logo
Regulator finds ‘concerning' evidence of poor handling of insurance claims

Regulator finds ‘concerning' evidence of poor handling of insurance claims

Leader Live12 hours ago
The regulator said that, while rising motor insurance premiums are largely driven by external cost pressures, shortcomings persist in how some insurers handle claims.
FCA analysis indicated that increases in the cost of motor claims – due to higher prices for cars, parts, labour, energy and more complex cars and supply chains – have contributed to premium increases.
The cost of hire vehicles, the number and cost of theft claims and uninsured drivers have also risen significantly. This confirms that increased costs outside of firms' control, rather than firm profit, were the biggest cause of recent premium rises in motor insurance.
But the FCA did identify that referral fees from credit hire firms and claims management companies were associated with slower claims processing and increasing costs.
Where it has seen poor practice from firms, the regulator said it is addressing it directly with them, including taking action against specific firms where necessary.
The regulator said that 'concerning' evidence of poor claims handling practices included a lack of oversight of outsourced services, resulting in poor customer outcomes, delays in settling claims and high complaint volumes.
It also found evidence of insufficient management information, resulting in failures to promptly identify and resolve claims handling issues.
Cash settlements were also being used in some cases without sufficient consideration of whether they are most suitable, the regulator said.
The FCA also highlighted high rejection rates for storm damage claims, saying only 32% of such claims made to a sample of firms in 2024 resulted in a payment.
The regulator is also providing evidence for coordinated action from Government, industry, and other regulators, as part of the Government's motor taskforce, to help drive down the cost of motor premiums. This could help limit cost increases but it cannot prevent them, the FCA said.
It has also published an interim update of an ongoing premium finance market study investigating whether consumers receive fair value when choosing to pay for insurance in monthly instalments.
While premium finance allows customers to spread costs, making them affordable and providing flexibility, the regulator has found some firms earn much more money than it costs to provide the service. It will explore these concerns further in the next phase of the study.
The FCA said it will seek to tackle any issues it finds first through the Consumer Duty, publishing a final report by the end of 2025.
Sarah Pritchard, deputy chief executive of the FCA, said: 'Insurance provides peace of mind but people must be confident they can get a fair deal and be treated right when the worst happens.
'External cost pressures are primarily to blame for recent motor premium increases, not increased firm profits, but there is some more work to do on claims handling, particularly in home and travel. That's why we're stepping up – making sure claims are handled promptly and fairly and pushing for a coordinated effort to tackle the root causes of rising motor premiums.
'A well-functioning insurance market helps consumers navigate their financial lives and supports growth by building people's resilience to financial and personal shocks.'
The FCA also said that evaluation of previous pricing reforms showed they are having the intended impact on the price gap between new and existing customers in both the motor and home markets.
This means its reforms were effective in curbing 'price walking' where loyal customers were charged more at renewal, the regulator said.
Association of British Insurers (ABI) director general Hannah Gurga said: 'The FCA's findings confirm that record-breaking claims costs are behind recent increases in motor insurance premiums.
'They also demonstrate that many of these cost pressures – such as rising vehicle repair costs, part shortages and increased thefts – stem from issues beyond the industry's direct control, making collaboration essential to find sustainable, long-term solutions.
'Ensuring a smooth and stress-free claims process is crucial for customers when going through what can already be incredibly difficult circumstances. Our members work hard to achieve this, but we will engage with them and the regulator to understand what improvements can be made in the claims handling journey, to ensure good outcomes for customers and to support trust and confidence in the industry.'
James Daley, managing director at Fairer Finance, said: 'As things stand, consumers continue to struggle to understand the differences between insurance products.'
He added: 'But even if consumers manage to buy a product that meets their needs, they still have no reliable way of knowing whether the insurer will treat them fairly at claims stage. And the FCA's research shows that there is a wide difference in standards at this crucial moment.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Insurance firms slammed for adding up to £51 a year to bills paid in monthly instalments
Insurance firms slammed for adding up to £51 a year to bills paid in monthly instalments

The Sun

time24 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Insurance firms slammed for adding up to £51 a year to bills paid in monthly instalments

INSURANCE firms have been slammed for adding up to £51 a year to bills paid in monthly instalments. Customers may also pay more for the initial premium in a practice called 'double dipping'. The Financial Conduct Authority said monthly bill payers face APRs of 20-30 per cent, adding £19-£28 to home insurance and £35-£51 to car insurance costs. With about half of such policies paid monthly in 2023, many customers are hit with these extra costs simply because they can't afford annual payments. Consumer group Which? director Rocio Concha urged the FCA to crack down on 'bad practice'. She said too many customers are forced into higher costs out of financial necessity. Insurers claim the charges reflect the cost of the agreements. But the FCA's rules state that premiums must not be increased without a 'reasonable basis'. The Association Of British Insurers insists its members follow 'fair and transparent' principles. Earlier this year Which? revealed that some firms charge APRs comparable to credit card rates, with One Insurance Solution and The Insurance Factory imposing above 30 per cent. The FCA also found motor insurance claims were subject to delays, lack of oversight on outsourced services and high complaint levels. It is taking action against the companies involved. FOOD CRUNCH GROCERY bills are biting harder as food prices rise at their fastest rate in 18 months. Inflation hit 5.2 per cent this month, adding an average £275 to annual spending, Worldpanel data showed. Grocery spending rose 4.6 per cent in the 12 weeks to July 13, with online grocer Ocado leading growth at 11.7 per cent. Lidl grew 11.1 per cent while leader Tesco saw a 7.1 per cent sales increase. RANSOMS BAN PUBLIC sector organisations including the NHS, schools and councils will be banned from paying ransoms to cybercriminals. Security Minister Dan Jarvis pledged to 'smash the cybercriminal business model' and safeguard essential services. Businesses outside the ban must now tell authorities before paying ransoms. The new rules come after attacks on Marks & Spencer and the Co-Op. GOOD WORKS PAY OFF THE WORKS is celebrating success in its turnaround strategy as profits surged 20 per cent to £8.3million. The books and stationery retailer saw 6.4 per cent growth in like-for-like sales in its final quarter, driven by improved store standards and new products, despite a 2 per cent dip in annual revenues. Online sales struggled but store sales led the charge. Boss Gavin Peck highlighted strong trading in the new financial year, with sales up 5 per cent. Shares jumped 9.4 per cent yesterday

Rachel Reeves warned that deregulation risks financial crisis
Rachel Reeves warned that deregulation risks financial crisis

Times

timean hour ago

  • Times

Rachel Reeves warned that deregulation risks financial crisis

The governor of the Bank of England has warned Rachel Reeves that cutting red tape on the banking sector risks sparking another financial crisis as he downplayed the rise in UK government debt costs. Andrew Bailey told a group of influential MPs on Tuesday that rolling back restrictions on the City and ditching bank ringfencing guidelines could destabilise the UK financial system and 'would not be [a] sensible' decision for the time being. In a near two-hour long session with the Treasury select committee before the parliamentary summer recess, Bailey also said that the rise in long-term government debt costs was not 'unique' to the UK. He said investors were ditching US assets to curb their exposure to the dollar owing to concerns about the economy since President Trump returned to the White House. The governor, who, alongside his role at the central bank, recently took up the chairmanship of the Financial Stability Board, said he could understand why some people would think that 'the financial crisis is now way in the past, we've got past that, that's all solved, that's all out of the way, move on'. However, he said that 'for those of us who were veterans of sorting the problems of [the financial crisis] out' there remained a live threat to financial stability which required lawmakers to retain robust regulations. His comments come after the chancellor told bankers at the annual Mansion House dinner this month that the UK's regulatory regime was a 'boot on the neck' of businesses which risked 'choking [them] off'. Bailey, 66, said he would not have used such phrasing. Reeves announced that the government would reform laws that require lenders to separate their retail and investment banking businesses, a requirement put in place after the 2008 global financial crisis to shield depositors from banks' riskier activities. Several City grandees, including Sir John Vickers, the architect of the ringfencing rules, have expressed concern at the government's deregulation drive, which is intended to reverse weak economic growth. Bailey also downplayed the rise in UK government borrowing costs and said that it was part of a worldwide trend created by Trump's volatile tariff policymaking and a general rise in public deficit spending. 'We've seen an increase in term premium in government bond markets… yield curves have steepened', Bailey said, adding this was 'a global phenomenon, it is not in any sense unique [to the UK]'. The rate on the 30-year UK government bond, or gilt, stands at 5.43 per cent, up from 4.67 per cent compared to a year ago. The yield, which moves inversely to prices, on the US equivalent has risen to 4.93 per cent from 4.48 per cent over the same period. Bailey's comments come as figures from the Office for National Statistics on Tuesday showed that UK debt interest spending jumped to £16.4 billion in June, the second-highest for that month since the records began in 1997. Government borrowing topped £20 billion in the month also, above the Office for Budget Responsibility's projection for the month, strengthening expectations for tax increases at the autumn budget. Trump's erratic decision-making on how much to tax imports from specific countries had led to 'rebalancing' among markets 'which involves a reduction in exposure to dollar assets', Bailey said. The dollar index, which measures the greenback against six comparable currencies, is down nearly 10 per cent since the start of the year. The governor said that, judging by conversations with market participants and based on granular data, 'the most crowded trade in the market at the moment is short dollar'. He said that since Trump first announced his 'reciprocal tariffs' in April, there had been 'a breakdown in established correlations in markets'. Stock markets globally jolted lower in the immediate aftermath of Trump's first tariff announcements, with the S&P 500 index posting one of its largest losses since the Great Depression. However, an equity rally has since pushed several indices to a record high. This week, the FTSE 100 closed at its highest-ever level of just over 9,000 points. Taxes on goods imported to the US from most countries will increase sharply from August 1 after Trump delayed the implementation of his 'reciprocal tariffs' several times.

I care more about getting a family on the housing ladder than snails
I care more about getting a family on the housing ladder than snails

The Independent

time3 hours ago

  • The Independent

I care more about getting a family on the housing ladder than snails

Rachel Reeves has said that she cares 'more about getting a young family on the housing ladder than I do about protecting some snails' as she defended the Government's planning bill. Speaking to the House of Lords economic affairs committee on Tuesday, the Chancellor urged parliamentarians to get the flagship Planning and Infrastructure Bill into law quickly as ministers look to reach their targets on housebuilding and major projects. The Chancellor was facing questions on Government amendments to the legislation designed to strengthen environmental protections, which one peer suggested would 'make it easier' than in the original plans 'to block and delay things'. The Government has pledged to reach decisions on 150 infrastructure projects and building 1.5 million homes over the course of this Parliament. The Chancellor said that ministers are of the view that their amendments do not 'water down' or 'weaken' the bill, and asked for people to be 'sympathetic' towards the legislation as it heads towards the statute book. Ms Reeves, who represents the Leeds West and Pudsey seat went on: 'The reason that HS2 is not coming to my city of Leeds anymore anytime soon, is because I'm afraid, as a country, we've cared more about the bats than we have about the commuter times for people in Leeds and West Yorkshire, and we've got to change that, 'Because I care more about a young family getting on the housing ladder than I do about protecting some snails, and I care more about my energy bills and my constituents than I do about the views of people from their windows.' A £100 million tunnel to protect bats along the route of the high-speed rail project has been singled out by ministers for criticism.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store