students, was determined by the distance each had travelled to compete.
In a room full of sharp minds, it was a bit of sport to guess at the order by which teams would take to the stage and pose for the cameras.
The Moroccans (17,934km) surprised many by being called up first, each in flowing white robes beneath a red fez, before making way for the Portuguese (17,887km), who bounded and hooted up the stairs to form a mini-pyramid. The Norwegians (15,333km) wore black suits, ties and sunglasses inside, the Peruvians (13,117km) football-style red and white trackies. The Iraqis (13,240km) chanted 'Lions of Mesopotamia!', the Aussies (1,030km) 'Oi, Oi, Oi!'
The three young Palestinians (14,044km), however, made no spectacle, each briefly clutching their national flag.
Their faces betrayed little emotion. They didn't have to – everyone in the room understood how much it meant to stand on that stage, knew the life-changing opportunity that platform might provide.
'It was very beautiful,' Palestine team leader Samed AlHajajla said. 'The happiness is not complete, it was sad that we couldn't have all the children.'
'But at least it is good to have half of the team here in person.'
Though few picked who would open the parade, it didn't take a genius to guess who would follow the Palestinians.
Six young Israelis (14,040km) came smiling on stage, playfully brandishing soft toy otters, the team's mascot, and two Star of David flags. The cheers and applause fell to a smatter. One or two muttered boos.
Had an effort to suspend Israel's IMO membership on Sunday been successful, this moment might never have transpired. These six young people could still have competed – but remotely. The Israeli flag, like the Russian, would not have flown on the Sunshine Coast, nor next year at Shanghai.
Instead, the opposite will happen.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The IMO is a tightly choreographed and controlled event: team leaders set the exam questions and so have to be quarantined from their students to prevent cheating.
Before being whisked away to the leaders' site at a resort in Noosa, IMO board president Gregor Dolinar briefly answered questions about the jury meeting which resolved to lift Russia's suspension.
He described it as a 'long and constructive' discussion from which the main message was that 'we want to stay out of politics as much as possible'.
'We exchanged our views and we said that our primary goal is to enable as many kids from all around the world to come to the same place and to give them this opportunity to show their talent,' Dolinar said.
'So mathematics is our primary goal – if we will start to be involved in politics, we do not know where to draw the line'.
The jury meeting began with AlHajajla and lasted several hours.
The Palestinian team leader spoke with passion about the ordeal of his country's representatives, in particular those trapped amid the horrors of Gaza.
Other nations, particularly those from the global south, agreed and spoke in support of the Palestinian motion to suspend Israel.
Dolinar made several arguments as to why the IMO should remain, nonpolitical. Among them was that being political was bad for business. The sponsors that the non-profit organisation needed to finance such a logistically complicated event, he warned, did not want to deal with politically motivated organisations.
The IMO board put forward its own motion which proposed that measures only be taken against a member for breaking IMO regulations – for widespread cheating, say. All current suspensions – only Russia – would expire at the end of the Australian event.
This caught many by surprise – restoring Russia's membership was not in the agenda.
But the motion passed with a secret ballot of 62 in favour to 23 against, with six abstentions.
Israeli team leader Dan Carmon said it was 'the right choice for the IMO at this time', adding that the organisation – which is run by volunteers – spent a lot of time in the lead up to the event discussing its stance on political matters.
'I think it will be much better for the IMO, and the fostering of young minds everywhere, that we are now focusing on inclusivity instead of excluding students and countries,' Carmon said. 'I think that is a much better direction for the IMO to go in order to promote the love of mathematics in the world and promote brotherhood between nations.'
Far from brotherhood – for Rublev, Venchkovska and the Ukrainians – even sharing a stage with the Russian flag was 'impossible and unacceptable'.
'We came here not only to compete but to remind the world that, behind every problem we solve on paper, there is a much bigger problem we are living through in reality,' they said. 'We ask the international community to stay consistent, to stay principled and to stand with Ukraine'.
Estonian team leader Oleg Košik said his was among the Baltic nations who made clear in 2022 that they would do so
'We see the continuous barbaric aggression of Russia against Ukraine,' Košik said.
'The constant bombings of cities, innocent civilians being killed every night. If the IMO will say now, 'OK, this is fine, we don't care about it' – what message does it send to the whole world?'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
27 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Minority government the new normal in Tasmania as voters turn away from major parties
Tasmania has just had its second state election in 16 months, the shortest gap between state polls in Australia since Queensland in 1957. For some voters it was their fifth trip to the ballot box in less than two years. The state's Labor opposition bore a heavy burden of explaining why voters were going through this just months after rewarding federal Labor with two extra seats in Tasmania. In terms of its own vote share, state Labor clearly failed on Saturday. It had just 26% of the vote with almost 75% of the ballots counted. The election was called after Labor moved a no-confidence motion in Jeremy Rockliff's Liberal minority government – citing issues with budget management, proposed asset sales and major projects delivery. Yet on the campaign trail, Labor's budget repair proposals were modest and undermined by their support for spending on the much-disliked Macquarie Point stadium project. Labor's anti-asset-sales position was also undercut by their intent to offload the state's share in the proposed Marinus Link Bass Strait connector. Meanwhile, the Liberals switched from would-be privatisers to promising a government-owned insurance company, a concept blasted by experts and insurers but which tapped into small business concerns and distracted the news cycle for days. The overall state vote share result is a swing of about 3% from Labor to the Liberals who recorded 40% of the vote. A record field of 44 independents gained, too, in the absence of the Jacqui Lambie Network. The four most prominent independents (incumbents Kristie Johnston, Craig Garland and David O'Byrne, and anti-salmon-farming campaigner Peter George) polled strongly but almost all of the others flopped. Another failure was the latest reappearance of the Tasmanian Nationals. Their endorsement of candidates who sent two Liberal governments to elections and generally ramshackle campaign should raise questions for the party at the federal level. The Nationals were outpolled by the Shooters, Fishers and Farmers party, whose campaign was barely visible, but are in serious contention for one seat and in a multi-way battle for another. Tasmania uses the Hare-Clark proportional representation system where candidates compete against others from their own party as well as other parties – with each of the state's five federal electorates electing seven state members in the 35-seat House of Assembly. The system makes majority government difficult, but voters have frequently routed around that by supporting whichever major party looks most likely to win. Usually, minority governments are followed by majorities of the other side, but polling this time never showed either major party close. With declining major party vote shares, non-majority parliaments look like the new normal in this system. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Rockliff's government has gained a seat in Braddon, the north-west and western electorate that at the federal election fell to Labor with a massive swing. It appears to have lost one narrowly in Franklin where George has taken a seat, and is still fighting for possible gains from its starting 14 seats in Bass and Lyons. Dean Winter's opposition seems to have held its 10 seats and is in the mix for a possible gain in Bass through quirks of the Hare-Clark system. Overall, Tasmania is pretty back much where it was. Labor could potentially govern, if willing to do so with support from the Greens and left-wing independents. Such an alliance could have 18 or 19 seats. But Labor could have tried this approach after the 2024 election, or after the no-confidence motion in June, and made no visible attempt to do so. If Labor were to form government after losing votes in an election they are blamed for, and performed badly in, it would look less legitimate than had it done so immediately after last year's election. Rockliff, the premier, has stated his intention to ask the governor to renew his commission. By precedent, he must be granted this, whether or not he can prove he has 18 promised votes on confidence and supply. Of course, it is better to have the appearance of stability, but if he cannot arrange enough support, he can at least go back to the parliament and defy it to vote him out. Then, another no-confidence motion would be needed to install Winter as premier. Labor would come to office with a shallow pool of MPs to draw on, a debt crisis requiring hard decisions that they did not campaign on, and a crossbench hungry to deliver for supporters on issues like native forest logging, salmon farms and the stadium. It's a sticky situation.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Australia's Tasmania on track for minority government after poll
SYDNEY, July 20 (Reuters) - Australia's island state of Tasmania appeared on Sunday to be heading for a minority government as vote counting continued after an election that did not produce a clear winner. The conservative Liberal government was on track to win more seats than the main Labor opposition in the new parliament but would probably fall short of a majority after Saturday's election, the Australian Broadcasting Corp. projected. The Liberals' strong performance under Jeremy Rockliff, premier since 2022, follows a heavy defeat suffered at May's national election, which returned Anthony Albanese-led Labor for a second term with an increased majority. Saturday's vote showed Tasmanians have "no confidence in the Labor party to form government and they have voted to reendorse our Liberal government," Rockliff said in televised remarks from the state capital of Hobart. The result for Labor, on track to win nine seats of a possible 35, was shaping as the party's worst-ever result in Tasmania, the Guardian Australia newspaper said. On Sunday, state Labor leader Dean Winter said the result was disappointing for the party, but he did not concede defeat. The election was triggered by a no-confidence vote against Rockliff initiated by Labor on concerns about public debt and plans to privatise assets. It came less than two years after the state's most recent poll, in which a majority eluded the Liberals. The only Australian state to elect its lower house on the basis of proportional representation, Tasmania has a long history of minority governments. Wilderness or protected areas make up 40% of the island, which is 445 km (275 miles) away from Melbourne, usually requiring a flight of an hour, or a ferry crossing 10 times longer, to cover the distance.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Federal opposition flags more ‘sensitive' approach to foreign students at Australian universities
The Coalition has walked away from its call for Australia to slash 80,000 international students from higher education institutions, with the opposition's education spokesperson promising a more 'sensitive' approach following the party's crushing election defeat in May. During the federal election campaign, then opposition leader Peter Dutton claimed cutting foreign student numbers would free up more housing and rental opportunities. Dutton said students were 'taking up accommodation that should be occupied by Australian citizens'. The approach was heavily criticised by the university sector and described by tertiary bodies as 'isolationist' and akin to the 'Donald Trump anti-migration card'. Jonathon Duniam on Sunday conceded the policy under Dutton wasn't 'as constructive as it could have otherwise been' as the Coalition continued to review its platform. 'Obviously, those numbers were part of a discussion that occurred before an election we lost,' the new education spokesperson told ABC TV. 'I don't think that any university should, as some have, use international students as a cash cow. That's not appropriate because it's not a good business model, but we need to recognise that a large part of the funding, for especially regional universities, comes from international students. 'So a more sensitive conversation needs to be had, and we will work with the sector and the government about that.' Labor also wants to reduce international student numbers, with a plan to drive down enrolments to a maximum of 270,000 in 2025. The shadow education minister on Sunday indicated the Coalition had softened its position on other education policies, including past opposition to the Albanese government's plan to wipe 20% off students' Hecs debts. Duniam said the Coalition accepted Australians 'had their say' at the election. 'We've got to move on,' he said on Sunday. The opposition's position on potential changes to the school system came under fire after Dutton pledged to 'restore' a curriculum focused on 'critical thinking, responsible citizenship and common sense' in his budget speech reply. While a clear policy or proposal was never announced or released, Dutton suggested students were being 'indoctrinated' at school and floated that federal funding to schools could be conditional on adherence to curriculum teaching rather than 'guided into some sort of an agenda that's come out of universities'. Duniam said his focus was on improving key metrics, such as maths, reading and science, rather than 'specific elements of the curriculum'. 'I think the rest of it will fall away if we're focusing on the priorities of getting kids out of schools with the best marks possible so they can go into university or higher education at the best standard possible and become the best graduates,' Duniam said. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion 'Then that will deal with all of the issues people have complaints around, including the 'woke' issues, as they're called.' A number of Coalition MPs and senators have remained vocal supporters of a push to ban transgender women from female sports, including Duniam's Senate colleague Claire Chandler. When asked whether it was an issue he shared with his colleagues, the senator said it deserved an 'adult debate' but that he did not believe it was up to him to decide how schools should facilitate arrangements. 'I honestly believe that girls' sports should be for girls, boys sports for boys. And if you have a mixed grouping, then that's something you can arrange by competition or in a school arrangement,' he said. 'I don't think it's for me to set down who should participate in what sport.' In late June, the shadow immigration minister, Paul Scarr, promised a new tone when talking about migrants as the Liberal party worked to rebuild support among multicultural communities. 'One of the things I am passionate about is getting the tone of discussion right – I think that is of critical importance,' Scarr told Guardian Australia. 'And any discussion of immigration must proceed, in my view, on the basis of the contribution that's been made to this country by so many people who have come to this country as migrants.'
