
Bara hospital: The good, bad and ugly
I was shortly to be transported from my bed in a very public – and noisy – ward onto a gurney and thence to the theatre.
There, a growing tumour was to be removed from my bladder. For I was in Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital in Soweto.
While awaiting my imminent hour of reckoning in theatre, I contemplated my brief journey to that moment.
It had all started a little over eight weeks previously when I had been incarcerated in a Netcare hospital seeking relief from a burgeoning sarcoma adjacent to my chest wall.
This malevolent growth had bloomed in a few short weeks, inducing, in the latter stages, chattering cold followed by blazing fevers on a daily basis.
And with an infection count of 200 – normal is zero – I was swiftly whisked into the high care ward of the hospital.
There were 14 beds curtained off, each with a TV screen and a locker for the few belongings.
Nurses, perhaps one for every two patients, clean towels, a green hospital gown into which you were expected to change and wear and two fully equipped bathrooms, plus several washing stations with soap dispensers.
And as expected, spotlessly clean. As for the meals, they are definitely edible, top boarding school stuff.
Ultrasound and MRI scans, chest X-rays and all other preparatory procedures were conducted swiftly and efficaciously.
ALSO READ: 'I could die before surgery': Cancer patient lost in Gauteng hospitals backlog
Your nurse could be summoned by the simple act of pressing a button, and lo! She manifested.
Once the operation was concluded, a visiting physio forced one to get out of bed and move around.
All of the above I recalled in a haze, which blurred into my arrival at Bara.
A total of 20 hours patiently queuing with a few hundred others over two days seeking admission, which, once granted, involved my finding my way from urology to ECGs and X-rays, through pharmacy and into accident and emergency, where I was informed my transport to a faraway ward could be accessed.
Carrying just a small canvas bag containing basic toiletries and a few snacks, I was squeezed into an already overloaded minibus and careened off through the vast confusion of Bara.
Finally, I arrived at a vast modern complex built to accommodate large numbers of Covid-19 patients, which never happened.
I set about finding my ward. Echoing long, empty corridors and passing several empty or half-empty wards, I finally arrived.
Large cubicles simply furnished… my own was equipped with a bed, a thin blanket and a thinner pillow encased in a thick plastic covering.
There were no lights behind the beds, allowing one to read. And there was a small locker. Nothing to change into, no gowns provided, the good-natured nurses smiled apologetically.
There were two large lavatories cum shower rooms, both spotless. But, sadly, no soap or towels. More smiling apologies.
ALSO READ: Gauteng hospitals get major tech overhaul to slash scan backlogs
The toilet bowls are clean, but they are devoid of seats. The harsh reality of a large state hospital and its offerings came as a sharp corrective.
The next day, I was transferred back into the main hospital building – the surgical ward where patients due for imminent surgery were bedded.
This was bedlam compared to the calm, quiet half-empty ward in which I had spent the previous night.
Patients head to toe in a corridor, in which I was shown my bed. Of privacy in a cubicle, there was none, of lockers, there were none.
Nor were there blankets on my bed, so two large coats were found and thrown over me. Nor was I offered anything to wear.
The following morning I was handed a pair of hospital pyjamas unnervingly similar to concentration camp uniforms and, of course, forbidden any food I nervously awaited the inevitable.
I had already received visits from the young anaesthetist and one of the surgical team members, who had done their best to calm my fluttering nerves.
Finally, the moment of reckoning. A porter arrived with the gurney, I climbed on, nerves jangling uncontrollably and then, as we moved, unbelievably and unexpectedly, the sound of singing.
Had I died and gone to heaven? It was the Lord's prayer, voices exquisitely harmonised. Around the corner in the main ward, they stood – a small shimmering complement of young women who sang.
All fear evaporated as I was wheeled at speed to the anteroom outside the theatre, my anxieties utterly stilled. In that lucid calm, I knew I was safe.
NOW READ: Alarm raised over 'R1.7bn fire safety gap' at Charlotte Maxeke hospital

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

IOL News
9 hours ago
- IOL News
Checkers employee's dismissal upheld by Labour Court for mask violation during Covid-19
A former Checkers employee was unsuccessful in his bid to get his job back after he was dismissed for not wearing a mask during Covid-19. A former Checkers employee was unsuccessful in his bid to regain his job after he was dismissed for failing to wear a mask during the Covid-19 outbreak. Kamogelo Ramogotwane, through the South African Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers Union (SACCAWU), brought a review application in the Labour Court in Johannesburg seeking to overturn a decision made by the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA). During proceedings at the CCMA, Ramogotwane acknowledged his failure to wear a mask—a requirement imposed both by his employer and governmental health regulations at the time. Yet, he argued that rather than facing dismissal, he should have received a warning. However, the Commissioner found that Ramogotwane was fully aware of the rules set by Checkers and the legal mandates that enforced mask-wearing. Therefore, the Commissioner found that a dismissal was appropriate due to the consequences of not wearing a mask.


Daily Maverick
20 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Deepfake of renowned SA physician used to promote bogus heart medicine
''The [deepfake video] has me saying anti-vax things… This company has just pounced on me, and they're not letting me go,' said Abdool Karim. A deepfake video, generated using artificial intelligence (AI) technology, is using the likeness of the renowned South African physician Prof Salim Abdool Karim to push disinformation about Covid-19 vaccines and promote a bogus heart medicine on social media. Abdool Karim, the director of the Centre for the Aids Programme of Research in South Africa (Caprisa), has refuted the contents of the video and reiterated that Covid-19 vaccines are safe. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads 'The [deepfake video] has me saying anti-vax things… This company has just pounced on me, and they're not letting me go. They are using me, and I think they're using me because it's good for their sales,' Abdool Karim told Daily Maverick. Caprisa said, 'Neither Abdool Karim nor Caprisa have endorsed any medicines for any company.' Snake-oil remedy It's the second time the scam company has used an AI deepfake video of Abdool Karim to market its product, with the previous video emerging around September last year. Before that, it used a still image of him on posters for the fake cure, shared on social media. The most recent deepfake video gives the appearance of an SABC news report in which Abdool Karim responds to a presenter. The AI-generated Abdool Karim gives a false account of blood clots linked to Covid-19 vaccines, before encouraging viewers to 'cleanse' their blood vessels using 'a unique formula, breakthrough remedy, that dissolves all types of clots after just one treatment cycle'. Despite the continued misuse of his identity, Abdool Karim said that little legal recourse could be pursued against those responsible. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads 'When [the adverts] first came out, I was furious and I said, 'I'm going to spare no cost in going after these guys'… We hired people to go and investigate it. We spent quite a bit of money, and when … we were getting close to figuring things out, we realised actually, this is best described by a fairground game called Whack-a-Mole,' he said. 'When you try to stop one, another emerges. So, there's no end to this.' The investigating team linked the scam to a Tanzanian company with a warehouse in Midrand, Johannesburg, but just as it narrowed down its search, the operation closed down and disappeared. A few weeks later, another advert using Abdool Karim's image emerged, seemingly shared by the same group. 'We tried to take out an injunction against them, but it proved to be a real challenge because we don't know who we're taking out an injunction against,' said Abdool Karim. 'I realised you actually have no legal recourse against these people, because it's not an established firm. It's not trading on any reputation. It's trading on my reputation because they have no reputation of their own. They're just a fly-by-night… There's nothing that creates an opportunity for us because they're not legal.' The scam company uses paid adverts on Facebook to circulate its marketing material, according to Abdool Karim. From there, users of the platform share the posters or videos on other social media platforms, including WhatsApp. After each advert, Abdool Karim gets up to 20 emails from members of the public seeking to buy the fake medicine, or reporting side effects as a result of its use. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads 'No stone unturned' In a statement released on Thursday, 26 June, the National Department of Health said it was aware of the AI-generated video of Abdool Karim that undermined the safety of Covid-19 vaccines. 'According to our information, these actions are meant to hoodwink members of the public into buying fake heart medicine. This is done through mail order, and the fake product is obviously not working or is making people feel even sicker,' said the health department. 'Minister [of Health Dr Aaron] Motsoaledi condemns in the strongest terms possible the fake news campaign by these charlatans with business interests, who for their nefarious reasons are determined to create confusion among the people for the sake of immoral profiteering.' Motsoaledi encouraged the public to rely on vaccines approved by the South African Health Products Regulatory Authority (Sahpra) and the National Department of Health. The department said it would leave 'no stone unturned' in combating the efforts of the scam company. Caprisa urged members of the public to: Refer to credible sources such as Caprisa, Sahpra, the Department of Health or a trusted, registered healthcare professional for accurate health information; Verify the authenticity of health claims, products and possible actions that are being recommended; Report any instances of fake news found online directly to the hosting social media platform, such as X, Facebook or TikTok; and Refrain from sharing fake news images, videos or messaging on mobile chat groups. Social media and health disinformation Abdool Karim noted that while there was a long history of disinformation in health, recent years had seen these narratives becoming more organised. Those sharing disinformation no longer had to depend on mainstream media, where fact-checking acted as a barrier to many false claims. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads 'Covid was a turning point, and what [happened during] Covid was that disinformation … became organised and it became amplified through social media,' he said. The 'moguls of social media' had effectively resisted controls and regulations on their platforms, said Abdool Karim, citing the example of a recent development in Canada where the government rescinded a tax on big US technology firms due to US President Donald Trump threatening to call off negotiations over a trade deal. 'That just tells you how much [Trump] is in the pocket of these social media moguls, and they will not tolerate any regulation. They will fight regulation in any country … because they see it as … affecting their bottom line,' he said. 'All of these companies have now either reduced or completely eliminated their curation and fact checking… I actually don't hold out much hope that we can reasonably regulate and control these big companies. Every indication is the opposite. They control everyone else.' Reflecting on the changes that could reduce the spread of disinformation on virtual platforms, Abdool Karim said there should be a warning label on social media pages that had not been fact-checked, showing that the content may not be true. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads 'The second thing is that I think we need to educate the next group of youngsters that they should have a high level of healthy scepticism when they go on to social media platforms because I worry that they think it's all real, and that they get sucked into these fake worlds,' he said. 'We have to educate the next generation to understand that everything they see [on social media] should be taken first and foremost … as a lie.' DM


Daily Maverick
20 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Don't panic about new SARS-CoV-2 variant, experts say
Covid has largely dropped out of the headlines, but the virus that causes it is still circulating. We ask what we should know about a new variant of SARS-CoV-2, the state of the Covid pandemic in 2025, and the lack of access to updated vaccines in South Africa. In the leafy Johannesburg suburb of Sandringham, the National Institute for Communicable Diseases (NICD) bears a deceptive facade. Do not be fooled by its sleepy campus, clustered face brick buildings and shade-cloth parking, this government facility is home to state-of-the-art biosafety laboratories and some of South Africa's top virologists, microbiologists and epidemiologists. Here, 71 scientists are tasked daily with laboratory-based disease surveillance to protect the country from pathogen outbreak events. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads On 5 March 2020, then health minister Dr Zweli Mkhize announced South Africa's first Covid infection at an NICD press briefing. At the time, the NICD was an obscure acronym for many, but that quickly changed as the institution became central to the country's pandemic response. While the Covid pandemic may have waned, the NICD hasn't stopped monitoring. That is because there remains a global public health risk associated with Covid. The World Health Organization (WHO) states: 'There has been evidence of decreasing impact on human health throughout 2023 and 2024 compared to 2020-2023, driven mainly by: High levels of population immunity, achieved through infection, vaccination, or both; Similar virulence of currently circulating JN.1 sublineages of the SARS-CoV-2 virus as compared with previously circulating Omicron sublineages; and The availability of diagnostic tests and improved clinical case management. SARS-CoV-2 circulation nevertheless continues at considerable levels in many areas, as indicated in regional trends, without any established seasonality and with unpredictable evolutionary patterns.' Thus, while SARS-CoV-2 is still circulating, it is clearly not making remotely as many people ill or claiming nearly as many lives as it did four years ago. Asked about this, Foster Mohale, spokesperson for the National Department of Health, says, 'There are no reports of people getting severely sick and dying due to Covid in South Africa at the current moment.' advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads 'Variant under monitoring' As SARS-CoV-2 circulates, it continues to mutate. The WHO recently designated variant NB.1.8.1 as a new variant under monitoring. There is, however, no reason for alarm. Professor Anne von Gottberg, laboratory head at the NICD's Centre for Respiratory Diseases and Meningitis, tells Spotlight that NB.1.8.1 is not a cause for panic, particularly not in South Africa. Von Gottberg says no cases of the new variant have been detected in South Africa. She refers to her unit's latest surveillance of respiratory pathogens report for the week of 2 to 8 June 2025. It states that out of 189 samples tested, 41 (21.7%) cases were influenza, another 41 (21.7%) cases were respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), and three (1.6%) cases were earlier strains of SARS-CoV-2. These figures suggest much greater circulation of influenza and RSV in South Africa than SARS-CoV-2. Over the past six months, 3,258 samples were tested, revealing 349 (10.7%) cases of influenza, 530 (16.3%) cases of RSV, and 106 (3.3%) cases of SARS-CoV-2. Since most people who become sick because of these viruses are not tested, these figures do not paint the whole picture of what is happening in the country. As of 23 May 2025, the WHO considered the public health risk of NB.1.8.1 to be 'low at the global level', with 518 iterations of the variant submitted from 22 countries, mainly around Asia and the Pacific islands. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads The WHO report states: 'NB.1.8.1 exhibits only marginal additional immune evasion over LP.8.1 [first detected in July 2024]. While there are reported increases in cases and hospitalisations in some of the WPR [Western Pacific Region] countries, which has the highest proportion of NB.1.8.1, there are no reports to suggest that the associated disease severity is higher as compared to other circulating variants. The available evidence on NB.1.8.1 does not suggest additional public health risks relative to the other currently circulating Omicron descendent lineages.' advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Combating misinformation Von Gottberg says that the NICD plays a critical public health communication role in combating misinformation and warns against alarmist and inaccurate online depictions of NB.1.8.1, the Omicron-descendent lineage dubbed 'Nimbus' by some commentators. 'There's fake news about NB.1.8.1 going around on social media,' she says. 'For example, supposed symptoms. I have been trying to look for articles and have not seen anything from [reliable sources],' she says. 'In fact, there is no information about whether there are any differences in symptoms, because there are so few cases and it is not causing more severe disease.' Von Gottberg implores members of the public to check information sources. 'We try hard – and the Department of Health does the same – to put media releases out so that accurate information is shared. What we ask is that all our clients, the public, verify information before they start retweeting or resending.' advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Covid vaccines in South Africa The WHO recommends that countries ensure continued equitable access to and uptake of Covid vaccines. They also note that the currently approved Covid vaccines are expected to remain effective against the new variant. But contrary to WHO advice, newer Covid vaccines are not available in South Africa and continued access to older vaccinations seems to have ceased. When Spotlight called two branches of two major pharmacy retailers in Cape Town, asking for available Covid vaccines, the answer at both was that they had none. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Several recently approved Covid vaccines are being used in other countries but are not available in South Africa. These include Moderna's updated mRNA boosters, approved in the United States and parts of Europe, Novavax's Nuvaxovid vaccine, approved in the United States, and Arcturus Therapeutics's self-amplifying mRNA vaccine Zapomeran, approved in Europe. Self-amplifying mRNA vaccines have the additional capacity to induce longer-lasting immune responses by replicating the spike-proteins of SARS-CoV-2. None of these vaccines are under review for registration in South Africa, according to the South African Health Products Regulatory Authority (Sahpra). Vaccines may not be made available in the country without the green light from Sahpra. 'It may be advisable to contact the owners of the vaccines to obtain clarity on whether they intend to submit for registration,' says Sahpra spokesperson Yuven Gounden. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Spotlight on Friday sent questions to Moderna, Novavax and Arcturus, asking whether they planned to submit their vaccines for registration with Sahpra, and if not, why not. None of the companies responded by the time of publication. Von Gottberg explains that vaccines can become available in South Africa only if their manufacturers submit them to Sahpra for approval. 'So, if a vaccine provider, a vaccine manufacturer, does not want to sell in our country because they do not see it as a lucrative market, they may not even put it forward for regulation so that it can be made available.' Professor of Vaccinology at the University of the Witwatersrand, Shabir Madhi, says the major concern with the lack of licensed SARS-CoV-2 vaccines in South Africa is that 'high-risk individuals remain susceptible to severe Covid, as there is waning of immunity'. 'High-risk individuals should receive a booster dose every 6-12 months, preferably with the vaccine that is updated against current or most recent variants,' he says. Von Gottberg has similar concerns. 'My hope as a public health professional is that these vaccine manufacturers take us seriously as a market in South Africa and in Africa, very importantly, and put these vaccines and products through our regulatory authorities so that they can be made available both in the public and in the private sector for all individuals who are at risk and should be receiving these vaccines,' she says. Gounden notes that should a public health need arise, 'Sahpra is ready to respond in terms of emergency use approval.' Concerns over vaccine expert dismissals in the United States Earlier this month in the United States, Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr. fired all 17 members of the Advisory Committee on Immunisation Practices (ACIP) – an expert body responsible for recommending vaccines for 60 years. He then appointed eight new members, some known for vaccine scepticism. Commenting on this, Von Gottberg says: 'I am hoping there will be those who will think about what he [Kennedy] is doing and question it. It is an unusual situation in the United States, you cannot call it business as usual.' In an article published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, former ACIP members voice grave concerns over the dismissals. 'Vaccines are one of the greatest global public health achievements. Vaccine recommendations have been critical to the global eradication of smallpox and the elimination of polio, measles, rubella, and congenital rubella syndrome in the US. 'They have also dramatically decreased cases of hepatitis, meningitis, mumps, pertussis (whooping cough), pneumonia, tetanus, and varicella (chickenpox), and prevented cancers caused by hepatitis B virus and human papilloma viruses. Recent scientific advancements enabled the accelerated development, production and evaluation of Covid vaccines…' they write. The article also questioned the announcement by Kennedy Jr on X that he had signed a directive to withdraw the recommendation for Covid vaccination in healthy children and healthy pregnant people. '[R]ecent changes to Covid vaccine policy, made directly by the HHS secretary and released on social media, appear to have bypassed the standard, transparent and evidence-based review process. Such actions reflect a troubling disregard for the scientific integrity that has historically guided US immunisation strategy,' the authors warn. Von Gottberg adds: 'We hope that this anti-vax, the denialism of vaccines and the good they do, won't come to South Africa.' In addition, she cautions public healthcare professionals to take heed of this discourse. 'We must take seriously that people have questions, and that they want to see us doing things correctly, transparently, always telling people of our conflicts of interest, being very upfront when things are controversial, when it's difficult to make decisions,' she says 'So I think what this teaches us is not to be complacent in the way we talk and write about vaccines, discuss vaccines, and we must take our clients, the public out there, seriously and hear their voices, listen to their questions.' DM This article was first published by Spotlight – health journalism in the public interest. Sign up to the Spotlight newsletter.