Uniformed protesters criticise introduction of AI line calls at Wimbledon
Gabriel Paul, 26, from Battersea, and Harry Robson, 27, from Marlow, stood outside the All England Club in south-west London holding placards reading 'AI took my job' and 'Don't sideline humans'.
The men, who are graduating this summer, said they wanted to highlight the wider impact of AI on employment and the role of people in sport.
'We're students – we're graduating in three months and worrying about the whole jobs market,' Mr Paul told PA news agency.
'There are so many moments from Wimbledon that line judges have been an essential part of – like the John McEnroe 'You cannot be serious' moment.
'Countless other times too – the controversy, the drama. That's what sport is about.
'Sport isn't just about clinical accuracy – it's about the human story. We've spoken to a few judges who are really backing the cause.'
Mr Robson added: 'If accuracy was the most important thing, we'd just get robots playing the sport.
'This is about keeping people in the game.'
It is the first year in Wimbledon's 148-year history that all line calls are being made by Hawk-Eye Live, an automated electronic system.
Line judge staff have been completely removed from court, with organisers citing a drive for 'maximum accuracy' for the move which brings Wimbledon into line with most other tournaments.
There is still a match umpire sitting in the chair and the uniformed ball boys and girls running to retrieve stray balls.
The most famous controversy over line calls at Wimbledon involved American champion John McEnroe in 1981 when he challenged a line judge during a first-round match against Tom Gullikson.
McEnroe's serve on the centre line was met by an outstretched arm from the line judge.
The umpire Edward James affirmed it was out, leading McEnroe to exclaim: 'You cannot be serious. That ball was on the line. Chalk flew up.'
Mr Paul said Wimbledon staff had reacted positively to the protest, suggesting they may fear their jobs will be the next to go.
'They don't seem to mind – they seem to be pretty friendly,' he said.
'There's been a lot of cheering for us from the stewards, which is quite funny.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
41 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Carlos Alcaraz escapes first-round scare as Fabio Fognini tests his limits
Carlos Alcaraz said he was proud to have squeezed into the second round after struggling with his nerves and the heat on Centre Court during his dramatic five-set win against Fabio Fognini on Monday. In searing temperatures, Alcaraz started his pursuit of a third consecutive Wimbledon title by outlasting the veteran Italian 7-5, 6-7 (1), 7-5, 2-6, 6-1 after 4hr 37min on-court. 'I'm getting mature and I know how to deal with some situations,' the Spaniard said. 'I always say that the champions always find a way. I really want to see myself in that [list] of champions. I really want to put myself like a champion that always finds a way to win. 'I've been playing really, really tough matches the last year, the last year in this tournament. Just really proud that I always find a way. Today I did it, even though Fabio was playing great tennis. Just really proud to overcome the problem, to overcome the tough moments.' Grand slam titles cannot be won on the first day of competition, but they can always be lost. So far in his career. Alcaraz has been brilliant at ensuring that he at least gives himself a chance in every tournament. With this victory, Alcaraz maintains his perfect record of 18 wins and no defeats in the first round of grand slam tournaments. He also has 14 wins and only one defeat in five-set matches. At 38, Fognini has been a fixture on the tour for much of the past two decades, with a career‑high ranking of No 9 and several monumental wins. This year, however, marks his final season on the tour and simple victories have been difficult to come by. He has lost all six of his ATP main draw matches this year, losing against multiple players ranked outside the top 350. Across the net, Alcaraz is the most in-form player in the sport after establishing an 18-match winning sequence, including titles at the French Open and Queen's Club. On paper, this match was not supposed to be close. Despite struggling with his serve early on, Alcaraz appeared to be moving confidently towards victory as he established a 7-5, 4-2 lead. But then, not for the first time, his concentration faltered. He played a dire service game to relinquish the break, and followed up with an error‑strewn start to the third‑set tie‑break. He soon found himself at one-set all and down a break at 2-3 in the third set. 'It doesn't matter that the winning streak that I have right now, that I've been playing great on grass, that I have been preparing really well the week before – Wimbledon is different,' Alcaraz said. 'I could feel today that I was really nervous at the beginning. Being the first match on Centre Court, it's a huge privilege for me. Even though I played the first match last year, it feels [like] the first time. I just try to deal with the nerves the best way possible.' Although Fognini has lost much of his speed in his later years, quality shotmaking remains and the lofty occasion inspired the best of his ball‑striking talents. His forehand was precise and lethal, lasering winners from all parts of the court, he continually closed down the net, volleying spectacularly, and he often matched Alcaraz's supreme variety of shot with his own deft hand skills. Sign up to The Recap The best of our sports journalism from the past seven days and a heads-up on the weekend's action after newsletter promotion Even when Alcaraz established a lead of two sets to one, Fognini refused to let his intensity drop and throughout the fourth set he suffocated Alcaraz's serve with his spectacular returning. As the match dragged on, and the pair headed for a decider, the world No 2 cut an increasingly distressed figure, repeatedly unloading his frustration on his player box. In the heat, Alcaraz walked gingerly between points. Early in the final set, play was halted after a fan was struggling with the heat, which prompted Alcaraz to sprint over with a bottle of water. 'Obviously playing with such a high heat out there is really difficult to deal with sometimes,' Alcaraz said. 'Even tougher when you're playing long matches, long rallies.' In the middle of some of the most intense months of his young career, which have pushed him to his physical and mental limit, a few efficient, relatively stress-free wins would not hurt Alcaraz. Although such straightforward matches have evaded him, he continues to show his ability to produce his best tennis when most needed. One set away from a catastrophic first-round defeat, he pulled himself together and closed out an important victory that keeps alive his dream of a Wimbledon hat-trick.
Leader Live
2 hours ago
- Leader Live
Tearful Ons Jabeur retires from Wimbledon match due to breathing difficulties
The 30-year-old, who has endured a torrid time with injuries, required a medical timeout in the first set of the contest on Court 14. Having been in clear distress, she managed to play on in scorching temperatures before withdrawing while trailing 7-6 (5) 2-0 to Bulgarian world number 111 Tomova. Jabeur, who was beaten in the 2022 and 2023 finals at SW19, has plummeted to 59 in the rankings amid ongoing fitness setbacks. A shoulder issue led to a premature end to her 2024 season and, just three months into her return, she hobbled off court in tears at this year's Miami Open after suffering a leg strain. Tournament organisers later confirmed the Tunisian had experienced breathing issues. 'I wasn't expecting not to feel good, I've been practising pretty well the last few days but I guess these things happen and I'm pretty sad,' said Jabeur. Heartbreak for Ons Jabeur 💔 The two-time Wimbledon finalist was in tears as she retired from her first round match against Viktoriya Tomova 😭#Wimbledon — BBC Sport (@BBCSport) June 30, 2025 'It doesn't really help me with my confidence. I keep pushing myself, even though it was a very tough season for me, so I hope I can feel better and see what's going to happen.' World number one Aryna Sabalenka eased into the second round by defeating Canadian grand slam debutant Carson Branstine in straight sets. The three-time major winner cruised through the opening set on Court One before securing a decisive break in game 11 of a closer second en route to a 6-1 7-5 success. Belarusian Sabalenka, who missed last year's championship due to a shoulder injury and has never been past the semi-finals, could meet British number one Emma Raducanu in round three. The world No.1 is off to a winning start 💪 Aryna Sabalenka defeats Carson Branstine 6-1, 7-5#Wimbledon — Wimbledon (@Wimbledon) June 30, 2025 'I'm super happy to be back, to be healthy and to compete at this beautiful tournament,' she said in her on-court interview. 'I was really depressed last year that I couldn't feel this atmosphere and I'm super happy with the performance. I feel like I'm in a good place.' Marketa Vondrousova – the 2023 champion – set up a second-round clash with home favourite Raducanu by defeating American McCartney Kessler. The 26-year-old Czech backed up her recent success at the Berlin Open with a 6-1 7-6 (3) victory over the 32nd seed, who won in Nottingham this summer. Starting strong 💪 Our 2023 Ladies' Singles Champion Marketa Vondrousova is into the 2R, beating McCartney Kessler 6-1, 7-6(3)#Wimbledon — Wimbledon (@Wimbledon) June 30, 2025 Australian Open champion Madison Keys avoided an upset by coming from a set down to scrape past Elena-Gabriela Ruse. The 30-year-old American sixth seed prevailed 6-7 (4) 7-5 7-5. Last year's runner-up Jasmine Paolini also survived a scare, coming from a set down to defeat Latvian world number 402 Anastasija Sevastova 2-6 6-3 6-2. Four-time grand slam winner Naomi Osaka overcame Australia's Talia Gibson 6-4 7-6 (4), while Lulu Sun, who knocked out Raducanu in round four last year, lost 6-4 6-4 to Marie Bouzkova. Fourteenth seed Elina Svitolina won 6-3 6-1 against Hungarian Anna Bondar.
Leader Live
2 hours ago
- Leader Live
Sonay Kartal and Arthur Fery pull off huge upsets on day one at Wimbledon
British number three Kartal and wild card Fery took out the respective women's and men's 20th seeds, with the former seeing off Jelena Ostapenko 7-5 2-6 6-2 and the latter defeating Alexei Popyrin 6-4 6-1 4-6 6-4. For Fery, it is by a long distance the biggest victory of his life, with the 22-year-old's only top-100 win before this coming against then 99th ranked David Goffin two years ago. BIGGEST WIN OF ARTHUR FERY'S CAREER!!! 🔥 @ArthurFery02 fights through to the @Wimbledon second round for the very first time, taking down the No. 20 seed Alexei Popyrin#BackTheBrits 🇬🇧 | #Wimbledon — LTA (@the_LTA) June 30, 2025 Fery, whose French father Loic owns Lorient football club, was not in the initial batch of wild cards named by the All England Club having seen his ranking drop outside the top 400 because of injury but a strong week at the second-tier Challenger event in Nottingham earlier this month earned him a pass. He took advantage of it spectacularly to claim a first Wimbledon victory, and he will hope there is more to come with an unseeded opponent up next. Kartal reached the third round as a qualifier 12 months ago but her hopes of another good run appeared to have been dealt a blow when she drew seasoned grass-court campaigner Ostapenko in round one. The Latvian is a former semi-finalist and beat Kartal in Eastbourne last week but, after recovering from 5-2 down in the opening set and saving three set points, the 23-year-old also proved the stronger in the decider. Ostapenko's body language became more and more negative as Kartal opened up a 5-0 lead in the third, and the British star appears to have a good chance of going further with Bulgarian outsider Viktoriya Tomova up next. It is Kartal's third best win by ranking of her career and her best at a grand slam. She described the match as one of the toughest she had ever played, saying: 'Typically I struggle against the big hitters. So to be able to do that, get the win in front of the home crowd, I'm super proud of that one. 'She can go through games, even sets, playing tennis that's just unplayable. The pace she gets on the ball and the angle she gets off the ball is honestly unreadable at times. 'I knew that was going to happen. I knew it happened last week. I knew I just had to stay with it. If she was going to go on a good run, just not get too down, and know that hopefully I was going to get my opportunity, and when I got the opportunity, to maximise it the most I could. 'I feel confident. I feel like this is the best I've ever played on grass. It's the most confident I've also got in my game, as well. I think I'm in a pretty good spot for round two.' Kartal's win was swiftly followed by another notable British success, this time for debutant Oliver Tarvet, who made it four victories in a row after coming through qualifying with a 6-4 6-4 6-4 win over Swiss Leandro Riedi. Former British number one Cameron Norrie claimed his first win on grass this year with a narrow 6-3 3-6 6-4 7-6 (3) victory over Spanish veteran Roberto Bautista Agut. Big WIN for @cam_norrie at @Wimbledon 🙌 Cam beats an in-form Bautista Agut to move into the second round#BackTheBrits 🇬🇧 | #Wimbledon — LTA (@the_LTA) June 30, 2025 Norrie rediscovered his form on clay after almost dropping out of the top 100 and will next take on 12th seed Frances Tiafoe. Billy Harris was another Briton to progress on day one. The world number 151 won 6-3 6-2 6-4 against Serbian lucky loser Dusan Lajovic and will face Portuguese Nuno Borges in round two. But former boys' champion Henry Searle and wild card Oliver Crawford were both knocked out in four sets by American world number 89 Ethan Quinn and Italian world number 73 Mattia Bellucci respectively, while Harriet Dart lost to Hungary's Dalma Galfi 3-6 6-3 7-5.
