‘You did it': Doc who treated mushroom killer Erin Patterson tells how he knew she was a ‘heinous' murderer in minutes
Dr Chris Webster treated the Leongatha, Victoria, mother and now-
9
Infamous convicted mushroom killer Erin Patterson
Credit: AFP
9
The partially eaten beef wellington
Credit: AFP
9
Erin Patterson checking herself out of hospital
9
Patterson, 49, had cooked a beef wellington with lethal death cap mushrooms and intentionally fed it to four guests, killing three, for lunch in July 2023.
Webster he had spent the next morning treating two of the poisoned four only for Patterson to turn up complaining of gastro, he
Within minutes, Webster knew she was a cold-blooded killer.
The doctor said: "I thought, 'Okay, yep, you did it, you heinous individual. You've poisoned them all'."
Read more on world news
The at-home chef was also convicted of one count of attempted murder against local pastor Ian Wilkinson - Heather's husband - in the Supreme Court of Victoria.
Webster had first treated Heather and Ian at Leongatha Hospital the next morning after the lunch with intense gastroenteritis-like symptoms.
He initially believed it was a case of mass food poisoning and through quizzing his patients suspected the meat in the beef wellington was the culprit.
Most read in The US Sun
Webster said: "I did ask Heather at one stage what the beef Wellington tasted like and she said it was delicious."
The doctor took Heather and Ian's blood samples and then sent them for analysis to a larger town with better facilities than the small rural Leongatha Hospital.
'Mushroom killer' Erin Patterson GUILTY of murdering three relatives with deadly beef wellington
Soon after, he received a call from the doctor treating the other two who were poisoned - Don and Gail - at Dandenong Hospital.
She said it was the mushrooms, not the meat, and Webster's stomach dropped.
Webster had hooked Heather and Ian with fluids, but quickly changed tack as he realised their life was on the line.
He knew he needed to save their failing livers and prepared to send them to a larger hospital where they could get better care.
9
Dr Chris Webster said he knew Erin Patterson was a killer
Credit: ABC
9
CCTV video footage of Patterson disposing of a food dehydrator used to prepare the mushrooms
Credit: AFP
But then a person presented themselves to the hospital claiming they had gastro symptoms.
Webster asked Patterson for her name and said when he heard it: "The penny dropped… it's the chef."
The doctor quizzed the chef about where the mushrooms had come from - Woolworths, she said.
It was with that answer that Webster knew she was guilty.
But the doctor said that made no sense as the supermarket giant would have stringent food safety standards.
Webster also said Patterson didn't seem worried about the danger Heather and Ian - lying only metres away - were in.
He then sent Ian and Heather off in an ambulance to Dandenong Hospital, saying he tragically knew they wouldn't return.
When he returned, Patterson had checked herself out against medical advice.
After desperately trying to call Patterson but being unable to reach her, Webster called the cops.
He said: "This is Dr Chris Webster from Leongatha Hospital. I have a concern about a patient who presented here earlier, but has left the building and is potentially exposed to a fatal toxin from mushroom poisoning."
9
Patterson in court during the trial
9
The chef broke down in tears when she spoke to media after the deaths
At the trial, Patterson said she had been caught off guard by the information about the deadly mushrooms and went home to pack an overnight bag and feed the animals.
She also had a "lie-down" before returning to the hospital.
When she finally did, Webster tried to get her to also bring her children, who the chef claimed had eaten leftovers.
In court, Patterson said she was "concerned that they were going to be frightened."
Days later, Patterson was
Wearing a long coat and sunglasses, Patterson is seen unloading the food dehydrator at the Koonwarra Transfer Station on August 2, 2023 - an apparent attempt to erase evidence linked to the deadly beef wellington meal.
And in a chilling image also released by the court, the meal that left her family dying in agony is laid out next to forensic evidence bags.
The annotated photo was taken during toxicology testing at the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine.
9
A death cap mushroom
Credit: Nine
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
'It was a very frightening time': Cork gay activist on Aids and preparing for Pride
Arthur Leahy will never forget the 'balloon-like' figure standing in the hospital doorway as he held the hand of a man dying from Aids. The junior doctor buried beneath multiple layers of protective clothing was clearly terrified but it offered Arthur a moment of light relief during what was a very dark time for Ireland's gay community. 'He had so much protective gear on that he looked like a giant balloon,' Arthur said. 'People were so frightened they would catch the disease.' Trailblazer Arthur had founded the inclusive space in Cork City known as the Quay Co-op back in 1982. The business continues to operate to this day as a vegetarian restaurant and health food store. It opened three years after the activist made television history with an RTÉ interview as Cork's first openly gay man. He, along with his Australian partner at the time, Laurie, provided an insight into life at the time for a gay couple. At the time, the country was pockmarked by homophobia, shockingly highlighted by the death of Declan Flynn who was beaten to death by a gang of teenagers in 1982. Arthur Leahy says the onset of the Aids epidemic 'was a torturous situation for families.' Picture: Jim Coughlan News of his perpetrators walking free from court with suspended sentences rocked the country. One of the attackers was just 14 at the time and could not to be named for legal reasons. The miscarriage of justice sparked a protest 11 days later that inspired the first Dublin Pride parade that June. Nonetheless, gay people remained extremely vulnerable, with homosexuality in Ireland not decriminalised until 1993. However, the threat of homophobic abuse wasn't enough to keep Arthur from the grim task of helping Aids victims to die with dignity. He was a founding member of Gay Health Action and Cairde which were established respectively to address HIV and Aids and provide hands-on support to patients. 'During that time it took over our lives.' The six houses in Cork Arthur co-founded to support those impacted by the Aids epidemic is among his proudest achievements. Years on, as we approach Cork Pride 2025 - which takes place from July 26 to August 3 - Arthur is pleading with people not to forget what people went through. Colour and celebration at last year's Cork Pride. 'If you're part of the gay community now, you get the sense that it never happened,' said Arthur, who turns 80 in November. 'There is a kind of denial there and not a lot of awareness and recognition around what people went through. People can take a drug for it now so there is no big drama about it. However, during the time we are talking about it was terminal.' Arthur recalls supporting Aids patients in hospitals. 'I remember being in the hospital with one person who was actually dying at the time. I was sitting by his bed and holding his hand. The junior doctor came in but we couldn't see him. His clothes looked like they had been blown up like a balloon because he had so many protective coverings on. "That was just the way it was. It was a very frightening time for people. It took me by surprise how I dealt with it, because I was able to transcend the horrors of it all. I dealt with it in such way that I didn't have to live with the trauma.' Mr Leahy recalled why some members of the gay community had little faith in medical professionals. 'In those days, on the medical front at least, it was the predominant view that gay people were mentally ill. It was something you just kind of accepted at the time. "There was one man named Jack Coughlan who dealt with venereal diseases in Cork and he was very progressive but a lot of others were very repressive and conservative.' He said that families were often in denial about the cause of a loved one's death. 'It was a torturous situation for families. In the beginning they didn't want to know but love usually took over towards the end. Sometimes, the control of families was very negative. It was at that point that we were pushed out of the situation. "They wanted to deal with it in a conventional way. That's where you're kind of pushed out of this situation. The Irish solution was denial at all costs.' He recalls how a number of Irish people impacted by Aids had returned from the UK to die. 'The great majority of Irish people with Aids were in London. If you looked in any hospital about half of the people there with Aids were Irish. "The houses we had in Cork were paid for by the Health Board. They helped with funding but the situation wasn't acknowledged. There were some people from the Health Board who were outstanding but they weren't supported by the establishment.' The same, Arthur recalled, could be said for the Church. There were individuals within the Catholic community who were enormously supportive and very courageous but the establishment of the Church was very negative. It was, and still is, to a great extent, in terms of all these issues. The trailblazer said he has lived a very privileged life in comparison to many others. 'I've been very lucky in life. My life is very privileged. I don't feel like I've suffered or done anything particularly brave. I think about the challenges that people are facing around the world right now. They are really enormous. "We all know what is happening. I've spent a lot of time in Gaza and in the Middle East in the last number of years so I think about their struggles all the time.' (Left to right) Cork Drag Queens Liam Bee and Lucina Schynning at Cork Pride 2024. Arthur said that while Ireland has progressed beyond recognition, other parts of the world remain in a time warp. 'The change in Ireland is remarkable. It's hard to believe the extent of the change that has taken place. However, if you look around the world there is very little change. On the contrary, we are seeing things go backwards. "We tend not to recognise in a sense how lucky we are. So many changes have taken place, not just with the gay issue but with regard to other issues too.'
Irish Post
4 days ago
- Irish Post
Tánaiste says conditions in Gaza have reached 'new depths of despair and misery'
TÁNAISTE Simon Harris has called for an immediate ceasefire in the Middle East, saying conditions in Gaza have reached 'new depths of despair and misery'. His plea comes as more than 100 aid agencies released a joint statement today, saying Israel's restrictions on aid have created 'chaos, starvation and death'. According to the Palestinian Ministry of Health, 59,219 Palestinians have so far died as a result of Israel's actions since the October 7, 2023 Hamas attacks. 'Mass starvation' The Tánaiste's statement comes two days after he and 25 other Foreign Ministers signed a joint statement urging Israel to lift its 'unacceptable' aid restrictions. "The suffering of civilians in Gaza has reached new depths of despair and misery," said the Tánaiste. "Mass starvation is now spreading across the population. People are dying every day from lack of food and medicines. Children are starving before our eyes. "Hundreds have been killed while trying to collect what little food is available. "This is an affront to our collective humanity. A medic cleans the body of Abdul Jawad al-Ghalban, 14, who died of starvation at the Nasser hospital morgue in Khan Yunis in the Gaza Strip on Tuesday (Image: AFP via Getty Images) "Ireland calls for an immediate and permanent ceasefire. "Israel must lift its blockade and allow the full resumption of humanitarian aid into and throughout Gaza. "All hostages must be released by Hamas and returned to their families. "UN and other humanitarian organisations must be allowed to do their work." 'Cycle of hope and heartbreak' Meanwhile, the statement released today, signed by aid agencies including Amnesty International, CAFOD and Save the Children, said even aid workers are joining the food lines 'as the Israeli government's siege starves the people of Gaza'. "Every day without a sustained flow means more people dying of preventable illnesses," it read. "Children starve while waiting for promises that never arrive. "Palestinians are trapped in a cycle of hope and heartbreak, waiting for assistance and ceasefires, only to wake up to worsening conditions. "It is not just physical torment, but psychological. Survival is dangled like a mirage. "The humanitarian system cannot run on false promises. Humanitarians cannot operate on shifting timelines or wait for political commitments that fail to deliver access." It added: "Piecemeal arrangements and symbolic gestures, like airdrops or flawed aid deals, serve as a smokescreen for inaction. "They cannot replace states' legal and moral obligations to protect Palestinian civilians and ensure meaningful access at scale. "States can and must save lives before there are none left to save." See More: Gaza, Palestine, Simon Harris
RTÉ News
5 days ago
- RTÉ News
Hunger affecting journalists' ability to work in Gaza
Journalists in Gaza have said that chronic food shortages are affecting their ability to cover Israel's war on Gaza. Palestinian text, photo and video journalists working for the international news agency AFP said desperate hunger and lack of clean water is making them ill and exhausted. Some have even had to cut back on their coverage of the war, now in its 22nd month, with one journalist saying "we have no energy left due to hunger". The United Nations in June condemned what it claimed was Israel's "weaponisation of food" in Gaza and called it a war crime, as aid agencies urge action and warnings about malnutrition multiply. Israel claims humanitarian aid is being allowed into Gaza and accuses Hamas of exploiting civilian suffering, including by stealing food handouts to sell at inflated prices or shooting at those awaiting aid. Witnesses and Gaza's civil defence agency, however, have repeatedly accused Israeli forces of firing on aid seekers, with the UN saying the military had killed more than 1,000 Palestinians trying to get food since late May. 'We have no energy' Bashar Taleb, 35, is one of four AFP photographers in Gaza who were shortlisted for the prestigious Pulitzer Prize earlier this year. He lives in the bombed-out ruins of his home in Jabalia al-Nazla, in northern Gaza. "I've had to stop working multiple times just to search for food for my family and loved ones," he said. "I feel for the first time utterly defeated emotionally. "I've tried so much, knocked on many doors to save my family from starvation, constant displacement and persistent fear but so far to no avail." Another Pulitzer nominee, Omar al-Qattaa, 35, is staying in the remains of his wife's family's home after his own apartment was destroyed. "I'm exhausted from carrying heavy cameras on my shoulders and walking long distances," he said. "We can't even reach coverage sites because we have no energy left due to hunger and lack of food." Mr Qattaa relies on painkillers for a back complaint, but said basic medicines were not available in pharmacies, and the lack of vitamins and nutritious food have added to his difficulties. The constant headaches and dizziness he has suffered due to lack of food and water have also afflicted AFP contributor Khadr Al-Zanoun, 45, in Gaza City, who said he has even collapsed because of it. "Since the war began, I've lost about 30 kilos and become skeletal compared to how I looked before the war," he said. "I used to finish news reports and stories quickly. Now I barely manage to complete one report per day due to extreme physical and mental fatigue and near-delirium." Worse, though, was the effect on his family, he said. "They're barely hanging on," he added. 'Hunger has shaken my resolve' Eyad Baba, another photojournalist, was displaced from his home in Rafah, in the south, to a tent in Deir el-Balah, in central Gaza, where the Israeli military this week began ground operations for the first time. But he could not bear life in the sprawling camp, so he instead rented an apartment at an inflated price to try to at least provide his family some comfort. Mr Baba, 47, has worked non-stop for 14 months, away from his family and friends, documenting the bloody aftermath of bullets and bombs, and the grief that comes with it. Hardest to deal with, though, is the lack of food, he said. "I can no longer bear the hunger. Hunger has reached my children and has shaken my resolve," he added. "We've psychologically endured every kind of death during our press coverage. Fear and the sense of looming death accompany us wherever we work or live." Working as a journalist in Gaza is to work "under the barrel of a gun", he explained, but added: "The pain of hunger is sharper than the fear of bombing. "Hunger robs you of focus, of the ability to think amid the horrors of war." 'Living the catastrophe' The director of Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza, Mohammed Abu Salmiya, warned yesterday that Gaza was heading towards "alarming numbers of deaths" due to lack of food, revealing that 21 children had died from malnutrition and starvation in the last three days. AFP text journalist Ahlam Afana, 30, said an exhausting "cash crisis" - from exorbitant bank charges and sky-high prices for what food is available - was adding to the issue. Cash withdrawals carry fees of up to 45%, said Khadr Al-Zanoun, with high prices for fuel, where it is available, making getting around by car impossible, even if the streets were not blocked by rubble. "Prices are outrageous," said Ms Afana. "A kilo of flour sells for 100-150 shekels (€25-40), beyond our ability to buy even one kilo a day. "Rice is 100 shekels, sugar is over 300 shekels, pasta is 80 shekels, a litre of oil is 85-100 shekels, tomatoes 70-100 shekels. Even seasonal fruits now - grapes, figs - cost 100 shekels per kilo. "We can't afford them. I don't even remember how they taste." Ms Afana said she keeps working from a worn-out tent in intense heat that can reach more than 30C, but going days without food and only some water makes it a struggle. "I move slowly, unlike before," she said. "The danger isn't just the bombing. Hunger is slowly killing our bodies and threatening our ability to carry on. "Now, I'm not just reporting the news. I'm living the catastrophe and documenting it at the same time." 'I prefer death over this life' Media watchdog Reporters Without Borders (RSF) said on 8 July that more than 200 journalists had been killed in Gaza since Hamas's attack on Israel on 7 October 2023, which sparked the war. Video journalist Youssef Hassouna, 48, said the loss of colleagues, friends and family had tested him as a human being "in every possible way". But despite "a heavy emptiness", he said he carries on. "Every frame I capture might be the last trace of a life buried beneath the earth," he added. "In this war, life as we know it has become impossible." Zuheir Abu Atileh, 60, worked at AFP's Gaza office, and shared the experience of his journalist colleagues, calling the situation "catastrophic". "I prefer death over this life," he said. "We have no strength left; we're exhausted and collapsing. Enough is enough."
