Dublin Islamic centre criticises ‘radicalised' members as internal row deepens
Islamic Cultural Centre of Ireland (ICCI)
at Clonskeagh in Dublin has accused a 'radicalised' wing of the Muslim community of intimidating and trying to 'silence' one of its leading members.
A bitter dispute over control of the centre deepened on Friday when the ICCI criticised attacks on social media against Dr Eid Zaher, who had pleaded during the week for a resolution.
In a letter circulated on Muslim-community WhatsApp groups last Wednesday, Dr Zaher, who is secretary to ICCI imam Sheikh Hussein Halawa, called on an unnamed 'senior official' at the ICCI 'to step down in favour of the public interest and to prevent further harm'.
He also appealed to 'wise and thoughtful members of the Muslim community in Ireland to kindly encourage this senior official to step down'.
READ MORE
The ICCI has been closed since an alleged physical altercation took place there
at a meeting on April 19th, to which gardaí were called
. An auditor has been appointed by the Al Maktoum Foundation, which built and funds the ICCI, to investigate
alleged financial irregularities there
.
In a statement following social media posts about Dr Zaher's intervention this week, the ICCI said it was 'deeply saddened by the radicalised behaviour of certain individuals within our community who have attacked, intimidated, harassed, insulted and defamed Dr Sheikh Eid [Dr Zaher]'.
He 'is a member of the religious Dawah department of our mosque (which gives religious guidance),' it said. 'Such actions to silence dissenting voices are unacceptable' and were 'a cowardly attack and yet another example of the extremist tendencies of certain elements within the community', it said.
'Freedom of expression is a deeply valued principle and an integral part of the shared norms that are firmly established in Irish society,' the ICCI statement said.
'We pray for the enlightenment and reform of these radical elements so that the mosque and centre can reopen in an atmosphere of peace and security for our employees, the children and the community,' it said.
However, as it 'takes seriously the safety and security of our staff, employees and the public', and 'in an effort to maintain the sanctity and security of our beloved mosque, we had to take the difficult decision to close the mosque and centre until further notice', it added.
Meanwhile, a group of Muslims pleaded at a press conference in Dublin on Friday
for the reopening of the mosque at the ICCI
, describing it as 'the heartbeat of our community'.
The Muslim Community Ireland group described itself as 'a grassroots, community-led initiative formed to peacefully advocate for the reopening of the Masjid [mosque] at the ICCI'. Its chair, Abdul Haseeb, insisted they had gathered 'not in protest, but in pain, and in hope'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
No move on Triple Lock from cross-party committee
A cross-party Oireachtas committee examining the Triple Lock which governs the deployment of defence forces personnel overseas has made no recommendation on whether the existing system should be removed or retained. RTÉ News understands the Oireachtas Committee on Defence and National Security's final report on the matter - which will be sent to the Department of Foreign Affairs on Wednesday - does not include a recommendation on the future of the Triple Lock. Under existing rules, any foreign deployment of 12 or more Irish Defence Forces personnel can only take place when it has been approved by: the Dáil, the Government, and has received a United Nations security council mandate. While the rule is heavily linked with Irish neutrality, the Government has called for its removal in recent years, due to concerns the UN security council could see legitimate Irish deployments vetoed by larger nations like the US, China or Russia. The Oireachtas committee on Defence and National Security has been tasked in recent weeks with examining whether the third stage of the triple lock should be removed, changed or retained. However, it is understood that during a lengthy private meeting of the committee yesterday, during which more than 160 amendments to the original 49-page report were discussed, no definitive final conclusion was drawn. Amendments sought by Opposition A number of Sinn Féin and Labour amendments seeking to retain the UN security council stage of the Triple Lock were rejected by votes in the committee, which has a Government majority. However, no specific amendment to remove the UN security council stage was put forward to be included in the committee's final report. A number of TDs and senators on the committee privately told RTÉ News they were surprised no specific amendment to remove the UN security council stage was tabled. Some suggested this was an error by Government party members, others said that this potential removal will be included in the general scheme of a Government bill at a later date, and others suggested there has been a cooling of views within the coalition on the issue. The committee - which includes eight Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael TDs and senators compared to six Opposition TDs and senators, meaning there is a clear coalition parties' majority - will send its final report to the Department of Foreign Affairs on Wednesday. Any Government bill on the future of the Triple Lock will not go before the Dáil and Seanad until autumn.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Transgender prisoner held in ‘squalid, dungeon-like' conditions
A transgender prisoner was found in squalid conditions in a 'dungeon-like' unit of Limerick Prison , said an anti-torture report. The Council of Europe 's Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT) said the inmate, who it referred to as Prisoner X, was kept in near total isolation in the High Protection Unit of Limerick Men's prison with minimal access to natural light and ventilation. The CPT report did not name the prisoner, but it is understood to be a Brazilian named Barbie Kardashian who at the time of the inspection in 2024 was the only transgender prisoner in the custody of the Irish Prison Service. The Kardashian case has caused controversy in the past due to her history of violent offending and concerns about the threat she poses to other inmates and staff. READ MORE In early 2023, she was jailed for 4½ years for threatening to torture, rape and murder her mother. At the time, Leo Varadkar , then taoiseach, said violent biological males should not be housed in women's prisons. Kardashian was initially held in Limerick Women's Prison where she was accused of threatening to kill or cause serious harm to a fellow woman prisoner and a prison officer in 2023. She was transferred to Limerick Men's Prison following a directive from then minister for justice Helen McEntee. Last year, she was acquitted of threatening the woman prisoner and prison officer, but remains in the men's prison serving the remainder of her original sentence. Kardashian (25) is housed in the High Protection Unit on the D1 wing of the prison where inmates who require special protection are kept. Others on the wing include Jonathan Dowdall, the former Sinn Féin councillor who gave evidence against Gerry Hutch. In its report, the CPT described the High Protection Unit as 'dungeon-like' and said it is concerned about a number of prisoners who are held on 22-hour lock-up and 'hence were in a situation of de facto solitary confinement'. The committee said it was 'particularly struck by the situation of a transgender woman' who was 'living in squalid conditions with minimal access to natural light and ventilation.' She is kept in her cell for 23 hours a day, it said. At the end of their visit, the committee members made an 'immediate observation' that the inmate should be placed in a better cell. She should be given more time out of her cell and 'a meaningful regime of activities', it said. In a document responding to the recommendations, the State said the prisoner was able to use 'all services available within the prison'. It said work is ongoing to refurbish D1 wing of the prison. Elsewhere in its report, the CPT was highly critical of the overcrowding affecting most Irish prisons which has resulted in mentally ill prisoners and a pregnant inmate having to sleep on the floor. It was particularly critical of Cloverhill Prison in Dublin where inmates are subject to a 'degrading regime', including squalid cells shared by up to four men sleeping on mattresses on the floor. 'Taken together, this situation, in the Committee's view, may well be described as inhuman and degrading treatment.' The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission (IHREC) called the findings 'harrowing' and called for the State to urgently ratify the UN Optional Protocol to the Convention Against Torture (OPCAT).
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
The people who gave Ireland back part of its past
The recent announcement that the Virtual Treasury project , with its mission to recover archival records lost in the fire that wrecked the Public Record Office (PRO) at the start of the Civil War in 1922, has retrieved 60,000 names from the pre-famine census records that were destroyed, garnered much national and international interest. Boldly imaginative and ambitious, this project was conceived by Dr Peter Crooks of Trinity College Dublin in 2015 and has involved great effort on the part of archivists and historians to locate material in Irish and international archives. An all-island collaborative research endeavour, it involves millions of words being 'linked and reassembled from copies, transcripts and other records scattered among the collections' of numerous archives, including as far away as Australia. A project supported by the State, it is a reminder of Ireland's leading role in digitising and making accessible archival sources, previously underlined by the success of the digitisation and free access to the 1901 and 1911 census returns. Crooks has maintained that the Virtual Treasury project is guided by the spirit of Herbert Wood, the deputy keeper of the PRO, which was established by the Public Record Act (Ireland) 1867. Wood saw the archival records as belonging to the public, not academics: 'The history of a country is founded upon its archives, and the preservation not only of its public but also of its private documents'. He was devastated by the incineration of the priceless records in 1922, as 'the Irish Record Office is starting again like a new country almost without a history'. The project to recover 'seven centuries of Irish history' Listen | 24:57 In 1930, Wood spoke of 'how the body of public records may be reconstructed from duplicates or copies which may be found in other repositories or which have fortunately been printed ... to the numerous literary searchers, who, for over half a century, have been seeking material for their studies in the Record Office, we must be grateful, for much of the result of their research has appeared in print, and thus copies of many a document have been preserved ... It will be a useful and interesting work for some student to wade through all the Irish antiquarian publications and note any copies of public records appearing in those publications.' READ MORE Almost a century on, that work is being embraced with gusto and it is a cultural achievement to be admired. Another relevant spirit in this context is that of Robert Dudley Edwards, UCD professor of modern Irish history from 1944 to 1979, who devoted much of his career to raising archival awareness and whose work and complex personality are uncovered in detail in a new book by his granddaughter Neasa MacErlean, Telling the Truth is Dangerous: How Robert Dudley Edwards Changed Irish History Forever . Dudley Edwards was no saint and the book underlines how he could at times be disputative, inebriated and cruel, but he was an inspiring teacher and had an exceptional sense of purpose and public service. He spent much time traversing the country building awareness of the need to preserve local and national and personal and private documents. As someone centrally involved in building the framework for the academic study of history, he emphasised the importance of proper training and methodological soundness for historians and established the archives department in UCD. [ Black Death, Newgrange and the American Revolution: a virtual trove of Irish history rediscovered Opens in new window ] He was equally aware of the importance of extending the reach of history and archives beyond the confines of the university. Exactly 50 years ago he was vocal about the need for proper archives legislation in Ireland, as in its absence 'historians will necessarily have to rely on British archives for the last word' on Irish history. The answer to his plea eventually came with the National Archives Act of 1986, implemented just before his death in 1988. It is striking how the preoccupations and central messages of both Wood and Dudley Edwards continue to resonate, especially during this era when there is, in some quarters, such a cavalier and dangerous distortion of history and contempt for evidence, and where skewed and selective accounts of the past are weaponised, with devastating results. Dudley Edwards and his generation of historians were particularly mindful of that danger given that they came to public prominence during and after the second World War. In addition, some of the Irish historians of that era who studied in Britain before returning to Ireland, were, as noted by Robert's son Owen, also a historian, 'in a state of boiling rage at the ignorance of Irish history among English historians'. Dudley Edwards was happy, however, to invite British historian Herbert Butterfield to Dublin 80 years ago to deliver a lecture. Butterfield outlined what should be the essential mission of the historian: 'seeking only to make human understanding more profound'. That task is not the preserve of the professional historian; it is relevant to anyone who takes the past seriously.
