‘Youth-cession' sees young Canadians struggling most, poll data shows
Combined with consistent signs of a weakening youth labour market, some experts say young Canadians may be in an economic recession of their own.
'It's hard to argue that (Canadian) youth are not in some kind of 'youth-cession,' given what is happening to the jobs that are most often hiring them in retail and in hospitality — they (the jobs) ain't there,' says economist Armine Yalnizyan, who is also an Atkinson Fellow on the Future of Workers.
'Some of the basics of life are getting more expensive at a time when wage growth is slowing. That's a real problem for a lot of people. Young people are really getting hit on the head with the trends that are taking place right now.'
Story continues below advertisement
What does the study show?
Accounting firm and insolvency trustee MNP released its latest Consumer Debt Index, which collected responses from a variety of Canadians in June on issues like affordability and the cost of living, financial planning, as well as the amount of debt they are taking on.
The study, which is conducted every three months, found younger adults and lower-income households felt the most strained and 'stalled' when it came to their financial goals.
Nearly half (45 per cent) of respondents aged 18-34 said they felt anxious or stressed about their financial situation, and a third (33 per cent) of those younger Canadians polled said they felt like their lives were on hold because of their finances. Plus, 37 per cent of Canadians polled aged 18-34 said they felt stuck living paycheque to paycheque.
Younger Canadians are also the least likely to be able to set money aside for important life goals, according to MNP.
Story continues below advertisement
'Those making careful choices and delaying major decisions may be struggling to get ahead amid the current uncertainty around costs and income,' says president Grant Bazian at MNP.
'For many vulnerable households, particularly younger adults and lower-income Canadians, it may feel like they're constantly putting out financial fires.'
4:09
Student job seekers could face tough summer
Why are younger Canadians feeling the pinch?
The most recent Statistics Canada report on the labour market showed youth unemployment sitting at 14.2 per cent, up from 10.8 per cent before the pandemic in 2019. For students focused on seasonal summer work, the unemployment rate was 17.4 percent in June, compared to 15.8 per cent in 2024.
Story continues below advertisement
Although many young Canadians are putting off long-term financial goals to make ends meet, it still may not be enough to get by.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
'The pure scale of people struggling is really an alarm bell because it's not going to get easier as the tariffs really kick in and inflation continues to rise,' says economist Armine Yalnizyan, who is also a Fellow on the Future of Workers at the Atkinson Foundation.
'The tariff uncertainty means that fewer people are hiring, more people are laying off, and unemployment rates for young people are very elevated compared to previous years.'
Who's benefitting?
The MNP study shows the average Canadian household is ending each month with more money left over than before, but this is not consistent with each demographic.
Based on the findings in the study, households with higher incomes and less or no debt at all are better able to reduce their spending amid economic uncertainty and set aside funds in case of future financial burdens.
Story continues below advertisement
This as the trade war and United States President Donald Trump's tariffs has most economists predicting Canada's economy will take a hit in the form of higher prices and potential job losses.
The MNP report shows one third (33 per cent) of all Canadians are increasing savings or 'building emergency funds,' and two in five (41 per cent of) respondents said they are reducing their non-essential spending.
In doing so, MNP reports Canadians on average had $916 left at the end of the month, which is $49 more than the last report and the second-highest recorded amount since 2017. Although this is seemingly a good sign, it was mainly older and middle- to higher-income households which were able to do so compared to younger and lower-income Canadians.
For instance, Canadians aged 55 and older were saving on average $84 more every month in the three-month period leading up to June than the previous report, and those households earning between $60,000 and $100,000 reporting an increase of $260 each month.
When it comes to savings goals, one third of respondents (33 per cent) aged 18-34 said they were putting those aims on hold compared to less than a quarter (23 per cent) of all Canadians polled.
This means that because of the reported day-to-day affordability struggles of so many younger and lower-income Canadians, they may not be as able to save for their long-term financial goals.
Story continues below advertisement
'We are looking at 'scarring' for millions of young people who will not be able to launch their lives — forget about their careers,' says Yalnizyan.
'This is just a generalized failure to launch if you cannot get a foot in the door for self-sufficiency through the labour market.'
1:46
Charities providing essential period products as cost of living rises
How could the situation improve/get worse
Experts say the trade war is one of the reasons the labour market has weakened as businesses slow or pause hiring, and even lay people off to reduce costs.
Story continues below advertisement
'This whole thing is unfolding because of the uncertainty unleashed by the tariff threats. We could be making every job a good job at this moment if it wasn't for those factors,' says Yalnizyan.
'We had all the fixings for one of the best economies in the world until January.'
Although Prime Minister Mark Carney is still working with Trump on a new trade deal, Yalnizyan said public policy will also be crucial to help support the Canadian labour market and improve affordability — especially for young people.
'It's really time for the public sector to step up to the plate and make sure all the money that we are spending, which is our taxpayer money, is actually including a factor that brings along the next generation in not only training, but in jobs in construction, infrastructure and in healthcare,' says Yalnizyan.
'There are crises in all of these elements that could actually be incredible sources of jobs for young people, but you have to design public policy to do exactly that — not just leave it to the markets.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
14 minutes ago
- Global News
Retaliate against Trump's tariffs? Why Ford wants Carney to ‘hit back'
Now is not the time to 'roll over,' Ontario Premier Doug Ford is telling Prime Minister Mark Carney as Canada prepares to deal with U.S. President Donald Trump's latest trade war escalation. And he's not the only one, even as others are split on whether to retaliate. 'Canada shouldn't settle for anything less than the right deal. Now is not the time to roll over. We need to stand our ground,' Ford said in a statement released on social media on Thursday, just hours after Trump increased the tariffs on Canadian goods from 25 per cent to 35 per cent. Ford called for further retaliation. 'The federal government needs to hit back with a 50 per cent tariff on U.S. steel and aluminum,' he said. Story continues below advertisement 'Canada has what the United States needs: oil and gas, critical minerals, steel and aluminum, electricity, potash and uranium. We're America's number one customer and keep millions of Americans working,' the Ontario premier said, urging Carney to 'maximize our leverage and stand strong.' Nova Scotia Premier Tim Houston indicated that his province is considering retaliatory measures of its own. 'Our government will continue its part to support our province and the rest of Canada. Make no mistake: at the provincial level, we will not hesitate to implement retaliatory measures again if they are needed,' Houston said in a statement. Canada's largest private sector union echoed Ford's call for action. 'I agree with Premier Ford that we have to be prepared to use any and all leverage to win as much as we can in these circumstances. And I believe Canada has more strength and more leverage than any other nation in dealing with the United States,' Lana Payne, president of Unifor, told Global News. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'The president will continue to demand more and more and so we have to draw a line in the sand and push back hard but also make sure that we're protecting these workers and these industries.' Payne said retaliation could come in many forms. 'It can be more retaliation in terms of tariffs on the U.S. It could mean export controls. It can mean that we stockpile critical minerals. It could mean any number of things. We just have to understand that we have a lot of leverage,' she said. Story continues below advertisement 'We have to be willing to use it. We have put it all on the table and be strategic about what it is that we do here.' 5:48 Canadian Chamber of Commerce on Trump tariff increase 'Play the long game' Business groups, however, are urging caution. Dan Kelly, president of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, said that while he acknowledges there may be strong public support for further retaliatory tariffs, it could further raise trade uncertainty. Story continues below advertisement 'At this stage, though, it is difficult to say whether retaliation from Canada would cause this to escalate and worsen or potentially get better. I urge the government to use caution,' Kelly said. 'We saw that movie with China and the U.S., where tariffs went up over a hundred per cent, and that's certainly not a good thing for the Canadian economy. I think we have to be smart about this, be patient, and play the long game.' Business groups say any retaliatory measures should be applied very selectively and temporarily. 'Any retaliatory tariffs should be surgical, targeted and temporary so that they do as little harm to Canadian businesses as possible — and only enacted in unison with the larger pursuit of diversifying trade and getting big projects built,' said Matthew Holmes, executive vice-president at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce. Some experts say it is unlikely that Carney will hit back against Trump's latest escalation. 'Trump cited retaliatory tariffs as a justification for upping the ante, so it's doubtful that Canada will respond by raising the rates it has been applying to U.S. imports,' said Clay Jarvis, financial expert at NerdWallet Canada. 'If that's the case, Canadian consumers shouldn't see prices on American goods spike. But it's not as if the status quo has been all that affordable. Canadians have been paying more for food, cars, clothes and appliances for months.' Story continues below advertisement A Royal Bank of Canada report on Friday said that while the increased 35 per cent tariffs would be 'impactful,' they were not the worst-case scenario for Canada. 'Tariffs on Canadian goods announced by the U.S. on July 31 do not significantly alter Canada's economic outlook,' the report by RBC economists Nathan Janzen and Claire Fan said. This is because the increased tariffs maintain the exemption for goods traded in compliance with the Canada-U.S.-Mexico free trade agreement (CUSMA). Kelly urged Carney not to 'rush into a deal' since the exemption on CUSMA-compliant goods from tariffs gives Canada a bit of a cushion. 'A bad deal is a lot worse than no deal at all,' he said.
Edmonton Journal
14 minutes ago
- Edmonton Journal
Enbridge sees strong demand in U.S., hurdles in Canada
Article content Calgary pipeline giants Enbridge Inc. and TC Energy Corp. say they're seeing stronger customer demand in the United States, even as Canadian politicians push for nation-building infrastructure north of the border. Article content François Poirier, the chief executive of TC Energy, said its returns in the U.S. 'are meaningfully higher than in Canada,' which means it will focus on the much larger market, despite hopes for a pipeline project on its home turf. Article content Article content 'Canada gas has to compete for capital with the other business units in the company,' Poirier said this week during a conference call on quarterly earnings. Article content Article content For its part, Enbridge says federal energy policies are still standing in the way of a possible major new pipeline in Canada, while its customers are looking for relatively smaller and faster projects in the United States. Article content The pipeline operator, which was behind the ill-fated Northern Gateway project that would have taken Alberta oil to British Columbia's northern coast, said Friday policies such as a tanker ban are holding back investment. Article content 'The issue is one of government policy' Article content 'We have been a proponent of such a project in the past and, in fact, invested several $100 million dollars to get there,' Enbridge CEO Greg Ebel told analysts in a conference call. Article content Article content 'So the issue is not one of there being a proponent. The issue is one of government policy setting the conditions for that to get investment to occur. Let's be honest, the government has not done that yet, and it's not clear they intend to, at least from our perspective.' Article content Article content The Carney government's recent Bill C-5 gives Ottawa the ability to fast-track infrastructure projects it deems vital for the national economy, but has yet to announce a list of projects. Article content The controversial bill grants the government the authority to override existing laws, theoretically including the ban on oil tankers on the northwest coast of B.C., which would allow for export to Pacific markets.
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Federal committee begins probe of billion-dollar BC Ferries loan
Transport Minister Chrystia Freeland told MPs Friday she is 'dismayed' by a $1 billion federal loan for BC Ferries' purchase of four new electric-diesel ships from a Chinese shipbuilder – but did not call for the contract's cancellation. The House of Commons transport committee launched a study of the Canada Infrastructure Bank loan today. BC Ferries announced in June that it had hired China Merchants Industry Weihai Shipyards to build the new ships after a five-year procurement process that did not include a Canadian bid. 1:24 'We shouldn't be giving federal tax dollars to subsidize jobs overseas:' Poilievre calls for loan to BC Ferries to be cancelled The Canada Infrastructure Bank contributed $1 billion to the deal and said in June that the new ferries 'wouldn't likely be purchased' without this financing. Story continues below advertisement In her opening remarks before the committee Friday, Freeland said she was troubled by the planned purchase and she believes in supporting Canadian jobs. She said she has sent 71 letters directing all organizations under the Transport Canada umbrella to prioritize Canadian content in their major procurements where feasible, particularly Canadian steel, aluminum, and lumber. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy When Canadian options aren't available, she said, the preferred option is to buy from countries with trade deals that include reciprocal procurement agreements. Freeland also said Transport Canada will be convening a meeting with provinces and territories, ferry owners and operators, shipyards, labour representatives and the steel industry. She said she's also assembling a second meeting with major rail operators. 2:07 Premier Eby demands equal funding from federal government Freeland did not directly respond to questions from MPs about whether she would reject the loan. She said she agrees that this is a moment of crisis for the steel and aluminum sectors and they need the government's support. Story continues below advertisement Housing and Infrastructure Minister Gregor Robertson and the CEOs of BC Ferries and the Canada Infrastructure Bank are set to testify at the meeting later today. The Canada Infrastructure Bank is accountable to Parliament through Robertson. Jeff Groot, executive director of communications for BC Ferries, said the company signed the loan with the bank before the contract with the Chinese shipyard was finalized. Dan Albas, Conservative transport critic and committee co-chair, requested the study and has asked questions about why $1 billion in public funds was earmarked to finance overseas shipbuilding in the middle of a trade war with the U.S. 2:15 BC Ferries criticized over decision to award contract to Chinese-owned shipyard Freeland sent her B.C. counterpart, Mike Farnworth, a letter in June saying she was disappointed that BC Ferries would choose a Chinese state-owned shipyard 'in the current geopolitical context,' and asking him to confirm that no federal funding would be diverted to purchase the ferries. Story continues below advertisement Before Friday's meeting began, Bloc MP Xavier Barsalou-Duval said he'd like to see an apology from the government and from the Canada Infrastructure Bank. He said it's 'unacceptable' and 'problematic' that the government plans to invest in foreign infrastructure when Canada's steel industry is facing tariffs from the United States. The new vessels are expected to join the BC Ferries fleet between 2029 and 2031. — With files from David Baxter
