Dream Teammate? Worst Organization? It's Our Anonymous MLB All-Star Poll!
We anonymously polled 20 of the game's best players at All-Star Weekend on these topics, and more. Here's what they had to say: Automated Ball-Strike System: For or Against?
Winner: For
Just don't call it "robo-umps." The ABS technology has been used in the minors to challenge certain calls on balls and strikes. It was actually used in this year's All-Star Game. But how what in regular season games?
"I don't want full ABS. Being able to go down and pitch in Triple-A and rehab and other things, I've gotten experience with it. So, I think there is a use to it, but I don't want to take the human element out of the game. I don't want umpires to be completely out of it." — NL All-Star pitcher
"I'm for the challenge system. I think having umpires and then the human element, they've got the hardest job on earth, man. They're trying to dictate pitches coming in at 100 mph on the corners, trying to determine is this ball truly on the plate or not? I don't envy their job at all. But I do think there is a human element, and if they miss one, having a team have the opportunity to say, 'Hey, can we take a look at that? I don't think that's the worst thing, either." — AL pitcher
"I don't want to get rid of the umpire, but having some checks and balances would be cool." — AL All-Star pitcher Best Atmosphere?
Winner: New York Yankees
Opened in 2009 next to the original "House That Ruth Built," Yankee Stadium is certainly one of the great cathedrals in sports. Some of the other iconic parks got multiple votes, but there is something about playing in the Bronx that appeals: Vote Count New York Yankees (Yankee Stadium) 5 Los Angeles Dodgers (Dodger Stadium) 4 Philadelphia Phillies (Citizens Bank Park) 4 Chicago Cubs (Wrigley Field) 3 Boston Red Sox (Fenway Park) 3 San Diego Padres (Petco Park) 2 Houston Astros (Daikin Park) 2 New York Mets (Citi Field) 1 Toronto Blue Jays (Rogers Centre) 1 Most Surprising Team?
Winner: Detroit Tigers
With a whopping six All-Stars this season and running away with the AL Central, don't sleep on these Tigers. Led by back-to-back Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal, this team has put MLB on notice.
"The level that they've been at, the consistency they've shown, is very impressive." — NL All-Star
"I knew Detroit was good, but they've really impressed me with the way they've dominated." — NL All-Star
"What they've been able to do this year, they have like six All-Stars or something like that. Consistently, what they've been able to do is surprising." — AL All-Star
Also received multiple votes:
Milwaukee Brewers: "Whether they started hot or not, they finished really hot. So, good for them." — AL All-Star pitcher
Boston Red Sox: "Plenty of talent, but just kind of the start they got off to." — AL All-Star
Received one vote:
Toronto Blue Jays: "What they've done this last month has been impressive." — AL All-Star pitcher
Arizona Diamondbacks: "I thought they'd be better." — AL All-Star Vote Count Detroit Tigers 7 Milwaukee Brewers 3 Miami Marlins 2 Boston Red Sox 2 Toronto Blue Jays 1 Houston Astros 1 Tampa Bay Rays 1 Los Angeles Angels 1 Arizona Diamondbacks 1 Atlanta Braves 1 Chicago Cubs 1 Most Underrated Player?
Winner: José Ramírez, Cleveland Guardians
The Guardians slugger feels like a deserving winner in this category although it's surprising the defending AL MVP, who just eclipsed 350 career home runs, also getting a vote here.
"Yes, [Ramírez] is a superstar. But I just don't feel like he gets covered the way that the other top five or six players in the league do." — AL All-Star
Also received votes:
Aaron Judge, New York Yankees: "I just think people put other players in his league, and it's not right. Sometimes it's like, 'Who's the best hitter? Aaron or this guy?' And it's not even a discussion. There's no close second. I think the fact that people put hitters in the same conversation as him, offensively, makes him underrated. You can look at the numbers the last 6-8 years and it's not really close between anybody else." — AL All-Star
Zach Neto, Los Angeles Angels: "With the years that he's put up and the performances he keeps putting up, I think he definitely deserves more attention than he's getting." — AL All-Star
Framber Valdez, Houston Astros: "Quality start after quality start from that dude. He's a groundball pitcher. And he goes deep into games." — AL All-Star Vote Count José Ramírez, Cleveland Guardians 3 Juan Soto 1 Steven Kwan, Cleveland Guardians 1 Jonathan Aranda, Tampa Bay Rays 1 Joe Ryan, Minnesota Twins 1 Luke Raley, Seattle Mariners 1 Zach Neto, Los Angeles Angels 1 Otto Lopez, Miami Marlins 1 Luis Severino, Athletics 1 Framber Valdez, Houston Astros 1 Aaron Judge, New York Yankees 1 Player You'd Most Want to be Teammates With:
Winner: Aaron Judge, New York Yankees
The Yankees superstar runs away in this category. Who wouldn't want to play alongside a two-time MVP?
Also received votes:
Paul Skenes, Pittsburgh Pirates: "I'm just really impressed with who he is. Not many people had the accelerated path that he did with all the attention that he has had. I would really like going and playing behind that guy." — NL All-Star Vote Count Aaron Judge, New York Yankees 8 Shohei Ohtani, Los Angeles Dodgers 2 Clayton Kershaw, Los Angeles Dodgers 1 Kyle Schwarber, Philadelphia Phillies 1 Tarik Skubal, Detroit Tigers 1 Mickey Moniak 1 Mike Trout 1 Bobby Witt Jr. 1 Paul Skenes 1 Organization You'd Most Want to Play For:
Winner: Boston Red Sox
From the aura at Fenway Park to the four World Series this century, a fair amount of All-Stars have a roving eye for that Green Monster. Vote Count Boston Red Sox 4 Atlanta Braves 3 San Francisco Giants 3 Los Angeles Dodgers 1 Texas Rangers 1 Tampa Bay Rays 1 Pittsburgh Pirates 1 Philadelphia Phillies 1 New York Yankees 2 San Diego Padres 2 Organization You'd Least Want to Play For:
Winner: Chicago White Sox
Or shall we say, "loser" here? Even with super-fan Pope Leo XIV presiding over the Vatican, there seems to be little appeal to take up residence one Southside. As one player polled said: Vote Count Chicago White Sox 4 New York Yankees 1 Philadelphia Phillies 1 Cleveland Guardians 1 Miami Marlins 1 Any California team 1
Rowan Kavner is an MLB writer for FOX Sports. He previously covered the L.A. Dodgers, LA Clippers and Dallas Cowboys. An LSU grad, Rowan was born in California, grew up in Texas, then moved back to the West Coast in 2014. Follow him on Twitter at @RowanKavner .
Deesha Thosar is an MLB writer for FOX Sports. She previously covered the Mets as a beat reporter for the New York Daily News. The daughter of Indian immigrants, Deesha grew up on Long Island and now lives in Queens. Follow her on Twitter at @DeeshaThosar .
recommended
Item 1 of 1 Get more from the Major League Baseball Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
4 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
Big Dumper's big year: Cal Raleigh's ‘staggering' season leads an offensive surge by MLB catchers
Seattle's Cal Raleigh — better known by the catchy nickname 'Big Dumper' — has lived up to the moniker, dropping baseball into the outfield seats all over the big leagues this season. Manager Dan Wilson has been in awe of his talents. 'That's what you get from Cal,' Wilson said. 'Night in, night out, blocking balls, calling the game, leading a pitching staff, throwing runners out — that's what Cal does and he does it very well.' Oh … wait a second. Wilson obviously wasn't taking about Raleigh's prodigious power — he's talking about how the 28-year-old handles the most demanding defensive position on the baseball field: Catcher. Raleigh has smashed 42 homers this season, putting him on pace for 60, with a chance to catch Aaron Judge's American League record of 62. That would be fun to watch under any circumstance. The fact that the All-Star and Home Run Derby champion is also responsible for guiding the Mariners' pitching staff on most nights makes it even more impressive. Seattle is currently in the thick of the American League playoff race with a 60-53 record, and the Mariners are relying on Raleigh's bat and his brain to try and make the playoffs for just the third time since 2001. There's the mental side of the job — meetings, film study, calling pitches — but there's also the wear and tear of the physical side. The 2024 Gold Glove winner is also squatting, handling the run game, taking painful foul tips off all parts of his body, putting his 6-foot-2, 235-pound frame through the ringer four or five nights a week. All while hitting those homers. The fact that it took Raleigh a few years in the big leagues to emerge as a true superstar — this is his fourth full season with the Mariners — isn't surprising. The learning curve for young catchers can be severe and the defensive part of the job takes precedence. There's a long list of backstops who couldn't hit a lick yet carved out long MLB careers. Raleigh is a man of many talents and his power was always evident. He hit 27 homers in 2022, 30 in 2023 and 34 last season. Now he's on pace for 50 long balls and maybe more. There are only five other players in big league history who have hit at least 40 homers while primarily playing catcher: Salvador Perez, Johnny Bench (twice), Roy Campanella, Todd Hundley and Mike Piazza (twice). Bench, Campanella and Piazza are Hall of Famers. It's evidence of a player at the top of his game — and one who has come through plenty of experience. 'I don't think I'm trying any harder or doing any more than I have in the past,' Raleigh said. 'Maybe a little more focused on the right things, and not constantly trying to tweak or change something that I have been in the past. So, I think that's been the biggest part to the success, and just trying to keep that consistent and steady.' Wilson was more direct, putting into perspective what Raleigh has accomplished through the first four months of the season. 'It's pretty staggering,' Wilson said. Kyle Teel helps Chicago White Sox to 7-2 win in his MLB debut: 'I dreamed about this moment'Raleigh's big numbers are part of an offensive surge for MLB catchers: Will Smith, Hunter Goodman, Logan O'Hoppe, Shea Langeliers, Alejandro Kirk, Salvador Perez and William Contreras are among roughly a dozen at the position who are more than holding their own at the plate. Veteran catcher Carson Kelly is on pace to have his best offensive season in the big leagues at 31, batting .272 with 13 homers and 36 RBIs for the Chicago Cubs. He's been in the big leagues for 10 years and said the balance between offense and defense is tough for young players. 'It's almost like you're drinking from a firehose with how much information you have,' Kelly said. 'And I think, as you see catchers, as the years go on, you get smarter. 'You get smarter in your routines. and you're able to focus on the little details,' he continued. 'When you get called up as a young guy, there's so much going on. And as the years go by and as the days go by, you get more comfortable. 'OK, I know this, I know that, how do I really funnel this down into a couple points?' 'I think that's, you know, when you see catchers kind of take off.' One major factor for the increased offensive production for catchers could be the one-knee down defensive stance that's been adopted by nearly every MLB catcher over the past five years. The argument for the stance is its helpful for defensive reasons, including framing pitches on the corners. But there's also the added benefit that it's a little easier on the knees than squatting a couple hundred times per game. 'A hundred percent,' said Goodman, the Rockies primary catcher who is hitting .279 with 20 homers. 'You think about back in the day when everybody was squatting … being in a squat for that long can be can be hard on your legs. Getting on a knee gives your legs a little bit of rest for sure.' Statistical trends suggest he has a point. Catchers have accounted for 12.2% of all MLB homers this season, making a slow climb from 10% in 2018. Raleigh's been the best of the bunch and fans — along with his catching peers — are noticing. 'It just seems like on both sides of the ball, when he's behind the plate he's really focused on his pitchers and calling a good game and all the things that a catching position entails, and then when he comes up to the plate, he can do damage,' Kelly said.
Chicago Tribune
4 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
For artist Dave Shetsky, a family theme runs through his drawings of Chicago sports icons
If you need a crash course on Chicago sports, Dave Shetsky's art is the place to go. He recaptures various eras using only colored pencils. Upon entering his studio, you're met with framed depictions of local icons. To begin a recent studio tour, he presented two drawings of Derrick Rose: one from his MVP 2010-11 season with the Chicago Bulls and the other from Rose's final season in 2023-24 with the Memphis Grizzlies. You know what happened in between. The first picture shows Rose staring blankly ahead, mentally preparing for a game. The Bulls of that era had high hopes of returning to the prestige of the franchise's championship years, adding weight on Rose's shoulders. Shetsky said he enjoys drawing franchise players such as Rose because he feels 'sorry that they get hassled' by fans. 'You can't get more pressure,' Shetsky said. 'I always liked him because he's humble and soft-spoken. He's not a social animal. Just leave him alone.' Rose wrote in the 2019 book 'I'll Show You' that he felt betrayed by Chicago media in his final seasons with the Bulls and wished he had his 'own reporter' to go to when the narrative spiraled out of control, like he felt Michael Jordan had. '(After) that injury, reporters were questioning his bravery and if he could come back,' Shetsky said. 'When you have an injury and people are there every day, it gets on your nerves.' Shetsky drew a picture of Rose's mother, Brenda, and sent it to him in 2011. Rose told Shetsky he still has the portrait. 'I'm inspired by their character strengths, abilities and being Chicago,' Shetsky said. 'They get lambasted in the press, so I want to make them know that there's fans out there that aren't ripping on them.' The second drawing shows Rose in an entirely new light. 'Here, he's very happy,' Shetsky said, raising the smiling Grizzlies picture. Shetsky then walked to the corner of his studio, where portraits of Mike Ditka shined in the light. He showed a drawing of a young Ditka presenting a college All-America award to his mother, Charlotte. 'Who's that? That's Da Coach,' he said with a big smile. Ditka was instrumental in the launch of Shetsky's career. He saw Ditka in a restaurant one day in 2006 'holding court with a bunch of people.' He needed encouragement from his wife, Marsha, to present the portrait to the coach. 'I was scared his hands would envelop me,' Shetsky said. Ditka's serious demeanor earned him the 'Iron Mike' moniker, and smiles were a foreign concept. That's what Shetsky loves about him. 'Man, he's real,' Shetsky said. 'If he don't like you, you'll know in three seconds.' But beyond the gridiron, he was a family man. While Ditka's father worked, Charlotte raised their four children, strengthening Ditka's bond with his mother. Finally, Shetsky presented the picture. 'I just stuck it in front of him,' he said. 'They said he almost cried.' Ditka bought the portraits Shetsky made of him from that point on. He hasn't seen the coach in 'several years,' but the influence remains. Shetsky found a new purpose in his art. 'I can tell by reading eyes,' he said. 'My wife noticed that about me; that's one of the reasons I do it. He was extremely close to his mom, so that brought a reaction out of him.' Other portraits stood in the studio closet, hiding in plain sight. Kris Bryant with his wife after the 2016 World Series. A rookie Jimmy Butler with his adopted mother, Michele Lambert. Doug Buffone's children. In the back right corner lay a fresh portrait of Shetsky's grandson. The baby is wearing Cubs gear, likely an early influence from Granddad. (As for the chances of the Cubs fan creating any White Sox art, Shetsky said they're 'nonexistent.') A theme runs through Shetsky's art: family. 'They gave up a lot of their lives for them,' Shetsky said. 'I did one of Dan Marino and his dad (because) he sacrificed his whole life for him. 'What I major in, it's got to feel good for them to receive it. I would say I do it because it makes them feel good.' He describes his art in two words: strong and sweet. He admires the courage of the athletes he draws and their strength to endure pain, physically and mentally. 'When people look at art, they say it's strong realism,' Shetsky said. 'Art is a thousand different things, but if people say he looks real, that's strong in art. 'I'm not sweet, (so) I do little things to make them look their best. A lot of it is my love of being a fan. What I do is close to being a movie of their life. It's not just a moment.' The final stop of the tour was where Shetsky showed the rest of his work. The art sat under a large drawing of Jonathan Toews carrying the Stanley Cup after the Blackhawks' 2013 championship. The centerpiece is his drawing of Montreal Canadiens legend Guy Lafleur that was displayed in the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2020. Before exiting the studio, he got one final question: Who would be on a Dave Shetsky portrait? Faster than he first picked up the pencils, with that Ditka demeanor, he pointed toward his wife.
Chicago Tribune
4 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
3 takeaways from the 1st leg of the Chicago White Sox's West Coast trip, including the continued power surge
ANAHEIM, Calif. — The Chicago White Sox arrived at Angel Stadium on Friday needing two wins to surpass their 2024 total of 41 victories. They quickly checked that off the list, taking the first two games of the series against the Los Angeles Angels. A chance for a sweep slipped away on Sunday when the Angels climbed out of a five-run hole and beat the Sox 8-5 on a walk-off three-run home run by Taylor Ward. While Sunday was a gut punch for the Sox, there were still plenty of signs over the weekend of the strides the team has made and how they've put last year in the rearview mirror. 'No one had mentioned that we had surpassed (last year's total), which I think speaks to the fact that we've all moved on and the people who were here last year have moved on,' first-year Sox manager Will Venable said before Sunday's game. 'It's just not a thing anymore. 'Certainly positive as far as the progress of the organization from last year to this year. But we've got more games to play and more wins to try to get. We're excited to do that.' The Sox were off Monday. They'll start the second half of the six-game trip on Tuesday in Seattle. Here are three takeaways from the first leg of the journey after the three games against the Angels. The Sox were clinging to a one-run lead Friday when Colson Montgomery came up with no runners on and two outs in the sixth inning. He clobbered a first-pitch sinker from Angels starter Tyler Anderson for a mammoth 433-foot home run to center field. The shortstop provided instant offense again in the first inning on Sunday, following an RBI single by Luis Robert Jr. with a three-run home run. The Sox have produced staggering power numbers in the second half. They are tied for the major-league lead with 28 home runs following the All-Star Break after ranking 28th in the first half with 76. The Sox hit four solo home runs in Friday's 6-3 victory. Andrew Benintendi and Lenyn Sosa homered in the second inning, Montgomery's came in the sixth and Josh Rojas capped the night with a home run in the ninth. It was the second straight four-homer performance for the Sox, who had home runs by Kyle Teel, Montgomery, Miguel Vargas and Edgar Quero on Wednesday against the Philadelphia Phillies at Rate Field. 'Guys are being aggressive and going in there with a good game plan,' Rojas said after Friday's game. 'The biggest thing I've been seeing is guys are sticking to the plan. Take the borderline pitches, the called strikes you don't want, stay in your spot and be aggressive there.' Montgomery, in particular, has been on a tear. All seven of his home runs have come since the All-Star break. 'He's been outstanding, continues to take really good swings,' Venables said after Sunday's game. Aaron Civale surrendered an infield hit and a walk to begin the fourth inning Saturday. He said his mindset during the jam was, 'Just not to change.' Civale struck out Ward looking. Jo Adell lined out to Montgomery at shortstop. And former Sox Yoán Moncada struck out swinging. 'They're competitive at-bats leading up to that point,' Civale said. 'Just continue to attack and continue to stay with what we were doing and make adjustments as we see. 'You can think about hitters' aggressiveness with runners in scoring position. So trying to use that to your advantage a little bit. At the end of the day, you're trying to read what they're doing and make the best pitch based on that.' Civale kept making his best pitch throughout the outing. He teamed up with relievers Brandon Eisert and Jordan Leasure for a one-hitter in a 1-0 win. Civale allowed the one hit, struck out eight and walked two in 6 1/3 innings. It was the first one-hitter for the Sox since May 19, 2023, against Kansas City and their first 1-0 victory at Angel Stadium since Sept. 22, 1993. Civale has pitched 17 consecutive innings without allowing an earned run over his last three starts, lowering his ERA from 5.30 to 3.56. 'This game is momentum-based, just working on a lot of things in between,' Civale said. 'It's nice to see some things clicking on the field. 'The results are the results, it's something you can't really control. It's nice to have them, but at the end of the day the most important thing is covering innings and giving the team the chance to win.' The Sox learned just before Saturday's game that Vargas would be unavailable after suffering a left oblique strain. The third baseman/first baseman went on the 10-day injured list (retroactive to Saturday) on Sunday. 'For an oblique, we're not expecting it to be as long as some of the other ones,' Venable said Sunday morning. 'But it's still an oblique, it's still sensitive. We want to make sure we take care of it and progress him slowly.' The Sox had to navigate the final two games of the series without Vargas. Second baseman/shortstop Chase Meidroth didn't start in any of the three games (he made an appearance as a defensive replacement late Sunday) as he recovered after getting hit by a pitch on the right thumb on Wednesday against the Phillies. Still, the club won its fourth series since coming back from the break. 'I hope we get out of here feeling good about the fact we played a good series against a good team, and specifically for our pitching staff,' Venable said on Sunday. 'They did a really nice job. Especially (Saturday). 'We've just got to keep going. That's what we do, we've done it all year. Tough loss (Sunday), that's part of the game.'
