Musk's X must face claim of negligence over child abuse images, judge rules
While rejecting some claims, the ninth US circuit court of appeals in San Francisco said X, formerly Twitter, must face a claim it was negligent by failing to promptly report a video containing explicit images of two underage boys to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC).
The case predated Musk's 2022 purchase of Twitter. A trial judge had dismissed the case in December 2023. X's lawyers did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Musk was not a defendant.
One plaintiff, John Doe 1, said he was 13 when he and a friend, John Doe 2, were lured, on Snapchat, into providing nude photos of themselves to someone John Doe 1 thought was a 16-year-old girl at his school.
The Snapchat user was actually a child abuse images trafficker who blackmailed the plaintiffs into providing additional photos. Those images were later compiled into a video that was posted on Twitter.
According to court papers, Twitter took nine days after learning about the content to take it down and report it to NCMEC, following more than 167,000 views, court papers showed.
Circuit judge Danielle Forrest said section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act, which protects online platforms from liability over user content, did not shield X from the negligence claim once it learned about the images.
'The facts alleged here, coupled with the statutory 'actual knowledge' requirement, separates the duty to report child pornography to NCMEC from Twitter's role as a publisher,' she wrote for a three-judge panel.
X must also face a claim its infrastructure made it too difficult to report child abuse images.
It was found immune from claims it knowingly benefited from sex trafficking, and created search features that 'amplify' child abuse images posts.
Dani Pinter, a lawyer at the National Center on Sexual Exploitation, which represented the plaintiffs, said in a statement: 'We look forward to discovery and ultimately trial against X to get justice and accountability.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
5 minutes ago
- The Independent
Two snorkelers die, child injured during lobster miniseason in Miami
Two snorkelers died and a child was injured in separate incidents during Florida's two-day spiny lobster miniseason in the Keys, which has now ended. The miniseason, held on the last Wednesday and Thursday of July, attracts thousands eager to catch lobster before the regular season begins on August 6. On Wednesday, Clarence Shawver, 82, of Palm City, was found unresponsive about five miles off Grassy Key after going snorkeling around 10:45 a.m., according to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office. Shawver was later pronounced dead at Fisherman's Hospital in Marathon. The next day, around 8:30 a.m., Raymond Sasser, 61, of Loxahatchee, lost consciousness while snorkeling in the ocean. He was transported to Mariners Hospital in Tavernier, where he was pronounced dead. Authorities do not suspect foul play in either case. Both autopsy results are pending. Also on Thursday, around 11 a.m., a child suffered a leg injury from a boat propeller about five miles off Big Pine Key and was airlifted to Nicklaus Children's Hospital in Miami for treatment. 'Overall, the 2025 lobster mini season was typical for the Sheriff's Office,' the MSCO - Florida Keys said in a Facebook post Friday about the deaths and injury. 'Most people were in compliance and the number of vessel stops, notice-to-appear in court citations, and arrest figures were normal/typical compared to recent years.' Police made no arrests during the two-day lobster miniseason but issued approximately 16 mandatory-court-appearance citations and carried out 526 resource checks to ensure conservation law compliance.
The Guardian
6 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Police continue to search for Montana gunman who killed four people in a bar
Authorities continued to search Saturday afternoon for the man accused of killing four people at a Montana bar. Local, state and federal law enforcement were looking for 45-year-old Michael Paul Brown, a US army veteran who lived in a small town, Anaconda, next to The Owl Bar, where on Friday morning he allegedly opened fire and killed a bartender and three patrons. Officials located Brown's abandoned white truck according to Lee Johnson, Montana division of criminal investigation administrator. They concentrated their search in the mountains west of Anaconda, a town of less than 10,000 residents that was centered around a copper processing facility. 'This is a small, tight-knit community that has been harmed by the heinous actions of one individual who does not represent what this community or Montanans stand for,' Johnson said. On Friday night, nearby residents were encouraged to stay inside their homes and be on high alert as law enforcement believed Brown was armed and dangerous, Johnson said. But on Saturday afternoon, Bill Sather, the Anaconda-Deer Lodge police chief, told residents it was 'OK to go about your business in town' but to use caution and report anything suspicious to law enforcement. Authorities released a photo of Brown, who is 5ft 10in tall; weighs about 170lbs; and has blue eyes and brown hair, according to USA Today. The FBI and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives were assisting local and state police with the search, according to posts on X. As of Saturday afternoon, law enforcement had not released the names of the victims. Brown served in the US army as an armor crewman from 2001 to 2005 and was deployed to Iraq from early 2004 until March 2005, according to an army spokesperson. He was in the Montana national guard from 2006 to March 2009 and left military service in the rank of sergeant. 'This isn't just a drunk/high man going wild,' Brown's niece, Clare Boyle, wrote in a Facebook message to the Associated Press. 'It's a sick man who doesn't know who he is sometimes and frequently doesn't know where or when he is either.' Montana ranked second worst in the country in terms of prevalence of mental illness and access to care, according to the non-profit Mental Health America. Two-thirds of adults in Montana also lived in homes with guns, the highest rate in the country, according to a 2016 study from RAND, a thinktank. The owner of the Firefly Café in Anaconda told the Associated Press that she locked up her business after a friend alerted her to the shooting. 'We are Montana, so guns are not new to us,' Barbie Nelson said. 'For our town to be locked down, everybody's pretty rattled.' Associated Press contributed reporting
Daily Mail
36 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Billionaire fraudster Elizabeth Holmes seen enjoying facilities at Ghislaine Maxwell's cushy new prison
Blood tech fraudster Elizabeth Holmes was spotted enjoying some leisure time at the same cushy Texas prison Ghislaine Maxwell has just been moved to. The disgraced Theranos founder became jail mates with Maxwell at Federal Prison Camp Bryan after the notorious madam was moved to the facility Thursday. Barring a longshot pardon from President Donald Trump, Maxwell will spend about seven years incarcerated at the same time as Holmes, who is scheduled to be released on April 3, 2032. Maxwell, who was convicted in June 2022 recruiting underage girls into Jeffrey Epstein 's sex trafficking ring, had been serving her sentence at a more restrictive prison in Florida. But she was moved after complaining to authorities that she was fed up of listening to transgender prisoners having loud sex. On Saturday, Holmes was seen taking a leisurely jog in a grassy area of the minimum security Texas prison. She was wearing a gray T-shirt and matching gray shorts with black sneakers. She also appeared to be wearing a watch. She was notably without fellow high profile inmate Jen Shah, the former Real Housewife of Salt Lake City who is also incarcerated at the facility. Shah pleaded guilty to fraud charges related to a telemarketing scheme she ran targeting the elderly. Photos have also shown Holmes and Shah running at the same time while engaging in cozy chats. Maxwell, who herself has been pictured running at her Florida prison, will likely soon run into both women. Camp Bryan is an all-female prison, unlike the Tallahassee prison, which housed men and women. The camp is also a much more comfortable prison that holds primarily white-collar criminals and not people convicted of violent crimes. Maxwell's sudden removal to Texas from a low-security prison in Tallahassee outraged Epstein's victims and their families. 'This is the justice system failing victims right before our eyes,' said sisters Annie and Maria Farmer and members of Virginia Giuffre's family in a statement obtained by Daily Mail. 'Ghislaine Maxwell is a sexual predator who physically assaulted minor children on multiple occasions, and she should never be shown any leniency. 'Yet, without any notification to the Maxwell victims, the government overnight has moved Maxwell to a minimum security luxury prison in Texas.' Prison consultant Justin Paperny told Daily Mail he had never seen anyone convicted of a sex offense serve time in a minimum security prison such as Camp Bryan. 'She was in a low security prison, that looks like prisons on TV or in the movies. You're fenced in, razor wire, women serving typically 10 years or longer, more violent crime, sexual offenses,' Paperny said. Paperny runs White Collar Advice, which advises future inmates on what to expect inside. 'She will feel incredibly free. There is a very low staff to prisoner ratio and camps like Bryan, no fences or barbed wire,' he said. 'You can literally walk off and nobody will stop you. It's a cushy country club and looks like a corporate office park or a junior college.' Maxwell will also be able to purchase beauty and leisure items from the commissary, including make-up and crochet and sewing kits. There is even a softball field and pickleball courts at the facility. It is undoubtedly a huge upgrade for Maxwell, who was previously dealing with transgender prisoners having loud sex out in the open, a source told Daily Mail. The source also said Maxwell was bitter and frequently complained about the conditions at the Tallahassee prison. 'There was inadequate food. Ghislaine is a vegetarian and each prisoner is supposed to get 8oz of protein a day, but she was getting 2oz or less. The food was moldy. Everyone, not just Ghislaine, complained about the food,' the source said. Maxwell's lawyer David Oscar Markus confirmed to Daily Mail that she was moved from the Tallahassee prison on Thursday. The Bureau of Prisons confirmed the transfer on Friday. Neither Markus or the BOP have offered any reason for why Maxwell was moved. This comes the Trump administration struggles to contain the fallout of its decision not to release the unredacted Epstein files. Maxwell has promised to testify about what she knows about the Epstein case in exchange for immunity or a presidential pardon. House leaders have roundly rejected giving her immunity, while people close to Trump have insisted a pardon is not in the works.
