Equalities watchdog threatened with legal action after saying trans women must use men's toilets
The Equalities and Human Rights Commission (EHRC)'s was published in the wake of last month's Supreme Court ruling on gender, which ruled trans women are not legally women under the Equalities Act.
The guidance states that trans women 'should not be permitted to use the women's facilities' in workplaces or public-facing services such as shops and hospitals.
But lawyers acting on behalf of leading UK trans rights group TransLucent have now sent a letter to the watchdog warning that the guidance 'incorrectly states the legal position' of the court ruling.
The letter, seen by The Independent, criticises the body, saying it failed to consult with trans people before publishing its interim guidance, ahead of an ongoing consultation on the issue.
It demands the EHRC issue a clarification statement and criticised the commission's chair Baroness Falkner's description of the ruling as a "a victory for common sense' and another which stated: "If a male is allowed to use a women-only service, it isn't any longer a single-sex space."
The campaigners argue the remarks have caused 'immense distress to the trans community and confusion to both service providers and employers'.
Meanwhile, lawyers Leigh Day warned: 'The worry for our client is that there has not yet been any consultation with trans communities and other affected groups, and the statements from the chair and commissioner that followed the publication of the update, particularly in relation to provision of single sex spaces, suggest that their minds are closed to any other outcome.'
The letter adds: 'If those are their personal views, then, while still unsatisfactory, they should have made that very clear. In any event, it is incumbent on the EHRC to provide urgent clarity so as not to undermine the fairness of the forthcoming consultation.'
It urges the EHRC to respond by May 19 and confirm whether it plans to issue clarification.
Steph Richards, CEO of TransLucent, warned that the watchdog 'appears to have ignored the fact that trans people are still protected under the Equality Act and, as such, can only be legally discriminated against in circumstances when it is a 'proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim'.'
It comes amid mounting concern over the impact of the EHRC's guidance, with Labour MP Nadia Whittome telling The Independent it was a 'devastating blow for trans people and their rights'.
'This guidance is not statutory but it indicates what the draft statutory guidance is likely to contain. It is essential that the government rejects it', the MP for Nottingham East said.
'The Equality and Human Rights Commission should be safeguarding trans people's rights at a time when they are being threatened. Sadly, this vital institution has fallen victim to successful attempts by the previous Conservative government to co-opt it in line with its agenda, undermining its independence and neutrality.'
Meanwhile, Carla Denyer, co-leader of the Green Party, said the interim guidance was 'rushed and ill-thought-through, and was clearly drawn up without consulting trans people on their experiences and needs'.
'I'm worried that the guidance could act as a bigot's charter, emboldening people to harass and victimise trans people in public places, and the Green Party has called for it to be withdrawn until something more considered can be produced.'
jane fae, director of fellow trans rights group TransActual, told The Independent the organisation is also 'watching very carefully and are ready to take legal action should it be necessary'.
'We welcome this analysis from TransLucent. It is very clear that in her intemperate rush to self publicity, the head of the EHRC Baroness Falkner did not take the time to consult with groups affected and as a result she has caused alarm, distress and further encouraged vigilantism against trans people.
'We echo TransLucent's conclusion that her stance is very concerning and would question whether she is a fit person to be in charge of the equalities commission', she said.
The letter was sent to the EHRC on Monday, The Independent understands.
A UK government spokesperson said: 'The EHRC is an independent regulator, and we will review their Code of Practice and work with them to ensure it provides the certainty and clarity service providers and businesses need, in line with the Supreme Court ruling.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
28 minutes ago
- The Sun
Norman Tebbit was a wise politician whose destiny was decided by love… he should be seen as an inspiration to all
NORMAN TEBBIT has died at the age of 94, but we shall feel his steely, steadfast presence for many years to come. Because nobody ever came closer to diagnosing what ails this country better than Norman 'Bites Yer Legs' Tebbit. 6 6 Derided in his prime as a knuckle-dragging skinhead by his lefty political opponents and soft-bellied satirists, Tebbit was, in reality, the most wise and prescient of politicians. It feels like he saw it all in his Chingford crystal ball — our nation's post-Covid torpor, the lazy working from home culture, the 4.2million working age individuals now claiming health benefits. Norman saw it all coming — this country fit for skivers that we have become. So Tebbit's words become even more relevant as time goes by. 'My father did not riot,' he said, in response to the view that the widespread riots of 1981 were caused by unemployment. 'He got on his bike and looked for work, and he kept looking until he found it.' Norman Tebbit never told anyone to get on their bike. What he said was that his father got on his own bike during the Great Depression, proving that nobody should ever rely on the state to feed their family when they can do it themselves. It is ultimately the most life-affirming of belief systems. The state is NOT the answer to each and every human problem. We are better human beings — healthier, happier, more at peace with ourselves — if we can solve our own problems. This was not the patrician Conservatism of the past. This was the Tory creed of the future — born not on the playing fields of Eton but in the streets of Essex. So much of what goes on today would have had Norman's skull-like head tightening with fury. Tebbit was never against immigration — he was against a lack of INTEGRATION, and knew in his bones that a multi- racial, multicultural country would never work unless we all believed in the same values, and if we all felt the same pride and affection in the country we call home. Norman Tebbit lived. He transformed two years of National Service into a visa to another life — becoming a pilot first for the RAF, and later for the British Overseas Airways Corporation. Appalling injuries He once crawled from a burning cockpit after smashing the glass. That is what he was doing at an age when today's MPs were getting their PPE degrees at Oxford or working as human rights lawyers. No wonder Norman had the bottle to take on the big beasts of the trade union movement. Tebbit believed in the power of the individual — to pay their way, to change their life, to look after and protect those they love. It is the brand of Conservatism that believes we all prosper when the raw animal spirit of private enterprise is unleashed. All the nanny-state policies that have killed that spirit — prolonged lockdowns, endless state handouts, massive pay rises for public sector unions, the conviction of both Tory and Labour politicians that the British people need the state to wipe our helpless bottoms — were all anathema to Norman Tebbit. It is ironic that he is seen as a hard man, an uncaring man. Because there was nobody more compassionate than Tebbit. He was a man whose destiny was decided by love. Norman Tebbit, modern working-class Conservatism made flesh and blood and bone, could reasonably have expected to take over from Margaret Thatcher when her time was done. Instead, he gave his life to another Margaret — his wife of 64 years, who was paralysed from the neck down in the IRA bombing of Brighton's Grand Hotel at the Tory Party Conference of 1984. Tebbit also suffered appalling injuries in the terrorist attack that caused him great pain for the rest of his life. But his beloved wife would never walk again and would always need help with everyday tasks. So Norman walked away from his career to care for Margaret. He was always by her side. There was never anything more important in his world than the wife who, he knew, was not even that interested in politics. 'An inspiration to all Conservatives,' Kemi Badenoch called Norman Tebbit. I would put it even higher. Norman Tebbit was an inspiration to the human race. WRITER HIT BY SALT BURNS 6 THE Salt Path is a beautiful book. But the reason Raynor Winn's story exploded – a massive bestseller turned into a film starring Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs – is because its tale of a destitute married couple walking England's South West Coast Path was pitched to the world as an 'unflinchingly honest' true story. And that now seems, ahem, unlikely. Some of the alleged fabrications, uncovered by a forensic investigation by the Observer newspaper, are merely embarrassing. Raynor Winn and her partner Moth were once called plain old Sally and Tim Walker. Moth's terminal illness CBD – in The Salt Path he is presented as a man with one hiking boot in the grave – is perhaps not quite as terminal as it is cracked up to be. Nine neurologists raised a wry eyebrow at the notion of Moth living for so many years (12 and counting) with a condition that was expected to kill him in six to eight years. In response, Winn has posted letters addressed to Timothy Walker, which she said showed he had been treated for CBD for 'many years'. But one letter said Moth was 'affected very mildly' by CBD, another suggested he had an 'atypical' form of the condition. But the truly damaging allegation is that Winn embezzled a previous employer, the late Martin Hemmings, out of £64,000 when she was his bookkeeper – and that is why she eventually became homeless. 'Her claims that it was all just a business deal that went wrong really upset me,' says Hemmings' widow, Ros. 'Highly misleading,' said Raynor Winn of the Observer expose – later issuing a lengthy statement offering vague 'regrets' about 'past mistakes', maintaining her book was 'accurate'. Which doesn't really clear things up, does it? The Salt Path's millions of readers have a right to know if this beloved book is ultimately based on lies. And a grubby crime. Until then, we will just have to think of it as The-Pinch-of-Salt-Path. SO WHY NO ROMP ROUND TWO, CHARLIZE? CHARLIZE THERON, 49, tells the Call Her Daddy podcast about an amazing one-night stand. 'I've probably had three one-night stands in my entire life,' confesses the actress. 'But I did recently f* a 26-year-old and it was really f*ing amazing.' Lucky Charlize. Even luckier 26-year-old! But I am just a teeny-weeny bit sceptical about tales of one-off brief encounters where the earth moves. Because if it was really that incredible, then why wouldn't you do it all again next week? SPLAT'S A WINNER 6 ED SHEERAN is putting some of his paintings on sale to raise money for his Ed Sheeran Foundation, which helps provide inclusive music education for children. And like many of the singer's melodies, the man's artwork is disarmingly beautiful. A paint-stained Ed poses before a large canvas that has been splattered with colours from multiple directions. It looks like paintings by John Squire of the Stones Roses, another musician who was a dab hand at abstract expressionism. Both Ed and John paint in the style of Jackson Pollock, who revolutionised art after the war with his 'drip technique'. So don't be alarmed if someone says Ed Sheeran's paintings resemble a load of old Pollocks. Because that's a compliment. FEARS OVER RICKY RICKY HATTON, 46, is planning to supplement his pension pot by stepping back into the ring against Eisa Al Dah in Dubai in December. Those of us who love and admire the Hit Man can't help but have mixed emotions. For we all remember Ricky's heavy defeats to Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather. We know about his struggles with depression outside the ring. And yet Hatton deserves a comfortable retirement. Who can begrudge him one more big pay day? And yet who cannot be worried for him? We are right to have mixed emotions about Hatton coming back. It is being called an Oasis-style return. Please. Noel and Liam are not going to get smacked in the cakehole while touring. Fingers crossed! AFTER the state visit of Monsieur le President and Madame Macron, there is a lot of chatter about French chic. But the most sophisticated woman at that state banquet was Catherine, Princess of Wales. Just look at the devastating impact she had on the French president himself. Kate's radiant presence turned Macron into a total winker. MIXED reviews for the new Superman reboot. But the latest Man Of Steel does have a lovely dog – Krypto, who has his own little red cape. Krypto's breed? CGI. So he is not going to need much grooming.
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
More than 70 arrests at protests over Palestine Action ban
More than 70 people have been arrested at protests against Palestine Action being designated a proscribed terrorist group. Protesters gathered for the second week in a row in central London, where the Metropolitan Police made 42 arrests. Other demonstrations took place around the UK, including in Manchester, where police said 16 arrests were made, and in Cardiff, where South Wales Police arrested 12 people. In London, two groups of protesters gathered underneath statues of Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela in Parliament Square, shortly before 1pm. They wrote the message "I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action" on pieces of cardboard and silently held the signs in the air as they were surrounded by police officers and members of the media. Some demonstrators could be seen lying on top of each other on the floor as police searched their bags, and took their ID cards and signs. Officers then carried away a number of protesters, lifting them off the ground and into waiting police vans. The last protester was lifted from the Nelson Mandela statue shortly after 2.30pm. Forty-one of the 42 arrests at the London protest were for showing support for a proscribed organisation, while one person was arrested for common assault, the Met Police said. Palestine Action's terror group designation means membership of, or support for, the group is a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison. Greater Manchester Police said it had arrested 16 people under the Terrorism Act 2000 after responding to a protest in St Peter's Square at around 2.30pm. South Wales Police confirmed 13 people were arrested on suspicion of offences under the same act in the vicinity of Central Square in Cardiff. The Met Police arrested 29 people at a similar protest last weekend. Scotland Yard has said its stance remains that officers will act where criminal offences, including support of proscribed groups or organisations, are committed. It added that this includes "chanting, wearing clothing or displaying articles such as flags, signs or logos". The move to ban Palestine Action came after at RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire last month.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
A warmer climate requires adaptation
Britain, as Aneurin Bevan once complained, is an island 'made mainly of coal and surrounded by fish'; 'only an organising genius' could somehow manage to produce a shortage of both at once. Things have moved on from Mr Bevan's day, but it remains the case that our Government is wonderfully adept at contriving to produce shortages of those things that ought to be abundant, and then attempting to manage the consequences through rationing rather than any attempt to expand supply. The latest examples of this technocratic desire to apportion what currently exists can be found in the reaction to our sweltering summer. Water supplies are low; the priority for the Government, accordingly, is to seek to use smart meters to introduce 'surge pricing ' for those households that have installed them. Houses are hot, but the heat pumps installed under government grant schemes are unable to run as air conditioning units, and in London Sadiq Khan's planning rules prioritise 'passive ventilation' over air conditioning in part owing to fears over energy use. As shadow energy secretary Claire Coutinho correctly notes, this is a 'poverty mindset'; Britain's energy and water policies 'should fit what people want to do, not the other way around'. In a country that last finished building a reservoir in 1992, and where the focus of energy policy on decarbonisation appears to be threatening further deindustrialisation – Britain's industrial electricity users pay the highest prices in the world – the overwhelming effort of the Government should be on loosening the straitjacket on Britain's economic growth and consumer comforts, not attempting to tighten the straps. As the pro-growth campaign group Britain Remade has noted, too, our current trajectory is one more suited to 'a world where summer was 25C and our electricity was coal-powered'. A warmer climate requires adaptation; a cleaner grid removes an old objection to higher energy use. With heatwaves marked by spikes in excess deaths, it is surely time to change course and embrace an approach rooted in meeting the needs of the population, expanding water storage capacity, removing constraints on air conditioning, and providing the energy generation necessary to do so.
