Which? reveals best supermarket Magnum ice cream dupes
Of course, the top chocolate-covered ice cream brand in the UK is Magnum. However, you could make some savings by buying supermarket own-label ice creams instead - but how do they stack up against a Magnum Classic?
Consumer champions Which? tested nine supermarket own-label ice creams in a blind-tasting that involved 60 people, and found that while none of them trumped a classic Magnum, one supermarket did hold a candle to it.
A close runner-up came from a budget supermarket, giving ice cream fans more bang for their buck. In fact, two budget supermarket ice creams got higher ratings for flavour and value compared to posh supermarkets like Waitrose.
Jessica Carson, Which? Food and Health Editor, said: 'Cooling down with a delicious ice cream on a hot day is the stuff that summer holidays are made of, so having a box full in the freezer is bound to please - whether you are entertaining or if you've got kids.
'While the Classic Magnum wasn't beaten in our test, one supermarket brand matched it and a bargain alternative from Lidl wasn't far behind - and is less than half the price.'
The supermarket own-brand ice cream that matched Magnum's rating was none other than the M&S Chocolate Sticks. Both ice creams were rated at 82% and tasters said they loved the balance of chocolate and vanilla flavours, as well as the creamy texture of the ice cream within its chocolate shells.
Which? advised customers to look out for deals on the Classic Magnums, which cost £3.50 for a pack of three, making them the most expensive of the lot. However, they are frequently on some kind of deal, so it's best to keep an eye out for special offers to get the most value for money.
Classic Magnums are currently £2.75 for three for loyalty card holders at Tesco and Sainsbury's, according to the consumer website.
It can also be cheaper to buy Magnums in bigger multipacks of six, if you have the freezer space for them.
Here's how Which? rated the nine supermarket Magnum dupes.
M&S Chocolate Sticks
£2.40 for three 110ml ice creams (80p per stick)
These were the only supermarket own-brand ice creams that matched up to Magnums in the Which? taste test, with tasters loving the sweetness and strength of the chocolate flavour, as well as the vanilla flavour.
They are the most expensive own-label ice cream tested, but are still over a pound cheaper than full-price Magnums.
Lidl Gelatelli Classic Ice Cream Sticks
Rated at 79% for great value, Lidl's ice creams are cheap and cheerful. Tasters said they had 'just the right sweetness, creaminess and vanilla flavour'.
These ice creams are slightly bigger than Magnums (120ml vs 100ml) yet are less than half the price of Magnum Classics, so customers will be getting more bang for their buck.
Aldi Gianni's Milk Chocolate Ice Creams
£1.69 for four 100ml ice creams (42p per stick)
German budget supermarket Aldi offers the cheapest ice cream tested by Which? and received a decently high rating for flavour. It came in at a 77% rating.
While the flavour was good, tasters said they weren't creamy enough, but at just 42p per ice cream, they're a good budget-friendly alternative to Magnums.
Iceland Belgian Milk Chocolate Majestics
The frozen food specialists' ice cream treat rounds off the Which? top five list, scoring well at 77% for looking great and offering a satisfyingly creamy texture. However, nearly a third of tasters complained they were too sweet.
£2.25 for three 100ml ice creams (75p per ice cream)
Waitrose has a reputation for being posh and expensive, but their ice creams are 5p cheaper than M&S - however, nearly half of tasters thought the vanilla flavour was far too weak.
Morrisons Classic Milk Chocolate Amour Sticks
£2.25 for three 110ml ice creams (75p per ice cream)
Half of the tasters thought Morrison's Magnum dupes 'weren't bad', but they also were not creamy enough.
£2.10 for three 110ml ice creams (70p per ice cream)
Asda scored decently for sweetness and strength of chocolate flavour, but the vanilla ice cream within let it down by not being creamy enough.
Tesco Milk Chocolate Ice Creams
£1.39 for three 110ml ice creams (46p per ice cream)
Whilst this was among the cheapest ice creams that Which? tested, over half of the tasters thought the vanilla flavour was too weak.
Despite being more expensive than three of the top five ice creams, Co-op's Magnum dupes ranked the lowest because the ice cream wasn't creamy enough and the chocolate wasn't chocolatey enough. 'A bit of a letdown, but not terrible,' Which? said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
36 minutes ago
- BBC News
Oil and gas drilling licence surrendered at Dunsfold site
A licence to drill for oil and gas at a site in Surrey has reportedly been relinquished by UK Oil & Gas (UKOG).The firm had previously applied to explore the site in Dunsfold, with the application approved by the government, despite it twice being refused by the local Borough Council said the decision for UKOG to surrender its licence marked a "significant victory for the local community, environmental campaigners and the council".UKOG has been approached for comment. Local farmers previously argued that the disruption to traffic, businesses and the environment were not in proportion to potential the decision, councillor Steve Williams said it was a "momentous day for our community and our environment"."The decision by UKOG to surrender their licence is a testament to the tireless efforts of residents and campaigners who have stood firm in their opposition to this project," he said."It is a clear message that the protection of our natural heritage and the well-being of our residents must come first."Council leader Paul Follows added that the decision was "a step in the right direction" and reinforced the council's commitment to protecting the environment for future Sir Jeremy Hunt said drilling in Dunsfold was "always a ridiculous idea and would have ruined the area".He added: "This is wonderful news and totally the right decision."Meanwhile, UKOG previously said the project would benefit energy and economic firm said it would be able to extract gas from the Dunsfold site worth £123m, and that the project was in keeping with the government's Hydrogen, Energy Security and Net Zero strategies.
BBC News
36 minutes ago
- BBC News
Former Coventry Labour MP Geoffrey Robinson's spending probed
An investigation has been launched by a parliamentary watchdog into whether former Labour MP Geoffrey Robinson breached spending rules. The Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (Ipsa) probe would look at his spending for accommodation, office and staffing, it said. Mr Robinson, aged 87, served as MP for Coventry North West from 1976 until was paymaster general between 1997 and 1998 when Tony Blair was prime minister, but resigned after it was revealed he had made a secret interest-free loan to Peter Mandelson. The revelation also led Lord Mandelson to resign from his role as trade secretary at the Robinson stood down as an MP in 2019 saying he would not stand for re-election due to ill health. He also owned the New Statesman magazine from 1996 to 2008 and served as chairman of Jaguar and Coventry City FC. Follow BBC Coventry & Warwickshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Daily Mail
38 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Britons deliver a devastating verdict on Keir Starmer's first year in power... so what DO they think has been his biggest achievement?
Voters have answered with a resounding 'NOTHING' when asked what has been the biggest achievement of Keir Starmer 's first year in power, a new poll shows. More in Common asked voters to offer their one or two-word responses to Labour 's best and worst actions of the party's first 12 months in power to create a word cloud. And it was pretty brutal, with most people unable to thing of anything good. Only its work on the NHS made much of a dent in people's gloomy assessment. On the flipside, they were very clear in what has gone wrong. The Winter Fuel Allowance row was far and away the biggest cock-up in people's minds. It saw Sir Keir and Chancellor Rachel Reeves try to take away the £300 universal benefit away from all but the poorest recipients, before being forced into a U-turn. More in Common's director Luke Tryl said it was 'one of the most stark word clouds we've seen - the Winter Fuel Allowance drowns everything else out'. The other major problem to stand out for voters was immigration, with more than 20,000 people already having crossed the English Channel in small boats this year, a record. More in Common asked voters to offer their one or two-word responses to Labour's best and worst actions of the party's first 12 months in power to create a word cloud. And it was pretty brutal, with most people unable to thing of anything good. Sir Keir is facing Labour dissent, economic uncertainty and spiralling conflict abroad as he marks a year in Number 10. The Prime Minister led his party back into power with more than 400 MPs on July 4 last year – clinching a majority just short of Sir Tony Blair's landslide in 1997. But with a daunting in-tray of problems including a stuttering economy, creaking public services and global volatility, his political honeymoon period was short-lived. His personal popularity is now the lowest of any British premier after their first 12 months in office, political scientist and polling guru Professor Sir John Curtice said. 'There were pretty clear potential weaknesses before they even started, and most of those weaknesses have basically just been exposed over the course of the last 12 months.' Sir John said part of the problem lay in what he described as a failure of narrative in setting out the Government's vision for change to the public. 'They're portraying themselves as a repair gang rather than the builders of a new Jerusalem. Pessimism doesn't necessarily go down very well,' he said. 'The thing with Starmer is, he's a brilliant prosecution lawyer… But prosecution lawyers present cases that have been (put together) by someone else. The problem is that as a political leader you've got to prosecute your own case. 'Maybe he needs new personnel? Either he's got to learn to do it himself or get someone in to do it for him.' That verdict was echoed by some dissenting voices within Labour ranks, where there is lingering discontent among rebels over the Government's Welfare Bill despite Number 10 offering major concessions on the legislation. The Government saw off the threat of a major Commons defeat over the legislation on Tuesday after shelving plans to restrict eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip), the main disability benefit in England. 'I think he really needs to think about why he wants to be a Labour Prime Minister and what is it he actually cares about,' one long-serving Labour MP said. They said Tuesday had marked 'the lowest point' in Sir Keir's premiership so far and raised questions about his authority, warning that backbenchers may now feel emboldened to demand further U-turns elsewhere. Sir John said that the Government's challenges in passing legislation were unsurprising in light of the broad but fragile coalition of support on which Labour built its election victory, securing 412 seats on just 35% of the vote. That means many MPs defending narrow majorities and raises the prospect of 'a large body of people who are nervous about their political futures,' he said.
