‘Simply not good enough': MPs concerned by ‘intolerable risks' at Sellafield site
Sellafield nuclear site
are being exacerbated by poor performance, substandard equipment and staff shortages that make the facility even more dangerous, according to a report by MPs in Westminster.
The UK's public accounts committee (PAC) also raised concerns about the proliferation of non-disclosure agreements to settle staff whistle-blowing complaints about safety and bullying at the site, located on the Cumbrian coast about 170km from Ireland. It said safety concerns and galloping cost overruns were 'simply not good enough'.
The committee has released a report on the £136 billion (€162 billion) clean-up job at Sellafield, a former reprocessing and power plant that now essentially operates as a nuclear dump. It said the clean-up of the site is too slow and management keeps missing targets.
It highlighted problems at decrepit buildings such as the Magnox Swarf Storage Silo (MSSS), which has leaked hazardous nuclear pondwater into the soil for seven years. The committee said it was enough to fill an Olympic swimming pool every three years.
READ MORE
The committee accused Sellafield Ltd, the company that operates the site on behalf of the British state, of 'underperformance' by taking too long to clear crumbling old buildings such as the MSSS. Its report said the 'consequence of this underperformance is that the buildings are likely to remain extremely hazardous for longer'.
It complained that the timeline given by the company for clearing Sellafield's most dangerous buildings has slipped by 13 years since 2018. The leaking MSSS is being slowly emptied of its lethal material, but the PAC said it needs to be removed 24 times faster than it was last year within a decade, if it is to hit targets.
[
Inside Sellafield: behind the razor wire, gun-toting guards and blast barriers at the toxic nuclear site
Opens in new window
]
'The intolerable risks presented by Sellafield's ageing infrastructure are truly world-class,' said Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the Tory MP who chairs the PAC. 'When visiting the site, it is impossible not to be struck by the fact that one can be standing in what is surely one of the most hazardous places in the world.'
The PAC found that management needs to 'fundamentally transform how the site functions'. It is already estimated the clean-up of the site will take at least 100 years. Sellafield told the PAC it had made progress in some areas.
The report also warned management must do more to 'build a culture where all employees feel able to raise concerns and report poor behaviour'. The PAC was told the company had used non-disclosure agreements 16 times in the last three years when settling staff claims.
[
Nuclear accident in UK or Europe could significantly contaminate food in Ireland, EPA told Government
Opens in new window
]
Alison McDermott, a former executive at Sellafield who fought a legal battle with the company after she made a whistle-blowing complaint about safety and bullying, said the PAC report 'vindicates everything I said' about a 'toxic and dangerous' culture at Sellafield.
She said 'Ireland is not safe' due to the way the site is run: 'This is not a British problem – it's a threat to everyone across the Irish Sea. The Irish Government must wake up.'
The Irish Government once sued Britain over safety fears at Sellafield. It is believed the State made no submissions to the UK's PAC as part of its latest inquiry into the site.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Housing target should be revised up to 60,000 homes per year, Dublin Chamber says
A national target of 60,000 new homes per year should be set, with half of these delivered in the Greater Dublin Area to align with increased population growth and pent-up demand in the region, Dublin Chamber has urged the Government. The proposal is contained within the business lobby's pre-budget submission. Just 30,330 homes were completed during 2024, while the programme for government pledges to deliver more than 300,000 by the end of 2030. This year's target is 41,000. 'Dublin does not have sufficient housing and infrastructure to meet its current needs, and the future outlook is bleak,' Dublin Chamber said. The group also called on Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe to increase the standard rate income tax band by a minimum of €2,100 for single earners and €4,200 for married couples. READ MORE It said this adjustment would help 'redress the lack of indexation in recent years and ensure that workers are not penalised for modest income growth that simply keeps pace with inflation'. It also called for capital gains tax on disposals of investments in unquoted, actively trading Irish companies to be cut from 33 per cent to 20 per cent. 'This measure would directly incentivise entrepreneurial risk-taking,' it said. 'It would also more effectively appeal to gain-seeking investors than existing measures such as the Employment and Investment Incentive Scheme (EIIS).' The group was also critical of the supports available to small businesses. It said Dublin's start-up ecosystem 'is faltering', and that early-stage funding has 'declined sharply' since peaks in 2021. 'Instead of attracting entrepreneurs and founders, the current system often deters them, weighed down by misaligned and bureaucratic supports,' it said. Furthermore, it called Ireland's non-residential stamp duty rate of 7.5 per cent a 'significant barrier' to commercial development across offices, logistics, and retail. 'In an already high-cost market, this rate adds a substantial upfront cost, undermines project viability, and deters both domestic and international investment,' it said. It recommended a return to the pre-2017 rate of 2 per cent to 'unlock stalled development, ease supply constraints, and support wider economic growth'. The group said businesses are 'increasingly dissatisfied and frustrated' by the lack of delivery of infrastructure by the Government. 'Many do not believe that the investments proposed under the Programme for Government will happen, given past delays,' it said. On water, it said Dublin faces a 'major crisis', and that the provision of water and wastewater in the Greater Dublin Area is 'wholly inadequate and in need of urgent review'. 'The risk of a water shortage due to necessary maintenance and remedial work is high and rising,' it said. 'The lack of water and wastewater is a direct limiting factor on the delivery of affordable accommodation across the Greater Dublin Area. 'Currently, Uisce Éireann has no mandate or increased funding to support the supply of new housing developments. This must change and Government must put in place a multiannual budget for the utility to ensure new housing developments are connected.' At present, the Greater Dublin Area is 'excessively reliant' on a single water source, with 85 per cent coming from the Liffey. The group said the Eastern and Midlands Water Supply Project is 'urgently required' to meet the needs of half of Ireland's population. 'This must be accompanied by the Greater Dublin Drainage Scheme (GDDS), as the need for wastewater facilities has risen in line with the growing population,' it said. 'The need for adequate wastewater facilities and the building of the GDDS cannot be overstated. If this facility is not built, this will have a detrimental effect on the provision of housing.'
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Loyalist activist Jamie Bryson and former Sinn Féin MLA Daithí McKay cleared in Nama misconduct trial
Three men, including loyalist activist Jamie Bryson and former Sinn Féin MLA Daithí McKay, have been cleared at Belfast Crown Court of charges relating to misconduct in public office. Mr Bryson (35), from Rosepark, Donaghadee, Co Down, and co-accused Thomas O'Hara (41), from Lisnahunshin Road, Cullybackey, Co Antrim, were found not guilty of conspiracy to commit misconduct in public office. The charges related to a Stormont finance committee hearing that examined the sale of the National Asset Management Agency's (Nama) Northern Ireland assets in 2015. Mr McKay (43), from Loughan Road, Dunnamanagh, Co Tyrone – who was chairman of the Stormont finance committee at the time – was found not guilty of misconduct in public office. Daithi McKay outside Belfast Crown Court on Thursday. Photograph: Liam McBurney/PA Wire Mr Bryson and Mr McKay said there were questions for the Public Prosecution Service (PPS) to answer over why the prosecution was brought. Trial judge Gordon Kerr KC said he believed Mr Bryson had lied while giving evidence in the case, but said he was not involved in a criminal conspiracy. The long-running trial related to Mr Bryson's 2015 appearance before the committee, chaired by Mr McKay, which was investigating the sale of Nama's Northern Ireland assets to US investment fund Cerberus for £1.2 billion. The criminal inquiry opened after the publication of leaked Twitter messages between Mr Bryson, Mr McKay and the account of Mr O'Hara, who at the time was a Sinn Féin activist in north Co Antrim. Mr McKay quit as an MLA within hours of the messages being published in August 2016. Thomas O'Hara outside Belfast Crown Court on Thursday. Photograph: Liam McBurney/PA Wire Giving evidence to the committee in 2015, Mr Bryson used Assembly privilege to name former DUP leader Peter Robinson as a beneficiary of the sale. The then-first minister strongly rejected any suggestion he benefited from the deal. All other parties involved in the transaction also denied wrongdoing. Delivering his judgment in the non-jury trial on Thursday, Judge Kerr said: 'Despite his lies in court, I am sure that Mr Bryson was at all times communicating with Mr McKay. 'I am sure that the communications were designed to give Mr Bryson the best advice and guidance to maximise his chances of giving evidence. 'My analysis of the messages do not show any occasion where Mr McKay undertook to say or do anything outside his duties as chairman to ensure Mr Bryson's evidence would be in open session.' Clearing Mr Bryson, the judge said the evidence did not establish there had been a criminal conspiracy between him and Mr McKay. 'In the absence of an agreement, the conspiracy charge must fail.' Turning to Mr McKay, the judge said there was 'no doubt he deliberately misled the committee to ease the way for Mr Bryson's presentation'. The judge pointed out the Assembly had its own code of conduct and said there was 'no precedent for a prosecution in these circumstances'. 'I do not consider it my role to expand the offence,' the judge added. He said the evidence against Mr O'Hara 'fell well short' of anything which would convince him of his guilt. Asked outside the court about Judge Kerr's view that he had lied during his evidence, Mr Bryson said: 'Absolutely not, I told the truth about all of my evidence. 'I absolutely didn't; the fact is this, no crime, I am innocent, that is the end of the matter.' He added: 'To drag us through the gutters for 10 years and to top that off with a seven-week trial raises massive questions for the Public Prosecution Service.' Mr McKay's lawyer, Michael Madden, said his client had been vindicated by the judgment. 'Daithí McKay has already paid a heavy price for the decision of the PPS to prosecute this case. He was placed in a legal pressure cooker for 10 years and has had to endure a seven-week trial.' – PA
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Former John Barleycorn hotel site poised for a healthy makeover
THE long-vacant site of the former John Barleycorn Hotel, destroyed by fire in 2006, is set for redevelopment as a primary care centre. Permission for the c 36,000sq ft (3,313sq m) one-stop healthcare hub in Riverstown, Glanmire, clears the way for productive use of the brownfield site, which has lain idle for almost 20 years. Artist's impression of the proposed Valley Healthcare Primary Care Centre in Riverstown, Glanmire The hotel, which began life as a coach stop in the 18th century, was repeatedly targeted by vandals and was demolished in 2008 to make way for a mixed-use development, including a foodstore, a 67-bed hotel, a gaelscoil, a leisure centre with a 25m swimming pool and substantial underground parking. However, the proposal 'fell victim to the economic recession and was never built' — as per planning documents submitted by HW Planning on behalf of current developers Valley Healthcare Fund/Infrastructure Investment Fund, who have been given the go-ahead to build the new primary care centre. The John Barleycorn in Rivestown on fire in August 2006. Picture: Jim Jamel Valley Healthcare is also planning a €20m-plus 55,000sq ft primary care centre on the former Douglas Woollen Mills site, south of Cork City. The project was approved by Cork City Council, but appealed to An Coimisiún Pleanála, with a decision due in early August. The fund has a presence in Cork since 2018, when it opened a primary care centre in Midleton. It acquired two more the following year in Carrigtwohill and Fermoy. Last year, it opened another in Ballincollig, at the former Murphy Barracks site. The Glanmire project was refused planning by Cork City Council in January on the grounds of flood risk — the Glashaboy River is nearby — but the planning board reversed the decision. Aerial picture of the former John Barleycorn site The 1ha site — part of a larger landholding of 2.25ha — is now set for redevelopment as a part two-storey/three-storey primary care centre, to include a retail unit and two GP practices. The land parcel is south of Old Court Rd and west of East Cliff Rd, where a Lidl supermarket and Sarsfield Hurling Club are located. Peggy McTeggart receiving a guard of honour as she arrives at the John Barleycorn, Glanmire, at a function to honour her achievements after her pupils captured seven trophies at the All-Ireland dancing championship held in Derry. Picture: Eddie O'Hare John O'Callaghan Park is immediately to the south, and the permitted Glanmire & Riverstown Greenway will provide direct pedestrian and cycle connections to the park and beyond. The site has been the subject of various proposals in the past, including a plan to expand the John Barleycorn Hotel, after developer/investor Joe O'Donovan bought it for a reported €5m in 2004 — with Rebel Bar group input. Scoil Mhuire Debs Ball at John Barleycorn Hotel, 1976. Actress Fiona Shaw, seated, front left. It was put on the market again in 2012 for a reported €2.5m. Clyda Eco Homes Ltd, whose directors are Barry Coleman and Patricia Carty, are the current owners, although the land is likely to transfer to Valley Healthcare following the grant of planning permission. It's understood the sale of the land to Valley Healthcare was contingent on a successful planning application. A source close to the deal, who did not want to be named, said it was 'welcome news for Glanmire, and hopefully will facilitate the development of the site, after so many years lying idle'. Glanmire's population is close to 10,000 and Valley Healthcare said in its submission to the planning board there was a demand for a primary care centre in the area, now classified as an 'urban town'. The new centre is likely to operate under an operational lease model, with the HSE leasing it from Valley Healthcare. A similar arrangement is in place for the planned Woollen Mills primary care centre. Valley Healthcare, now owned by international investor John Laing, has about 20 primary care centres across Ireland, with at least half a dozen more in the pipeline. They provide single point of access to outpatient care to local communities, offering patients a full range of non-acute healthcare and social services. Valley generates revenue through rental and service income, coming from the HSE and other tenants. Tenants in the centress typically include GP practices, pharmacies, and ancillary healthcare tenants.
