Looking To Domestic IT Operations For Data Security

Forbes

4 days ago

Tony Williams Raré, CEO/CIO at Global IT Communications, Inc., overseeing technical and operational strategies for company and customers.
In today's global economy, outsourcing is often seen as a cost-saving solution. The global outsourcing market is expected to reach $866.9 billion by 2027, driven by labor arbitrage and operational flexibility. Yet, increasing cybersecurity threats and shifting U.S. policy are forcing businesses to reconsider the long-term implications, especially when handling sensitive data.
The Illusion of Cost Savings
Outsourcing can initially appear beneficial. A Deloitte outsourcing survey report shows that 57% of businesses outsource to reduce costs. However, while immediate savings are tangible, hidden costs quickly emerge. Quality control, increased management oversight and infrastructure investments all add up. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, outsourced workers earn significantly less than domestic employees, revealing a cost that is both economic and ethical.
More concerning are the risks. IBM's 2024 Cost of a Data Breach Report shows the average breach costs $4.9 million. For companies dealing with protected health information (PHI), financial data or personally identifiable information (PII), those savings can rapidly become liabilities.
Who Bears The Risk?
While operations are outsourced, accountability stays in-house. A PwC study found that 32% of customers would stop using a brand after only one bad experience. Potential language barriers, poor voice quality or time zone differences can impact service delivery and resolution times. High turnover and minimal training at offshore centers can further reduce service consistency. According to a study by Intercom, 70% of end users feel more loyal to companies that provide support in their native language.
HR And Legal Complications
Offshore outsourcing introduces HR and legal complications. U.S. labor laws don't apply abroad, raising ethical and PR issues. Enforcement of intellectual property (IP) rights is weaker in many countries, making businesses vulnerable to trade secret theft and insider threats. The U.S. Department of Justice has increased enforcement under the Defend Trade Secrets Act, particularly in cases involving the mishandling of trade secrets offshore.
Jurisdictional confusion also hinders legal recourse. If offshore personnel mishandle sensitive data, determining liability across borders becomes nearly impossible.
Security And Compliance Failures
Another issue is data security. Offshore data centers and cloud environments frequently replicate or store data across multiple jurisdictions—often without customers' awareness—leading to diminished data control and transparency. U.S.-based organizations embracing cross-border outsourcing must therefore navigate a complex web of legal and regulatory frameworks to maintain compliance and visibility over their sensitive information.
The U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) continues to identify third-party and supply chain attacks as top national cybersecurity threats, particularly as more organizations rely on outsourced and offshore vendors.
Cross-border data workflows present significant compliance challenges, particularly with standards such as HIPAA, SOC 2 and NIST. Processing sensitive data across jurisdictions with different legal protections increases the risk of unauthorized access, data exfiltration and regulatory violations.
Political And Strategic Vulnerabilities
Political tensions and evolving trade policies can disrupt outsourcing relationships. The 2024 Republican platform aims to "stop outsourcing and turn the United States into a manufacturing superpower," potentially signaling more restrictions ahead, particularly in government contracts.
As geopolitical alliances shift, organizations risk sudden disruptions or surveillance by foreign governments. Even with contracts in place, enforcing U.S.-level protections abroad remains difficult.
The Case For Domestic IT Operations
The tide is shifting. U.S.-based managed service providers (MSPs) offer several key advantages:
• Compliance with domestic regulations like CMMC 2.0 and HIPAA
• Seamless communication and customer service
• Lower latency and higher service quality
• Legal and regulatory alignment
Domestic operations can allow for greater control, faster response times and higher accountability.
Strategic Reassessment
The question businesses must ask is: Do the savings justify the risk? Offshore outsourcing may reduce direct costs, but it exposes organizations to regulatory penalties, customer dissatisfaction and long-term brand damage.
To adapt to increasing compliance demands and the evolving security landscape, organizations should consider strengthening their internal governance frameworks—such as implementing role-based access controls and conducting regular third-party risk assessments—to reduce their dependence on outside vendors for sensitive functions. Additionally, investing in cybersecurity training for in-house teams and designating a compliance officer can help ensure ongoing adherence to CMMC 2.0, SOC 2 and NIST standards, even without external partners.
For those considering U.S.-based managed service providers (MSPs), it's essential to assess vendor transparency, data residency policies and experience with regulatory compliance. Look for MSPs with clear incident response plans and the ability to customize security frameworks to meet your industry's specific needs. Common pitfalls to look out for include unclear SLAs, vendor lock-in and underestimating the internal preparation needed to manage third-party partnerships. A readiness checklist—including asset inventory, current documentation and executive alignment—can help ensure smoother collaboration.
Conclusion
The global outsourcing landscape is shifting under the weight of cybersecurity threats, changing regulations and evolving political priorities. Protecting your business's future now means going beyond cost-cutting.
Smart enterprises are reassessing their outsourcing strategies, focusing on domestic partnerships, investing in in-house cybersecurity maturity and refining their governance frameworks. The future belongs to businesses that build resilient, secure and ethically grounded operations that safeguard both customer trust and long-term value.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?