Tetchy scenes between neutrality activists and politicians during Triple Lock abolition meeting
Politicians on the committee are hearing from experts on a government proposal to remove the need for formal UN approval from the existing triple-lock system for deploying Irish troops abroad.
Niamh Ní Bhriain of the Transnational Institute and Chairperson of the Peace and Neutrality Alliance Stephen Kelly appeared before politicians today to advocate for the retention of the triple lock.
The pair clashed with TDs and senators on many occasions, as it become abundantly clear that there were vast differences in ideology between some members of the committee and the invitees.
At one point, Fianna Fáil senator Diarmuid Wilson called out Kelly for comments he made regarding politicians' ability to approve future military personnel deployments and Ní Bhriain for remarks about the deploying of Irish children.
In her opening remarkers, Ní Bhriain said: 'I urge the members of this Committee to scrutinise this legislation as though it were your sons and daughters being deployed on EU battlegroup or NATO-led missions.
'For those who vote in favour of this legislation such that it is eventually passed, you should know that if Irish personnel are deployed to future wars from which they will return maimed, traumatised or in body-bags – because no one returns from war unscathed – your cards will have been marked and this will be your legacy.'
Speaking later, Wilson told her: 'I speak as a father of a member of the Irish Defence Forces. And as I said to a number of people who came before us as witnesses, we take every piece of legislation seriously in this house.
'And we take it as if we're talking about the sons and daughters or gender-neutral members of any family. No matter what the piece of legislation, I want to assure you of that.'
Advertisement
'I do not appreciate those comments'
Kelly, in his opening remarks, questioned how effective a 'double lock', the deployment of troops following Government and Dáil approval, would be. He said the Peace and Neutrality Alliance reject it as an adequate replacement from the Triple Lock.
Both invitees refused to say what would be an adequate replacement to the triple lock, arguing that the existing framework is the closest thing to ensure the neutrality of Ireland in law.
Kelly accepted that neutrality and the triple lock were separate, but described them as 'close cousins'. Many politicians challenged this view, claiming that the abolition of the triple lock was to provide more control to Ireland around Defence Forces' deployments.
Addressing Kelly's remarks, Wilson asked if Kelly had ever stood for election, to which the chairperson of the neutrality group said he did not.
'Well, it's important that you realise the fact that the people who put themselves forward for election – in every election there are hundreds of people who put themselves forward, be it at local level or national level – some are successful, some are not, but at least they tried.
'I would suggest to you, you should try it yourself sometime before you make those comments in relation to public representatives,' he said.
Wilson continued to ask his questions to the invitees. Before answering, Kelly said: 'I don't particularly appreciate your comment.'
'I'm sure you don't,' Wilson replied.
'I don't appreciate it – at all. I'm a citizen, I've come here, I was invited to come here. I didn't have to, I was invited, I took the day off work. And I don't like the implication that you have to run for election to have an opinion on something,' Kelly said.
The committee today also heard from Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Andrews and Sinn Féin MEP Lynn Boylan.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
UN reports 613 killings in just one month near aid distribution points and convoys in Gaza
The deaths have occurred since an Israeli-backed American organisation began operations in late May ©Press Association The UN human rights office has recorded 613 killings near humanitarian convoys and at aid distribution points in Gaza run by an Israeli-backed American organisation since it began operations in late May. Spokeswoman Ravina Shamdasani said the rights office was not able to attribute responsibility for the killings.
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Latest DOUBLE €280 Child Benefit update for 171k kids with ‘targeted' top-up focus & ‘complex' alert on 2 key payments
MINISTER Dara Calleary has confirmed a double €280 Child Benefit payment for thousands will cost the State around €288million per year. The Minister for Social Protection established the figure after he said his Department is "working on" a Advertisement 2 Child Benefit has increased by less than €10 in two decades Credit: Getty Images - Getty 2 Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary Credit: © 2025 MAXWELL'S - NO REPRO FEE The Department of Social Protection is currently exploring the interaction a Calleary explained: "Existing supports include the and the And when asked by Child Benefit is a , meaning Irish parents can receive the €140 monthly cash regardless of their income and PRSI record up until a child is 16. Advertisement READ MORE IN MONEY Currently, the payment continues to be paid in respect of children until their nineteenth birthday where they are in full-time education or have a disability. A Calleary explained: "My department currently has 83,241 children benefiting from One Parent Family Payment and 100,117 children benefiting from Working Family Parent. "However, there are an estimated 11,500 children where the claimant is in receipt of both One Parent Family Payment and Working Family Payment. Advertisement MOST READ ON THE IRISH SUN Exclusive "Consequently, the number of individual children supported by One Parent Family Payment or Working Family Payment is calculated at 171,858. Martin vows to do 'everything we can' to reduce pressure on families ahead of Budget 2026 "Doubling the monthly Child Benefit payment for a year for each of these children would increase the overall expenditure on Child Benefit by approximately €288million per year." Calleary warned that these figures are subject to change, with the estimates based on figures from May 2025. Child Benefit is currently paid at a rate of €140 per child monthly to over 650,000 families in respect of over 1.2 million children - but it has risen by less than €10 in the last 20 years. Advertisement The monthly payment for a first child was €131.60 in 2004 and stands at €140 now, just six per cent higher. But Taoiseach €285 MONTHLY CASH The "second-tier" allowance worth an average of €285 per month would allow lower-income families to top up the existing €140-a-month benefit. And those who don't qualify for the extra cash will still receive the basic €140 payment. Advertisement Martin said: "I have a unit within the Department that is focusing on this issue and I've already spoken to Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary on this. "Nothing is off the table. There is a wide menu of options to choose from to target resources to meaningfully impact on the child poverty situation." The would lift some 55,000 children out of income poverty and 25,000 from consistent poverty, according to a recent report from the Economic and Social Research Institute. It estimates that spending just under €800m a year on the scheme could halve the number of children experiencing consistent poverty. Advertisement But Calleary said it is a "complex issue" and an "unintended consequence" of a of child income supports could result in a PAYMENT 'COULD BE SUSPENDED' ALERT SOME 650,000 Irish parents have been warned that their monthly €140 Child Benefit "payment will be suspended The form is part of on-going control measures carried out periodically to confirm that qualifying conditions continue to be fulfilled by those receiving the social welfare payment. The form, which is sent out via post, must be completed and returned within 28 days of being received. And the Department of Social Protection has warned that the cash "will be suspended if the form is not returned within 28 days". The form requires parents or guardians receiving the universal Claimants are also required to confirm that both they and the child they are claiming for are resident in the State and detail any change in circumstances that could affect their Child Benefit claim. He explained: "The work of the Department is to help those who are struggling. "One of the considerations in the ESRI proposal was to amalgamate the working family payment with the child support payment but that would result in people losing out on what they are getting at the moment. "If we are to do this, people cannot lose out. We have to look at expanding the working family payment and the child support payment as part of targeted measures. Advertisement "Anything we do in this space needs to be targeted and focused on those on low incomes, particularly workers. "We have to ensure that people do not get a lower payment under a new system than they are currently getting. "That could be an unintended consequence of some of the work we have seen today." A policy paper is currently being worked on to set out the options ahead of the budget. Advertisement Other areas being examined to reduce child poverty levels are payments for children of primary-school age, lone parents, working families on low incomes and children with disabilities. Calleary vowed that any changes made to the social welfare system will be targeted and "focused on those most at risk" of poverty and those in consistent poverty.
Irish Post
2 hours ago
- Irish Post
The Ireland that still works
THIS Ireland might be a small island on the edge of Europe. An often wet, windy, place facing out into the Atlantic. It's beautiful and, if you ever leave and come back you realise just how it is very, very green. It's distinctively itself with a long cultural history. The world is more different now though than even twenty years ago. Due to communication advancements and technology what happens in New York happens in Newtownmountkennedy too. For good or for bad, take your pick, we're interconnected in ways unimaginable even a decade ago. Loud, noisy, insistent, the modern world is in rural Cork as much as it is in Chicago. Which is why, in an increasingly tense, unstable world, even apparently slight things can take on a much larger echo. We are, much to our detriment, becoming increasingly inured to the crass and rash things the President of the United States says. He has clearly operated along the principle of saying the unsayable so often that it becomes everyday. He utters the shocking thing so much that we are no longer shocked. With a world teetering on God-only-knows-what one more little cruel aside from a man dedicated to such sayings can appear utterly trivial. It shows, though, the bar at which we now operate. Not only that but this casual cruelty leaks everywhere now. It sets the tone. In response to the shocking shooting dead of two politicians in Minnesota Trump was asked if he would call the Governor there to, presumably, sympathise and offer support. This was his response. 'I think the Governor of Minnesota is so whacked out. I'm not calling him. Why would I call him? The guy doesn't have a clue. He's a mess. So I could be nice and call him. But why waste time?' What is most disturbing about this is not that Trump would say such a thing, such an utterly cruel thing, but that we now think so little of it that it doesn't even come anywhere near a headline. One of the enduringly fine things about Ireland is the way society works. We have problems, of course, prejudice, bigotry, we have unpleasant people, people you just want to avoid. We're not the Hollywood Ireland of smiling leprechauns and rainbows. Ireland is a just a country like any other country. A place like every other, full of the whole gamut of humanity. What we do have, though, is a society that works. Yes, we have enormous housing problems, enormous health inequalities, we do a lot of things in a way that I would disagree with intensely. But on an everyday level society works. It works because people treat each other with understanding and patience and kindness. Of course, there are exceptions to this too but the overall impression you get from interactions in Irish society is that people are friendly and considerate. It might sound trivial but it is the very thing that oils society along, that makes it work, that makes life pleasant. It is not trivial but essential. In everyday discourse, for instance, people are calm and obliging. It is not nothing. If, for instance, we conducted ourselves the way people do online, the President of the United States, for instance, who behaves like an online troll, what would that be like? If we engaged in endless petty resentments and regurgitated vitriol and an inability to display civility even at the most extreme moments, what would that be like? Isn't that the worry? Our culture is now so influenced by outside, technologically inspired, behaviours it has to be a concern that one of the planet's most influential men is like this. Not so long ago teachers expressed concern about the influence of online influencers on young Irish men in particular. What if our culture becomes open to the idea that this casual cruelty and arrogance is the way we should conduct ourselves? Ireland's smallness and geography has shaped the country and the people. Technology makes so much of that irrelevant. It makes us vulnerable to things we wouldn't have imagined. How ironic that people fear the country will be changed by the immigrant family down the road working hard for a better life but not by the loudmouths yelling awfulness through the devices they always have with them.
