‘Are your promises worth anything?': Fiery clash in NSW parliament over controversial workers comp reform
A revised proposal to reform workers compensation, specifically psychological injuries claims, was tabled last week by Industrial Relations Minister Sophie Cotsis.
Ms Cotsis said the compensation plan sought to instil a 'culture of prevention' in the scheme, and give clarity to employers on their rights and responsibilities.
Detractors argue the changes would lock many out of receiving damages – namely a new 30 per cent threshold for permanent impairment due to psychological injury.
While the Opposition is yet to formally announce its position on the bill, Liberal leader Mark Speakman questioned Ms Cotsis on Tuesday morning over the threshold.
Mr Speakman claimed during question time that Ms Cotsis had pledged to remove the provision – known as Section 39 – altogether prior to the 2023 state election.
'Are your promises worth anything?' Mr Speakman asked, sparking shouting across the chamber.
In the fiery exchange that ensued, Ms Cotsis shot back that she was 'more of a worker's friend than the Leader of the Opposition (is)'.
'Where were you when people died under your watch?,' Ms Cotsis said, referencing the former Coalition government.
'Where were you when review after review came out and said that you needed to fix work health and safety? You were nowhere.'
Police Minister Yasmin Catley, Roads Minister Jenny Aitchison, and Building Minister Anoulack Chanthivong were all also grilled over their position on Section 39.
'I'm delighted to always get a question about workers in this place,' Mr Chanthivong said.
'Because there's only one party in this parliament to speak when it comes to workers – its actually us'.
The planned reforms have stirred controversy since they were first introduced earlier this year, with support from some of the businesses community.
The state's unions, including the NSW Teachers Federation, Unions NSW, and the NSW Nurses and Midwives Association, have instead opposed the bill.
Their members rallied outside parliament earlier this month, calling on the government to reconsider the plan and to engage with the unions.
In tabling the bill last month, Ms Cotsis noted amendments had been made since its first iteration and that a tripartite review committee would be established, including Unions NSW.
The bill also seeks to address the NSW government's bottom-line, with Treasurer Daniel Moohkey ruling out any further payments to the state's self-insurer.
Business leaders told a parliamentary inquiry into the bill earlier this year that insurance premiums to businesses and charities had seen their premiums increase.
Treasury modelling released by the Daily Telegraph on Tuesday warned business and not-for-profits may be forced to fork out an extra $1bn per year if reforms aren't made.
A separate bill seeking to amend workplace health and safety legislation was also tabled in NSW parliament.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
2 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Internal wars erupt as idea of political wilderness begins to dawn
Staring at perhaps three years of increasing irrelevance, Australia's small and once-influential political parties have turned to their own internecine wars on the very day the lopsided 48th federal parliament opened for business – pretty much as a Labor shopfront. The Greens have dropped one of their founders in an unedifying brawl over transgender policy and two Nationals warhorses are advocating abandonment of net zero emission targets just as both Coalition parties review their climate and energy policies following Peter Dutton's thumping election defeat in May. The Nationals' self-absorption is unforgivable as the Liberals struggle to recapture their lost heartland by addressing modern-day problems, including climate change. No such concerns appear to bother perverse MPs from the Nationals heartland, where the effects of climate change, bushfires and floods are most pernicious. Former Nationals leaders and once-bitter rivals Barnaby Joyce and Michael McCormack have curiously joined forces to spruik dumping net zero emissions and publicly undermine leader David Littleproud. Out of nowhere, they have raised the spectre of a challenge just as Liberal leader Sussan Ley tries to project an image of unity so the Coalition can rediscover its mojo and become a credible opposition. Meanwhile, the Greens wasted little time digesting their election failure to instead grab headlines for expelling Drew Hutton, co-founder of the Queensland and Australian Greens, after he refused to delete transphobic comments made by others on his Facebook page. Former Greens leaders Bob Brown and Christine Milne opposed blackballing Hutton, who then accused the Greens of trying to stifle free speech, adding the party was 'authoritarian, aggressive, unlikeable'. Greens leader Larissa Waters went on the ABC to defend the move, ludicrously saying she had not read documentation about Hutton's expulsion. Compare and contrast the Greens' lack of feeling for their own history with Labor's actions this week, when it decided against banishment and allowed a portrait of the less-than-shining example of Labor values, former leader Mark Latham, to remain in the caucus room leaders' gallery – with a note that he was dead to them and had been expelled for life. Maybe losing badly rattles judgment: the Greens lost three seats, including the Melbourne electorate of former leader Adam Bandt. Their Senate primary vote was down almost 1 per cent too, though they maintained the same number of Senate seats. Against that, the Nationals held ground, winning 15 seats with 3.8 per cent of the national vote, but it was a scant 0.2 per cent increase from 2022. In fact, the Nationals vote has been stuck beneath 5 per cent for nearly 20 years as their heartland shrank to ageing populations drip-fed by Sky News.
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Federal government under pressure to intervene in NT incarceration 'crisis'
One of Australia's largest Aboriginal legal services is calling on the federal government to intervene in what it is calling an incarceration "crisis" in the Northern Territory. The NT's prison population has soared to unprecedented levels in recent months, with prisoners locked up inside police watch houses for days on end due to a lack of beds at correctional facilities. In one recent incident, an 11-year-old Aboriginal girl who was initially denied bail was detained overnight inside Palmerston's overcrowded police watch house, where the lights remain on 24 hours a day. The North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency's (NAAJA) acting chief executive, Anthony Beven, has called on the federal government to suspend Commonwealth funding for remote policing and other justice-related operations until the NT government changes its hardline approach to crime. Since the Country Liberal Party came to power last year, the NT government has lowered the age of criminal responsibility from 12 back to 10 and introduced tougher bail laws for both adults and children. Mr Beven said the measures were not working to reduce crime and were leading to large numbers of Aboriginal people being incarcerated. "One of the unique things we have here in the Northern Territory is that the Commonwealth actually funds the Northern Territory police for remote policing and other options," Mr Beven said. The NT Police Force was budgeted to receive about $50 million in Commonwealth funding in 2024-25. Mr Beven also said NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro had so far refused to meet with NAAJA and other Aboriginal leaders to discuss strategies aimed at reducing crime. In a statement, Federal Indigenous Australians Minister Marndirri McCarthy said: "There is something very wrong with the Northern Territory justice system when an 11-year-old girl is held in an adult police watch house for two days and one night." "It is primarily Northern Territory bail laws that are driving this issue," she said. Ms McCarthy said the NT government had previously committed to reducing the incarceration rates of First Nations people under the National Agreement on Closing the Gap. NT Attorney-General Marie-Clare Boothby slammed Mr Beven's comments as "utterly absurd". "Threatening to cut essential funding to remote policing is counterproductive, dangerous, and undermines community confidence," Ms Boothby said in a statement. "There is no alternative: those who break the law will be arrested. "Corrections will continue to expand capacity to ensure those who are remanded or sentenced have a bed, because that's what the community expects." Ms Boothby said the adult prison in Berrimah, on Darwin's outskirts, would be expanded to accommodate an extra 238 prison beds by mid-August. Ms Finocchiaro has been contacted for comment. The situation in the Northern Territory comes amid growing international concern about youth justice in Australia. In a letter to the federal government in May, the United Nations (UN) Special Rapporteur on Torture, Alice Edwards, and the Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Albert K Barume, singled out the NT's record on human rights. "Several states and the Northern Territory are announcing new 'tougher' criminal legislation, which seem to give little regard to international human rights standards," they wrote. The letter said there was an "ongoing pattern" of First Nations children being disproportionately incarcerated, noting that in the Northern Territory, Indigenous children are 32 times more likely to be incarcerated than non-Indigenous children. It also said the NT government's decision to reduce the age of criminal responsibility from 12 to 10 was "a step backwards", and criticised the lifting of a ban on spit hoods being used on children. "Spit hoods … are considered inherently in violation of the prohibition of torture and/or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment," they wrote. The federal government has not responded to the letter in the requested 60-day timeframe.
Sky News AU
3 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Coalition enters 48th Parliament with lowest ever seat tally in its history
Day one of the 48th Parliament has commenced and Labor has the equal most ever seats at 94 in the lower house. The Coalition has its lowest ever tally as a Liberal-National entity at 43 seats.
