
TD criticised for saying Irish people may become 'minority in our own country'
The comments were made on the plinth in Leinster House amid questions from the media regarding the upcoming presidential election.
Mr O'Donoghue stated that Independent Ireland wanted to "have a presidential candidate that reflects this country, that will go out of this country and represent us outside this country".
He said: "Whether you're urban or rural and all the cultures of Ireland, we want someone that will represent our culture in this country, so that it's not obliterated.
"We welcome other cultures in here. We do that, and 100 per cent.
"But we also want to make sure the Irish culture is recognised and set in stone."
When asked by members of the media what he meant, Mr O'Donoghue said he has "no problem" with an "international candidate" once that person represents the country and "protects all culture, including the Irish culture".
He continued: "If it's somebody that's running from the north of Ireland, to me they're Irish.
"If it's somebody that's running internationally, once they want to protect our culture in this country and all the other cultures that come in here and enhance that, 100 per cent I'm behind it.
"Ireland has a great culture. You go to Australia, you go anywhere, they love the Irish and our culture.
"But what I want to make sure is that ours is protected here, regardless of what cultures come in here.
"We recognise all other people's cultures, as we do when we go to other countries, we recognise.
"I want our own protected."
Mr O'Donoghue said that when people travel abroad, they have to respect different rules and norms. He gave the example of Dubai and stated that you could not enter some mosques unless you were covered up.
He said that when people move to Ireland, they need to respect Irish culture in the same way, including religion.
Mr O'Donoghue said he "loves learning [about] other cultures", including food.
He said that communities are created when everyone shares their cultural standpoint and learns about one another.
However, he repeated that Irish culture "needs to be protected".
He stated that five million people live in Ireland currently, up from "2.9 million, three million."
Mr O'Donoghue continued: "That means the Irish people here could end up in a minority in years to come. So that's why I want our culture.
"By 2040, they want to increase this country to 10 million people. If we only had 3 million, and 10 million is the prediction for 2040, then you're a minority in our own country.
"We're not going to produce 7 million people in this country ourselves, are we?. Then we become a minority in our own country.
"Protect all cultures. Protect our own and we can all live together happily and gracefully."
Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon branded the comments as "pathetic", while his colleague Jennifer Whitmore branded them "ridiculous" and "untrue".
She said: "Irish people are not at risk.
"Our culture is strong and part of our culture is being inclusive and welcoming people in the same way that we expected other nations to look after us when we needed to go overseas.
"I think to have a public representative saying something like that, I think it is very concerning."

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Taoiseach accuses Pearse Doherty of ‘asserting falsehoods' over claim Japan flight rebooked for hurling semi-final
Micheál Martin accused Pearse Doherty TD of "asserting falsehoods" and "poor politics" when he made the suggestion, based on media reports. He also said there was no additional cost from a late decision to fly east, via Toronto, rather than west, via Dubai. But the Taoiseach then said the final costs "haven't been reconciled," but would be published in due course on his Department's website. The story was "unequivocally and categorically" wrong, he said, because the Cork v Dublin All-Ireland hurling semi-final was due to begin at 5pm. One flight would have landed him back in the capital at 8am and the other at noon, so he was going to see the match in either case, he said. He indeed attended Croke Park to see his native county's famous win. The Finance committee was discussing revised estimates when Mr Doherty said: "Your travel made the media recently. You returned from a trip to Japan, and you rebooked that trip home through Toronto. "It is suggested that that was on the basis of security advice. Can you explain, if that is the case, why you didn't share the security advice with any of the media corps who were travelling, in relation to their security?" Mr Martin replied: "It's a nonsense story. It is important that the context is made very clear. The story is suggesting there was a rescheduling to do with the match. There wasn't. "The alternative would have had me in at 12 o'clock. The way I went, I came in at eight. I had nothing to do with it. I don't book the travel. "And in terms of the security at the time, these were booked a week in advance. And in the Middle East there are issues, as we all know. It was a precautionary approach." Mr Doherty asked him to explain why, if it was security advice that avoided the risk of flying through Dubai, he had not shared that information "with other Irish citizens who were accompanying you on the trip." Mr Martin said: "Two things. First of all, there wasn't additional cost as a result of that, to my knowledge. I don't get into the minutiae of the routes. "Anybody who's a journalist sent out by their media organisation, they take their own advices. They organise their own travel and so forth. "The people who were organising on my behalf took a view that the Middle East was problematic in terms of cancelations and in terms of activity. "That's what I've been told." Mr Doherty said it was "a bit bizarre", saying the Taoiseach had suggested it was "more about [onward flight] cancellation, as opposed to anything personally happening yourself." Instead of "an abundance of caution," he said the Taoiseach "flew through Toronto because there was a risk of cancelation, and therefore you would miss the match." Mr Martin said the assertion was wrong. "I just want to unequivocally say to you, and categorically -- like the truth does matter on these matters - this had nothing to do with the match. "The match was on at five o'clock that day. So either route would have got me in at eight or 12. "This has nothing to do with budget spending, it's just political. That's what you're at, and it's regrettable." Mr Martin said that the switch was "to mitigate any risk of flight cancelations," Mr Doherty said. "You would have missed the match. That is simple fact, because the security situation already had resulted in extensive Middle East airspace being closed in the days prior to this being booked." Mr Martin snapped: "You're not asking a question. You're asserting falsehoods. And you don't want to allow a reasonable, rational explanation to be given."


RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
GAA Palestine denied visas for summer tour of Ireland
GAA Palestine has said a group of its players and mentors have had their their visa applications denied by the Irish Immigration Service ahead of summer tour. A team of 33 children and 14 mentors were due to travel to Ireland for a summer tour, but have been denied entry. GAA Palestine had sought clarity on the status of their visa applications, and were due to arrive in Ireland on 18 July. In a post on social media, the club said: "Our Irish visa applications for the GAA Palestine summer tour have been refused by the Irish Immigration Service. "To say that we are deeply disappointed is an understatement. We will be appealing this decision imminently. "Our hearts right now are with the 33 young hurlers & 14 mentors who are so looking forward to being welcomed to Ireland next week. "Against all odds, we're doing all we can to make this tour happen. We're not giving up hope... " Lack of compliance to application criteria In a statement provided to RTÉ News, the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration cited a lack of compliance to visa application criteria as reasons for visa denials. "Each visa application is decided on its own merits. Confirming that appropriate child protection requirements are in place is essential when considering visa applications for minors," the statement said. "This includes a requirement that a child is travelling with their parents or an appropriate guardian, which requires additional documents to be verified such as birth certificates and consent letters. "In adult cases, evidence of financial means, employment or other ties that indicate a person intends to return home are important criteria. These help to establish that a person has a legitimate reason to come to Ireland, and that they will comply with the conditions of a short-term visa. "An application will be refused if it cannot demonstrate compliance with such conditions. An appeals process is available to anyone who has a visa application refused." Criticism of decision The refusal to award the visas to the club has drawn criticism, with Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald calling on the Government to resolve the issue. "What on Earth is the Irish government at?! They say they stand with Palestine but delay visas for a small number of children seriously injured in Israel's genocide coming to Ireland for urgent medical treatment," she said in a post on X. What on Earth is the Irish government at?! They say they stand with Palestine but delay visas for a small number of children seriously injured in Israel's genocide coming to Ireland for urgent medical treatment Now, they refuse visas for children living through a daily onslaught… — Mary Lou McDonald (@MaryLouMcDonald) July 9, 2025 "Now, they refuse visas for children living through a daily onslaught who were due to come here for a few weeks to play hurling and football. GAA clubs across the country were busy preparing for their arrival. Children now left devastated. "The government needs to sort this out!"


Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Visas for 46 Palestinians denied by Irish Immigration Service ahead of upcoming GAA tour
Group included 33 children aged between 9 and 16 GAA Palestine Chair, Stephen Redmond and other adult is a Coach from Moataz Sarsour Club in Al Am'ari Camp, named Mohammad GAA Palestine has been told that the visas for 46 Palestinians planning to travel to Ireland - including 33 children aged between nine and 16 – have been denied by the Irish Immigration Service. The group of Palestinians were scheduled to tour Ireland from July 18 to August 1. The tour was set to see Irish and Palestinian children engage in friendly hurling matches across Ireland, showing children from the war-torn area the most important GAA sites in Ireland. International Spokesperson for GAA Palestine and Clare woman, Claire Liddy, told the Irish Independent that officials in the Irish Immigration Service claimed they have not received the correct documentation from the group. 'They said that they don't have the documentation… we've sent them the documentation multiple times,' Ms Liddy said. 'I have screenshots [of sending the documentation], because you can't get a receipt [from the website]. They have added new documents that we were never ever asked for, ever. They sat on this. 'This is being done purposefully, we know of several other groups [that it has also happened to]. This is being done to stop Palestinians from coming to Ireland – children. Palestinian children at hurling training with GAA Palestine. Image: Claire Liddy 'I am absolutely furious. We have been chasing them for weeks… Why would Tel Aviv send the file to Ireland if they didn't have all the documents? They said they didn't have a detailed itinerary; I sent them three pages of an itinerary. We sent them everything that they asked for. They said that they needed Garda vetting – they had never asked for that. 'I am livid. We will be going further with this.' The news comes after the group launched a large media campaign to get the visas issued in time for the 46-person trip. Ms Liddy said applications for the 46 visas were put in back in May, with the usual waiting period for a visa between Ireland and Tel Aviv being four weeks. GAA Palestine Chair, Stephen Redmond and other adult is a Coach from Moataz Sarsour Club in Al Am'ari Camp, named Mohammad After eight weeks of waiting, the group had to cancel the trip they had planned to Derry and Belfast as the visa application to the North of Ireland needed proof of a successful visa to the Republic of Ireland. Now, it is unlikely the group will be able to travel at all. In a statement on GAA Palestine's Instagram, the group said they are 'deeply disappointed' but 'not giving up hope'. GAA Palestine has been encouraging the public to write to their local TDs and other government representatives to allow these 46 Palestinians to complete the tour they have been 'dreaming' of. GAA Palestine volunteers from across Ireland and the West Bank Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 9th