O'Gorman says legal advice on Occupied Territories Bill did not mention issue with services
O'Gorman said the issues the government are now claiming exist in relation to services have only emerged since the last general election.
'It's a delaying tactic,' he said.
The Occupied Territories Bill, in its initial form, would ban trade in goods and services with illegal settlements anywhere in the world, but most notably in Palestine.
Passing the Bill, which has been in existence since 2018, was a promise made by the governing parties ahead of the general election last year.
But it has yet to be passed or even drafted because of what the government has described as 'constitutional issues' and complications related to the inclusion of services alongside goods.
Speaking on The Week in Politics on RTÉ today, O'Gorman said that when he was in government, legal advice provided by the Attorney General in July last year 'raised some issues' with the original draft of the bill, which he said were 'legitimate issues that can be addressed by amendment'.
Advertisement
However, he added: 'There was no reference to an issue around services in his very detailed legal advice.
'This is a new issue that has been brought in subsequent to the general election, a general election where Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael made extensive commitments about passing the Occupied Territories Bill and, to my mind, it's a delaying tactic.
'The Government have said they will publish a draft before summer, they haven't promised to pass it.
'This is about kicking the can down the road,' he added, adding that the Bill could be passed by the summer 'if there was the will'.
The government has been asked repeatedly for the legal advice it has received in relation to services to be published in order to put the matter to bed.
Minister for State Hildegarde Naughton was asked if the government would be willing to publish the advice that has led to the delays in producing a new version of the bill.
'I have no issue with that,' Naughton said, but she pushed back on the suggestion that the government was delaying putting forward the bill.
'This is not a policy difference – I want to be very clear – around goods and services, this is about ensuring that we get that legislation right,' she said.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Germany says Israel ‘violating law of war' in Gaza but refuses to sign ceasefire letter
Israel is violating the law of war in Gaza , a senior Berlin official has conceded, while insisting Germany won't be the 29th signatory to a letter demanding Israel 'end now' its military action. Amid reports of an imminent ceasefire, Jürgen Hardt, foreign policy spokesman for the ruling Christian Democratic Union (CDU), argued the letter was 'already being used by Hamas and other parts of the Arab world for propaganda purposes'. 'That doesn't need to happen with German assistance,' he said. However, Mr Hardt admitted German officials no longer believe that Israel is doing everything it can to allow enough humanitarian aid into Gaza. READ MORE 'I tend towards the view that they are clearly doing too little,' he said, 'and that would be in contradiction to the obligations Israel has under the law of war.' Chancellor Friedrich Merz has shrugged off demands that Germany sign the letter and insisted it echoes a recent, critical EU statement he helped devise – and signed. Since taking power in May, Mr Merz has adopted more critical language, distancing himself from the idea of 'unconditional support' for Israel from Berlin. In Thursday's Zeit weekly, German foreign minister Johann Wadephul declined to say whether Berlin had carried out a promised review of weapons deliveries to Israel. However, he said he was anxious to keep open diplomatic channels to his Israeli opposite number, Gideon Sa'ar. 'I have the feeling that I get through and, though I'm not yet happy with that, what we have achieved between the EU and Israeli govermment is a start,' he said. In his Berlin ministry, meanwhile, protest is growing – led by younger diplomatic staff, demanding action to follow critical words. Reportedly at least 150 diplomats have taken the unusual step of forming a protest group under the motto 'loyal, conforming'. A foreign ministry spokesperson confirmed the existence of the group, with members mostly under 40 years old. When they presented their arguments at a ministry staff meeting earlier this month, attended by the minister, attendees say they were 'greeted with applause'. As well as a tougher approach to Israel, the group is demanding the creation of a 'dissent channel' in the ministry, where staff can air protest to official policy line without fearing consequences. Their protest echoes demands by Germany's junior coalition partner, the centre-left junior Social Democratic Party (SPD), to sign the international letter. 'The reports of starving children and a rapidly-escalating famine show we have reached the much-vaunted 'point of no return',' noted two senior SPD officials in a letter to Mr Merz and Mr Wadephul. Opposition Green politician Katharina Dröger accused the German government of being all talk and no action: 'If Friedrich Merz means it with his [critical] words, then Germany should sign the statement'.
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Cllr Willliam O'Leary elected new chairperson of Northern Committee
Cllr O'Leary was elected the new chair of the Northern Committee following their recently monthly meeting. The Northern Committee is comprised of 15 councillors from the Kanturk/Mallow and Fermoy municipal districts. Cllr O'Leary succeeds Fianna Fáil councillor Ian Doyle who received lavish praise from his political colleagues for his professionalism during his tenure. Cllr Frank O'Flynn paid tribute to the outgoing chair. 'The meetings were very positive and very well organised. You were very fair and you gave everyone an opportunity.' Fine Gael councillor Tony O'Shea also thanked Cllr Ian Doyle for his contribution and professionalism throughout the year. He also wished Cllr O'Leary all the very best in the year ahead. Cllr O'Leary who is based in Rathcormac was nominated for the role of chair by Cllr Frank O'Flynn and Cllr Peter O'Donoghue. Cllr O'Flynn said Mr O'Leary is firmly 'embedded' in the local community and a man destined for greater things. 'William is a second time councillor in the area. He is a colleague of ours in the Fermoy MD. He is very well known in this area. He is very embedded in the local community and in the GAA with Bride Rovers who are synonymous with success. I think William is a man destined for greater things.' Independent councillor Peter O'Donoghue who seconded the nomination said William is a great representative for all the people in the Northern Division. 'He is widely respected by all political parties and by all Independents. He does Trojan work for the area. He is a fair and reasonable person. He would be the ideal candidate for chair of this division.' Cllr O'Leary was subsequently elected as chair for 2025-26 and he began his opening speech by thanking Cllr O'Flynn and Cllr O'Donoghue for the nomination. 'I want to congratulate the outgoing chair Ian Doyle and I want to wish him well in his year as deputy mayor. He is a very popular member of Cork County Council. 'I will keep the programme of work going,' said Cllr O'Leary. 'It is an important committee. We have our directorates coming in here and it is an opportunity to work with them. I might be a bit quieter up here than down there. I will try anyway.' Fianna Fáil councillor Nelius Cotter was elected as the new vice-chairperson of the Northern Committee. Cllr Frank O'Flynn who proposed Cllr Cotter for the role said he is very much stepped in farming organisations. 'He was a first-time candidate in the last election and he got elected in the Fermoy local electoral area. He is very much embedded in the community and especially in the farming organisations. He came up through the Fianna Fáil ranks.' Fianna Fáil councillor Ian Doyle seconded the nomination of Cllr Cotter. The new chairperson received warm and very supportive messages from all his political colleagues. Cllr Pat Hayes thanked Cllr Ian Doyle for his work over the last year before wishing Cllr O'Leary and Cllr Cotter the very best in their new roles for the coming year. Cllr Gearoid Murphy (Fianna Fáil) also offered warm congratulations to Cllr O'Leary: 'It is not an easy job. There are 15 of us in here. In terms of the population that we represent in the Northern Division, it is bigger than some county councils. Best of luck. You have great experience and I'm sure the next year will run smoothly.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Fine Gael irked by Niall Collins's dismissal of blanket VAT cut for ‘price-gouging' hospitality sector
A row has emerged between Fianna Fáil TD Niall Collins and some Fine Gael representatives over his recent dismissal of a blanket cut to the VAT rate for the 'price-gouging' hospitality sector. Mr Collins, Minister of State at the Department of Justice, said luxury and five-star hotels benefiting from a universal reduction in the VAT rate to 9 per cent would sit 'very, very uncomfortably with me'. Fine Gael TD John Clendennen, who has previously worked in Irish and international hotel chains, questioned the Limerick politician's claim that the industry has engaged in 'immense' price gouging. Some Fine Gael Ministers also criticised Mr Collins for trying to 'split hairs' and for criticising a policy that would help support entry-level jobs in rural Ireland. READ MORE This week it emerged the full-year cost of the proposed VAT cut for the hospitality sector would be almost €1 billion, taking up the majority of the €1.5 billion tax package available for Budget 2026. It is understood the Government is now considering delaying the cut until the middle of next year and applying the cut to food and drink services but not accommodation. Mr Collins told Limerick's Live 95 radio station this week he is 'not convinced that a VAT reduction is merited within the hospitality sector'. He said there was 'little to no evidence' that a previous temporary reduction from 13 per cent to 9 per cent for the sector 'was actually passed on to the consumer'. 'There's no evidence that that ever happened. And secondly, we saw an immense amount of price gouging within the sector in recent years,' Mr Collins said. The Fianna Fáil TD said he would favour 'targeted interventions' for parts of the hospitality sector 'where there is a genuine threat of job losses'. Mr Collins repeated his opposition to a blanket VAT rate on RTÉ Radio 1 on Thursday morning. However, Mr Clendennen, a Fine Gael TD for Offaly, told The Irish Times he 'was not so sure' about Mr Collins's claim there was widespread evidence of price gouging in the hospitality sector. Mr Clendennan said many hospitality businesses have come under 'pressure' with rising costs. He said he is 'very much in favour of VAT 9 as a measure to help business'. 'I think we need to try to ensure that the maximum number of hospitality businesses can remain viable,' he said. Mr Collins's comments went down badly with Fine Gael Ministers, one of whom pointed out that he seemed to be at odds with Taoiseach Micheál Martin, who has indicated support for the measure this week. Another Fine Gael Minister said he felt Mr Collins was complicating matters by singling out luxury hotels. The Minister said it was difficult to hear 'a rural TD trying to split hairs' over something that would create and sustain entry-level jobs in his own constituency. 'People have been crying out for this,' the Minister said. Tánaiste Simon Harris had previously described the Government's commitment to cut VAT for the hospitality sector to 9 per cent as a 'solemn' vow. Mr Harris also told his parliamentary party last month that the measure would be included in Budget 2026.
