Protest laws questioned after 'indefensible' injuries
Days after the violent arrest of one-time federal Greens candidate Hannah Thomas, advocates have written an open letter to NSW Premier Chris Minns with concerns about a "criminalisation and police powers creep".
Ms Thomas, who was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets, was hospitalised and could suffer permanent vision loss.
The arrests will be investigated by police officers from another command, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Australian Democracy Network protest rights campaigner Anastasia Radievska said the incident showed the 'places of worship' laws had given police extra impetus to violently shut down protests.
The laws were introduced by the state Labor government after a spate of anti-Semitic attacks across the country, with the stated intention of protecting people being targeted by disruptive protesters when entering or leaving a place of worship.
"The passage of the places of worship anti-protest legislation has emboldened the NSW Police to act with impunity in shutting down protests when they're merely occurring near a place of worship," Ms Radievska said.
"The place of worship move-on powers are not fit for purpose, and they must be immediately repealed before more protesters are subject to reckless police action … participating in protest cannot be an invitation to assault and serious injury from police."
Friday's protest in Belmore was opposite a mosque but it was not the target of demonstrators.
Police have denied the laws were relied upon in the arrest.
Doctor Mitch Hickson said Ms Thomas' injuries were "medically significant" and "ethically indefensible".
"Facial trauma of the kind she has experienced - requiring surgery and with the potential for permanent vision loss - should never be the outcome of lawful protest activity and reveals a disproportionate and excessive use of force by the police," he said.
""A democracy cannot function where lawful protest is met with force, where questions are answered with violence, and where power is exercised without accountability."
The open letter calls for an independent investigation into the policing of the Belmore protest and urgent amendments to the places of worship protest laws.
Signatories include Amnesty International Australia, Australian Lawyers for Human Rights and the Jewish Council of Australia.
Pro-democracy groups say controversial laws granting police powers to move protesters on from places of worship have emboldened the force to "act with impunity".
Days after the violent arrest of one-time federal Greens candidate Hannah Thomas, advocates have written an open letter to NSW Premier Chris Minns with concerns about a "criminalisation and police powers creep".
Ms Thomas, who was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets, was hospitalised and could suffer permanent vision loss.
The arrests will be investigated by police officers from another command, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Australian Democracy Network protest rights campaigner Anastasia Radievska said the incident showed the 'places of worship' laws had given police extra impetus to violently shut down protests.
The laws were introduced by the state Labor government after a spate of anti-Semitic attacks across the country, with the stated intention of protecting people being targeted by disruptive protesters when entering or leaving a place of worship.
"The passage of the places of worship anti-protest legislation has emboldened the NSW Police to act with impunity in shutting down protests when they're merely occurring near a place of worship," Ms Radievska said.
"The place of worship move-on powers are not fit for purpose, and they must be immediately repealed before more protesters are subject to reckless police action … participating in protest cannot be an invitation to assault and serious injury from police."
Friday's protest in Belmore was opposite a mosque but it was not the target of demonstrators.
Police have denied the laws were relied upon in the arrest.
Doctor Mitch Hickson said Ms Thomas' injuries were "medically significant" and "ethically indefensible".
"Facial trauma of the kind she has experienced - requiring surgery and with the potential for permanent vision loss - should never be the outcome of lawful protest activity and reveals a disproportionate and excessive use of force by the police," he said.
""A democracy cannot function where lawful protest is met with force, where questions are answered with violence, and where power is exercised without accountability."
The open letter calls for an independent investigation into the policing of the Belmore protest and urgent amendments to the places of worship protest laws.
Signatories include Amnesty International Australia, Australian Lawyers for Human Rights and the Jewish Council of Australia.
Pro-democracy groups say controversial laws granting police powers to move protesters on from places of worship have emboldened the force to "act with impunity".
Days after the violent arrest of one-time federal Greens candidate Hannah Thomas, advocates have written an open letter to NSW Premier Chris Minns with concerns about a "criminalisation and police powers creep".
Ms Thomas, who was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets, was hospitalised and could suffer permanent vision loss.
The arrests will be investigated by police officers from another command, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Australian Democracy Network protest rights campaigner Anastasia Radievska said the incident showed the 'places of worship' laws had given police extra impetus to violently shut down protests.
The laws were introduced by the state Labor government after a spate of anti-Semitic attacks across the country, with the stated intention of protecting people being targeted by disruptive protesters when entering or leaving a place of worship.
"The passage of the places of worship anti-protest legislation has emboldened the NSW Police to act with impunity in shutting down protests when they're merely occurring near a place of worship," Ms Radievska said.
"The place of worship move-on powers are not fit for purpose, and they must be immediately repealed before more protesters are subject to reckless police action … participating in protest cannot be an invitation to assault and serious injury from police."
Friday's protest in Belmore was opposite a mosque but it was not the target of demonstrators.
Police have denied the laws were relied upon in the arrest.
Doctor Mitch Hickson said Ms Thomas' injuries were "medically significant" and "ethically indefensible".
"Facial trauma of the kind she has experienced - requiring surgery and with the potential for permanent vision loss - should never be the outcome of lawful protest activity and reveals a disproportionate and excessive use of force by the police," he said.
""A democracy cannot function where lawful protest is met with force, where questions are answered with violence, and where power is exercised without accountability."
The open letter calls for an independent investigation into the policing of the Belmore protest and urgent amendments to the places of worship protest laws.
Signatories include Amnesty International Australia, Australian Lawyers for Human Rights and the Jewish Council of Australia.
Pro-democracy groups say controversial laws granting police powers to move protesters on from places of worship have emboldened the force to "act with impunity".
Days after the violent arrest of one-time federal Greens candidate Hannah Thomas, advocates have written an open letter to NSW Premier Chris Minns with concerns about a "criminalisation and police powers creep".
Ms Thomas, who was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets, was hospitalised and could suffer permanent vision loss.
The arrests will be investigated by police officers from another command, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Australian Democracy Network protest rights campaigner Anastasia Radievska said the incident showed the 'places of worship' laws had given police extra impetus to violently shut down protests.
The laws were introduced by the state Labor government after a spate of anti-Semitic attacks across the country, with the stated intention of protecting people being targeted by disruptive protesters when entering or leaving a place of worship.
"The passage of the places of worship anti-protest legislation has emboldened the NSW Police to act with impunity in shutting down protests when they're merely occurring near a place of worship," Ms Radievska said.
"The place of worship move-on powers are not fit for purpose, and they must be immediately repealed before more protesters are subject to reckless police action … participating in protest cannot be an invitation to assault and serious injury from police."
Friday's protest in Belmore was opposite a mosque but it was not the target of demonstrators.
Police have denied the laws were relied upon in the arrest.
Doctor Mitch Hickson said Ms Thomas' injuries were "medically significant" and "ethically indefensible".
"Facial trauma of the kind she has experienced - requiring surgery and with the potential for permanent vision loss - should never be the outcome of lawful protest activity and reveals a disproportionate and excessive use of force by the police," he said.
""A democracy cannot function where lawful protest is met with force, where questions are answered with violence, and where power is exercised without accountability."
The open letter calls for an independent investigation into the policing of the Belmore protest and urgent amendments to the places of worship protest laws.
Signatories include Amnesty International Australia, Australian Lawyers for Human Rights and the Jewish Council of Australia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
26 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
Billions locked in for 2032 Olympic Games with new Queensland and federal government deal
Brisbane 's Olympic dream is becoming a reality with an intergovernmental agreement securing a $1.2 billion federal fund for the new Brisbane stadium. Deputy Premier Jarrod Bleijie announced the funding partnership and the plans for the Games on Thursday. 'To deliver this once-in-a-generation event, you need to work with partners,' he said. 'What today's deal means is certainty for games infrastructure going forward.' Federal contributions for this project will total $3.4 billion and both governments will commit a combined $7.1 billion to deliver 17 new or upgraded sports venues, including the promised Victoria Park stadium. 'Despite being from different political persuasions, we have worked well together in the state and in the national interest,' the deputy premier said. Federal Infrastructure Minister Catherine King said the deal will help the Olympics leave an 'incredible legacy for Queensland'. 'The Australian government's commitment of $3.4 billion towards the Games venues is the single largest contribution any Australian government has made towards sporting infrastructure in this country,' she said. At the heart of Brisbane 2032 is Victoria Park's proposed 63,000-seat stadium. It was confirmed on Thursday that the stadium will be used for the opening and closing ceremonies. Work has already begun, including soil sampling and geotechnical studies, to ensure the site will be fit to build on. The site, however, holds major cultural significance with First Nations people and the redevelopment plans have brought about cultural heritage controversy for the state government. The LNP ensured on Thursday that they acknowledge their obligation to reach an agreement with First Nations groups, 'but ultimately if an agreement can't be reached, then the laws have to override', Bleijie said. This controversy is yet another for the state government, which has continually been challenged by First Nations people since coming into office. Leeanne Enoch, Labor member for Algester in Queensland, commented in parliament last week that 'this LNP government is hell-bent on winding back any progress made regarding reconciliation in this state'. Enoch accused the LNP of attempting to 'erase' First Nations people from the QLD public sector. 'This government is determined to undermine the impact of years of cross-cultural training and agreed protocols designed to ensure government agencies are able to effectively serve some of the most vulnerable people in our community,' she said. Bleijie said that the LNP recognise Victoria Park is a significant issue, but was 'confident that we will secure the support (of First Nations people)'.
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Jewish school security like 'counter-terrorism' squad
Jewish school principals say their security teams resemble counter-terrorism squads in an effort to keep students safe after a rise in anti-Semitism. Giving evidence to a NSW parliamentary inquiry examining anti-Semitism in the state, leaders revealed schools had dealt with a barrage of incidents including frequent verbal abuse laden with Nazi references. The inquiry was set-up in February after a swathe of incidents in Sydney, including the firebombing of a non-religious childcare centre located near a synagogue and Jewish primary school in the city's east. That the centre was targeted for simply being near Jewish institutions highlighted the scope of the issue, Moriah College principal Miriam Hasofer said. She said her school was spending $3.9 million a year on security, an 86 per cent increase compared with before October 7, 2023 when Hamas attacked Israel. "We comfort students, call families, write reports, put together briefs, and then try attending to the teaching until (another anti-Semitic incident) happens again days later," she told the inquiry. "Education is constantly disrupted, our teachers are drained, our wellbeing team is overstretched, our leaders are operating like a counter-terrorism unit, and this has become our normal." Moriah College has dealt with one security incident per week in 2025, Ms Hasofer said. Emanuel School principal Linda Emms, who started the school this year, said the childcare centre firebombing had created a heightened sense of tension among the community. "My first communication to parents and staff should have been that of setting my vision for our school," she told the inquiry. "Instead, it was a communication outlining the steps being taken to ensure the safety of students and staff for term one, there was nothing normal in the measures to make our community feel safe." A spate of high-profile attacks over summer included the targeting of a Jewish community leader's former home and the spray-painting of anti-Semitic slurs in various prominent locations. At a previous hearing, Jewish Australians labelled the inquiry "troubling" because it risks exacerbating anti-Semitism by focusing on just one form of racism. Those advocates said the inquiry itself and potential subsequent action could stoke the fires of anti-Semitism by treating one form of racism separately from others. Jewish school principals say their security teams resemble counter-terrorism squads in an effort to keep students safe after a rise in anti-Semitism. Giving evidence to a NSW parliamentary inquiry examining anti-Semitism in the state, leaders revealed schools had dealt with a barrage of incidents including frequent verbal abuse laden with Nazi references. The inquiry was set-up in February after a swathe of incidents in Sydney, including the firebombing of a non-religious childcare centre located near a synagogue and Jewish primary school in the city's east. That the centre was targeted for simply being near Jewish institutions highlighted the scope of the issue, Moriah College principal Miriam Hasofer said. She said her school was spending $3.9 million a year on security, an 86 per cent increase compared with before October 7, 2023 when Hamas attacked Israel. "We comfort students, call families, write reports, put together briefs, and then try attending to the teaching until (another anti-Semitic incident) happens again days later," she told the inquiry. "Education is constantly disrupted, our teachers are drained, our wellbeing team is overstretched, our leaders are operating like a counter-terrorism unit, and this has become our normal." Moriah College has dealt with one security incident per week in 2025, Ms Hasofer said. Emanuel School principal Linda Emms, who started the school this year, said the childcare centre firebombing had created a heightened sense of tension among the community. "My first communication to parents and staff should have been that of setting my vision for our school," she told the inquiry. "Instead, it was a communication outlining the steps being taken to ensure the safety of students and staff for term one, there was nothing normal in the measures to make our community feel safe." A spate of high-profile attacks over summer included the targeting of a Jewish community leader's former home and the spray-painting of anti-Semitic slurs in various prominent locations. At a previous hearing, Jewish Australians labelled the inquiry "troubling" because it risks exacerbating anti-Semitism by focusing on just one form of racism. Those advocates said the inquiry itself and potential subsequent action could stoke the fires of anti-Semitism by treating one form of racism separately from others. Jewish school principals say their security teams resemble counter-terrorism squads in an effort to keep students safe after a rise in anti-Semitism. Giving evidence to a NSW parliamentary inquiry examining anti-Semitism in the state, leaders revealed schools had dealt with a barrage of incidents including frequent verbal abuse laden with Nazi references. The inquiry was set-up in February after a swathe of incidents in Sydney, including the firebombing of a non-religious childcare centre located near a synagogue and Jewish primary school in the city's east. That the centre was targeted for simply being near Jewish institutions highlighted the scope of the issue, Moriah College principal Miriam Hasofer said. She said her school was spending $3.9 million a year on security, an 86 per cent increase compared with before October 7, 2023 when Hamas attacked Israel. "We comfort students, call families, write reports, put together briefs, and then try attending to the teaching until (another anti-Semitic incident) happens again days later," she told the inquiry. "Education is constantly disrupted, our teachers are drained, our wellbeing team is overstretched, our leaders are operating like a counter-terrorism unit, and this has become our normal." Moriah College has dealt with one security incident per week in 2025, Ms Hasofer said. Emanuel School principal Linda Emms, who started the school this year, said the childcare centre firebombing had created a heightened sense of tension among the community. "My first communication to parents and staff should have been that of setting my vision for our school," she told the inquiry. "Instead, it was a communication outlining the steps being taken to ensure the safety of students and staff for term one, there was nothing normal in the measures to make our community feel safe." A spate of high-profile attacks over summer included the targeting of a Jewish community leader's former home and the spray-painting of anti-Semitic slurs in various prominent locations. At a previous hearing, Jewish Australians labelled the inquiry "troubling" because it risks exacerbating anti-Semitism by focusing on just one form of racism. Those advocates said the inquiry itself and potential subsequent action could stoke the fires of anti-Semitism by treating one form of racism separately from others. Jewish school principals say their security teams resemble counter-terrorism squads in an effort to keep students safe after a rise in anti-Semitism. Giving evidence to a NSW parliamentary inquiry examining anti-Semitism in the state, leaders revealed schools had dealt with a barrage of incidents including frequent verbal abuse laden with Nazi references. The inquiry was set-up in February after a swathe of incidents in Sydney, including the firebombing of a non-religious childcare centre located near a synagogue and Jewish primary school in the city's east. That the centre was targeted for simply being near Jewish institutions highlighted the scope of the issue, Moriah College principal Miriam Hasofer said. She said her school was spending $3.9 million a year on security, an 86 per cent increase compared with before October 7, 2023 when Hamas attacked Israel. "We comfort students, call families, write reports, put together briefs, and then try attending to the teaching until (another anti-Semitic incident) happens again days later," she told the inquiry. "Education is constantly disrupted, our teachers are drained, our wellbeing team is overstretched, our leaders are operating like a counter-terrorism unit, and this has become our normal." Moriah College has dealt with one security incident per week in 2025, Ms Hasofer said. Emanuel School principal Linda Emms, who started the school this year, said the childcare centre firebombing had created a heightened sense of tension among the community. "My first communication to parents and staff should have been that of setting my vision for our school," she told the inquiry. "Instead, it was a communication outlining the steps being taken to ensure the safety of students and staff for term one, there was nothing normal in the measures to make our community feel safe." A spate of high-profile attacks over summer included the targeting of a Jewish community leader's former home and the spray-painting of anti-Semitic slurs in various prominent locations. At a previous hearing, Jewish Australians labelled the inquiry "troubling" because it risks exacerbating anti-Semitism by focusing on just one form of racism. Those advocates said the inquiry itself and potential subsequent action could stoke the fires of anti-Semitism by treating one form of racism separately from others.
Perth Now
3 hours ago
- Perth Now
Jewish school security like 'counter-terrorism' squad
Jewish school principals say their security teams resemble counter-terrorism squads in an effort to keep students safe after a rise in anti-Semitism. Giving evidence to a NSW parliamentary inquiry examining anti-Semitism in the state, leaders revealed schools had dealt with a barrage of incidents including frequent verbal abuse laden with Nazi references. The inquiry was set-up in February after a swathe of incidents in Sydney, including the firebombing of a non-religious childcare centre located near a synagogue and Jewish primary school in the city's east. That the centre was targeted for simply being near Jewish institutions highlighted the scope of the issue, Moriah College principal Miriam Hasofer said. She said her school was spending $3.9 million a year on security, an 86 per cent increase compared with before October 7, 2023 when Hamas attacked Israel. "We comfort students, call families, write reports, put together briefs, and then try attending to the teaching until (another anti-Semitic incident) happens again days later," she told the inquiry. "Education is constantly disrupted, our teachers are drained, our wellbeing team is overstretched, our leaders are operating like a counter-terrorism unit, and this has become our normal." Moriah College has dealt with one security incident per week in 2025, Ms Hasofer said. Emanuel School principal Linda Emms, who started the school this year, said the childcare centre firebombing had created a heightened sense of tension among the community. "My first communication to parents and staff should have been that of setting my vision for our school," she told the inquiry. "Instead, it was a communication outlining the steps being taken to ensure the safety of students and staff for term one, there was nothing normal in the measures to make our community feel safe." A spate of high-profile attacks over summer included the targeting of a Jewish community leader's former home and the spray-painting of anti-Semitic slurs in various prominent locations. At a previous hearing, Jewish Australians labelled the inquiry "troubling" because it risks exacerbating anti-Semitism by focusing on just one form of racism. Those advocates said the inquiry itself and potential subsequent action could stoke the fires of anti-Semitism by treating one form of racism separately from others.
