‘Gut punch': top shark expert quits Queensland advisory panel after LNP expands cull program
Announcing an $88m shark management plan overhaul which would see shark nets and baited drum lines designed to kill target shark species rolled out at more beaches, and existing drum lines used more intensely, the primary industries minister, Tony Perrett, claimed this week that the Liberal National party's strategy was backed by research.
'I have said time and time again; the best science must inform our actions when it comes to Fisheries,' Perrett said on Sunday.
But the expansion of the state's shark cull was slammed by conservation groups such as Australian Marine Conservation Society as an 'outdated' and 'unscientific' approach that 'does nothing to improve beach safety'.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Amid the noisy backlash this week, marine science professor Colin Simpfendorfer quietly handed in his resignation from the scientific working group to Perrett.
Simpfendorfer had been a member of the advisory body since its inception in 2017 and is regarded as one of the country's foremost shark experts, having served as the co-chair of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature Species Survival Commission's (IUCN SSC) shark specialist group. He declined to comment.
Speaking on the condition of anonymity, however, several members of the working group said they advised against the expansion of lethal control and were not informed of the LNPs plans to do so until days before they were announced.
'Everyone was shocked and everyone was pretty upset that there wasn't consultation,' one working group member said.
'We were told there was something coming and it was postponed and postponed and postponed. We kind of had the feeling that it was going to be bad … but it was a gut punch.'
AMCS shark scientist and campaigner Dr Leonardo Guida said Simpfendorfer was 'unequivocally' Australia's most renowned and respected shark scientist.
'I don't think anyone would dispute the fact that Colin is, not just Australia's best and most respected and well known shark scientist but, even globally, he is up there at the top,' he said.
Guida said he would like to sincerely thank Simpfendorfer for his expertise and service in the 'undoubtedly very challenging role' of providing scientific advice to 'what is essentially a state sanctioned marine cull of sharks'.
'As to what his resignation says, only a matter of days after Queensland's announcement to extend the shark cull, my interpretation of that would be that the Queensland government has made a decision that is no longer in line with scientific advice and recommendation,' Guida said.
'That this is a clear departure from scientific advice itself'.
Several sources said that in its nearly eight years the working group had been successful in getting 'more science into decision making' around shark management in Queensland and in moving from lethal to non-lethal shark control – but that Sunday's announcement marked a 'philosophical' shift from the top.
Some attributed the shift to pressure from commercial and recreational anglers who report increasingly having fish taken from their lines by sharks. Many scientists agree this behaviour – known as shark depredation – is on the rise in many places around the world, though none spoken to for this article believe that a shark cull will have any impact on depredation rates, nor improve the safety of swimmers.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Others said the decision was partly a reaction to a number of recent shark bites in Queensland, including that which killed 17-year-old surf life saver Charlize Zmuda while swimming at a Bribie Island beach in February, and that which killed youth pastor Luke Walford, who was spear fishing in the Keppel Bay Islands last December. Bribie Island has baited drum lines, while the Keppel islands do not.
Shark scientist and Emmy award-winning underwater cinematographer Richard Fitzpatrick, who has been on the scientific working group since its inception, says media reporting around fatal shark incidents may also have contributed to the expansion of lethal shark control measures.
'Media hysteria in Australia is one of the biggest problems with the whole shark issue,' he said 'Imagine if it were reported at the same level we do with car fatalities'.
Fitzpatrick said the expansion of lethal shark measures had 'definitely' made him consider his position on the working group, but said that, ultimately, working with the government had allowed scientists to pursue much-needed research into shark tracking and movement.
Included in the government's shark control plan, he said, was a survey of shark populations which would be 'essential', would 'not be cheap' and 'must be done properly'.
'We haven't had a stock assessment done on the target species in Queensland properly ever,' he said. 'Getting that done is absolutely critical now'.
'At the end of the day our approach is to do the best research possible.'
Whether that research informs decision making or not, however, is a minister's prerogative.
The primary industries minister said he stood by his comments the shark control plan was backed by science in the wake of Simpfendorfer's resignation.
'The Crisafulli Government makes no apology for reaffirming the purpose of the Shark Control Management Plan 2025-2029 Plan to prioritise the safety of people above all else,' Perrett said.
The minister said research showed and a recent KPMG report confirmed that 'traditional methods (nets and drum lines) are still the most effective way of protecting swimmers'.
'Until the new technology is scientifically proven as effective at protecting beach goers as traditional methods, we will continue to invest in what keeps Queenslanders and our beaches safe,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Tasmanian election: Liberal premier Jeremy Rockliff declares victory as Labor loses ground after forcing early poll
Tasmania faces a period of political talks after a snap election delivered another hung parliament and more seats to the Liberals than Labor. The Liberal premier, Jeremy Rockliff, declared victory on Saturday night after his party secured 14 seats to Labor's nine, both short of the 18 required for a majority. Rockliff said he would ask the governor to recommission his government, noting a roughly 3% swing to the Liberals. They had secured 40% of the vote with two-thirds of the ballots counted. However, the Labor leader, Dean Winter, whose party experienced its worst-ever result in Tasmania with just 26% of the primary vote, didn't concede defeat. He appeared to leave the door open to governing, if the Liberals couldn't make it work. 'The result of this election is that the Liberals will have the most seats, but it is uncertain as to how they will achieve a majority,' Winter said. 'Another election is not an option, which means we need to figure this out.' The Greens retained at least five seats with 14% of the vote, while there are three independents, with counting potentially extending for weeks to determine four undecided seats. Rockliff would need to work with left-leaning independent crossbenchers to govern. Independents Kristie Johnston and Craig Garland, who both voted for the June no-confidence motion against Rockliff that triggered the election, have been returned. Johnston urged the next premier to be more collaborative and said she wouldn't enter into a formal deal for confidence and supply with either major party. 'They need to negotiate and respect the views of parliament,' she said. Anti-salmon activist and independent Peter George has been elected after a strong campaign in the federal election. The state Greens leader, Rosalie Woodruff, has called on Winter to 'have a conversation' about forming an alliance with her party. However, Winter has repeatedly ruled out doing a deal with the Greens and on Saturday night also said he wouldn't 'be trading away any of Labor's policies or our values'. The drawn-out post-election scenario, just 16 months after the previous poll, will further delay the parliamentary approval process for a new $945m stadium in Hobart. The venue, a condition of Tasmania's AFL licence, is supported by the Liberals and Labor but opposed by the Greens, Garland, Johnston and George.
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Catastrophic new poll shows support for one major party has plummeted to 40-year-low
Support for the Coalition among Australian voters has dropped even further since the federal election to its lowest level in four decades. The latest Newspoll figures, published by The Australian, showed that the primary vote for the Coalition has dropped to just 29 per cent, falling even further from its record poor performance at the voting booths just a few months ago. The Coalition has never recorded such a low proportion of the primary vote since Newspoll was established in 1985. The primary vote for Labor is at 36 per cent, with the Greens and Independents steady and One Nation seeing a small uptick in support. With the flow of preference votes factored in, Labor is ahead on a two-party preferred basis 57-43 per cent. This is almost 2 per cent higher for Labor than at the election, however, it is a drop of more than 5 per cent for the LNP. The majority of those surveyed said they preferred Anthony Albanese as Prime Minister at 52 per cent, while 32 per cent said they preferred Sussan Ley and 16 per cent were undecided. Voter satisfaction with Albanese's performance in the nation's top job has seen a small lift but remains under the halfway mark at 47 per cent. Labor secured an increased majority at the election and holds 94 of the 150 seats in the House of Representatives. The prime minister has urged MPs not to take their stint in Canberra for granted, as they gather in the capital ahead of the resumption of federal parliament. MPs and senators were welcomed by Governor-General Sam Mostyn at Government House on Sunday as part of formalities before the official opening of the 48th parliament on Tuesday. Speaking to federal MPs, the prime minister said those elected to parliament should not forget their responsibility to voters. 'It is such a privilege to sit either in the House of Representatives or the Senate. And something that none of us should ever take for granted,' he said on Sunday. 'We need to take that responsibility seriously as well, as I know all of you will. And overwhelmingly, regardless of who you represent, people put themselves forward for public office overwhelmingly for all of the right reasons, because they want to make a difference to this country.' Mr Albanese said the make up of the next parliament was vastly different to that when he was first elected almost 30 years ago. 'In 1996, a lot of blokes from similar backgrounds made up most of the House of Representatives and the Senate,' he said. 'As I look out here today, we are far more representative of the people that we represent and that is a very good thing.' The governor-general said Sunday's event was a chance for many to relax before parliament ramps up. She said the gathering was also one of the only times she got to partake in a popular Australian tradition. 'It's the only time I get to have a democracy sausage in my term, because I have chosen not to vote over the period of my term,' she said. 'My job is above politics and I felt it was important that I not choose anyone during this time, so I don't get democracy sausages other than (at Government House).' While Tuesday's opening of parliament will largely be ceremonial, the federal government has flagged it would use the opening days of the new term to implement election commitments. Among them are laws to reduce HECS debts for university students by 20 per cent, increase safety measures for children in childcare, as well as legally protect penalty rates for workers. About 40 politicians will enter parliament for the first time and will give their maiden speeches.
The Guardian
7 hours ago
- The Guardian
Liberal and Labor leaders court crossbench after snap Tasmanian election delivers another hung parliament
Tasmania's premier and opposition leader have both reached out to independent MPs in the hope of forming government, after the Labor party lost ground in an early election it brought on. Saturday's snap poll, 16 months after the last election, returned another hung parliament with the Liberals so far securing 14 seats and Labor nine, as counting continued. Both parties will be short of the 18 seats required for majority, with the Liberal premier, Jeremy Rockliff, declaring victory on election night and saying he would try to form a minority government. Rockliff on Sunday told reporters he'd reached out to potential crossbench collaborators. 'My view is that the crossbench, in the cold, hard light of day, will recognise the party – being the Liberal party – with the most number of seats are able to, of course, form a cabinet,' the premier said. 'What Tasmanians clearly voted for yesterday was an end to the political games. They expect a parliament to work together and they expect the parliament to last four years.' Labor under Dean Winter suffered a 3% swing against it to the Liberals. It was Labor's worst vote in Tasmania in more than a century with the party securing 26% of the vote with three-quarters of the ballots counted. However, Winter hasn't ruled out trying to form government if the Liberals are unable to get a left-leaning independent crossbench onside. 'I've spoken to a number of members of the crossbench and offered Labor will try and work differently and collaboratively,' the opposition leader said. 'I won't go into the details of any of the conversations but we'll treat people with respect. I think that's what the crossbench is looking for and it's also what Tasmanians are looking for.' Winter reiterated on Sunday that he would not 'do a deal' with the Greens. Labor would need support from the minor party, which holds five seats, to govern. Winter said he would not compromise on Labor policy, including support for a $945m stadium which is opposed by the Greens and three crossbench independents. One of those independents, a re-elected Kristie Johnston, said she wouldn't enter into a formal deal for confidence and supply with either major party and would provide support on merit. 'They need to negotiate and respect the views of parliament,' she said. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion It could take weeks for the final outcome in four remaining undecided seats, meaning a formal minority agreement might take even longer. Rockliff would need to work with independents to govern, including two, Johnston and the re-elected Craig Garland, who voted for June's no-confidence motion against him. The June vote, which triggered the election, lashed ballooning debt under the Liberals and a bungled Bass Strait ferry delivery. The state Greens leader, Rosalie Woodruff, kept the door ajar for a Labor alliance, calling on Winter to 'have a conversation'. A drawn-out post-election scenario would delay the parliamentary approval process for the new stadium, a condition of Tasmania's AFL licence. The project is supported by the Liberals and Labor but opposed by the Greens, Garland, Johnston and the third elected independent Peter George. The new parliament will be very similar to the previous one that included 14 Liberals, 10 Labor MPS, five Greens, five independents and one Jacqui Lambie Network member.
