Irish women 'still not safe', say Plunkett sisters
Kathleen Nolan and Bernie Plunkett claim nothing has been learned since their sister's murder in 1976 by Ireland's first serial killers - John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans.
The Plunkett family are currently collaborating with RTÉ's seven-part podcast series Stolen Sister to raise awareness around Elizabeth Plunkett's case.
Calling for stricter rules on bail conditions, Ms Plunkett said: "We're going on to 50 years, next year, 76 to 2026. How many women have been murdered in the meantime?"
She added: "This is still happening all these years later. So, if anything, we want to draw attention to the fact women are not safe."
Shaw and Evans were on £40 bail at the time of Elizabeth Plunkett's and later Mayo woman Mary Duffy's murder.
Ms Plunkett said: "If they had held on to them at that time, our Elizabeth would be still alive and so would Mary Duffy.
"But no, they obviously didn't take that seriously enough that two lives had to be lost."
Both men were from the north of England and were arrested in Ireland before the murders for burglary and had a year-long stay in Irish prisons in Limerick and Mountjoy.
When they murdered Elizabeth Plunkett and Mary Duffy, they were awaiting an extradition hearing back to the UK to face rape and sexual assault charges.
Ms Nolan said too much time elapses between missing persons and murder investigations. She believes an elite team should be sent in promptly after a person goes missing "because they're losing too much information".
The women mention the cases of Annie McCarrick and Tina Satchwell as examples of cases where there have been serious questions surrounding investigations.
'Like getting slapped in the face'
Originally Shaw and Evans were charged with the murder, rape and false imprisonment of Elizabeth Plunkett and Mary Duffy.
However, when Shaw applied for parole in 2023, it was revealed he had never been convicted for Elizabeth Plunkett's murder despite previous reports.
The family also discovered that the State did not hold an inquest into the death of Elizabeth Plunkett, nor ever issued a death certificate in her name.
As Shaw was never convicted of any charges relating to Elizabeth Plunkett, her family said they are no longer considered victims of a crime under the 2019 Parole Act and are not entitled to take part in the parole process.
Evans died in 2012.
According to Ms Plunkett, the shock she felt following the revelation from the Parole Board was "like getting slapped in the face".
The collaboration between the family and the Stolen Sister podcast led to an inquest being held into Elizabeth Plunkett's death earlier this year.
Ms Plunkett said the family hope new information gathered during the podcast, which to date includes 11 new witness statements, will also lead to a retrial.
These statements include accounts from women who said they were approached by men they identified as Shaw and Evans.
In late May, the family's solicitor James MacGuill SC wrote to the DPP, the Garda Commissioner and the Minister for Justice requesting a cold case review into her death and a renewed public appeal for evidence.
Aside from an acknowledgement of receipt from the Minister, no further contact has been made.
RTÉ's Documentary On One wrote to the Minister for Justice on 7 March looking for any records relating to Elizabeth Plunkett.
They responded 16 weeks later and are still looking for the records.
In a statement, the minister extended his "deepest condolences" to the family of Elizabeth Plunkett for her tragic death.
The statement read: "While the minister is very much conscious of the case of Ms Plunkett, he is mindful that a number of matters referred to are under the remit of bodies who are independent in the performance of their functions."
"The Department has undertaken a preliminary search of records to identify what is held on file related to this matter.
"Work is ongoing to retrieve and review records on file. When this is complete, the Department will be able to consider the request related to the release of these records."
Ms Plunkett said nearly 50 years ago, the authorities did not have the same access to information gathering, but that excuse is no longer valid in today's world.
"Their investigations were kind of notebook and pen, you know, whereas it's not like that today. And still, the cases are happening."
Her sisters described Elizabeth Plunkett as a social, fun-loving and independent young woman with big ambitions for her future.
"We used to say she's full of notions. Because she wasn't going to just be in Ringsend, and a housewife. She wanted to be big time and style and fashion and go somewhere..." said Ms Plunkett.
While taking part in the Stolen Sister podcast has been difficult for the sisters, Ms Plunkett said they are "prepared to take the punches to get the justice we want".
If anyone has any information on John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans, the Plunkett family have asked that you contact the podcast makers through documentaries@rte.ie.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
44 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Radiographer banned from conducting X-rays on anyone under 18 for 12 months
A radiographer who was found guilty of professional misconduct over his inappropriate behaviour in carrying out a chest X-ray on a young female patient whom he later tried to contact via social media has been banned from conducting any radiography services on anyone under 18 for 12 months. The prohibition on carrying out X-rays on children and adolescents apart from exceptional circumstances and then only under the supervision of a healthcare practitioner is one of five conditions imposed on the registration of radiographer, Adrian Peconcillo, by CORU – the regulatory body of health and social care professionals. It follows a fitness-to-practise inquiry by CORU earlier this year at which Peconcillo admitted he had acted in a manner that was not clinically justified or appropriate when he was carrying out a chest X-ray on a 16-year-old girl at Tallaght University Hospital on January 25, 2023. The inquiry heard that the patient had come out of the changing area undressed from the waist up and covering her chest due to the failure of Peconcillo to provide her with a hospital gown prior to her undressing. The radiographer – an Irish citizen who comes originally from the Philippines – was also accused of looking at her in a forward-facing manner whilst her back was against the X-ray board and later inviting her to look at her X-ray while she remained undressed. Evidence was heard that Peconcillo had also sent the teenager one or more follow requests to her Instagram account on the same date that were inappropriate and without any clinical justification. It emerged that the radiographer had tried to contact her with his own Instagram account which was in the name of 'Adrian Wanderman'. He had originally claimed in correspondence with CORU that he had sent the Instagram request to an Australian DJ with the same name as the girl. The girl's father said his daughter had been doing her mock exams at the time and her head was 'all over the place' and she was blaming herself for the incident. The inquiry was held after a formal complaint was made to CORU about Peconcillo's behaviour by the radiography services manager at TUH, Laura Gannon. It heard that Peconcillo was suspended by TUH after the teenager's parents had made a complaint to the hospital and he was subsequently dismissed in April 2023 following an internal investigation. The CORU inquiry heard he has not worked as a radiographer since but had found employment as a phlebotomist at St Vincent's University Hospital in Dublin where he primarily works with geriatric patients but on a salary 50% less than he earned in TUH. The fitness-to-practise committee also found the radiographer's actions constituted breaches of the Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics adopted by the Radiographers Registration Board. They related to his failure to maintain high standards of personal conduct and behaviour and to use social media responsibly. The committee noted that Peconcillo had shown remorse and recognised his poor judgement in dealing with the young patient. The committee's chairperson, Geraldine Feeney, said they had considered a period of suspension to be the appropriate sanction but had decided against it in circumstances where Mr Peconcillo had not worked as a radiographer for almost two years. The committee rejected an application by his legal representatives for the inquiry to be concluded by his consenting to admonishment and censure and giving an undertaking about his future conduct. Ms Feeney said the seriousness of the proven allegations required some form of sanction. She said the committee also recognised that the incidents had been devastating for the radiographer both professionally and personally after he lost his job and was refused access to his only child by his former partner. The committee observed that there were 'system shortcomings' within TUH that had facilitated Peconcillo's actions albeit they did not excuse such conduct. Other conditions imposed on the radiographer require him to complete courses relating to safeguarding children and vulnerable adults as well as ones on social media and professional practice and relating to professional ethics, trust, care and dignity in the workplace. All courses have to be completed within 12 months and at his own expense. CORU also required Peconcillo to notify any current or prospective employer about the findings against him and the conditions attached to his registration to practise as a radiographer. The decision to attach conditions to the radiographer's registration was confirmed by the High Court earlier this week.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Senior FAI figure resigns from post
The vice-president of the FAI, John Finnegan, has resigned from his position at Irish soccer's governing body. He will, however, remain as the chairperson of the Munster Senior League. He has been a part of the FAI Board since 2019 and was made vice-president in 2023. His departure is said to be for personal and family reasons. The resignation comes after an anonymous email received by the FAI which detailed "a wider culture that remains toxic, unaccountable and in many cases unchanged despite past scandals" and named certain individuals involved in this. In a statement, the FAI said: "The Football Association of Ireland confirms that John Finnegan has resigned from his position as Vice President of the Association with immediate effect, due to personal and family reasons. "The Board has accepted his resignation and thanks him for his service to the association over the past number of years." His solicitor, Brendan O'Sullivan, spoke on his client's previous disciplinary process with a former employer in 2013, saying it had nothing to do with his resignation. He said: "He is resigning for personal and family matters. This regrettable incident happened 15 years ago. "It was handled at the time and the finding was that inappropriate language was used in messages. John would now like to put this matter behind him."
The Journal
2 hours ago
- The Journal
Ashling Murphy's partner settles BBC defamation case over reporting on victim impact statement
THE DEFAMATION CASE taken by Ryan Casey, the partner of murdered school teacher Ashling Murphy, against the BBC following comments made about his victim impact statement on a live broadcast has been settled, the High Court heard this morning. In a statement released after the settlement, Casey said he was now 'finally free' to use his voice again, to honour Ashling and to 'advocate for the changes we desperately require in this country'. 'Let's honour Ashling by building a better and safer Ireland,' he said. The BBC said it was 'happy to clarify' that it does not consider Casey to be 'someone guilty of or attempting to incite hatred'. Casey had taken the case in relation to a BBC Northern Ireland broadcast of 'The View' programme in November 2023, relating to Casey's victim impact statement at the sentencing of Ms Murphy's murderer Josef Puska. Casey was represented by Ronan Lupton SC, instructed by Tullamore firm Brian P Adams & Company. At the High Court today Alan Keating SC, for the BBC, read out a statement on the settlement of the case on behalf of the broadcaster. 'In the BBC's 30 November, 2023 episode of its live political programme 'The View', Ryan Casey's victim impact statement at the sentencing of his late partner's murderer was discussed. 'The BBC stands by the journalism involved in this episode which debated serious issues of public interest. 'The BBC is happy to clarify that it does not consider Ryan Casey to be a criminal or a racist or someone guilty of or attempting to incite hatred, or someone seeking to pose as a hero of the Far Right through his victim impact statement. 'The BBC acknowledges Casey's personal tragedy. This statement clarifies any unintentional inferences that could have been drawn from the broadcast and has enabled the BBC and Ryan Casey to resolve this matter amicably,' the statement read. It is understood the settlement is a six-figure sum. Justice Alexander Owens then struck out the case and made no order. Advertisement Jozef Puska (35) murdered Ms Murphy (23) on 12 January 2022, by repeatedly stabbing her in the neck after attacking her while she exercised along the canal towpath outside Tullamore, Co Offaly. He was later convicted of murder and is serving a life sentence. Originally from Slovakia, Puska had lived in Offaly with his wife and five children. Ashling Murphy, a talented traditional Irish musician and recent graduate from Mary Immaculate College in Limerick, was working as a teacher at Durrow National School at the time of her murder. Casey's statement In his statement, Casey said he welcomed the resolution of the matter and said the case was not just about him but about 'truth, fairness and decency'. His statement reads: 'Today marks the end of a long and difficult chapter of frustration and censorship. 'I took this legal action against the BBC not solely out of anger but out of a need for accountability and dignity for Ashling, for myself, our families and for all victims who deserve to have their voices heard without such harsh criticism or judgment. 'I welcome the resolution of these legal proceedings and the acknowledgements made by the BBC in their statement in open court today. 'I hope this serves as a reminder to all media organisations of the high level of responsibility that comes with running such public platforms. 'This was never just about me, it was about truth, fairness and decency. 'To everyone who supported me either in person, by post, text messages, phone calls, social media posts and comments over the last three-and-a-half years: I can now finally come forward and say from the bottom of my heart thanks to each and every one of you. 'Don't think for a second I didn't see all your amazing support across all platforms, it was humbling to say the least. 'I'd like to thank my lawyers, Ronan [Lupton SC], Gerard [Groarke BL] and Marianne [Deeley, solicitor] for their fantastic guidance, support and professionalism throughout the entire legal proceedings. 'I now move forward, finally free to use my voice again, to honour Ashling and to advocate for the changes we desperately require in this country, for the increased safety measures we so desperately need, and for a society that listens to its people, free of gaslighting, blacklisting or censorship. 'We all have a lot more in common than what separates us. 'Let's honour Ashling by building a better and safer Ireland, we all know we can do so much better,' he said. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
