Execution by firing squad for Utah killer Ralph Menzies as court told his dementia is worsening
Ralph Leroy Menzies, is set to be executed by firing squad on September 5 for abducting and killing a mother of three in 1986.
The 67-year-old's lawyers have filed multiple appeals, arguing his condition is worsening and he cannot understand his case.
In the US, both state and federal law require that death row inmates have an understanding of why they are being executed.
Despite this, a judge has ruled Menzies "consistently and rationally" understands why he is facing execution even with his recent cognitive decline.
While the date is set, it could be further delayed when later this month Judge Matthew Bates will decide whether the prisoner should undergo another mental evaluation.
The case highlights the use of and the rules and regulations surrounding capital punishment in the US which is still legal in more than 20 states as well as federally.
Here's what to know about this case.
In 1986, 26-year-old Maurine Hunsaker, was abducted by Menzies from a convenience store where she worked in the Salt Lake City suburb of Kearns.
She was later found strangled and her throat cut about 25 kilometres away at a picnic area in Big Cottonwood Canyon.
Menzies had Hunsaker's wallet and several other belongings when he was jailed on unrelated matters.
He was convicted of first-degree murder and other crimes in 1988.
When given a choice decades ago, Menzies selected a firing squad as his method of execution.
He would become only the sixth US prisoner executed by firing squad since 1977.
But after more than four decades, lawyers for Menzies filed multiple appeals that delayed his death sentence, which had been scheduled at least twice before it was pushed back.
In the US, capital punishment, also known as the death penalty, is legal for certain crimes in 27 states.
Across the US, there are 10 scheduled executions for the rest of 2025 in Florida, Tennessee, Utah, Texas, Indiana, Montana and Alaska.
Twenty-five men have been put to death in the US this year.
There are several methods of capital punishment in the US and they can vary by state.
It is primarily used for those convicted of first-degree murder.
Menzies and other Utah death row inmates sentenced before May 2004 were given a choice between firing squad and lethal injection.
For inmates sentenced in the state after that date, lethal injection is the default method unless the drugs are unavailable.
In the US, the death penalty is far more common in state cases than federal.
Former president Joe Biden placed a moratorium on federal executions for all cases except terrorism and hate-motivated mass murder during his term.
"I am more convinced than ever that we must stop the use of the death penalty at the federal level," he said late in his presidency.
When Donald Trump took office again, he made "restoring the death penalty" an early priority.
In January, he signed an executive order to "counteract the politicians and judges who subvert the law by obstructing and preventing the execution of capital sentences".
Lawyers for Menzies say his dementia has gotten so severe that he uses a wheelchair, is dependent on oxygen and cannot understand his legal case.
They have petitioned the court for a reassessment, but Judge Bates said that the pending appeal was not a basis to stop him from setting a date.
He did schedule a July 23 hearing to evaluate a competency petition.
"We remain hopeful that the courts or the clemency board will recognise the profound inhumanity of executing a man who is experiencing steep cognitive decline and significant memory loss," said Lindsey Layer, a lawyer for Menzies.
"Taking the life of someone with a terminal illness who is no longer a threat to anyone and whose mind and identity have been overtaken by dementia serves neither justice nor human decency."
The Utah Attorney General's Office has "full confidence" in Judge Bates's decision, Assistant Attorney General Daniel Boyer said.
The US Supreme Court has spared prisoners with dementia from execution before.
In 2019, Vernon Madison, an Alabama man who had killed a police officer, had his execution stayed by the government and died in prison at the age of 69.
If a defendant cannot understand why they are being put to death, the high court said, then an execution is not carrying out the retribution that society is seeking.
For Hunsaker's son Matt, who was 10 years old when his mother was killed, it has been "hard to swallow that it's taken this long" to get justice.
"You issue the warrant today, you start a process for our family," he told the judge on Wednesday.
"It puts everybody on the clock. We've now introduced another generation of my mom, and we still don't have justice served."
ABC/Wires
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
10 hours ago
- News.com.au
Tourists outrage over sight on board fishing boat in Florida
A video shot by a boatload of tourists has sparked international outrage, with some calling for charges to be laid against the fishermen behind the catch as well as the global company who allegedly requested the creature. The short clip, which has gone viral, shows five men hauling in a massive manta ray from the ocean that surrounds Shell Island off Panama City Beach in Florida. The disturbing footage shows the large animal struggling in a black net as the fishermen haul what is believed to be a female manta ray aboard their white boat. Speaking to local media 10 News, Denis Richard — the founder and CEO of dolphin swim tour company Water Planet USA — recorded the video while on his way back to the marina with a group of tourists. Mr Richard claims the men struggled to bring up what he initially believed was a shark before realising it was an endangered giant manta ray. 'I was horrified, and everybody on board was really upset,' Richard said of the ordeal, which left his boatload of tourists shocked, horrified and angry. 'We saw the wings of a manta ray and the manta ray was not hooked through the mouth … So they must have snagged him.' Mr Richard claims the mammoth ray was dumped into a small pool on board the boat, with the fisherman allegedly appearing to celebrate the fact they'd snagged a female. ''Oh, good, that's a female,' Mr Richard claims one of the fisherman said, adding the animal would've 'been in pain'. While these giant oceanic manta rays are protected under the Endangered Species Act, some fishermen who hold a permit to harvest these animals under a Marine Special Activity License means they are technically allowed to catch and keep. According to The Independent, the group of fisherman did have a permit and that their company typically supplies marine life caught around Florida and the Caribbean 'to public aquariums and stores, such as SeaWorld.' In a statement shared by The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, a spokesperson said while they are aware of the video circulating on social media, the fisherman didn't commit a crime. 'The take of manta rays is prohibited in state waters. However, the capture of the ray shown in this video was permitted by a Marine Special Activity License that allowed for the take of one manta ray. 'The Marine Special Activity License Program issues licenses for activities requiring a marine fisheries regulation waiver. Activities that are licensed by this program include, but are not limited to, scientific research, education, exhibition, aquaculture, and more.' has contacted the marine supplied, with the company describing themselves as 'effectively' serving aquarist customers by 'discovering, acquiring, and acclimating difficult-to-capture marine life of all sizes for public display or the home hobbyist.' It is understood the company has been in practice since 1984. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) said the wild female manta ray 'doesn't belong' in captivity. 'Manta rays are gentle, intelligent fish who glide through the open ocean using their wide, winglike fins,' the non-governmental organisation said on their website. 'They belong in the ocean, not behind glass at a marine park for humans to gawk at. 'These men abducted this manta ray from the only home she has likely ever known. This is the last time she'll feel ocean waves.' Local 10 News — a television station in Miami, Florida and who is affiliated with ABC (America) — confirmed that SeaWorld Abu Dhabi contracted the marine supply group to procure the giant manta ray.
News.com.au
13 hours ago
- News.com.au
Most Americans disapprove of Trump admin's handling of Jeffrey Epstein files, poll finds
Most voters don't like the way President Donald Trump has dealt with an investigative review of the federal case against notorious paedophile Jeffrey Epstein, according to a new poll out Wednesday. A Quinnipiac University national survey found 63 per cent of American voters disliked the Trump administration's approach to the probe of Epstein, a one-time acquaintance of the president in the 1990s and early 2000s — who also associated with Hollywood celebrities, business titans and British royalty. Just 17 per cent approved of the administration's actions in the Epstein matter, while said 20 per cent they were undecided. The 'systematic review' concluded last week that the 66-year-old committed suicide in his Manhattan jail cell on August 10, 2019, after being charged with trafficking dozens of young girls for sex — and never had a 'client list' of powerful associates allegedly implicated in his sickening crimes. The two-page memo was unsigned but bore FBI and Department of Justice letterhead — despite bureau Deputy Director Dan Bongino clashing with Attorney-General Pam Bondi and even threatening to quit over the meagre findings and public relations fallout. 'There was … no credible evidence found that Epstein blackmailed prominent individuals as part of his actions,' the memo noted. 'We did not uncover evidence that could predicate an investigation against uncharged third parties.' Epstein harmed more than 'one thousand victims', according to the DOJ-FBI memo, many of whom were allegedly trafficked to his home in the US Virgin Islands. The financier's association with influential figures like Microsoft founder Bill Gates, former President Bill Clinton and Prince Andrew has been the subject of frenzied online speculation since he was found dead in New York City's Metropolitan Correctional Center almost six years ago. The odd circumstances of Epstein's demise included guards falling asleep and cameras outside of his cell not functioning. Both former attorneys and medical examiners have also theorised that Epstein may not have committed suicide. A majority of US voters (53 per cent) disapprove of Ms Bondi's job performance, while 32 per cent approve, the Quinnipiac survey found. FBI Director Kash Patel is seen favourably by 36 per cent of voters, but 47 per cent disapprove of his job performance. A slightly lower 41 per cent disapprove of Mr Bongino, and 34 per cent approve of the job he's doing. The DOJ previously released records of flight logs and a contact list the financier kept before his second federal arrest in 2019, most of which had already been made public during the 2021 trial of his now-convicted madam Ghislaine Maxwell. Epstein evaded more serious charges in the mid-2000s as part of a controversial plea deal for soliciting sex from a minor that was brokered by then-Miami US Attorney Alex Acosta, later Mr Trump's Labor Secretary in his first term. Maxwell is currently serving 20 years in prison as Epstein's accomplice. Mr Trump reportedly banned Epstein from Mar-a-Lago in 2007 following an incident with a club member's teenage daughter — before he was first charged with sex crimes — but has rebuffed attacks from right-wing critics that his administration mishandled its probe of the deceased sex trafficker. 'I don't understand why the Jeffrey Epstein case would be of interest to anybody,' the President told reporters outside Air Force One on Tuesday. 'It's pretty boring stuff. It's sordid, but it's boring, and I don't understand why it keeps going.' 'Anything that's credible, I would say, let them have it,' he added, suggesting Ms Bondi — who before the memo's release suggested the 'client list' was on her desk at main DOJ — could disclose more information. 'In February, I did an interview on Fox, and it's been getting a lot of attention because I said — I was asked a question about the client list, and my response was, 'It's sitting on my desk to be reviewed,' meaning the [Epstein] file along with the JFK and MLK files as well,' Ms Bondi said during a Cabinet meeting July 8. House Speaker Mike Johnson and other Republicans have urged more transparency on the issue, which could lead to congressional subpoenas for federal records — something Democrats have already pushed in some committee votes. According to the Quinnipiac poll, 40 per cent of GOP voters approve of how Mr Trump handled the disclosure of information about Epstein in federal files, 36 per cent disapprove and 24 per cent have no opinion. A whopping 83 per cent of Democrats disapprove of the President's handling of the Epstein files, while 2 per cent approve. 'Unlike Republicans, they [Democrats] stick together like glue. Their new SCAM is what we will forever call the Jeffrey Epstein Hoax, and my PAST supporters have bought into this 'bulls**t', hook, line, and sinker,' Mr Trump posted on Truth Social on Wednesday. 'Let these weaklings continue forward and do the Democrats' work, don't even think about talking of our incredible and unprecedented success, because I don't want their support anymore! Thank you for your attention to this matter. MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!' Epstein's ex-attorney Alan Dershowitz has recently claimed that there is an FBI affidavit about his late client's connections that could be made public — and blamed federal courts for blocking the release of those files.
News.com.au
15 hours ago
- News.com.au
AI-powered 'nudify' apps fuel deadly wave of digital blackmail
After a Kentucky teenager died by suicide this year, his parents discovered he had received threatening texts demanding $3,000 to suppress an AI-generated nude image of him. The tragedy underscores how so-called sextortion scams targeting children are growing around the world, particularly with the rapid proliferation of "nudify" apps -- AI tools that digitally strip off clothing or generate sexualized imagery. Elijah Heacock, 16, was just one of thousands of American minors targeted by such digital blackmail, which has spurred calls for more action from tech platforms and regulators. His parents told US media that the text messages ordered him to pay up or an apparently AI-generated nude photo would be sent to his family and friends. "The people that are after our children are well organized," John Burnett, the boy's father, said in a CBS News interview. "They are well financed, and they are relentless. They don't need the photos to be real, they can generate whatever they want, and then they use it to blackmail the child." US investigators were looking into the case, which comes as nudify apps -- which rose to prominence targeting celebrities -- are being increasingly weaponized against children. The FBI has reported a "horrific increase" in sextortion cases targeting US minors, with victims typically males between the ages of 14 and 17. The threat has led to an "alarming number of suicides," the agency warned. - Instruments of abuse - In a recent survey, Thorn, a non-profit focused on preventing online child exploitation, found that six percent of American teens have been a direct victim of deepfake nudes. "Reports of fakes and deepfakes -- many of which are generated using these 'nudifying' services -- seem to be closely linked with reports of financial sextortion, or blackmail with sexually explicit images," the British watchdog Internet Watch Foundation (IWF) said in a report last year. "Perpetrators no longer need to source intimate images from children because images that are convincing enough to be harmful -- maybe even as harmful as real images in some cases -- can be produced using generative AI." The IWF identified one "pedophile guide" developed by predators that explicitly encouraged perpetrators to use nudifying tools to generate material to blackmail children. The author of the guide claimed to have successfully blackmailed some 13-year-old girls. The tools are a lucrative business. A new analysis of 85 websites selling nudify services found they may be collectively worth up to $36 million a year. The analysis from Indicator, a US publication investigating digital deception, estimates that 18 of the sites made between $2.6 million and $18.4 million over the six months to May. Most of the sites rely on tech infrastructure from Google, Amazon, and Cloudflare to operate, and remain profitable despite crackdowns by platforms and regulators, Indicator said. - 'Whack-a-mole' - The proliferation of AI tools has led to new forms of abuse impacting children, including pornography scandals at universities and schools worldwide, where teenagers created sexualized images of their own classmates. A recent Save the Children survey found that one in five young people in Spain have been victims of deepfake nudes, with those images shared online without their consent. Earlier this year, Spanish prosecutors said they were investigating three minors in the town of Puertollano for allegedly targeting their classmates and teachers with AI-generated pornographic content and distributing it in their school. In the United Kingdom, the government this year made creating sexually explicit deepfakes a criminal offense, with perpetrators facing up to two years in jail. And in May, US President Donald Trump signed the bipartisan "Take It Down Act," which criminalizes the non-consensual publication of intimate images, while also mandating their removal from online platforms. Meta also recently announced it was filing a lawsuit against a Hong Kong company behind a nudify app called Crush AI, which it said repeatedly circumvented the tech giant's rules to post ads on its platforms. But despite such measures, researchers say AI nudifying sites remain resilient.
