'Caution Not Anti-Science': Siddaramaiah On Covid Vaccine-Sudden Death Claim
Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah has responded to Biocon Ltd Executive Chairperson Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw's suggestion that he acknowledge the science behind vaccine development, rather than engage in retrospective blame.
The chief minister shot back, "Seeking answers is not retrospective blame. It is the duty of a government that values every life."
Siddaramaiah had fired the first shot with his post on X on July 1 that the state government ordered a study to find the reasons behind sudden deaths among young people in Karnataka, and whether Covid vaccines could have any role in them.
This had prompted the reaction from the Biocon chief, who pointed out that the chief minister's claim that the vaccines were hastily approved was "factually incorrect and contributed to public misinformation".
On Thursday, Siddaramaiah doubled down on his claim.
"As Chief Minister, I have a duty to respond to the genuine concerns of people who have lost loved ones unexpectedly. When parents lose their young children or families lose breadwinners without warning, seeking clarity is not misinformation; it is an act of governance rooted in empathy," he said.
"Scientific caution is not anti-science. Many peer-reviewed studies (such as Nature, Circulation, Journal of the American College of Cardiology) have discussed myocarditis and cardiac arrest risk, particularly among young adults post-vaccination. Publicly funded stakeholders must acknowledge both the benefits and the potential risks without fear or favour.
"When I said 'hastily', it reflects the unprecedented speed of emergency rollouts globally without complete long-term data, acknowledged even by WHO and global regulatory agencies, who termed it a 'calculated risk' during a pandemic. Haste is not a sin when saving lives, but acknowledging potential unintended consequences is wisdom," Siddaramaiah said in a long post on X.
As Chief Minister, I have a duty to respond to the genuine concerns of people who have lost loved ones unexpectedly. When parents lose their young children or families lose breadwinners without warning, seeking clarity is not misinformation; it is an act of governance rooted in... https://t.co/JjssvDhNeV
— Siddaramaiah (@siddaramaiah) July 3, 2025
On Wednesday, the Union Health Ministry dismissed the Karnataka chief minister's comment, saying extensive studies by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) have conclusively established no linkages between coronavirus vaccines and sudden deaths.
Studies by the ICMR and the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) also affirm that Covid-19 vaccines in India are safe and effective, with extremely rare instances of serious side effects, it said.
Sudden cardiac deaths can result from a wide range of factors, including genetics, lifestyle, pre-existing conditions, and post-covid complications, the ministry had said in a statement.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
34 minutes ago
- Mint
Wall Street worries as crisis-level deficits become the government's default mode
U.S. budget deficits were already approaching $2 trillion when Republican lawmakers set out to extend and expand tax cuts this year. Interest rates were high and the bond market was jumpy, producing worrying spikes in borrowing costs. Republicans forged ahead anyway, defying warnings from Wall Street to Washington that they were pushing the country further down a dangerous fiscal path. On Thursday, the House voted in favor of the sprawling tax-and-spending bill that was passed on Tuesday by the Senate. The resulting legislation headed for President Trump's desk adds $3.4 trillion to federal deficits through 2034 compared with a scenario in which Congress did nothing, according to the Congressional Budget Office. The extent of the projected shortfall increased as the measure worked its way across Capitol Hill, as the Senate made some business tax breaks permanent. Economists, investors and politicians have often warned that the U.S.'s growing debt burden would punish future generations. The market has been willing to tolerate spikes in borrowing during crises such as a war or Covid, seeing it as a logical, and temporary, response to a sharp growth slowdown. What stands out now to those sounding the alarm the loudest is that America is bingeing on debt when there's no such emergency requiring it. The deficit as a share of the economy is already around the levels reached in the era of the 2008 financial crisis and the pandemic. Many investors are concluding that financial profligacy isn't a bug, but rather a feature of U.S. policymaking. 'The government is like a teenager with a credit card that has no limits until it has to be paid," said Bill Gross, founder of Pimco. ''Payment due' comes not with default but with a weak dollar and higher interest rates." Trump and his GOP backers in Congress dismiss those bleak projections and, armed with their own budget math, paint a very different fiscal reality. They say tax cuts will accelerate growth and, along with new tariffs and heavy cuts to social programs such as Medicaid, will actually put the nation on sounder financial footing. The long-term verdict might be rendered in U.S. bond markets. The U.S. borrows money by issuing Treasurys, and an oversupply of those bonds would drive up yields, which rise when prices fall. Because interest rates on other debt are linked to Treasury yields, that would also lift costs on mortgages, car loans and corporate bonds. The market has been calm lately. But it has sent warning flares about the fiscal trajectory, most recently in May when yields on 30-year bonds climbed close to a two-decade high. Some investors, meanwhile, are concerned that massive debt projections are weighing on the dollar, which just posted its biggest first-half decline since 1973. The deficit, or annual gap between government revenue and spending, was $1.8 trillion, or around 6% of gross domestic product, last fiscal year. Moody's estimates it will reach nearly 9% of GDP by 2035, pushing publicly held federal debt—or the sum of all the annual shortfalls—from a little under 100% of GDP now to more than 130%. That compares to the previous record of 106% in 1946. Ken Rogoff, a Harvard University professor and former chief economist for the International Monetary Fund, said the U.S. is leaving itself little room to go on a borrowing binge when it really needs to. 'We typically look to borrow 20% or 30% of GDP in these big crises," he said. 'It's not clear markets will tolerate that." Even if Congress wasn't adding new tax cuts this year, federal debt would grow from around $29 trillion to $50 trillion in 2034, according to the CBO. The bill's advance, though hardly unexpected on Wall Street, has dimmed budget hawks' already modest hopes that lawmakers would make deficit reduction more of a priority. Ray Dalio, founder of Bridgewater, warns that staying on the current path will ultimately lead to some mix of a bond-market slide, a severe economic contraction or an inflation-fueling intervention by the Federal Reserve. The GOP bill 'reflects a political system that favors indulging voters over prudence," he said. Trump says skyrocketing growth will avert any downsides. 'For all cost cutting Republicans, of which I am one, REMEMBER, you still have to get reelected," he wrote in a social-media post shortly before senators began voting on the bill earlier this week. 'Don't go too crazy! We will make it all up, times 10, with GROWTH, more than ever before." Members of Congress during the House vote on Thursday. The U.S. government borrows money to pay for the shortfall between what it collects in taxes and what it spends on programs, such as defense and Social Security, by issuing Treasury securities that mature over varying periods of time. Buyers of this debt range from foreign banks to hedge funds to everyday investors. In principle, Treasurys are subject to the forces of supply and demand, like any other item. If the government issues more Treasurys than investors want or need, it will need to win them over with higher interest rates. If investors are worried about that happening in the future, they will likely sell bonds now, causing an immediate jump in yields. Treasurys, though, have long been viewed as the ultimate safe investment, especially in rocky economic times, because they are backed by the world's richest country and are effectively guaranteed to be repaid at maturity. That has historically kept America's borrowing rates in check, even as the volume of debt grew. Yet deficit worries still go back a long way, in government and on Wall Street. Peter Peterson, the late co-founder of the Blackstone Group who also served as President Richard Nixon's secretary of commerce, became concerned when planning for a talk on President Ronald Reagan's budget in 1981. Its big increase in defense spending and substantial tax cuts didn't make sense to him, and he was especially worried about the looming costs of Social Security and other entitlement programs. 'To put the matter bluntly, Social Security is heading for a crash," he wrote in a 1982 essay so long that the New York Review of Books split it into two parts. That same year, Salomon Brothers chief economist Henry Kaufman, known as Dr. Doom for his pessimistic forecasts, warned that proposed tax cuts and the resulting deficits would effectively block recovery from an ongoing recession. Worries about the deficit flared up regularly in the decades that followed—taking a break in the 1990s when the Clinton administration briefly engineered a surplus. But the concerns were little more than minor impediments to a long bull market in bonds that dragged Treasury yields steadily lower. Rogoff, the Harvard professor, who with Carmen Reinhart wrote the 2009 book 'This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly," has long argued that high levels of debt can weigh on growth. A 2012 paper he wrote with Reinhart and her husband, Vincent Reinhart, found that for advanced economies since 1800, debt levels above 90% of GDP corresponded to significantly lower levels of growth. The U.S. shot past that 90% threshold when the government spent massively in its efforts to bolster the economy during the pandemic. The overall level of America's GDP is significantly higher than what forecasters on the eve of the pandemic expected it would be in 2025, but Rogoff still thinks that at some level deficits matter. 'The appetite for U.S. debt may be very large, but it's clearly not infinite," he said. The Department of Treasury building in Washington. Nearly a third of publicly held U.S. debt is owned by foreigners, including foreign central banks. If they start worrying more about America's large debt load, they could become less willing holders. A wholesale dumping of U.S. debt by foreigners—a doomsday scenario—is extremely unlikely, according to Jeremy Stein, a Harvard economist who was a Fed governor from 2012 to 2014. 'But I wouldn't be surprised if, over the next couple of years, as their portfolios roll off and they have to reinvest, they start shifting that reinvestment more towards, say, Europe or German bonds," he said. Stein also worries that as the supply of Treasurys increases, hedge funds will become even bigger players in the market for U.S. debt. That could raise the odds of market disruptions, because fast-money traders occasionally run into problems that force them to sell. A mix of factors has created the current fiscal imbalance, including recessions, an aging population and rising federal assistance to households. Those spending policies were largely championed by Democrats. Republicans, meanwhile, have led the charge in cutting taxes. This year's budget negotiations revealed fissures among Republicans, with some expressing more concern about deficits than others. With the 2017 tax cuts set to expire at the end of the year, many in the party argued that an extension shouldn't count as a deficit increase because it was merely a continuation of current policy. Others, though, opposed that approach, citing concerns about national debt. House conservatives, led by Reps. Jodey Arrington (R., Texas) and Lloyd Smucker (R., Pa.), along with others such as Rep. Chip Roy (R., Texas), forced the House's budget framework to link tax cuts and spending cuts, with no more than a $2.5 trillion gap between them. By that approach, if the House could find $2 trillion in spending cuts, it could have $4.5 trillion in tax cuts. If it could only find $1.5 trillion, the tax cuts would have to shrink, too. 'We can't continue to have quote, a free lunch, by just saying that every single tax cut pays for itself," Roy said in an April interview. The House, on May 22, passed a version of the tax bill that adhered to those demands. CBO estimated that it would cost $2.4 trillion over a decade. In June, 38 Republicans led by Smucker signed a letter saying they wouldn't support legislation coming back from the Senate that violated their framework. Doing so, they wrote, 'would invite higher borrowing costs and undermine the economic growth that Americans need." In the end, though, it is estimated the Senate's version of the legislation would add $1 trillion more to the deficit over the next 10 years than the House bill—well above what those House Republicans said they would accept. All of them voted for it anyway on Thursday. Johnson showed the tally of the vote in the House on Thursday. The question of how much deficits matter ultimately depends on the bond market—and the corresponding effect on borrowing costs for businesses and consumers. Worries about government borrowing have already caused a couple of selloffs in Treasurys over the past two years. One came two summers ago, when the Treasury Department announced that it would need to borrow more than investors had expected in the coming months. Another occurred in May, after Moody's became the last major ratings firm to downgrade the U.S. to below triple-A. In both cases, the selloffs were temporary. Bond prices rebounded and yields fell, suggesting to some analysts that investors are only sporadically worried about deficits. Others, though, note that yields on longer-term Treasurys, in particular, are higher than what would be expected based just on the projected path of short-term rates set by the Fed. That extra yield, known on Wall Street as a term premium, can only be estimated. But one popular estimate, published by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, indicates the premium for the 10-year Treasury note has reached its highest level since 2014. Deficits are 'absolutely at the back of anybody's mind who's buying anything" other than the shortest-term Treasurys, said Priya Misra, a fixed income portfolio manager at J.P. Morgan Asset Management. 'You have to think about how much you want to get paid up for a fairly unsustainable debt trajectory." Deficits are still not the biggest influence on yields, which are largely determined by economic data and investors' expectations for Fed policy. A run of mild inflation data has helped bring yields lower recently. Investors also say that the Trump administration has ways it could mitigate the impact of deficits on the market. The most meaningful is its ability to lean more on ultrashort-term debt to meet coming borrowing needs, thereby minimizing pressure on longer-term bonds, which matter more for consumer and business borrowing costs. The administration has strongly suggested it intends to do that by leaving the sizes of longer-term debt auctions unchanged at least through the end of the year. When it does come time to increase auction sizes, many analysts expect the Treasury Department to mostly focus on debt that matures in just two to seven years. If demand is stronger for shorter-term bonds, it makes sense to 'just give the investors what they want," said Blake Gwinn, head of U.S. rates strategy at RBC Capital Markets. Write to Sam Goldfarb at and Justin Lahart at
Time of India
44 minutes ago
- Time of India
Hassan heart attack death cases: India's top drugmakers rally behind Covid vaccines
Leading drugmakers on Thursday rallied in support of Covid vaccines , using various social media platforms, amid a series of deaths in Karnataka's Hassan district due to heart attacks. Dilip Shanghvi, chairman and managing director at Sun Pharmaceuticals said in a post on LinkedIn, 'The deaths of multiple young individuals in one district of Karnataka due to cardiac ailments are unfortunate. While this appears to be specific to the district, linking it to the Covid-19 vaccine without any scientific evidence is "incorrect and misleading". "India's vaccine approval process is rigorous and science-driven, and we must continue to have confidence in it. The vaccine has been administered to millions across the country. If there were a connection, we would have seen similar incidents in many other places — which is not the case. The State health authorities should thoroughly investigate the situation to determine the cause,' Sanghavi said. Sorting to allay the apprehensions, Pankaj Patel, chairman, Zydus Lifesciences , which also manufactures Covid DNA vaccine, said in a post on X, 'There are other multiple reasons like age, environmental factors, genetics, lifestyle etc, that could be the leading cause of heart attacks in people. Several scientific studies globally and in India have conclusively shown that the risk of heart attack or myocarditis is greater after SARS-CoV-2 infection. #Vaccines save lives.' Appreciating the vaccination programme, Patel said, "the massive vaccination programme in our country during the peak of Covid phase saved millions of people and families. In fact a study published in Lancet estimated that India averted almost 3.4 million deaths due to vaccination in the year 2021," he said. Live Events Satish Reddy, chairman, Dr Reddy's Laboratories, wrote, 'India-made vaccines are by WHO and used worldwide. They helped end polio and fight Covid. At a time when India is seen as a vaccine leader, let's build trust in science, not doubt it. Public health must stay above politics.' A post on X attributed to Samir Mehta, executive chairman, Torrent Pharma said, 'India has earned global recognition as the Pharmacy of the World, supplying safe and effective vaccines to over 90 countries…Let's not allow misinformation to erode trust in science or the integrity of India's healthcare ecosystem.' Responding to rising concerns over the sudden deaths of more than 20 people in Hassan district, the Karnataka health department formed an expert committee to probe a possible link to Covid vaccines. However, support came pouring in for Covid vaccines. The Indian Vaccine Manufacturers Association said Covid-19 vaccines were developed and manufactured in the country with the highest safety and quality standards. Assuring about the safety of these vaccines, Dr/ G.V.J.A. Harshavardhan, director general at the association said the approvals were based on extensive evaluation in preclinical studies and human clinical trials with positive results on safety, efficacy, and immunogenicity of the vaccines. 'Patient safety and product quality are always prioritised during the vaccine development and its manufacture,' he said in a statement. He said prior to releasing the vaccines, they were tested extensively for safety by the manufacturers and are also provided batch release certification by the Central Drugs Laboratory (CDL) of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. Sudarshan Jain, secretary general, Indian Pharmaceutical Alliance (IPA) said during the pandemic, vaccines played a crucial role, and India consistently supplied medicines and vaccines across the world. "These vaccines have been well documented and rigorously tested as per regulatory processes. Misinformation and distortion of facts endanger public health and undermine the trust built on science and patient care globally".
Scroll.in
an hour ago
- Scroll.in
‘Tell the judge he has done no crime': The struggles of Hany Babu's family
On July 28, Delhi University professor 51-year-old Hany Babu will complete five years of incarceration. When the National Investigation Agency came for Babu in 2020, India was battling the Covid-19 virus, which is known to fester and multiply in densely packed spaces, such as prison cells. Babu was soon infected by the virus, but his suffering was not limited to it. He subsequently contracted a serious eye infection for which he was hospitalised after his condition was reported to have deteriorated alarmingly. At the time of his arrest, his daughter was 17 years old, and his mother – then in her late 70s – kept telling his wife, Jenny Rowena: 'Go and tell the judge that Babu is a nice person. Tell the lawyer this, that Babu is a good person and he has done no crime. Tell them to let him out, his mother is waiting.' But now, she has stopped saying this, Rowena, who is also a Delhi University professor, said in a phone call. 'It's been five years and she is not able to sleep,' Rowena added. 'She is now in her 80s, has a lot of health issues and she just waits for that one phone call every week.' 'She went numb' Babu was among 16 people – activists, lawyers and professors – who were arrested under strict anti-terror laws in connection with caste violence at Bhima Koregaon near Pune in January 2018. He was a member of a committee formed to defend GN Saibaba, a former Delhi University professor who had been sentenced to a life term for his alleged links to the banned Communist Party of India (Maoist). The first batch of arrests in the Bhima Koregaon case took place in 2018. In the years that followed, others were arrested too. Since then, independent investigators have found clues that allegedly show that the authorities have used fabricated evidence to build a case against the accused. Human rights organisations have described the case as a witch-hunt against political dissidents. When Babu was arrested in 2020, their teenage daughter could not understand what had happened. She did not speak to anyone for the first three months after his arrest. 'She went numb,' Rowena said. The first time she visited her father in Taloja jail near Mumbai, they met in a small crowded shed. She suffered a sun stroke and contracted a fever. Now 22, she is about to finish a degree in journalism. Every month the mother and daughter rattle down in a train from Delhi to Mumbai to meet Hany Babu either at the court or at Taloja jail. Of the 16 people arrested in the Bhima Koregaon case, eight have been released on bail so far. One person, an octogenarian Jesuit priest, died while still in judicial custody. Meetings with Babu I asked Rowena what she and Babu talk about when they meet. 'We usually just discuss what he is reading and what I am reading,' Rowena said. It has been that way with them since the beginning: 'That is how we became friends, also, and that's how our relationship began.' While Rowena feels happy when she is going to see Babu, the journey back from Mumbai is arduous. 'Going is very nice,' she said. 'But coming back is very bad. Most of the time I get a fever.' The constraints of their lives – Rowena's job and her daughter's education – mean that they cannot spend too much time travelling to and from Maharashtra. So they take the train the evening before their visit and return right after. 'I am somewhat struggling to manage everything,' Rowena said. 'What is the logic?' What Rowena too does not understand is why Babu still needs to be in jail. 'Babu now completes five years in jail', she said. 'What is the logic of keeping people as undertrials for so long? At the same time, the prisons are overcrowded, and there is no facility for anyone there.' According to the India Justice Report 2025, the national occupancy rate in prisons stands at 131%, with 76% of the prison population merely comprising people whose trials have not been completed – or are still waiting for proceedings to begin. In Maharashtra alone, the prison occupancy rate as of December 2022 was 161%. 'I think this is the punishment,' Rowena said. 'They know that if they hold a trial, there is no case.' Evidence questioned Hany Babu and the 15 others in this case were booked under the stringent Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, which makes obtaining bail very difficult. However, independent experts have questioned the charges in this case and the credibility of the evidence cited to incarcerate the accused. In a 2023 book, Alpa Shah, a professor of social anthropology at Oxford, described how electronic devices and email accounts belonging to the accused may have been hacked in order to plant evidence. She named Babu as being among those whose email accounts had allegedly been hacked. She also presented information to allege links between this hacking operation and those investigating the Bhima Koregaon case. Babu's computer had been seized in a raid on his home in September 2019 but he was neither summoned nor arrested until July 2020. 'If I ask them to tell me in a sentence what is Babu's crime, what did he do, will they be able to tell me?' Rowena asked. Costs and consequences of imprisonment It takes several years before a UAPA case reaches its conclusion – and even then the conviction rate is very low. The government's own data shows that of the total of 8,719 cases registered under the UAPA between 2014 and 2022, only 215 cases resulted in conviction; 567 were acquitted. One of the accused in the case with Babu, Father Stan Swamy, died as an incarcerated undertrial in 2021, a day before his bail hearing. Swamy, 84, who had Parkinson's disease, died a prisoner without ever being found guilty. When Swamy passed away in Mumbai's Holy Family Hospital, he had already told the court that his body functions had undergone a steady regression in jail and all he wanted to do was to go home. But Indian jails are full of ailing prisoners. In 2024, the Bombay High Court reversed the conviction of former Delhi University professor Saibaba, wheelchair bound and 90% disabled, and five of his co-accused in another UAPA case. Babu had formed a committee to coordinate Saibaba's legal defence. Saibaba and the others had been convicted under UAPA by a sessions court in 2017 for allegedly having links with the banned Maoist party and sentenced to life imprisonment. But by the time the High Court acquitted them and ordered their release, one of Saibaba's co-accused, 33-year-old agricultural worker Pandu Narote, had been dead for 19 months already. He had reportedly contracted swine flu in jail. Saibaba too passed away from post-surgery complications within months of his release, after suffering in jail for a decade. He was 57. When asked about Babu's health, Rowena said that he is suffering from a series of ailments: frozen shoulders, knee pain, high blood pressure and cataract. Despite this, and the fact that nearly five years have lapsed since his arrest and the trial is yet to begin, the courts have not demonstrated any desire to grant Babu his freedom. On June 23, the Supreme Court refused to grant an urgent listing on Babu's plea seeking a clarification on whether he could approach the Bombay High Court for bail. The apex court questioned the urgency of his plea. It said that the High Court had on May 2 sought this clarification from the Supreme Court but Babu's counsel had not approached the Supreme Court before it shut for vacation on May 23. Babu's lawyer explained that the delay had occurred because certified copies of some documents were still being gathered. Nonetheless, the vacation bench of the Supreme Court asked him to come back when vacation ends in mid-July. But it is not just Babu's health that Rowena worries about. She recalled the ordeal of another person accused along with Babu, 38-year-old Mahesh Raut. In September 2023, the Bombay High Court had granted bail to Raut, noting that the material against him does not lead to a prima facie inference of him having committed a terrorist act as defined under the UAPA. However, the High Court stayed its own order for three weeks to allow the National Investigation Agency time to appeal their decision. The Supreme Court then went on to extend the stay. A year later, in September 2024, The Indian Express reported that the appeal had already come up for hearing 13 times in the Supreme Court. But the court has still not passed a verdict in the matter. Barring two brief spells, when Raut stepped out for his grandmother's last rites in 2024 and to prepare for his LLB exams earlier this year, Raut has languished behind bars. 'And Mahesh is very sick,' Rowena tells me. 'He has a lot of issues. His stomach is in a bad condition and he really can't eat anything.' Prisoner stories But it isn't just the accused in the Bhima Koregaon case whose plight Rowena laments. 'There are people in prison whose stories never come out,' she said. 'They are not released when they are sick. They die in prison for want of adequate treatment. Many can't pay their bail bonds so they are never released. There are a lot of Adivasis who don't even have anyone to come to visit them. Whenever you write about us, you should also write about these people.' Rowena is joined by her husband in her concern for other prisoners. Babu spends his time in jail teaching his fellow inmates English and helping many of them make sense of the legalese that defines the contours of their lives. In his free time, Rowena said, he likes to write, even though his barrack is crowded, the TV is usually blaring and there is no table for him to sit and study. And even though he may be slowly losing vision in one eye from cataract. In 2023, while in jail, Babu was awarded an honorary doctorate degree by Ghent University in Belgium. He was nominated for the honour as an acknowledgment of his efforts to safeguard the importance of academic freedom, language rights and equal access to education for minorities. Meanwhile, Hany Babu's octogenarian mother continues to quietly wait for her son to return home. Said Rowena, 'She is literally getting tortured.'
