logo
Texas' latest anti-abortion bill should alarm anyone who cares about rule of law

Texas' latest anti-abortion bill should alarm anyone who cares about rule of law

Yahoo19-05-2025
You know how some showrunners try to amp up the sex and gore in streaming series when they're worried about fading viewer interest and don't have better ideas? The Texas Legislature is following this playbook when it comes to abortion.
After lawmakers in 2021 passed Senate Bill 8, the "Texas Heartbeat Act" that banned abortion once fetal cardiac activity was present, Texas abortions officially fell to negligible numbers. But Texas women continued getting abortions at nearly the same rate as when the procedure was legal. Abortion pills are easy to obtain and take, even in states where they are illegal. The pills are almost always effective, and have fewer serious side effects than drugs such as Viagra and penicillin.
With the Senate's recent passage of SB 2880, the 'Women and Child Protection Act,' the desperation of Texas legislators is palpable. The Protection Act would make abortion pill manufacturers, distributors, prescribers and transporters strictly liable for the death or injury of a pregnant person or fetus. Nearly any private person could bring a civil suit up to six years after the alleged abortion, seeking damages of up to $100,000. Additionally, the bill authorizes the Texas attorney general to bring a civil action on behalf of fetuses to enforce the state's criminal abortion laws.
The bill would make not only defendants but also their attorneys liable to pay the attorney's fees and costs of prevailing plaintiffs.
The corker is that the bill purports to prevent courts from finding the bill unconstitutional, whether in part or in whole. In fact, should any court dare to find any portion of the bill unconstitutional, the bill declares such a finding to be void — and SB 2880 says that any person may sue the judge or anyone following the judge's ruling and obtain at least $100,000 in punitive damages from them, among other damages and relief.
Clearly, the Texas Legislature thinks that those prescribing and supplying abortion pills to Texas women are scofflaws who need to be disciplined. But the Legislature is woefully impotent on this issue.
The Texas Heartbeat Act already permits private people to bring these sorts of 'bounty suits' against many of the defendants that SB 2880 contemplates. If the Heartbeat Act isn't working, why should SB 2880 yield greater success? Damages under the Heartbeat Act start at $10,000 rather than the $100,000 offered under SB 2880, but given that both also cover prevailing plaintiffs' attorneys fees and costs, it's hard to see how the increased bounty would spur the thousands of private suits needed to help deter illicit abortions.
The Legislature should realize that the bounty hunter tactic isn't working.
The tactic is unconstitutional. To sue for civil damages, a person must have suffered a redressable injury. Without an actual injury, a person doesn't have the right to bring a civil lawsuit seeking damages against another party. Imagine if anyone — your neighbor, a business competitor, some person on the other side of the country — could haul you into court and sue you for thousands of dollars if they learned that you did something that the Legislature decided wasn't allowed, like jaywalking or wearing a red shirt.
This is what the Heartbeat Act and SB 2880 do. They throw the bedrock constitutional principle of due process under the bus. What's more, in an outrageous attempt to circumvent the courts, SB 2880 would heavily penalize any judge who dared to find the statute unconstitutional.
Most of published decisions to date involving the Heartbeat Act, including decisions at the U.S. and Texas Supreme Courts, have concerned matters other than the bounty hunter provision. But one Texas district court has addressed the substantive issue. It held that the Heartbeat Act's enforcement mechanism is unconstitutional. Any other holding would be absurd. It would throw state courts open to anyone, potentially, to sue another party for any reason or no reason at all.
The Texas Legislature is trying to tear down the rule of law. Regardless of our views on abortion, we should all oppose this.
Laura Hermer is a professor of law at Mitchell Hamline School of Law in Saint Paul, Minn. She previously served on the faculty at the University of Texas Medical Branch and the University of Houston Law Center. She teaches and writes on health law and reproductive rights.
This article originally appeared on Austin American-Statesman: Texas' anti-abortion bill is an attack on the rule of law | Opinion
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Benson raises over $3.5M in Michigan governor's bid
Benson raises over $3.5M in Michigan governor's bid

The Hill

time34 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Benson raises over $3.5M in Michigan governor's bid

Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson's (D) gubernatorial campaign said it has raised over $3.5 million since its launch in January, according to figures first shared with The Hill on Thursday. Benson's campaign reported receiving over 27,000 individual contributions from the state's 83 counties during the period, with over 95 percent of them under $100. According to her campaign, Benson has over $2.4 million cash-on-hand. The fundraising haul is more than double the $1.5 million Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D), raised at this point in 2017 after announcing her first gubernatorial bid in January of that year. The haul also puts Benson ahead of her opponents in the state's Democratic gubernatorial primary. Lt. Gov. Garlin Gilchrist's (D) campaign said he raised over $750,000, while former Genesee County, Mich. Sheriff Chris Swanson (D) said his campaign has raised over $1 million. Gilchrist jumped into the primary in March, while Swanson announced his bid in February. 'The numbers make it clear: Jocelyn Benson is the best person to take on any candidate, Republican or Independent, in November 2026,' Benson's campaign manager Nikki Goldschein said in a statement. 'This record-breaking haul not only showcases the strength of this campaign, it tells the story of the movement we are building.' A poll commissioned by the Detroit Regional Chamber and released in May showed Benson leading the Democratic primary field with 59.3 percent support from registered Democratic voters. Gilchrist and Swanson trailed at 6.9 percent and 8.1 percent respective. Nearly 26 percent of registered Democrats said they were undecided. 2024 Election Coverage Republicans are also facing a crowded gubernatorial primary in the state. Rep. John James (R-Mich.), state Senate Minority Leader Aric Nesbitt (R ), former state House Speaker Tom Leonard (R ), and former state Attorney General Mike Cox (R ) are vying for the party's nomination. Cox, who jumped into the race in April, said his campaign has raised $2.4 million and has $1.9 million in the bank. Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan announced earlier this year that he is running for governor as an Independent. Michigan's governor's race is slated to be one of the most competitive races in 2026. The nonpartisan Cook Political Report rates the race as a 'toss-up.'

Lara Trump won't run for North Carolina senate seat
Lara Trump won't run for North Carolina senate seat

Axios

time34 minutes ago

  • Axios

Lara Trump won't run for North Carolina senate seat

Lara Trump, the president's daughter-in-law and former co-chair of the Republican National Committee, will not be pursuing a run for retiring North Carolina Sen. Thom Tillis' seat. Why it matters: The announcement from President Trump's daughter-in-law comes after multiple outlets reported RNC chair Michael Whatley will join the race. Lara Trump's connection to the president would have made her a highly competitive candidate in a swing state like North Carolina, giving Republicans a boost in a race that could be a potential pickup opportunity for Democrats in 2026. What they're saying: " After much consideration and heartfelt discussions with my family, friends, and supporters, I have decided not to pursue the United States Senate seat in North Carolina at this time," Lara wrote in a post on X. "While I am not running in this election, my passion for Making America Great Again burns brightly, and I look forward to the future, wherever that leads."

1 big thing: PBS North Carolina grapples with budget cuts
1 big thing: PBS North Carolina grapples with budget cuts

Axios

timean hour ago

  • Axios

1 big thing: PBS North Carolina grapples with budget cuts

Zachery Eanes, Lucille Sherman Hello Thursday! 🌤️ Weather: Mostly sunny with a high in the low 90s and a chance for thunderstorms. 🎂 Happy birthday to our Axios Raleigh members Rick Powell and Donna Crocetti! PBS North Carolina, which reaches 14 million people in North Carolina and surrounding states, is set to lose around 15% of its funding over the next two years due to federal cuts to the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Why it matters: The funding reduction is equal to around $9 million over two years, PBS North Carolina's CEO David Crabtree tells Axios, and it will likely force the 70-year-old organization to make some tough budget decisions. Already, it's made two separate cuts to non-personnel expenditures this year, including pausing some local production projects. Driving the news: The downsizing made earlier this month to the Corporation of Public Broadcasting is expected to have significant ramifications on local NPR and PBS stations nationwide. What they're saying: "Bottom line is, we have to play the hand we're dealt," Crabtree said. "Our budget is finite. It could go up a little again with donations coming in, but right now, we are looking at a substantial shortfall. Zoom in: In addition to showing content produced by PBS, PBS North Carolina produces a host of its own shows and documentaries, operates four channels and creates educational resources for children in the state. Its network of broadcast towers across the state also provides broadcasts for the state's Emergency Operations Center and is used by first responders for emergency communications. Threat level: Crabtree said no cuts are off the table right now, but the goal is to find a way to not cut production or staff. PBS North Carolina employs around 140 people in the state and has its headquarters in Research Triangle Park. The organization is looking at new ways to keep the same level of local content, Crabtree said. One move might be to scale back its own productions and instead purchase projects about North Carolina from other producers, a move that would lessen its editorial control. The bottom line:"We will have to be more creative with what we have, without having content and quality suffer in any way. That is my commitment," Crabtree said. "How we're going to get there, I'm not sure, but we are working on it at least 18 hours a day right now." 2. Cooper Senate announcement nears Stephen Neukam Former North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper is preparing to launch his Senate campaign next week, multiple sources told Axios. Why it matters: Cooper is the Democratic Party's top recruit in 2026, bolstering their chances of flipping a critical seat from Republicans. Cooper, a popular former governor, will instantly become the Democratic favorite to challenge the GOP for the open Senate seat next year. The party's leadership, including Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee Chair Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), has lobbied Cooper for months to run. The big picture: Cooper and Democrats will now await a decision from Lara Trump, President Trump's daughter-in-law, who essentially has the right of first refusal on the GOP side. Democrats see their path as widening in the North Carolina Senate race after Sen. Thom Tillis' retirement announcement last month. Cooper was floated as a possible vice presidential candidate in 2024, but opted instead for a stint at Harvard at the beginning of this year. Former Rep. Wiley Nickel, a Democrat who served for one term before Republicans redrew his seat before the 2024 election, announced a Senate bid in April. 3. The Tea: Meredith's cuts 🎓 Meredith College, the Raleigh-based women's liberal arts school, is cutting 6% of its workforce as part of a restructuring of its budget. (Triangle Business Journal 🔒) ⛽️ Wawa, the popular Pennsylvania gas station and hoagie maker, will open its first location in Garner today. (WRAL) 🌲 Restoring North Carolina's peat bogs could help both store planet-warming carbon and soak up flood waters. (New York Times) ✈️ JetBlue will add a new direct flight between RDU and Fort Lauderdale, Fla., starting Oct. 26. (News & Observer 🔒) 4. Nash Street tower downsizes plans The developer behind a planned condo tower on Nash Square are downsizing its plans for the tower from 36 stories to 20 stories. Why it matters: The original plans from New York-based Alchemy Properties, which would be built on the former site of Berkeley Cafe at 217 W. Martin St., would have made it the tallest building in downtown Raleigh. Zoom in: The new plans call for 82 condo units, starting at $795,000, according to a spokesperson for the company. The building would also include: a pool deck, spa, fitness center and ground-floor retail space. Alchemy plans to resubmit its adjusted plans to the city by the end of the year, with a goal of completing the tower in two and a half years. 5. Stat du jour: 🏈 The Belichick effect UNC said Wednesday that all single-game and season tickets for games at Kenan Stadium have been sold out, the earliest in the calendar the school has ever been able to do that. Why it matters: The sellouts provide evidence that the school's bet on hiring legendary NFL coach Bill Belichick is coming with some financial successes, at least in the short run. Between the lines: UNC is funneling huge financial resources into its football program, and that investment is pushing the university to find new forms of revenue to keep up with college athletics' changing financial realities.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store