Former DWP employee warns of two-tier State Pension payments for older people
Pension Credit – Could you or someone you know be eligible?
The latest figures from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) show there are now 13 million people of State Pension age across Great Britain, including 1.1m in Scotland. Of that total, 34 per cent are in receipt of the New State Pension while 66 per cent receive the Basic/Old State Pension.
Under the Triple Lock guarantee, the New and Basic State Pensions increase each year in-line with whichever is the highest between the average annual earnings growth from May to July, Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation rate in the year to September, or 2.5 per cent.
However, additional elements of the State Pension, including deferred amounts, rise by the September CPI rate, something a former DWP employee warns is creating a 'two-tier uprating system for pensioners'.
Sandra Wrench has 42 years experience in dealing with State Pensions and benefits delivered by the DWP and previously wrote to DWP Ministers in 2023 expressing her concerns.
Mrs Wrench told the Daily Record how some pensioners may not be aware that this year's Triple Lock uprating of 4.1 per cent only applies to the New and Basic State Pension payment rates; additional components h
The ex-DWP employee said: 'The Triple Lock guarantee only covers the BASIC State Pension and not all components, the other components being Additional Pension (the scheme which existed between 1978-April 5, 2016 and which you could contract out of), Graduated Pension (1961-1975), increments for deferring your State Pension, and the protected pension which is any amount in excess of the 100 per cent rate of the new 100 per cent State Pension which you might be entitled to at April 6, 2016.
'With the calculation of the New State Pension at April 6, 2016, in most cases, all the components of the old State Pension have been added together to give a basic State Pension, and where applicable a protected pension, which is the excess above the 100 per cent rate of the New State Pension.
'So by adding all the components together this has brought components such as additional pension, within the scope of the Triple Lock, which was 4.1 per cent. Under the old scheme, additional pension would have just been increased by the CPI rate of 1.7 per cent.'
Mrs Wrench warned: 'With The Triple Lock relating to the basic rates of the State Pension only, this has created a two-tier uprating system for those who reached State Pension Age before April 2016 where the 100 per cent rate of the Old/Basic State Pension is currently £176.45 a week and those who reached retirement age after April 2016 where the 100 per cent rate of the New State Pension is higher at £230.25.'
She shared an example to help illustrate the difference:
A person who was State Pension Age before April 2016, has a weekly amount of State Pension as £240.00, consisting of 100 per cent Old/Basic State Pension of £176.45, additional pension of £59.75 and graduated pension of £3.80.
Compare this with a person who reached State Pension Age after April 2016, who also has a weekly pension of £240.00, but this consists of 100 per cent New State Pension of £230.25 and a protected payment of £9.75.
In April 2026, the person who reached State Pension Age before April 2016, will only have £176.45 increased by the Triple Lock, compared with a person who reached State Pension Age after April 2016, who will have a higher amount of £230.25 increased by the Triple Lock.
Mrs Wrench continued: 'You can see how a person who reached State Pension Age before April 2016 has a lower percentage of their State Pension uprated by the Triple Lock compared with those who reached State Pension Age after April 2016.
'Because of this difference in basic pension and the Triple lock only relating to the basic rate of the State Pension, this will inevitably lead to those who reached State Pension Age before April 2016 falling further behind with every annual uprating.'
The insider explained that when the Triple Lock was introduced in 2011, there was only one State Pension system (Old/Basic), but the introduction of the New State Pension in April 2016, calls into question whether it should also be uprated under the Triple Lock.
However, she warns that any future adjustment to the Triple Lock 'will particularly affect poorer pensioners, such as those who do not have other sources of income, those who are disabled and not able to work full time, and women with caring responsibilities who have had to work part time and who may not have had the opportunity to build up any private or work pension'.
Mrs Wrench added: 'The DWP have confirmed they cannot means-test the State Pension, so possibly the only way that the increased costs for State Pension can be addressed is through some adjustment to the Triple Lock, and to reassess the annual uprating of the State Pension.
Mrs Wrench shared two examples to help highlight the uprating impact:
From April 6, 2016, a woman, who is State Pension Age after April 2016. has a Basic State Pension of £63.63, and Additional Pension of £24.82. These two components were added together on April 6, 2016 to give her a starting amount of £88.45 for the New State Pension, and this £88.45 is now all Basic State Pension under the new scheme.
If you were State Pension Age before April 2016, under the old scheme the basic State Pension of £63.63 would have increased by the Triple Lock, and the additional pension of £24.82 increased by the lower CPI rate , but by adding the two together for the New State Pension from April 6, 2016, this means that all this amount is basic state Pension and increases by the Triple Lock. So those who are State Pension Age after April 2016 are at an advantage compared to those who reached retirement age before April 2016, as regards the Triple Lock increase.
A person who reached State Pension Age after April 6, 2016 has the full 100 per cent rate of the basic State Pension which was then £119.30 (under the old scheme) and Additional Pension of £75.00.
Basic £119.30 plus AP £75.00 is equal to £194.30 at April 6, 2016, which was converted into the 100 per cent rate of the New State Pension of £155.65 (the 100% rate at April 6, 2016) plus a protected payment of £38.65.
Basic State Pension increases by the Triple Lock, but protected payment increases by CPI rate, so some of the additional pension has been converted into Basic State Pension and brought within the scope of The Triple Lock.
State Pension payments 2025/26
Full New State Pension
Weekly payment: £230.25
Fortnightly payment: £460.50
Four-weekly payment: £921
Annual amount: £11,973
Full Basic State Pension
Weekly payment: £176.45
Fortnightly payment: £352.90
Four-weekly payment: £705.80
Annual amount: £9,175
Future State Pension increases
The Labour Government has pledged to honour the Triple Lock or the duration of its term and the latest predictions show the following projected annual increases:
2025/26 - 4.1%, the forecast was 4%
2026/27 - 2.5%
2027/28 - 2.5%
2028/29 - 2.5%
2029/30 - 2.5%
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
DWP announces 'old' and 'new' PIP system ahead of benefits shakeup
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall has confirmed that those currently receiving Personal Independence Payment (PIP) will not be affected by the proposed changes outlined in the new welfare reform Bill. The Department for Work and Pensions' (DWP) primary disability benefit presently provides between £116.80 and £749.80 every four weeks to nearly 3.7 million people in England and Wales. However, the proposed changes to eligibility will impact new PIP claimants when implemented next year. The DWP chief explained this will effectively create two PIP systems, pre-November 2026 and post-November 2026, operating concurrently to support individuals with disabilities, long-term illnesses, or physical or mental health conditions. The Government's reversal on welfare cuts is expected to cost taxpayers around £2.5 billion by 2030, Ms Kendall told MPs on Monday, outlining concessions to Labour rebels. She noted that it is "very common throughout the benefits system to have existing claimants protected on old rules and old rates. That is what we are doing today". The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) will confirm the financial details of the UK Government's adjusted welfare plans during the Autumn Budget, as reported by the Daily Record. With regards to worries over a possible "two-tier" benefits system for existing PIP recipients, Ms Kendall pointed out: "The fact is, our welfare system frequently ensures that existing claimants are shielded from new rates or rules, as people build their lives around that support and adjusting can be extremely challenging." Previous forecasts by the DWP suggested that proposed reforms could see an additional 150,000 individuals sliding into poverty by 2030. Whilst this number is lower than the initial estimate of 250,000 additional cases of relative poverty brought on by housing costs, it remains a significant cause for concern. The DWP's published modelling noted the estimate did not account for potential positive effects from increased funding and support for people with disabilities or long-term health conditions seeking employment. Ms Kendall maintained that the revised amendments for PIP and Universal Credit "ensure no existing claimants are put into poverty". Ministers are counting on these concessions to avoid defeat when MPs cast their votes for the reforms on Tuesday, particularly in light of a "reasoned amendment" proposed by senior Labour backbencher Dame Meg Hillier. This amendment had the support of 126 Labour MPs, a number sufficient to jeopardise Sir Keir Starmer's majority. However, on Friday, Dame Meg characterised the concessions as a "workable compromise". Labour MP and chair of the Work and Pensions Committee, Debbie Abrahams, has spoken out about the UK Government's apparent backtrack on previously negotiated concessions. Speaking to ITV News, Ms Abrahams labelled the concessions as "good" but cautioned that they were not quite sufficient for a deal just yet. Ms Abrahams expressed her discontent, saying, "The actual offer that was put to one of the negotiating team wasn't actually what we thought we had negotiated on Wednesday and Thursday. There are some issues around that." Her statement reflects unease over the negotiation process's transparency and outcome. Concerns were also raised by both Dame Meg and Ms Abrahams in the Commons regarding the timeliness of a forthcoming review of PIP led by disabilities minister Sir Stephen Timms, suggesting it may not impact the planned changes set for November 2026 soon enough. On the opposing side, Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately has levelled criticism against the UK Government, accusing them of making "unfunded U-turns costing billions and welfare plans that are not worth the paper that they are written on". She sharply criticised, "Their latest idea is a two-tier welfare system to trap people in a lifetime on benefits and deny them the dignity of work while leaving the taxpayer to pick up the ever-growing bill." Tory leader Kemi Badenoch confirmed the party's stance on Monday evening, stating they would vote against the Labour Government's proposals, dismissing them as "not serious welfare reform". Join the North Wales Live WhatsApp community group where you can get the latest stories delivered straight to your phone Find out what's happening near you
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Exact date pensioners need to opt out of Winter Fuel Payment to avoid HMRC clawback
Around two million pensioners with an income over £35,000 are due to receive this year's Winter Fuel Payment. Pension Credit – Could you or someone you know be eligible? The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) will issue Winter Fuel Payments of between £100 and £300 to an estimated nine million pensioners in England and Wales over November and December. People over 66 in Scotland will receive up to £305 through the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment on November 30. Payments of both benefits will be issued automatically. However, Pensions Minister Torsten Bell has confirmed around two million people over State Pension age currently have an annual income above the £35,000 eligibility threshold and can either pay the money back through PAYE or a self Assessment tax return. They can also opt out of receiving the payment. He explained there is no need to take any 'immediate action' but if anyone wants to opt out they must do so before September 15, 2025. The DWP Minister's comments came after Conservative MP Charlie Dewhirst asked the Treasury about the number of pensioners 'who will need to pay back the Winter Fuel Payment through tax system, in each financial year between 1 April 2025 and 31 March 2029'. In a written response on Tuesday, Mr Bell said: 'From this winter 2025-26 Winter Fuel Payment eligibility will be expanded in England and Wales. Pensioners with incomes below or equal to £35,000 will benefit from Winter Fuel Payments. 'About nine million individuals will benefit from a Winter Fuel Payment this winter. Winter Fuel Payments will be paid automatically meaning any pensioner receiving a State Pension or DWP benefit or who has previously received a Winter Fuel Payment will not need to make a claim. 'There are about two million individuals with an income above £35,000. Those who receive a Winter Fuel Payment will have the full amount of their Winter Fuel Payment recovered via HMRC. Pensioners do not need to take any immediate action, and those that wish to opt out of receiving the winter fuel payment can do so.' Full details on what you will need before contacting the Winter Fuel Payment Centre can be found on here. Eligibility for Winter Fuel Payments You can get a Winter Fuel Payment if you were born before September 22, 1959 and live in England or Wales. When you will not be eligible You will not be eligible if you: live outside England and Wales were in hospital getting free treatment for the whole of the week of 15 to 21 September 2025 and the year before that need permission to enter the UK and your granted leave says that you cannot claim public funds were in prison for the whole of the week of 15 to 21 September 2025 If you live in a care home You can get Winter Fuel Payment if you live in a care home, however, you will not be eligible if both of the following apply: you get Universal Credit, Pension Credit, Income Support, income-based Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA) or income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) you lived in a care home for the whole time from 23 June 2025 or earlier Payments DWP guidance explains: 'You'll get a letter in October or November telling you how much Winter Fuel Payment you'll get, if you're eligible. 'If you do not get a letter but think you're eligible, check if you need to make a claim.' It's important to be aware that scammers may try and trick you into making a claim by text, prompting you to click on a link. This is not an official DWP message and should be deleted. If you think you need to claim, follow the guidance on here. The amount you get is based on when you were born and your circumstances between 15 to 21 September 2025. This is called the 'qualifying week'. Any money you get will not affect your other benefits. If you live alone or no one you live with is eligible for the Winter Fuel Payment You will get either: £200 if you were born between September 22, 1945 and September 21, 1959 £300 if you were born before September 22, 1945 If you live with someone else who is eligible for the Winter Fuel Payment Your payment may be different if you get one of the following benefits: Pension Credit Universal Credit income-based Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA) income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) Income Support If you do not get any of the benefits You will get a payment of: £100 if you and the person you live with were both born between September 22, 1945 and September 21, 1959 £100 if you were born between September 22, 1945 and September 21, 1959 but the person you live with was born before September 22, 1945 £200 if you were born before September 22, 1945 but the person you live with was born between September 22, 1945 and September 21, 1959 £150 if you and the person you live with were born before September 22, 1945 If you and your partner jointly claim any of the benefits One of you will get a payment of either: £200 if both of you were born between September 22, 1945 and September 21, 1959 £300 if one or both of you were born before September 22, 1945 The money will be paid into the bank account your benefits are usually paid into. If you get any of the benefits (not as part of a joint claim) You will get a payment of either: £200 if you were born between September 22, 1945 and September 21, 1959 £300 if you were born before September 22, 1945 If you live in a care home If you are eligible you'll get either: £100 if you were born between September 22, 1945 and September 21, 1959 £150 if you were born before September 22, 1945 When you will get paid DWP said most payments will be made automatically in November or December. You should get a letter telling you: how much you'll get which bank account it will be paid into - this is usually the same account as your State Pension or other benefits Article continues below DWP added: 'If you do not get a letter or the money has not been paid into your account by 28 January 2026, contact the Winter Fuel Payment Centre.'
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
New DWP changes to PIP will only be brought in after review of assessments next year
Reforms to PIP have been put on hold until a full review of the assessment process has been completed. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has announced no changes will be made to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) until a review of the current assessment process has been completed. Minister for Social Security and Disability Sir Stephen Timms will co-produce the review with disabled groups and charities, which is expected to be completed next year. Sir Stephen announced the climbdown in the middle of the debate on the legislation in Parliament on Tuesday. He acknowledged 'concerns that the changes to PIP are coming ahead of the conclusions of the review of the assessment that I will be leading'. Sir Stephen said the UK Government would now 'only make changes to PIP eligibility activities and descriptors following that review', which is due to conclude in the Autumn of 2026. However, the move will cause a headache for Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who has seen a forecast £4.8 billion saving from the welfare budget whittled away through a series of concessions, leaving her to seek extra money through spending cuts, tax hikes or borrowing to balance the books at the Autumn Budget. The Resolution Foundation's chief executive Ruth Curtice said the concessions meant the reforms would now make no 'net savings' in 2029/30 - a key year for Ms Reeves's fiscal targets - even if they did reduce costs in the longer term. The decision to remove the PIP changes from the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill was announced just 90 minutes before MPs voted on Tuesday night. The legislation cleared its first hurdle by 335 votes to 260, majority 75. Despite the late concession, there were 49 Labour rebels, the largest revolt so far of Sir Keir Starmer's premiership. Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall insisted the Labour Party was '100 per cent' behind the Prime Minister, but acknowledged there were 'lessons to be learned' after the rebellion. She also appeared to express regret over the handling of the issue, saying: 'I wish we had got to this point in a different way.' But Ms Kendall also insisted it was 'really important we passed this Bill', saying: 'We need to make changes, because too many people have been written off, are left to a life on benefits, when being in good work is so important.' The UK Government must abandon its 'unfair' welfare reforms in the wake of its late climbdown on a key plank of the proposals, Scotland's Social Justice Secretary has said. Adult Disability Payment Under Scotland's devolved social security system, PIP is currently being replaced by the Adult Disability Payment. Reacting to events at Westminster, Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville reiterated the Scottish Government's pledge not to cut that benefit. Ms Somerville said: 'Despite the panicked, last-minute concessions they have made, if the UK Government presses ahead with cuts to disability support they will plunge more people into poverty. That is unconscionable. 'Their approach also risks creating a deeply unfair two-tier system, pushing the impact of cuts onto future applicants for disability benefits. 'The UK Government needs to stop balancing the books on the backs of some of the most vulnerable people in society. 'They need to properly listen to the overwhelming criticism their proposals have generated and do the right thing by disabled people by abandoning this bill entirely. 'I want to reassure disabled people in Scotland, that the Scottish Government will not cut Scotland's Adult Disability Payment, we will not let disabled people down as the UK Government has done.' Charlotte Gill, head of campaigns and public affairs at the MS Society, said: 'We thought last week's so-called concessions were last minute. But these panicked 11th hour changes still don't fix a rushed, poorly thought-out Bill.' But Jon Sparkes, chief executive of learning disability charity Mencap, said: 'The last-minute change relating to the review Sir Stephen Timms is leading sounds positive and we are pleased that the Government has listened.' He added: 'Disabled people should not have to pay to fix black holes in the public finances.' The Government's concessions have gutted the reforms, leaving only parts of the current Bill still on the table. Proposals to cut the health element of Universal Credit by almost 50 per cent for most new claimants from April 2026 remain in place, along with an above-inflation increase in the benefit's standard allowance. In an earlier climbdown, Work and Pensions Secretary Ms Kendall said existing recipients of the health element of Universal Credit, and new claimants with the most severe conditions, would have their incomes 'fully protected in real terms'.
