
UK Government 'must take Scottish approach to disability payments'
A PROMINENT disability campaigner has called for the UK Labour Government to take the 'more humane' approach Scotland is taking with disability payments.
It comes after the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill passed its first hurdle on Tuesday.
When the legislation was first announced, it included measures to limit eligibility for Pip, the main disability benefit in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and freeze the health-related element of universal credit.
But a huge backbench rebellion saw the changes to Pip stripped from the legislation with a review commissioned.
The so-called Timms review is expected to report next autumn after consulting with the disabled community and stakeholders.
READ MORE: Faslane nuclear base radioactive secrets to be released after FoI battle
That same day, Marylynne Hunter – an ex-Labour member and activist who resigned in March – told The National that she received a call from Social Security Scotland, who administers the devolved Adult Disability Payment (ADP) and Child Disability Payment.
Her daughter Freya has severe complex health problems and disabilities, is non-verbal and blind and requires full-time oxygen and at-home nursing care.
'The guy from Social Security Scotland was amazing. They actually spoke to me with dignity and respect,' she said.
'And I was part of those consultations way back with (former minister for equalities) Jeane Freeman in the Scottish Parliament talking about the way in which you're spoken to by people down in Westminster sometimes before it was devolved and it could be quite distressing.'
Hunter added: 'But this guy was brilliant. The dignity and respect part is there, you know, it's completely there. It was actually a really nice meeting, and he met Freya online and everything and he was lovely.'
(Image: Marylynne Hunter)
She also said that with the Scotland's Child Disability Payment, with someone with Freya's condition, they won't have to reapply for the Adult Disability Payment – an aspect which would have been the case if she was applying for PiP.
'She'll just naturally go to the next stage of Adult Disability Payment without any big forms or anything,' Hunter said.
'It's just a wee form that you have to fill in because she's not going to get better. So, that's the Scottish way of doing it. But if it had been the English way of doing it, I would have had to have reapplied. I would have had to have applied for Pip for Freya. And it would have been horrific.'
She added: 'It's that whole thing about having to do that big massive form again and talk about what she can't do. I'd rather talk about what she can do, because that's distressing when I have to talk about what Freya needs in terms of her medical care. It's horrific. I don't want to be reminded of that because it's really difficult for me to deal with.'
'The Scottish Government do it in a really good way where they take all the information from the GP and consultants and they don't put you through that torture.'
Hunter went on: 'You know what, that's the power of consultation with people who are on the ground with lived experience. The Scottish Government did that, they've consulted with people who are actually accessing these benefits.
'They've done it right.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
10 minutes ago
- BBC News
Powys bus vote sees £1.3m found for key rural routes
Powys County Council will provide an extra £1.3m for key bus services, but the last-minute nature of the decision has been money will help connect five hub towns in Wales' biggest local authority area to larger cities, as well as providing longer hours and weekend extraordinary meeting of council members on Friday agreed to find £1.349m from internal budgets, as the new service needs an extra £2.354m on top of the basic £5.442m set was the last possible date to sign paperwork that would allow the seven-year contract to come into force on 1 September and the timing angered opposition councillors. The services are seen as crucial to help residents in the largely rural area access health, education and other services that are not available in the county."It's highly unfortunate and some would say unprofessional that we're having such an important discussion on multimillion-pound contracts at the very last minute," said Plaid Cymru group leader Elwyn Charlton, Liberal Democrat cabinet member for highways, transport and recycling, responded: "I think it's been one of the most professional processes I have seen in this authority."It's been through the full democratic process, it's been through scrutiny, cabinet and has been out to engagement."Independents councillor Gareth E Jones believed that funding could result in a 2% increase in council Democrat cabinet member for legal and regulatory services Richard Church said: "We should be shouting from the rooftops the fact that we are bringing back Sunday and evening services."The move was backed by the Labour-Liberal Democrat cabinet last month, and in Friday's vote by 25 councillors, with 21 against, and one abstaining. This article was written by a trusted journalist and then edited for length and style with the help of AI, before being checked again by a BBC Journalist. It's part of a pilot.


Telegraph
18 minutes ago
- Telegraph
The Daily T: Why Starmer could be facing another rebellion
Last week it was the failed welfare bill causing an embarrassing rebellion for the government. And now this week, Labour have set themselves up for more anarchy on the back benches with their plans to scrap support for children with special educational needs. Rachel Reeves has to find £5 billion to fill her black hole, and Tim Stanley and Cleo Watson discuss the Chancellor's conundrum, whether they could end up raising money through a wealth tax, and how Starmer's government has to get better at party management. And on the anniversary of the 7/7 London bombings, we speak to Gordon Rayner about his Telegraph exclusive investigation into Samantha Lewthwaite aka the 'White Widow', who married one of the bombers before vanishing and joining forces with the terror group Al-Shabaab, becoming one of Britain's most wanted terror suspects.


Daily Record
40 minutes ago
- Daily Record
East Kilbride MP blasted for 'leaving disabled in limbo' following Commons welfare vote
Collette Stevenson MSP has said Labour must now apologise to the disabled but Joani Reid MP insists Labour is turning the economy around. Joani Reid MP has again come under fire for voting in favour of Labour's Welfare Bill which her opposers say will leave her disabled constituents in limbo. The Bill had initially proposed to slash eligibility for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) - a move which the government's own analysis showed would remove support from 800,000 people by the end of the decade – but now promises a 'review' of PIP at the end of 2026. In Scotland, the SNP Government had committed to protect disabled people from these cuts by protecting the Adult Disability Payment, Scotland's equivalent of PIP, from any reductions – though Labour's cut would have had a knock-on impact on Scotland's budget. After months of backlash from disability and anti-poverty groups, an eleventh-hour change to the bill threw the vote into 'chaos and confusion', and resulted in The UK Government promising a review of PIP to be concluded by autumn 2026, which East Kilbride SNP MSP Collette Stevenson says is leaving disabled people in limbo. A revolt by Labour MPs led to 49 of them voting against the motion but that number would have been far higher but for the government making a number of eleventh-hour adjustments to gain support for the Bill. East Kilbride SNP claimed the Labour cuts would push hundreds of thousands of disabled people into poverty, hitting the most vulnerable hardest. Collette Stevenson has said Labour must now apologise to disabled people for keeping them in limbo. The MSP said: "This Welfare Bill has been a disaster from the start – Labour have gone from ignoring disabled people to changing the Bill minutes before the vote – that is a total joke, and no way to run a country. 'But by voting for this bill in its amended form, Ms Reid is only making that uncertainty for disabled people worse, by delaying any clarity on PIP until the end of 2026. "Labour have shown their true colours here - any cut to PIP will be devastating for disabled people who rely on these payments to live and work – which is why the SNP pledged to protect these payments here in Scotland. 'With the limited powers of the Scottish Parliament, we can step in to protect disabled people here in East Kilbride and across Scotland – just imagine what we could do with the full powers of independence.' In response, Joani Reid said that reforming welfare to help people "who can and should work" into jobs while protecting those who need help is all part of turning the economy around. 'With Labour the minimum wage is rising, the economy is growing and families can start to see the light at the end of the tunnel on the cost of living crisis as energy costs come down", she said. "Reforming welfare to help people who can and should work into jobs while protecting those who need help is all part of turning the economy around and I am proud of the work Labour is doing. 'But under the SNP government, slavishly supported by Collette Stevenson, the NHS is getting worse, schools are falling behind and promise after promise is being abandoned. 'Now she wants to plunge Scotland back into the chaos and division of another referendum on independence, as though that answers any of the problems our country faces. Nobody outside the SNP wants or needs that. What a colossal waste of time, energy and money that would be.' In a scathing open letter to the MP, East Kilbride South SNP Councillor Geri Gray spoke of her "disgust" at the decision by the granddaughter of veteran trade unionist and socialist Jimmy Reid who led the Upper Clyde Shipbuilders' work-ins during the 1970s. She wrote: "I am disgusted that the granddaughter of the late and legendary Jimmy Reid could vote for the welfare cuts to the sickest and most vulnerable in our society. I have worked in Welfare Rights since before you left high school, and have seen the attacks on disabled people first by the Tories and now by your government. "Have you spoken to any disabled charities or Welfare Rights organisations before you took this decision? Having recently attended a Welfare Rights Conference where Sir Stephen Timms was in attendance via video link, appears there was no discussion at all. "No one is saying that people who are disabled shouldn't be assisted to work, and many do. However where are all these dream jobs? How many employers are going to realistically take on a disabled person who wakes up that morning in pain or with poor mental health and is unable to attend work that day? Employers are running a business, they need their staff. They can only be sympathetic to a point. "So in conclusion Joani Reid, you are using disabled people as an easy source to save money. There are many other sources of income you could have looked at. "Labour were always the party of the 'working class', no longer is this true. And why my previous Labour voting family turned to the SNP over 20 years ago. How a society treats its most vulnerable is always the measure of its humanity." A Labour source said: 'Councillor Gray does herself and her party no favours with her bad tempered and inaccurate and personal attack on Joani Reid. "Spending to assist disabled people is rising substantially, something you would expect someone who claims to be an expert on the subject to know, but instead Councillor Gray claims it is being cut. She can do better. 'Nor are the measures she attacks in the Bill.'