
Questions over why Bo'ness centre 'serious' failings report not acted on
A 'lack of urgency' and 'a lack of documented communication' were just two of many issues identified by auditors looking at why a 2019 report into "serious structural failings" in a swimming pool was not acted on by Falkirk Council.
An internal Falkirk Council investigation that followed the closure of Bo'ness Recreation Centre has concluded that "many areas remain unanswered", as many of those involved are no longer with the council.
The recreation centre closed earlier than had been agreed last May after corrosion was identified in the concrete walls of the swimming pool.
But council chiefs were disturbed to find that serious structural failings of a very similar nature appeared to have been highlighted previously in a report written in 2019.
The 2019 report, written by the council's structural engineer, stated: 'In view of the hazard to the public and the increased risk caused by the weakened corner of the structure, it is my opinion that the swimming pool should be closed and drained as soon as possible.
'Monitoring the cracks and damage would not be appropriate in these circumstances. A specialist contractor should be appointed to repair the swimming pool. The will involve replacing all defective concrete and reinforcement at the South East corner of the pool as soon as possible.'
However, while the proposal was made to close Bo'ness Recreation Centre as part of Falkirk Council's strategic property review, that report was not part of any considerations.
One of the new officers involved in the closure came across the report by chance and brought it to the council's attention.
An internal audit report ordered by Director of Place, Malcolm Bennie, aimed to find out why the work had not been carried out and how the report had eventually been completely overlooked.
But auditors found that many of the people who made the decisions at the time - when the building was managed by Falkirk Community Trust - no longer work for the council and it has been difficult to get answers.
An executive summary of the "fact-finding exercise" is being presented to members of Falkirk Council's Audit committee next Tuesday, as an appendix to the Internal Audit Progress Report.
From several interviews and reviewing the evidence received, the latest report says that "contributing factors towards the failings identified can be summarised as follows:
• There was no-one within the council who actively followed up the actions of the original 2019 report. • There was a lack of urgency to undertake the repairs (could be in part due to Trust management stating to staff the pool was safe to use). • There was a shortage of health and safety / Facilities Team inspections on the fabric of the building. • A lack of documented communication between the Trust and the Council around repair requirements and seeking additional quotes. • The tenders requested did not follow proper procurement guidance. • Tenders, reports, and details of repairs were not centrally stored to monitor progress, resulting in no follow ups on work undertaken. • No decision process documented throughout to support any actions taken.
The 2019 report - which identified the structural issues with the pool tank - was commissioned by Falkirk Community Trust, following "the discovery of water pooling in a publicly accessible corridor floor, as well as walls which were damp to the touch."
The audit summary states: "We found no evidence to confirm that the hard copy of the original '2019 report' (which reflected the urgency required) had been cascaded to relevant officers, for example, the Trust's General Manager and the Sports and Recreation Manager, although there was dialogue documented in monthly SLA meetings between all the relevant parties that suggested they knew of its existence."
Discussions between the Trust and the Council about what could be done and how to repair the pool structure resulted "in several conflicting tenders from four different companies".
One was for repairing the deteriorating concrete, another for regrouting the pool.
The audit report notes: "There was, however, a lack of consistency in the responses from each of the four companies about what repair was appropriate.
"There was also very little evidence to support the final decision and course of action to regrout the pool.
"This gathering of different tenders and the related decision making resulted in delays in achieving the final repair of regrouting the pool."
But the auditors also note that after several interviews and reviewing all the documentation available "there are many areas that remain unanswered" - partly due to the difficulty in interviewing some former employees.
They say there is:
• No evidence of the distribution of the hard copy of the original 2019 report to members of the Trust. • No evidence of why a 'second opinion' on action to be taken was required. • Unclear why the opinion was that the pool was safe in 2019, and the decision was to drop water levels prior to any work being undertaken. • No evidence of agreement with the council's facilities team for the work required to be included in the second opinion quotes.
The report says it is also unclear why the Trust took the lead for the repair work when issues with structural integrity were the responsibility of the Council and there is "no evidence of what was actually quoted for".
There is also: • No evidence why the planned regrouting work was not completed after the Covid-19 lockdown. • No evidence why the five year repair plan didn't pick up the work still to be done earlier. • Unable to determine why the SPR condition survey did not initially pick up an issue with the pool tank.
The issue was raised at a meeting of Falkirk Council in March 2024 by Councillor Brian McCabe who wrote to Audit Scotland demanding an investigation.
At the time, councillors were advised to wait for the outcome of the internal audit investigation.
Falkirk Council's audit committee meets on Tuesday, April 29 at 10 am in Grangemouth Community Education Unit, Abbots Road, Grangemouth.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Trust to remove unsafe Attenborough Nature Reserve bridge
A wildlife trust is preparing to remove an unsafe footbridge at a nature reserve ahead of a replacement being Works Bridge at Attenborough Nature Reserve, near Beeston in Nottinghamshire, closed to the public in April 2023 after a safety Wildlife Trust said it would soon submit plans for a replacement to Broxtowe Borough Council, with the entire project expected to cost £375,000. Work is under way to create an access route needed to remove the old bridge and install its replacement, pending approval. In March, the trust said flooding and the discovery of high voltage cables close to the planned route had delayed its bid for planning an update in July, the trust said an application would soon be submitted to Broxtowe Borough Council, and that feedback from the planning authority had been "positive and constructive".It added the bridge's technical design work was also under way. The Works Bridge - which forms part of an existing bridleway - was closed before the trust purchased the reserve in was reopened as a footpath only, as it could not be repaired to a standard required for a bridleway. But in 2023 another safety inspection of the bridge identified it was no longer safe for anybody to use, and it was closed once more. Erin McDaid, head of communications at the trust, previously said the "contentious" closure had "been a real source of frustration".


BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Rare bee 'beach' habitat in Walsall supported by sand donation
About 10 tonnes of sand have been donated to support ongoing work to create "bee beaches" in a Black Country nature conservation effort is being carried out at Pelsall North Common in Walsall, with the sand being used to create a further two beaches in the is part of the Purple Horizons Nature Recovery Project, led by Natural England. The work involves using diggers to remove vegetation and create bare ground areas - known as 'bee beaches' - which are crucial habitats for many threatened project, now in its second year, has created bee-friendly habitats across seven sites in the region. These are Shire Oak Park, Barr Beacon, Pelsall North Common, Chasewater Country Park, Brownhills Common, Wharf Lane and Muckley sand used to create the newest two bee beaches was collected as part of ongoing work at Tamworth Road Narrows carried out by the Lichfield & Hatherton Canals Restoration Lord from the trust said they were proud to support "such an important conservation initiative" by repurposing excess sand excavated from the Lichfield Canal channel. "Creating sustainable habitats and enhancing biodiversity is one of our core aims," he said. "While our focus is obviously along the blue-green corridor of the Lichfield Canal it's a real bonus to be able to extend that impact to another location."Walsall councillor Gary Fling said: "This project continues to go from strength to strength and Walsall is proud to be playing its part in preserving and restoring these habitats." Bees spotted Purple Horizons is being delivered by a partnership between Walsall Council, Staffordshire County Council, Lichfield District Council, Natural England, University of Birmingham researchers, and the Birmingham and Black Country Wildlife around 80% of heathlands have been lost since 1800 and globally the habitat is rarer than a tropical year, two "near-threatened" species of bees were spotted thriving at Barr Beacon local nature reserve in Walsall thanks to the discovery of the Cats Ear Mining Bee (Andrena humilis) and the Cats Ear Nomad Bee (Nomada integra) was made by Aaron Bhambra, a researcher at the University of Birmingham. Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.


BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Charity appeal to save prehistoric ritual site in Cornwall
Cornwall Heritage Trust has launched a fundraising appeal to rescue and secure the future of a "unique prehistoric ritual site".The charity said it hoped to raise £50,000 towards the acquisition of Castilly Henge, just off the A30 near Henge is a substantial oval earthwork, with an external bank and internal ditch, which the trust said would have formed an amphitheatre-like settings for gatherings and ritual trust said the scheduled monument, described as "Cornwall's ancient sacred heart", was currently at risk due to the threat posed by "invasive vegetation". It said modern development of the nearby road infrastructure and local service network, which lie within meters of the site, also posed potential charity also said the henge was currently inaccessible to the CEO Cathy Woolcock said: "The henge has been at risk for some time – a threat which urgently needs to be addressed before this special place and the secrets it holds are potentially lost."She said the charity had been protecting historic landscapes and monuments across Cornwall for the last 40 years."We have a strong track record of giving these special places the archaeological and land management expertise they need and have helped save a number from the Heritage at Risk Register," she said."We hope to be able to do the same for Castilly Henge." The trust said recent surveys undertaken by Historic England's Archaeological Investigation Team discovered traces of a now-removed possible stone circle in the middle of the henge. "Not all henges contain stone circles, and there is only one other known to survive in Cornwall," it added."A four-week archaeological excavation is set to take place at the monument in September and October 2025 to target important questions about these findings to understand more about the monument's character, date and potential later reuse."