Why single out Helen Zille's age and race?
Editor Sifiso Mahlangu wasted no time in announcing Helen Zille's age and race in his opinion piece, 'In the DA, upward mobility is conditional' (The Star, June 17).
This smacks of ageism, racism and selectivity. He forgot to mention Zille's struggle credentials and her sterling work on the anti-apartheid newspaper, the Rand Daily Mail, under the stewardship of the late Allister Sparks.
Mahlangu also seems to have forgotten that black DA (Democratic Alliance) candidates have been given the chance at the mayoral seat. One male DA mayor left for reasons of his own, while one young female medical doctor, Mpho Phalatse, was hounded out of office before she could even prove herself.
After Phalatse, we saw some incompetents warming the mayoral seat, one or two with dubious credentials. Under their watch, Johannesburg, the so-called World-Class African City, has been reduced to a slum, with crime and corruption rampant.
No doubt Zille is a polarizing and abrasive figure, but if she can kick butt and restore this city to its pristine place among South Africa's metros, why not give her the chance to do so?
To single out Zille's age and race is mischievous. Progressive Western nations do not have a mandatory (compulsory) retirement age as we do.
Some of our competent, NRF-rated academics, for example, are forced to retire at age 65 and are expected to play with their grandkids or fill in crossword puzzles!
As for Helen Zille being white, I thought we were a non-racial society?
Harry Sewlall
Parkmore
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
5 minutes ago
- Daily Maverick
Policing crisis is symptom of SA's transition into a violent democracy
South Africa has undergone a second transition, away from the ideals of a constitutional democracy, first into a gatekeeper state, and then increasingly into what academics call a 'violent democracy'. President Cyril Ramaphosa recently established a judicial commission of inquiry, chaired by Acting Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga, to investigate Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi's allegations that 'sophisticated criminal syndicates have infiltrated law enforcement and intelligence structures in South Africa'. Naturally, much of the attention has been on the toxic relationship between ANC politicians, corrupt businesspeople and the country's top police structures. However, while it is tempting to believe that this is just another example of the rot infecting the South African state, this would be a mistake, because these activities are not an aberration of South Africa's weak state but rather an outcome of the dysfunctional democratisation process that has unfolded in the country over the last few decades. Gatekeeper state In common with many other post-independent African states, South Africa transitioned from the horrors of colonialism and racism into being a gatekeeper state. In these fragile states, the control of access to wealth and power, rather than governance, is the ultimate political prize. Over time, state wealth and power are increasingly centralised and contested among the elites, while service delivery and governance for most of the population languish at the periphery. Political authority is therefore less about guiding national development and more about managing the intersection between internal resources and external recognition. At its core, a gatekeeper state revolves around who controls the 'gate'. In South Africa, this gate was historically guarded by the ANC so long as there was uncontested electoral recognition. Governance, in this framework, becomes a zero-sum game where controlling the gate is paramount because losing power means losing access to wealth. This has irredeemably reshaped the internal dynamics of the ANC, fuelling factionalism as different groups within the party compete for control of shrinking state resources. Consequently, the government is increasingly unable to meet its service delivery obligations because public office is not about public service but is instead a means of ensuring financial rewards, and because service delivery is not about optimal provision within the budgetary limits but is instead a means to garner political loyalty. Over time, as the ANC's factional battles worsened, the ANC's response has been to centralise control, consolidating authority in the Presidency, marginalising Parliament, and actively eroding independent institutions. However, as the ANC's electoral support has declined, gatekeeping, instead of weakening, has decentralised and now infects both formal and informal political-economic structures. The consequence of this system is neo-patrimonialism — ruling by patronage rather than by policy — that replaces governance as hollowed-out formal institutions are replaced with informal networks based on political allegiance and reciprocal favours. Loyalty is rewarded not through public service delivery or national development, but instead by access to tenders, jobs, and contracts. As the electorate loses faith in political leadership, political support is 'purchased' via patronage networks rather than earned through effective governance. Violent democracy The implications for South Africa's democratisation have been grim. In the years of the Zuma-Ramaphosa presidencies, South Africa has undergone a second transition, away from the ideals of a constitutional democracy, first into a gatekeeper state, and increasingly into what academics call a ' violent democracy '. This is not merely a democracy with violence. In this aberrant form of democracy, violence is an implicit part of the political system. Assassinations, intimidation and State Capture are features of how power is contested, contained, and controlled. In a violent democracy the state does not have the sole legitimate right to use violence — instead elite coalitions, criminal networks, and even taxi associations can use violence to capture and replace democratic governance. Naturally, as violent democracy deepens, constitutional democracy weakens. South Africa's democratic institutions, once the pride of our post-apartheid dispensation, are now infected with corruption, inefficiency and decay. The ANC cannot be reformed, but whether the Government of National Unity can resurrect the democratic institutions of accountability and reverse the country from its dark path remains to be seen. If not, then the dream of a free, fair, and equal South Africa will likely become just another casualty of rapacious greed. DM
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
Inkosi Zuma's arrest: New murder charges emerge in DA chief whip's death
Umngeni Municipality Mayor Chris Pappas, his deputy mayor Sandile Mnikathi, and DA provincial leader Francois Rodgers attending the appearance of Inkosi Simphiwe Zuma at the Howick Magistrate's Court for the murder of DA Chief Whip Nhlalayenza Ndlovu. Image: Bongani Hans It is not raining but pouring for a traditional leader who is related to former president Jacob Zuma, as he has been sent back to holding cells now for the murder of the DA chief whip Nhlalayenza Ndlovu in 2023. Amanxamalala Traditional Authority's Inkosi Simphiwe Zuma, who gained popularity because of his proximity to the uMkhonto weSizwe Party leader, was arrested together with 26-year-old Thabo Mathonsi-Chonco on Wednesday, barely a month after being released on bail for a separate murder case. Although the latest charges against Inkosi Zuma remain unclear, Mathonsi-Chonco is accused of conspiracy to commit murder and murder of Ndlovu on December 23, 2023. The Howick Magistrate's Court, Court A, where the accused appeared from holding cells, was fully packed with DA members, Inkosi Zuma's supporters, and other members of the public who were interested in the matter. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading In the dock, Inkosi Zuma and Mathonsi-Chonco joined their two co-accused in the matter related to Ndlovu's murder, Thobani Hlongwa, and Khayelisha Shabalala. The matter was postponed to August 8 for a bail application. Another co-accused, Zwelithini Buthelezi, his induna, was not in court. A source, who is a court official, told this reporter that Buthelezi's charges were withdrawn on July 29 after he agreed to testify for the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) under Section 204. Inkosi Zuma and Buthelezi are also facing another murder charge of killing Zuma's head of izinduna, Qalokunye Zuma, on January 23, 2023. In that charge, Inkosi was granted R25,000 bail on July 3 after his arrest on June 13; however, Buthelezi, who had already been denied bail in Ndlovu's murder case, did not apply for it. He was arrested for Ndlovu's murder almost a month after being freed on bail from holding cells by Impendle Magistrate's Court in connection with Qalokunye Zuma's murder. During Thursday's court appearance, the Howick court only dealt with Mathonsi-Chonco, who wanted to be transferred from Westville Prison in Durban to Pietermaritzburg's New Prison. His lawyer, Nkomo, who refused to give his first name, stated that his client wished to be transferred to Pietermaritzburg due to ill health and that the city fell within the jurisdiction of the Howick court. However, Prosecutor Advocate Elvis Gcweka rejected the request, saying that the accused might collude with Buthelezi, who is being held in Pietermaritzburg. Magistrate Ntini rejected Mathonsi-Chonco's request. 'As the State has its fears, I don't see the problem in keeping the accused at Westville. If he is unwell, he can get medical treatment while kept in Westville,' said Ntini. Outside the court, Inkosi Zuma's relative, who cannot be named as he is not appointed to speak for the family, said it was shocking that Inkosi has been arrested for another murder. 'When we thought things were difficult, they just got worse,' he said. The DA has been fighting to see justice from the day Ndlovu was gunned down in cold blood in front of his children and wife, and after the case had gone cold, the party hired AfriForum private investigators who were able to gather information and gave it to the police. It was believed that Ndlovu was killed at his home to shut him up from spilling the beans about Buthelezi's alleged theft of electricity transformers, which were illegally connected and power sold to residents of newly developed villages outside Mpophomeni township, who were without electricity. Buthelezi is still facing charges in connection with electricity theft. Qalokunye Zuma was also killed at his rural Impendle home in front of his family members and patrons of his shebeen, allegedly following a dispute over the affairs of the Nxamalala traditional authority. During his bail hearing in Impendle court, it was revealed that Inkosi Zuma, who is facing charges of conspiracy to commit murder, murder, possession of illegal firearms, and ammunition, paid R30,000 to hitmen to eliminate Qalokunye Zuma. Police obtained this information when they analysed Buthelezi's cellphone records, who they had been hunting for Ndlovu's murder. Impendle court Magistrate Bongiwe Nhlapo told Inkosi Zuma that his bail conditions were that he must report in person to the Impendle police station every Monday and Friday between 8.30am and 4.30pm. Umngeni Municipality Mayor Chris Pappas said while people might be shocked by Inkosi's implication in Ndlovu's murder, 'some of us are not'. 'The DA has an investigating team working on this, doing proper oversight over the police investigation. 'Our investigation team has come to the same conclusion in terms of the number of people that have been arrested,' said Pappas.
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Cape Town's lost threads: How tariffs unravelled our clothing industry
We remember the profound impact of tariff reductions had on Cape Town's clothing industry. Image: Wikipedia It's fascinating the way the world has suddenly latched onto the word "tariffs" since Donald Trump has once again become president. But for me, who grew up in Cape Town, that word carries a much heavier weight than just a headline. It brings back a flood of memories, tinged with a deep sadness for what we lost. Thirty years ago, when our own government started cutting tariffs, especially with China, we watched as the heart of Cape Town's clothing industry was ripped out. It was a lifeline for so many, and its destruction left scars that still run deep. Growing up in the Southern suburbs, my wardrobe was built almost entirely from the factory shops. Every clothing manufacturer had these "side doors" open to the public, overflowing with garments at a fraction of the retail price. It taught me a lifelong habit of never needing a clothing account because quality clothes were simply affordable for everyone. I remember the chaos of entering Venus, one of the biggest factory shops in Lansdowne, run by the Patel family. Huge wooden crates would be piled high with overruns of the latest fashion. Mrs. Patel, always in her silk sari and gleaming gold jewellery, would stand on a platform like a queen, barking orders at staff to repack the mountains of clothes. Then there was Beeline, more organised, almost like a proper retail shop, selling fashion items practically at cost. The real giant was the Seardel group They dominated underwear manufacturing, churning out Triumph underwear and Speedo swimsuits for export around the globe. Their factory shop was always buzzing with women searching for top-quality items at amazing prices. Aaron and Adele Searle the couple behind it, were some of Cape Town's real philanthropists, often seen in the Cape Times society pages for their charitable work. They started with a small factory in Salt River, making nurses' caps, and built an empire that became the largest clothing and textile producer on the African continent, employing over 10,000 people at its peak. Then came the tariff reductions in the mid-1990s, a consequence of South Africa joining the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and embracing trade liberalisation. Suddenly, cheap imports, particularly from China, flooded our markets. Local manufacturers, burdened by higher production costs, simply couldn't compete. The impact was devastating. The South African clothing and textile industry, once a significant employer, shed tens of thousands of jobs and saw countless factories close their doors. Seardel, that mighty empire, went into liquidation in 2018, unable to withstand the relentless pressure. Salt River Main Road, once lined with suit manufacturers like Rex Trufom, Fabiani, and Ralph Lauren Polo, which exported men's and women's business suits to high-end consumers worldwide, became a shadow of its former self. We used to buy a men's suit for less than half the retail price, and if it didn't fit, a seamstress on site would tailor it for a few extra rand. I recall being in Harrods in London and seeing a pair of khaki cotton Polo chinos for £150 (around R3,500). I hesitated, knowing I'd be back in Cape Town soon, and sure enough, I found the exact same chinos at Access Park for R150. Who could forget Ronald Sassoon jeans? In the 80s, they were a big deal, our South African answer to Guess Jeans, with iconic marketing campaigns shot in Cape Town, featuring glamorous models next to vintage cars. That brand, too, saw its journey changed by the tides of trade. It wasn't just Cape Town. In Durban, Clairwood, once the vibrant heart of South Africa's shoe manufacturing industry, became a ghost town, a direct result of the influx of cheap imported footwear. So, as tariffs once again hit the headlines, perhaps those countries with thriving local industries should pause and consider. Thirty years on, we in South Africa live with the stark reality of what trade liberalisation and reduced tariffs can truly do to local manufacturers and economies. It's a cautionary tale of the empty factories and lost livelihoods of our once-thriving clothing industry. IOL Lifestyle Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
