Canada plans to recognise Palestinian state, raising allies' pressure on Israel
The announcement came after France said last week it would recognise a Palestinian state and a day after Britain said it would recognize the state at September's U.N. General Assembly meeting if the fighting in Gaza, part of the Palestinian territories occupied by Israel, had not stopped by then.
Carney told reporters that the reality on the ground, including starvation of people in Gaza, meant 'the prospect of a Palestinian state is literally receding before our eyes.'
'Canada condemns the fact that the Israeli government has allowed a catastrophe to unfold in Gaza,' he said.
Carney said the planned recognition was based in part on repeated assurances from the Palestinian Authority, which represents the State of Palestine at the U.N., that it was reforming its governance and is willing to hold general elections in 2026 in which Hamas 'can play no part.'
The announcements by some of Israel's closest allies reflect growing international outrage over Israel's restrictions on food and other aid to Gaza in its war against Hamas militants, and the dire humanitarian crisis there. A global hunger monitor has warned that a worst-case scenario of famine is unfolding in the enclave.
The Gaza health ministry reported seven more hunger-related deaths on Wednesday, including a two-year-old girl with an existing health condition. The Hamas-run government media office in Gaza said the Israeli military killed at least 50 people within three hours on Wednesday as they tried to get food from U.N. aid trucks coming into the northern Gaza Strip.
Israel and its closest ally, the U.S., both rejected Carney's statements.
'The change in the position of the Canadian government at this time is a reward for Hamas and harms the efforts to achieve a ceasefire in Gaza and a framework for the release of the hostages,' the Israeli foreign ministry said in a statement. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made similar comments after the French and British announcements.
A White House official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said President Donald Trump also sees recognition of the State of Palestine as wrongly 'rewarding Hamas.'
U.S. special envoy Steve Witkoff is due to travel to Israel on Thursday to discuss Gaza. Trump said this week he expected centers to be set up to feed more people in the enclave.
The State of Palestine has been a non-member observer state of the U.N. General Assembly since 2012, recognized by more than three-quarters of the assembly's 193 member states.
Jonathan Panikoff, former deputy U.S. national intelligence officer on the Middle East, said recognition of Palestine is intended 'to increase pressure on Israel to compel it to return to a two-state paradigm.' But he said Canada's announcement is 'unlikely to be anything more than symbolic and risks undermining their relationship with a longtime ally in Israel.'
French President Emmanuel Macron, who spoke with Carney before Canada's announcement, said the recognition of Palestine will 'revive a prospect of peace in the region.'
POSSIBLE ULTIMATUM TO HAMAS
Israeli security cabinet member Zeev Elkin said on Wednesday that Israel could threaten to annex parts of Gaza to increase pressure on Hamas, eroding Palestinian hopes of statehood on land Israel now occupies.
Mediation efforts to secure a 60-day ceasefire and the release of remaining hostages held by Hamas ground to a halt last week.
In Gaza, resident Saed al-Akhras said the recognition of Palestine by major powers marked a 'real shift in how Western countries view the Palestinian cause.'
'Enough!' he said. 'Palestinians have lived for more than 70 years under killing, destruction and occupation, while the world watches in silence.'
Families of Israeli hostages still held in Gaza appealed for no recognition of a Palestinian state to come before their loved ones were returned.
'Such recognition is not a step toward peace but rather a clear violation of international law and a dangerous moral and political failure that legitimizes horrific war crimes,' the Hostages Family Forum said.
Netanyahu said this month he wanted peace with Palestinians but described any future independent state as a potential platform to destroy Israel, so control of security must remain with Israel.
His cabinet includes far-right members who openly demand the annexation of all Palestinian land. Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich said on Tuesday that reestablishing Jewish settlements in Gaza was 'closer than ever,' calling Gaza 'an inseparable part of the Land of Israel.'
AID GOING IN, BUT NOT ENOUGH
A 2-year-old girl being treated for a build-up of brain fluid died overnight of hunger, her father told Reuters on Wednesday.
'Doctors said the baby has to be fed a certain type of milk,' Salah al-Gharably said by phone from Deir Al-Balah. 'But there is no milk. She starved. We stood helpless.'
The deaths from starvation and malnutrition overnight raised the toll from such causes to 154, according to the Gaza health ministry, including at least 89 children, since the war's start, most of them in recent weeks.
Israel said on Sunday it would halt military operations for 10 hours a day in parts of Gaza and designate secure routes for convoys delivering food and medicine.
The U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs said the United Nations and its partners had been able to bring more food into Gaza in the first two days of pauses, but the volume was 'still far from enough.'
The war began on October 7, 2023, when Hamas led attacks on communities and military bases in southern Israel in which some 1,200 people were killed, including more than 700 civilians, and another 251 taken as hostages to Gaza, according to Israeli tallies.
Since then, Israel's offensive in the Gaza Strip has killed more than 60,000 people and laid waste to much of the territory, the Gaza health ministry says.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
4 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Global peace goals unite SA and China
China and SA highlight their roles in resolving global conflicts and commit to defending human rights and international cooperation. The different roles that South Africa and China continue to play in the pursuit of peace and stability in the world have been praised by Gauteng legislature speaker Morakane Mosupyoe and Chinese consul-general in Johannesburg Pan Qingjiang. Mosupyoe was a guest speaker at the commemoration of the 80th anniversary of China's victory over Japan organised by the China consulate on Wednesday evening. SA and China reaffirm commitment to global peace She cited South Africa's peace missions in conflicts such as the Ukrainian-Russian war, the Israel-Palestinian war, the Democratic Republic of Congo conflicts and several others on the continent. China mediated in ending long-standing tension between Iran and Saudi Arabia and albeit rejected by the US, it also offered its expertise in resolving the ongoing bloody war in Ukraine. ALSO READ: China pedals ahead with innovation 'Both China and South Africa are bound together by their shared values and aspirations – that of fighting for peace, promotion of human rights and international solidarity,' Mosupyoe said. 'Therefore, I want, on behalf of the people of South Africa, to recommit ourselves to a world free of any form of aggression, imperialism and subjugation of one nation by another. 80th war commemoration She said the commemoration of the resistance war against Japan was an opportunity to strengthen bilateral relations between South Africa and China, 'to continue fighting for our common interest in the world'. 'Our bilateral relations become even more relevant today when the world is beginning to experience the resurgence of narrow nationalistic sentiments which threaten world peace and solidarity. We must remain resolute in our commitment to a world free of any form of aggression.' NOW READ: SA and China agree to collaborate on AI and innovation
Daily Maverick
8 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
From prisoner to pawn: The US continues to undermine our democratic sovereignty
The window exploded before I saw the gun. Just a loud crack — then shards in my face, then a fist yanking the door open. Five of them. Muddy Converse. Beanies pulled low. One barely out of school. They dragged me out of my Mercedes and threw me under a bush like a bag of rubbish. I tasted blood before I knew where it came from. 'Please, take the car,' I said. 'Take everything. Just leave my bag.' It had my laptop. My notes. My life in zipped compartments. 'Fokof,' one spat. 'You think we're your BEE brothers?' Then came the boots. The insults. The gun. The shot. It was supposed to be a hijacking — but it felt like punishment. Not for resisting, but for representing something. For speaking calmly instead of cowering. For not bowing low enough. That moment — blurry, bloodied, and bewildering — is exactly where South Africa stands today. The sanctions are coming On 22 July 2025, the US House Foreign Affairs Committee advanced the US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act in a 34-16 vote. Introduced in April by Congressman Ronny Jackson, the bill is cloaked in diplomatic language, claiming to 'strengthen US-South African ties'. But beneath the façade, it reads like a warning shot. If passed, it would empower the US government to sanction South African officials under the Global Magnitsky Act — a law designed to target the world's worst human rights offenders and kleptocrats. Let's not pretend this is about corruption. South Africa has its own demons, from State Capture to service delivery failures. We've earned the anger of our own people, and rightly so. But if corruption were truly the standard, many of America's allies — some with far worse records — would be on the same list. This isn't a principled stand. It's a geopolitical lever. Nor is non-alignment an endorsement. Russia may have stood with us during the Struggle against apartheid, but that doesn't mean we baptise its every action today. We can remember who showed up without romanticising who they are now. To engage China or speak with Iran is not to sanctify them. To criticise Israel is not to erase Hamas' crimes. But in Washington's current mood, anything short of full compliance is labelled complicity. This isn't about justice — it's about obedience. Obedience to Washington's worldview. Obedience to its alliances. Obedience to its preferred version of moral clarity — one that always seems to exempt its closest partners. When democracy was dangerous History remembers differently than the West pretends. During apartheid, the US didn't stand with the oppressed — it stood with the regime. Nelson Mandela was branded a terrorist — and he remained on the US terrorist watchlist until 2008, 15 years after becoming South Africa's first democratic president. The ANC was labelled a communist threat. President Ronald Reagan vetoed sanctions. Then British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher called them 'immoral'. Western capital backed white supremacy under the banner of anti-communism. When Mandela defended ties to Cuba and Palestine by saying, 'your enemy is not our enemy', it was not defiance — it was sovereignty. It was the dignity of a people refusing to outsource their conscience. Today, once again, South Africa is being punished. Not for violence. Not for lawlessness. But for choosing a path of principle that diverges from Washington's. A loaded act The US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act does not centre human rights. Instead, it grants the US president sweeping authority to determine whether South Africa has 'undermined US national security or foreign policy interests'. That's it. No requirement of genocide. No proof of corruption. No actual misconduct. Just the crime of non-compliance. If enacted, it could trigger visa bans, banking restrictions, asset freezes and diplomatic disengagement. While targeted in language, sanctions rarely remain confined. We've seen the fallout before — from Zimbabwe to Venezuela — where sanctions chilled investment, collapsed currencies and deepened social crises. What's the real trigger? South Africa's vocal stance on Israel and Gaza. Its willingness to invoke international law at The Hague. Its refusal to toe the line in the emerging global Cold War. That — not misgovernance — is the perceived offence. Follow the money The bill's lead sponsor, Congressman Ronny Jackson, is a recipient of significant campaign funding from Aipac — the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. That's not conspiracy — that's public record. It's no coincidence his outrage peaks when South Africa critiques Israel's actions in Gaza — even when those critiques come through respected international legal mechanisms. Let me be clear: I do not uncritically endorse every aspect of South Africa's foreign policy. The Arab world is not beyond reproach. And the apartheid analogy — though emotionally potent — can sometimes oversimplify a complex conflict. But we will not be bullied into silence — not by donors, nor diplomats, nor those who confuse disagreement with disloyalty. This is not about governance — it's about punishment. Punishment for choosing diplomacy over deference. Punishment for saying we will not pick a side in your game. Yes, other nations — Brazil, Spain, Turkey, Colombia — have joined our legal case at the International Court of Justice. But only we are being threatened with sanctions. Why? Because we are easier to isolate. Because we have dared to speak truths the powerful do not wish to hear. The bullet and the bag That night in Johannesburg, I crawled back to my car, bleeding. I had offered everything — wallet, keys, car. But when I said, 'just leave my bag', they pulled the trigger. What they wanted was not my possessions — it was my silence. They could not stomach the audacity of someone like me asking for more than mere survival. And that is exactly where South Africa finds itself now. We've said: Take your trade deals — we'll still talk peace. We've said: We'll engage with China — but we'll also remain open to the West. We've said: We are non-aligned — not hostile. But when we asked for our bag — our voice, our dignity, our seat at the table of global justice — they reached for sanctions. And now the gun is cocked. This is the real danger The true threat is not sanctions — it's amnesia. Forgetting that our democracy was not a donation from the West, but the fruit of blood, prayer, protest and sacrifice. The danger is mistaking pressure for partnership. It's believing our legitimacy is measured by how well we echo Washington's voice. Let the record show: when we were fighting apartheid, they said, 'Not yet.' When we fight for Palestinian lives, they say: 'Not you.' We will not die quietly That night, I should have died. But I didn't. And neither will this democracy. So let the gun be cocked. Let the threats fly. We will not trade dignity for convenience. We will not barter sovereignty for appeasement. We will not be pawns in someone else's game. And we will not die quietly — not in the street.
The Citizen
11 hours ago
- The Citizen
24 hours in pictures, 31 July 2025
24 hours in pictures, 31 July 2025 Through the lens: The Citizen's Picture Editors select the best news photographs from South Africa and around the world. This handout photo released by the Military Emergency Unit (UME) on July 31, 2025, shows firefighters battling a wildfire near Caminomorisco, Extremadura region, western Spain. Firefighters battle a wildfire on the ground and in the air in the Spanish province of Avila and in the region of Extremadura. (Photo by Handout / UME / AFP) An underwater view shows South Africa's swimmer Erin Gallagher as she competes in a heat of the women's 100m freestyle swimming event during the 2025 World Aquatics Championships in Singapore on July 31, 2025. (Photo by Manan VATSYAYANA / AFP) An airplane drops water during a forest fire in Lugar de Real, Castelo de Paiva, Aveiro, Portugal, 30 July fire that has been raging in Arouca, in the district of Aveiro, has three active fronts and has already reached the parish of Santa Eulalia, the local authority said. Picture: EPA/ESTELA SILVA A security guard gestures to members of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) wearing alien outfits during a protest in the financial district of Manila on July 31, 2025, as part of their campaign for people to eat vegan, and highlighting greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture. (Photo by TED ALJIBE / AFP) Protesters hold a Palestinian flag during a rally in solidarity with the Palestinian people, at Sana'a University in Sana'a, Yemen, 30 July 2025. Protesters rallied at Sana'a University in solidarity with the Palestinian people, calling for humanitarian food aid to be let into Gaza since Palestinians are experiencing widespread starvation and severe malnutrition. Picture: EPA/YAHYA ARHAB Israeli right-wing settlers waving a national flag march during a rally calling for the return of Jewish settlements in Gaza, at an area near the border overlooking the Gaza Strip, in southern Israel, 30 July 2025. Picture: EPA/ABIR SULTAN This handout picture provided by the Morocco's Maghreb Arabe Presse (MAP) news agency shows Mudry CAP 230 aircraft of the the aerobatic demonstration team of the Royal Moroccan Air Force, Marche Verte (Green March), performing in Tetouan on occasion of the North African kingdom's Throne Day, marking the enthronement of King Mohammed VI, on July 30, 2025. (Photo by Maghreb Arabe Press (MAP) / AFP) A boy rides his bicycle as a flock of pigeons flies amid cloudy skies after a spell of rain in Jalandhar on July 31, 2025. (Photo by Shammi MEHRA / AFP) This handout photograph taken and released on July 30, 2025 by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) shows ISRO's launch vehicle GSLV-F16 carrying the NISAR earth observation satellite lifting off from the launch pad at the Satish Dhawan Space Centre in Sriharikota in India's Andhra Pradesh state. A formidable new radar satellite jointly developed by the United States and India launched on July 30, designed to track subtle changes in Earth's land and ice surfaces and help predict both natural and human-caused hazards. (Photo by Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) / AFP) Religious images are seen on the wall inside a house damaged by an earthquake in the village of San Miguel Comapa, Jutiapa, Guatemala, 30 July 2025. Guatemalan emergency services reported two deaths, 25 hospitalizations, and 288 people affected by a series of earthquakes in the southeast of the country with a 5.8 magnitude tremor, which was also felt on the borders of El Salvador and Honduras. Picture: EPA/Alex Cruz Aerial view of the Puente Nayero neighborhood during a tsunami warning in Buenaventura, Valle del Cauca Department, Colombia, on July 30, 2025. Colombia ordered residents to evacuate beaches and coastal areas along the Pacific on Wednesday following a tsunami alert triggered by the 8.8-magnitude earthquake off Russia's eastern coast, authorities said. (Photo by JOAQUIN SARMIENTO / AFP) A person watches waves during a storm surge off the coast of Leblon Beach, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 30 July 2025. Picture: EPA/Andre Coelho MORE: 24 hours in pictures, 30 July 2025
