Illegal immigrant killer of Laken Riley wins unexpected court victory for mental evaluation
Jose Ibarra was found guilty and sentenced to life in prison without parole for the death of Riley, a 22-year-old nursing student.
The judge who issued the sentence, Judge Patrick Haggard, on Thursday ordered that the Georgia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Disabilities (DBHDD) conduct a mental evaluation to determine his competency to stand trial and assist with post-conviction proceedings, meaning his appeal case.
In June, Ibarra's attorneys said they believe their client is "suffering from congenital deficiency which could render the client incapable of preparing a defense and standing trial," the New York Post reported.
They claimed that he "lacks the mental capacity to understand the nature and object and proceedings and counsel believes that this was in existence at the time of the offense and at the time of the trial."
"The mental competence of [Ibarra] has been called into question, and this court has found it appropriate for an evaluation to be conducted at the public expense," Haggard wrote in his order. He ordered the Georgia Department of Corrections to partner with DBHDD for the "prompt evaluation" at a GDC facility or a hospital.
In court documents, prosecutor Sheila Ross said there was no evidence during his trial that suggested Ibarra wasn't mentally competent. However, she didn't oppose Ibarra getting evaluated and left it up to Haggard to decide, the Post reported.
Ibarra, 27, an illegal immigrant from Venezuela, attacked and killed Riley as she was jogging along trails near Lake Herrick on the University of Georgia campus.
Prosecutors said Ibarra saw Riley running along popular trails on UGA's campus just after 9 a.m. and attacked her, dragged her 64 feet into a wooded area and beat her head with a rock repeatedly, killing her.
The case attracted national attention because of Ibarra's illegal status. He entered the United States illegally during the Biden administration through El Paso, Texas, in September 2022 and was released into the U.S. via parole.
He was arrested by the New York Police Department in August 2023 and was "charged with acting in a manner to injure a child less than 17 and a motor vehicle license violation" before making his way to Georgia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
25 minutes ago
- New York Times
Boy, 13, Started California Wildfire With Illegal Fireworks, Police Say
A 13-year-old boy was arrested this week, accused of setting off illegal fireworks that sparked a wildfire in Laguna Beach, Calif., that burned nearly five acres and led to evacuations and power outages, the authorities said. The blaze, called the Rancho fire, started just after 2 p.m. Monday, as flames burned along a hillside, the Laguna Beach Police Department said in a statement. As the fire spread to 4.6 acres, an evacuation order was issued for homes on four streets, and community centers were opened as shelters for displaced residents, officials said. By 5 p.m. Monday, the mayor had told residents in a video posted on Facebook that officials already suspected that the fire had been started by fireworks. The police said on Tuesday that witnesses had reported seeing a juvenile who was 'possibly involved in setting off fireworks.' Two juveniles were detained for questioning, but were released after they were found to have been witnesses, the police said. Investigators later obtained video evidence that they said showed another juvenile 'lighting a firework and fleeing the scene.' They identified the suspect as a 13-year-old boy and obtained a warrant for his arrest, the police said. The teenager was arrested on suspicion of felony reckless burning of forest land, the police said. Because of 'the absence of any injuries or immediate threat to structures,' he was processed at police headquarters before being released to his parents. The case will be submitted to the Orange County district attorney's office for review and the possible filing of criminal charges, the police said. A spokeswoman for the district attorney's office said California welfare law prevented her from discussing the case. Niko King, the Laguna Beach fire chief, said that around 200 firefighters, two planes, five helicopters and drones were deployed to battle the blaze, as officials used infrared scans to monitor its progress and containment efforts. The evacuation order was lifted just after 7:30 p.m. Tuesday, city officials. said. The fire was fully contained by 8 a.m. Wednesday and the roads that had been closed reopened to traffic.
Fox News
35 minutes ago
- Fox News
Notorious 'Hillside Strangler' seeks freedom after decades behind bars despite expert warnings
One of the notorious "Hillside Stranglers" was recently considered for potential parole in Washington state, with many asking how someone convicted of such heinous crimes could be considered for release. "When people hear that Kenneth Bianchi, one of the men known as the Hillside Stranglers, is up for parole again, it brings back fear and sadness for the families of the victims," retired FBI special agent Jason Pack tells Fox News Digital. "These families lost daughters, sisters, and friends in some of the most brutal and cold-hearted crimes this country has seen. For them, this hearing isn't just a legal step. It forces them to relive painful memories they've carried for decades." Anthony D'Amato, formerly known as Kenneth Bianchi, is one of the infamous "Hillside Stranglers," responsible for a series of murders involving women and girls during the late 1970s, including two killings in Washington. D'Amato and his cousin, Angelo Buono, were also convicted of murdering five individuals in Southern California. Buono passed away in a California prison in 2002. Acting alone, D'Amato also killed two women in the Bellingham area. Though suspected of additional killings, he was never convicted of those crimes. D'Amato then legally changed his name from Bianchi in 2023. "As a retired FBI agent who spent years working violent crime and studying the behavior of offenders like Bianchi, I can tell you that this kind of danger does not simply go away with age," Pack said. "His crimes were carefully planned. He picked out his victims, gained their trust, and then attacked and killed them. Even after his arrest, Bianchi worked hard to avoid responsibility. He faked mental illness, claimed to have multiple personalities, and tried to manipulate doctors and the justice system," Pack pointed out. Pack said the fact that D'Amato changed his name could be seen as another attempt to distance himself from his past and confuse the process. "Some people watching at home may wonder why he's even getting a parole hearing. The reason is simple: under the law, certain types of sentences require parole reviews at scheduled times. This does not mean he is likely to be released. The parole board will consider many things: how serious his crimes were, how he has behaved in prison, whether he has shown real remorse, and what risk he would pose if ever released," Pack explained. "In Bianchi's case, the pattern of lies, manipulation and lack of accountability should weigh heavily against him." Pack added that even though Bianchi is now 74 years old, "age does not erase the mindset that led him to kill." "The thinking, manipulation and risk factors that made him dangerous in the past remain present today. People like him can still manipulate others, even from behind bars," Pack said. Even if paroled in Washington, California has active murder charges pending, Pack explained, working to ease concerns for those who are worried about public safety if he is paroled. "It's important to know that even if Washington state were to grant him parole, which I think is unlikely, California has multiple life sentences waiting for him. He would not be released into the community. He would be immediately transferred to California to serve those sentences," Pack said. Realistically, Pack said Bianchi could remain incarcerated well into old age – likely until death. Despite disturbing headlines, parole does not guarantee release, Pack said, adding that Bianchi still faces serious legal roadblocks. "At the end of the day, the families of the victims deserve peace. The community deserves to feel safe. And the justice system has a responsibility to make sure a man who caused so much harm remains where he belongs – behind bars," Pack said. After committing a series of violent crimes, including the sexual assault and murder of women in the Los Angeles area, D'Amato was employed as a security guard in Bellingham in January 1979. During his time there, he persuaded two Western Washington University students, Karen Mandic and Diane Wilder, to accompany him to a residence, where he subsequently strangled them. These murders prompted law enforcement to link D'Amato to approximately 10 similar cases in California. To avoid a death sentence, D'Amato pleaded guilty in Washington and received two consecutive life sentences without parole. During his incarceration, D'Amato has made repeated legal attempts to overturn his Washington convictions, arguing, among other things, that his confession was obtained under hypnosis. He has consistently proclaimed his innocence. Pack said that during the time of Bianchi's conviction, California law allowed for periodic parole hearings, even for convicted murderers. That law remains applicable to those sentenced under it. D'Amato's parole requests have been denied on multiple occasions in recent years in both Washington state and California. D'Amato, now 74 and incarcerated at Washington State Penitentiary in Walla Walla, was originally scheduled for a parole hearing in May 2025, which was later delayed. The board is expected to publish its decision by July 23. Stepheny Price is a writer for Fox News Digital and Fox Business. She covers topics including missing persons, homicides, national crime cases, illegal immigration, and more. Story tips and ideas can be sent to
Fox News
43 minutes ago
- Fox News
Olympic gold medalist Mary Lou Retton in denial after failing field sobriety tests in DUI arrest, video shows
U.S. Olympic gold medalist Mary Lou Retton was seemingly in disbelief after police determined she failed a series of field sobriety tests during a DUI stop, as seen in newly released police body camera footage of her May 17 arrest in West Virginia, obtained by Fox News Digital. The footage showed a Fairmont County police officer running the women's gymnastics legend through a series of sobriety tests for more than seven minutes. She was seen detaching and re-attaching oxygen tubes from her nose in order to carry out the tests. Retton was diagnosed with a "rare form of pneumonia" in 2023. Officers then asked if she had a valid driver's license on her, to which she replied, "It's in Texas." After nearly 10 minutes of taking tests, one officer told another officer, "She failed all of it." Retton gasped in disbelief. "I what!?" she asked. "You failed all your field sobriety, ma'am," the first officer said. "No, I didn't!" she retorted. "Yes, you did," he insisted. The former gymnast was then seen declining to take a breathalyzer test, as police officers informed her she would be arrested on suspicion of DUI. As the officers put her in handcuffs, she yelled to a nearby acquaintance, "They think I'm drunk!" Footage later showed Retton being escorted to the police station. Upon her arrival there, she was seen telling an officer, "I mean, really.… I know, you know [who I am]." There, Retton was seen agreeing to have her blood alcohol level tested via a blood test. Retton's mugshot showed her in a somber mood, seemingly on the verge of tears. The former gymnastics star was charged with one count of driving under the influence of alcohol, controlled substances, or drugs on May 17, according to Marion County court records. She was released from jail after posting a personal recognizance bond of $1,500. In a statement previously provided to Fox News Digital by Retton's attorney, Edmund J. Rollo, the gold medalist admitted to driving under the influence and apologized. "I take full responsibility for my actions," the statement said. "What happened was completely unacceptable. I make no excuses. To my family, friends and my fans: I have let you down, and for that I am deeply sorry. "I am determined to learn and grow from this experience, and I am committed to making positive changes in my life. I truly appreciate your concern, encouragement and continued support." Retton also entered a no-contest plea, and a Marion County judge fined her $100, according to Rollo. "Mary Lou Retton appeared in court this afternoon and entered a no-contest plea to a non-aggravated DUI charge stemming from a recent incident," Rollo told Fox News Digital. "Mary Lou accepted full responsibility for her actions and received a standard $100 fine, consistent with sentencing guidelines for first-time, non-aggravated offenses in this jurisdiction. "In keeping with her values, Mary Lou made no request for special treatment and was subject to the same legal process as any other individual. She is grateful for the professionalism of law enforcement and the court system, and she fully respects the outcome. Mary Lou has expressed a sincere desire to use this experience as a moment for reflection and accountability. She asks for privacy as she moves forward with her personal and professional life." Retton was nicknamed "America's sweetheart" during her gold medal-winning performance at the 1984 Summer Games in Los Angeles. She was just 16 when she scored perfect 10s in the floor exercise and vault in the final two rotations to become the first American woman to win the Olympic all-around title. She earned five medals that year – one gold, two silver and two bronze. After she retired from gymnastics, Retton became a motivational speaker and frequently shared messages about the benefits of proper nutrition and exercise. She also served on the President's Council on Physical Fitness and Sports under former President George W. Bush. When Retton was diagnosed with a "rare form of pneumonia" in 2023, her family said at the time she was "fighting for her life." She was admitted to an intensive care unit as doctors helped her fight the illness. "This is serious, and this is life, and I'm so grateful to be here," she said on NBC's "Today" in 2024. "I am blessed to be here because there was a time when they were about to put me on life support." Follow Fox News Digital's sports coverage on X, and subscribe to the Fox News Sports Huddle newsletter.
