Nearly half of Gen Z and millennials say college was a waste of money—AI has already made degrees obsolete
College is often advertised as the best four years of one's life, but many Americans now have regrets.
More than a third of all graduates now say their degree was a 'waste of money,' according to a new survey by Indeed. This frustration is especially pronounced among Gen Z, with 51% expressing remorse—compared to 41% of millennials and just 20% of baby boomers.
Overall, a growing share of college-educated workers are questioning the return on investment (ROI) of their degree, Kyle M.K., a career trend expert at Indeed, told Fortune. It's something that's not all too surprising considering that the average cost of a bachelor's degree has doubled in the last two decades to over $38,000, and total student loan debt has ballooned to nearly $2 trillion.
'Another 38% feel student loans have limited their career growth more than their diploma has accelerated it,' M.K. said. 'Together, these realities are nudging universities and employers to shift focus from pedigree to practical skill. In fact, 52% of U.S. job postings on Indeed don't list any formal education requirement.'
However, for many young people, this realization is coming too late. Already, some 4.3 million Gen Z have been left behind as 'NEETs'—not in education, employment, or training—with no clear direction on how to restart their early careers.
For young people in particular, who are navigating a less than ideal job market, it can be difficult to see the long-term ROI of college. This is especially true when, for some subjects, like psychology, philosophy, or English, it can take over 20 years in the workforce for the degree to pay for itself, according to the Education Data Initiative.
However, Christine Cruzvergara, chief education strategy officer at Handshake, warns against valuing a degree from a purely quantitative standpoint.
'It's shortsighted to focus only on immediate employment, as that makes the assumption that the value of higher education is only to get your first job,' Cruzvergara told Fortune. 'When in reality, higher education contributes to career advancement opportunities, exposure to a variety of fields, aids in self-discovery, and develops management and leadership skills.'
While nearly 70% of young graduates believe they could do their job without a degree, they may have not been exposed to their network without it. Cruzvergara says that universities are failing to promote that they're more than just a piece of paper that'll open doors after graduation day, but a hotbed for learning and meeting like-minded people while on campus.
For example, Mark Zuckerberg dropped out of Harvard during his sophomore year to focus on building Facebook into the social media empire it is today. But he couldn't have done it without the four cofounders he met at university.
'Gen Z faces a particularly uncertain job market, and there's a need for a better connection between education investment and outcomes,' she adds.
The spread of artificial intelligence into all parts of education and the workplace has made college graduates question their degree even more, with some 30% feeling AI has outright made their degree irrelevant—a number that jumps to 45% among Gen Zers.
This is despite efforts from thought leaders in the space to calm fears about AI replacing workers. 'AI is not going to take your job,' Netflix's co-CEO Ted Sarandos said last year. 'The person who uses AI well might take your job.'
While M.K. admits that skill areas like routine programming, basic data analysis, and templated content creation have become highly exposed to AI, fields like nursing, advanced project management, and creative strategy are relatively insulated.
'AI is more of an amplifier than a pink slip,' M.K. said, adding that above all else, those who prioritize lifelong learning and have open conversations with their employer about AI will be able to soar in the wake of technological advancements.
'AI won't invalidate a solid education, but it will reward those who keep upgrading their toolkit.'
This story was originally featured on Fortune.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Wire
4 minutes ago
- Business Wire
One Call, Zero Regrets: Essential Utilities Reminds You
BRYN MAWR, Pa.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--National Safe Digging Day is just a week away, and Essential Utilities and its subsidiaries, Aqua Water and Peoples Natural Gas, are urging customers and contractors to put safety first and call 811 before all projects involving digging. Critical utility infrastructure such as gas and water lines may be out of sight, but they cannot be put out of mind. Damage to lines can disrupt service and create dangerous situations that may lead to property damage and serious personal injury. Share A recent survey from the Common Ground Alliance (CGA) found that nearly half (46%) of Americans plan to dig without contacting 811 ahead of time, putting utility infrastructure and safety of communities at risk. To boost awareness about the 811 service and the importance of safe digging practices, Monday, August 11 (8-11) is National Safe Digging Day. Critical utility infrastructure such as gas and water lines may be out of sight, but they cannot be put out of mind, as damage to lines can disrupt availability and create dangerous situations that may lead to property damage, personal injury, and even death. Calling 811 before digging is free to homeowners and can prevent injuries, fines and outages in the community. The process is simple: Call 811, the national call-before-you-dig hotline, at least three business days before the planned start of excavation; Wait for the site to be marked by utility companies, such as Peoples and Aqua, with paint, flags or stakes; Dig with care. Respect the markings, use appropriate tools, and if you do damage a pipeline, line markers, locator wire or warning tape, immediately call 911 and notify the appropriate utility. 'As Essential invests more than $500 million annually to upgrade the underground infrastructure serving our 5.5 million customers, we encourage the public to help us protect those pipelines by calling 811 before every project involving digging,' said Essential Utilities Chairman and CEO Christopher Franklin. 'Excavation damages to pipelines can disrupt service and create serious safety hazards. Please, make this One Call for Zero Regrets: Wherever you live, whatever the project, call 811 before you dig!' The 811 service is required for all projects involving digging, from smaller jobs such as planting shrubs or installing a mailbox, up to building a swimming pool or installing a fence. Visit for more information about your state's safe digging laws. About Essential Utilities Essential Utilities, Inc. (NYSE: WTRG) delivers safe, clean, reliable services that improve quality of life for individuals, families, and entire communities. With a focus on water, wastewater and natural gas, Essential is committed to sustainable growth, operational excellence, a superior customer experience, and premier employer status. We are advocates for the communities we serve and are dedicated stewards of natural lands, protecting more than 7,600 acres of forests and other habitats throughout our footprint. Operating as the Aqua and Peoples brands, Essential serves approximately 5.5 million people across nine states. Essential is one of the most significant publicly traded water, wastewater service and natural gas providers in the U.S. Learn more at WTRGG
Epoch Times
31 minutes ago
- Epoch Times
Trump Says Americans Could Get Dividends From Tariff Revenues
Tariffs President Donald Trump floated the idea of giving dividends to some households as tariff collections reached $28 billion in July. President Donald Trump suggested on Sunday that his administration could distribute dividends from tariff revenues to Americans with certain income levels. Speaking to reporters before boarding Air Force One, Trump said that a distribution of dividends to selected U.S. households is possible, even as the government works to pay down the national debt.
Chicago Tribune
35 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
Jeb Bush: How postsecondary opportunities for students are changing for the better
Americans are losing faith in higher education. Nearly half of adults believe a college degree is less important to get a well-paying job than it was 20 years ago, and only a quarter believe a four-year degree is a very important part of getting a job that pays well. The question of value is front and center for policymakers across the country and in Washington. For too long, postsecondary education programs have been focused on too many aspects not related to student success. We've encouraged enrollment without as much concern for whether students are completing or getting the most value out of the program. That's no longer good enough. Students deserve programs that lead to meaningful, high-wage employment, and taxpayers deserve accountability for the billions they invest each year. Governors and policymakers must prioritize rethinking postsecondary resources to answer an important question: Is our system creating real value for students? Fortunately, a growing number of states are embracing student-centered reforms that align educational opportunities with economic mobility. Their efforts are pointing the way toward a smarter, more transparent model of postsecondary education that prioritizes outcomes over inputs. For example, Arkansas conducted a comprehensive return-on-investment analysis of every associate and bachelor's degree program in the state, assessing whether they help students earn more than they would with only a high school diploma. It's a simple benchmark that will be at the heart of every state's postsecondary strategy under the recently passed federal budget reconciliation bill, which will require states to measure graduates' median income four years after program completion and may result in decreased federal funding if earnings fall below a certain level. Now is the perfect time for states to innovate and customize even further using state funds to incentivize change. Florida has taken that one step further with its 'money-back guarantee' for workforce education programs. If a graduate can't get a job within six months, the college refunds their tuition. That approach gives students peace of mind and creates a powerful incentive for institutions to focus on offering programs that have value and are continually updated to reflect an alignment with the skills and expectations of employers. For example, technology moves at a much faster pace than schools, so this requirement gives an incentive for schools to keep a pulse on what's shifted from 'new' to 'required to be successful' in a field. A promising development is happening in Texas, where a new funding formula for community colleges links all state funding to a student's completion of a degree or certificate, with significantly higher bonuses for success in high-demand fields and with higher-need students. This ensures taxpayer investment is aligned with whether students finish and find meaningful employment instead of just the number of students enrolled in the program. Some states are leveraging other strategies to support completion. Tennessee's 'Tennessee Promise' provides last-dollar scholarships and intensive mentoring to help more students complete associate degrees or technical certificates without debt. Colorado recently issued a bold executive order to reimagine the future of the postsecondary talent development. It codifies years of stakeholder engagement and data analysis to translate recommendations into actions. Utah has developed stackable credential programs that allow learners to build toward a degree over time while working, helping them earn and learn without starting over. As states seek to create more opportunities for students to capitalize on education, it's important to make sure these programs are accomplishing what they set out to perform. Right now, many states don't know if they have underenrolled or lower-performing programs. Analyzing the existing landscape is the first step in preventing those programs from becoming the norm. In Indiana, colleges and universities, following legislative action earlier in the year, recently announced they will merge or sunset more than 400 underenrolled programs they say offer limited payoff in the labor market. This kind of data-informed decision-making sends the message that public colleges should focus their resources on offerings that give students a real shot at success after graduation. Editorial: Indiana University, Ball State and Purdue are gutted without logic or thoughtAt the heart of all these reforms is a shared understanding that postsecondary education should be a launchpad, not a dead end. Degrees and credentials should equip students with the tools they need to thrive in a dynamic economy. That means making tough choices about which programs to support, giving students the information they need to choose wisely while rewarding institutions where students achieve actual post-graduation success in employment, enlistment or enrollment. Affordability remains a top concern as families plan for the future. But reducing costs without increasing value is a hollow victory. States must make education more affordable and ensure that students are enrolled in programs that prepare them for tomorrow's job market. Policymakers in Washington are focusing on these issues, but state lawmakers can also take action. They have the tools, and many are already leading the way. By focusing on affordability, transparency and measurable outcomes, state leaders can reshape higher education into a system that works better for students, families and taxpayers alike. The way we've historically approached higher education isn't getting enough Americans where they need to be, so let's build state postsecondary systems that deliver real value and help every student access an education that pays off. Jeb Bush was governor of Florida from 1999 to 2007. He is the founder and chair of ExcelinEd.
