Sky Ireland says it is not obliged to give end-of-contract notice
ComReg claims Sky is in breach of 2022 EU regulations requiring communications service providers to inform consumers in a prominent and timely manner of the end of the contractual commitment and means by which to terminate the contract.
It says Sky is also contravening the regulations by failing to provide consumers with "best tariff advice" before the contract is automatically prolonged. Sky is the only one of the five big providers refusing to do so, ComReg says.
Sky disputes ComReg's interpretation of the relevant legal provisions and says they only apply to contracts with a fixed duration. Its customers' contracts are subscription contracts of indeterminate duration, it says.
The regulations, Sky argues, are designed to address the potential harm of consumers getting automatically prolonged in the contract for a second term without their knowledge. This harm does not arise in relation to Sky customers as its contracts do not follow this type of model in Ireland, it argues.
It also says the ultimate interpretation of the regulations is for the courts to decide.
On Monday, Mr Justice Mark Sanfey admitted ComReg's proceedings against Sky to the fast track commercial court on the application of Eoin McCullough SC, for the regulator, and on consent from Andrew Fitzpatrick SC, for Sky. The case was adjourned to December.
In an affidavit seeking entry of the case to the commercial list, Miriam Kilraine, ComReg compliance operations manager, said the purpose of end-of-contract information and best tariff advice, when a contract is nearing end and about to be "auto-prolonged", is that customers are afforded an opportunity of making an informed decision to stay with their current provider on the same or different package or to switch to a new provider.
This is important, particularly as customers may be losing discounts and therefore incurring higher prices and, in the case of Sky customers, this could include bundled TV, broadband and telephone services, she said.
As part of its review and enforcement functions, ComReg began an investigation last September and Virgin Media, Eircom, Three and Vodafone all confirmed they are in compliance, but Sky said it did not do so. Further investigations into Sky followed and in December Sky said it would not be complying because of its interpretation of the regulations.
Ms Kilraine said it was clear there was a fundamental disagreement between the parties regarding the interpretation of the relevant legal provisions in this case. It is ComReg's position that Sky has failed and continues to fail to comply with its obligations under the 2022 regulations, she said.
She also said Sky's UK arm, Sky UK Ltd, had taken a different position to its Irish counterpart and provided best tariff information to its customers. This followed enforcement action against Sky UK by the UK watchdog, Ofcom, in 2021, which concluded in Ofcom's favour last December, Ms Kilraine said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Elon Musk's Starlink network suffers rare global outage
SpaceX's Starlink suffered one of its biggest international outages when an internal software failure knocked tens of thousands of users offline, a rare disruption for Elon Musk's powerful satellite internet system. Users in the US and Europe began experiencing the outage at around 7pm Irish time, according to Downdetector, a crowd sourced outage tracker that said as many as 61,000 user reports to the site were made. Starlink, which has more than 6 million users across roughly 140 countries and territories, later acknowledged the outage on its X account and said "we are actively implementing a solution." Starlink service mostly resumed after 2.5 hours, Michael Nicolls, Starlink vice president of Starlink Engineering, wrote on X. "The outage was due to failure of key internal software services that operate the core network," Mr Nicolls said,apologizing for the disruption and vowing to find its rootcause. Mr Musk had also apologised: "Sorry for the outage. SpaceX will remedy the root cause to ensure it doesn't happen again," the Space X CEO wrote on X. The outage was a rare hiccup for SpaceX's most commercially sensitive business that had experts speculating whether the service, known for its resilience and rapid growth, was beset by a glitch, a botched software update or even a cyberattack. Doug Madory, an expert at the internet analysis firm Kentik, said the outage was global and that such a sweeping interruption was unusual. "This is likely the longest outage ever for Starlink, at least while it became a major service provider," Madory said. As Starlink gained more users, SpaceX has focused heavily in recent months on updating its network to accommodate demands for higher speed and bandwidth. The company in a partnership with T-Mobile is also expanding the constellation with larger, more powerful satellites to offer direct-to-cell text messaging services, a line of business in which mobile phone users can send emergency text messages through the network in rural areas. SpaceX has launched more than 8,000 Starlink satellites since 2020, building a uniquely distributed network in low-Earth orbit that has attracted intense demand from militaries, transportation industries and consumers in rural areas with poor access to traditional, fiber-based internet. "I'd speculate this is a bad software update, not entirely dissimilar to the CrowdStrike mess with Windows last year, or a cyberattack," said Gregory Falco, director of a space and cybersecurity laboratory at Cornell University. An update to Crowd Strike's widely used cybersecurity software led to worldwide flight cancellations and impacted industries around the globe in July last year. The outage disrupted internet services, affecting 8.5 million Microsoft Windows devices. It was unclear whether the outage affected SpaceX's other satellite-based services that rely on the Starlink network. Starshield, the company's military satellite business unit, has billions of dollars' worth of contracts with the Pentagon and US intelligence agencies.
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Central Bank investigating influencer Jonathan Finlay over promotion of unregulated trading platform T4Trade
The Central Bank of Ireland is looking into a matter concerning Irish influencer and content creator Jonathan Finlay, who has promoted an unregulated trading platform to more than half a million online followers. Boasting more than 260,000 followers on Instagram and 586,000 on TikTok, Mr Finlay, who also goes by Nasti_2k online, has made a name for himself in recent years by posting food reviews and luxury lifestyle content. The creator frequently shares photos and videos of himself on first-class flights, at Premier League matches, and on holidays in Dubai. However, the influencer also runs several channels on instant messaging app Telegram, which are focused on making money quickly from financial trading using a platform called T4Trade. In these channels, Mr Finlay encourages people to copy his trades, telling them what they should buy and sell. T4Trade disclaims on its website that it is not targeted to residents of the EU, where it is not licensed. In emails seen by the Irish Examiner,the Central Bank said neither T4Trade nor Mr Finlay was authorised to provide financial services in Ireland. 'The Central Bank can confirm that a firm by the name T4Trade is not authorised by the Central Bank to provide financial services. Further to this, we can also confirm that Jonathan Finlay is not authorised to provide financial services or advice.' The regulator also said that it was 'currently looking into this matter.' In a statement to the Irish Examiner, the Central Bank added: "Whether a particular entity or individual requires to be registered or authorised by the Central Bank depends on the exact nature of the services provided by the entity or individual. 'VIP' Channels Mr Finlay, who is based in Dublin and claims his primary income is from trading, heavily promotes the T4Trade platform, promising those who use it can copy his trades as well as receive 'VIP' attention from him. Mr Finlay says he charges €1,000 for access to a VIP channel which is owned and operated by him, but regularly allows small groups of people to enter 'free of charge,' for limited amounts of time, encouraging people to join quickly before access to the group closes. 'I show people how to make hundreds from their phone the same way as me for free,' Mr Finlay said in one of his Telegram channels with some 14,000 subscribers. 'But after next week, entry to the group will be €1,000.' For those in the VIP group, Mr Finlay shares his trading activity, which he says will earn his followers a profit if they use the T4Trade platform to copy his trades. 'Currently, there are over 2,000 people in my VIP group making consistent profit just from copying the exact same trades as me,' Mr Finlay told subscribers. To join his VIP channels, Mr Finlay also encourages followers to invest a minimum of €300 into the unauthorised platform T4Trade, which is registered in the Seychelles, adding that he will help 'guide' newcomers who are inexperienced in trading. 'By joining the VIP, you'll get access to: My daily trades, 24/7 support to help you get up and running and help with any issues, and educational material.' In another message sent to his 14,000 Telegram subscribers, Mr Finlay said those in his VIP group saw a '100% profit rate on trades,' across a one-week period, with 'not a single loser.' In another post, Mr Finlay said he would buy himself a new car with the money he made from trading. 'I'm in the market for a new motor,' Mr Finlay told subscribers earlier this month. 'I've been grinding lately and made serious profit on trading this year, so it's finally time to treat myself.' Mr Finlay continued by asking subscribers to vote on which car he should buy, choosing between a Porsche, a BMW X5 and a G Wagon. In a video post from July 20, Mr Finlay claimed he invested €50,000, saying he 'finally put pen to paper." 'In two weeks time, it will be exactly one year since I left my night shift job,' Mr Finlay said. 'If you told me then that I would be able to do all the things that I have been able to do; going on first and business class flights, private jets, going out to Dubai, 11/12 holidays this year, it is insane, and it is all because of trading.' T4Trade Describing itself as a 'global leader in online trading,' T4Trade is a trade name of Tradeco Limited, which is registered in the Seychelles. The platform also states that it is not targeted at residents of the EU, where it is not licensed, and that it does not offer its services to residents of certain jurisdictions, including the USA, Iran, Cuba, Sudan, Syria, and North Korea. In a risk warning published on its website, T4Trade says: 'Our products are traded on margin and carry a high level of risk and it is possible to lose all your capital. 'These products may not be suitable for everyone and you should ensure that you understand the risks involved.' In addition to the platform being unauthorised in Ireland, several EU regulators have issued warnings against the company. In October 2024, the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority issued a warning against T4Trade, adding that many Danish-speaking influencers were soliciting their followers to invest with the platform. Similar warnings have been issued in recent years by French, Spanish, Belgian, Portuguese, and Dutch regulators. Trading affiliates Despite claiming it does not target EU residents, the platform runs an affiliate program that EU residents can join, which is advertised as being 'well-suited to individuals and businesses who focus on driving traffic via a website or digital media and are usually digital marketers, social media influencers, bloggers, or SEO professionals.' It continues by saying it can provide affiliates with 'expert support' and 'exclusive marketing tools' to introduce the platform's products to their audiences and boost their conversion rate. The platform also says it offers 'competitive remuneration plans, including CPA commissions and extra cash bonuses.' T4Trade advertises bonuses of up to $10,000 for affiliates on its website, as well as tailored commission plans and performance-based upgrades. Mr Finlay has not confirmed to his followers whether or not he is an affiliate for T4Trade or if he receives payment from the platform for referring others. In a statement to the Irish Examiner, the Central Bank of Ireland said: 'The Central Bank is bound by strict statutory obligations of confidentiality and is precluded from commenting on the specific investigations it undertakes. 'Consumers should be aware that if they deal with a firm that is not authorised, there is no recourse to statutory compensation schemes or the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman.' 'Consumers are advised to check the official Central Bank website to see if the firm is authorised by the Central Bank.' The Irish Examiner has contacted Mr Finlay and T4Trade for comment.
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish Examiner view: Rural communities are losing their light
What now for the Irish pub? As reported on these pages in recent weeks, an average of two pubs are closing a week, with one third of those in Co Cork having shut since 2005. Overall, the country has seen 2,119 shut their doors, with as many as 1,000 more to follow suit in the next 10 years. Perhaps not surprisingly, it is rural Ireland taking the brunt of the losses, even if it's the part of the country that needs them most. On these pages yesterday, we voiced concerns about cutting the Vat rate for hospitality when it would take the room to manoeuvre away from areas of the economy that needed more help: We highlighted families struggling with the basics, including food. That Vat move is on pause, it was announced yesterday, and it likely wouldn't make a difference between keeping a pub open or shut given other cost pressures, but is there not scope to consider a more targeted tax reduction for rural pubs? That's not to minimise the challenges being faced by other hospitality businesses, but it recognises the unique place of the pub in rural Ireland. Vintners Federation of Ireland president Michael O'Donovan, in a piece published by the Examiner in May, noted: 'Pubs are the social fabric of rural Ireland. They are where local clubs meet, where fundraisers are held, where neighbours look out for each other. For many older people, a visit to the local pub is a lifeline, a chance to see familiar faces, catch up on local news and feel part of a community. Every pub that closes is another light going out in its community.' He also noted that pubs pay some €567m of the €1.26bn collected in alcohol excise duty, suggesting that some of this money be put toward keeping the industry going. We should recognise that, while some initiatives have been suggested, rural Ireland still needs considerable help, and this should be considered less a burden and more an investment in the country's social and cultural fabric. This is not a call to keep Ireland drinking; far from it. Pubs can reinvent or diversify, as long as the options and support is there. Clock ticking for X on safety rules It was, perhaps, inevitable that at least one of the big digital firms would be tardy in complying with the online safety code, which was brought in last November but which saw its last section come into force on Monday. It was also, perhaps, inevitable that the biggest outlier would be X, formerly Twitter. Under the code, companies are obliged to put measures in place to protect children from harmful material. Since Monday, they have been obliged to restrict access to adult content such as pornography, as well as provide for parental controls. Since its acquisition by Elon Musk (it's now owned by one of his other companies, xAI), the social media company has platformed all manner of hard right and racist detritus, with Musk himself known to champion conspiracy theories and other harmful nonsense. That it launched an anime-style AI assistant that can engage in sexual conversations just days before the code came into force indicates very much where the company's priorities lie. There is no age restriction on that tool, even if it requires a subscription. X has until today to provide answers to Comisiún na Meán, or face fines of up to €10m or 20% of its turnover, whichever is greater. The various online platforms had nine months to get ready for this, even if a sizeable amount of this crossed over with Musk's foray into politics and fractious relationship with US president Donald Trump, as well as declines at his car-marker, Tesla. Still, these are rules and not guidelines, so any failure to adhere to them, especially where child welfare is concerned, should be taken seriously. It remains to be seen just how the regulator will respond if X continues to fail in its responsibilities. It may become the first real test of not just the safety code, but of what teeth regulators have to enforce it. Put an end to dereliction Anything that puts unused property back into circulation is a welcome thing. Any street that has vacant buildings that might once have been shops or businesses looks a very sad thing, and the more they decline the more the town or city around them declines in turn. Dereliction is a blight. So the suggestion by Cork councillor Isobel Towse that empty properties in West Cork be given over — temporarily — to arts or community groups is a welcome one. Importantly, these are not gone in perpetuity: Rather, the idea is that while awaiting longer-term tenants, the buildings are used by smaller groups looking for a base or a home. Noting that some 12.4% of commercial buildings in Co Cork are vacant, among the highest in Europe, she says: 'All of this would boost economic development and innovation, attract tourism, and improve the liveability of towns, and importantly, tackle problematic vacancy and dereliction.' These are all worthwhile points that should be discussed even at the highest level — a pilot project in West Cork, for example, might be a blueprint to bring other parts of rural Ireland back to life as they see their pubs and social avenues decline. But a bigger question when it comes to vacant commercial property is, what about housing? That would be a much longer-term initiative and would have to very carefully weigh the needs of locals and, indeed, property owners. But with grants available for renovating derelict buildings, rural Ireland under pressure as we've noted above, and the country creaking under the weight of housing demand, is it not worth at least a debate? Read More Irish Examiner view: Food price cuts should be on the table in Budget 2026
