Meta, TikTok can be sued by mother of NYC teen killed while 'subway surfing'
NEW YORK, June 30 (Reuters) - Meta Platforms (META.O), opens new tab and TikTok owner ByteDance must face a wrongful death lawsuit by the mother of a 15-year-old Manhattan boy who died while "subway surfing" on a moving train, a New York state judge ruled.
Justice Paul Goetz ruled on Friday that Norma Nazario can try to prove Meta and ByteDance "goaded" her son Zackery into subway surfing by addicting him to Instagram and TikTok, where he viewed content about "dangerous challenges."
Meta, ByteDance and Snapchat parent Snap (SNAP.N), opens new tab have faced thousands of lawsuits saying their platforms are addictive, causing harm to children, schools and governments.
Zackery Nazario died on February 20, 2023, after he and his girlfriend climbed atop a Brooklyn-bound J train as it crossed the Williamsburg Bridge.
His mother said a low beam struck Zackery, causing him to fall between subway cars, which ran over him.
She said she later found several videos related to subway surfing on Zackery's social media accounts.
Meta and ByteDance called Nazario's death "heartbreaking," but claimed immunity from user content under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act, and the free speech clause of the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment.
But the Manhattan judge said Norma Nazario could try to prove her son was targeted because of his age.
"Based on the allegations in the complaint," Goetz wrote, "it is plausible that the social media defendants' role exceeded that of neutral assistance in promoting content, and constituted active identification of users who would be most impacted."
Goetz said Norma Nazario may pursue wrongful death, product liability and negligence claims.
He dismissed her claims against New York City's Metropolitan Transit Authority, saying common sense and "the realities of life in this city" should have signaled to Zackery that subway surfing was dangerous.
Meta, ByteDance and their lawyers had no immediate comment. Norma Nazario's lawyers did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The MTA did not immediately respond to a similar request.
At least six people died from subway surfing in 2024, New York City police have said.
The case is Nazario v ByteDance Ltd et al, New York State Supreme Court, New York County, No. 151540/2024.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Girl, seven, is 'murdered by her mother with single punch to the belly'
A Florida mother has been charged with murder after investigators determined that her seven-year-old daughter died from horrific stomach injuries. Naikishia Williams, 32, was arrested on Friday morning on accusations that she killed Nia Williams on April 28 in Riviera Beach. Medical personnel who found Nia rushed her to a nearby hospital, but they were too late to save her life. An indictment handed down on Thursday said that Nia died from blunt force trauma to her abdomen with 'premeditated design'. Williams was booked in Palm Beach County jail on charges of first-degree murder and aggravated child abuse. She appeared in a county courtroom on Friday where a judge granted the state's request to hold her without bond. A two-month investigation led to the murder charges against Williams, who caretakers said was known to abuse Nia. 'She caused the death. She should have been in jail a long time ago', the girl's caretaker, Rebecca Finley, told WPTV, alongside Nia's godmother, Whytni Walker. Walker said she had contacted the Department Of Children And Families (DCF) over concerns about Williams' children just 12 days before Nia's death. She described the kids as being 'very malnourished'. Finley said Williams' other kids are now safe and being cared for. Finley added: 'There wasn't one person who was not aware of this young lady being a dangerous mother.' She called Nia a 'brilliant' child who loved make-up and was a 'fashionista'. The caretaker added that she's now committed to speaking out for Nia. Finley said: 'I'm guaranteeing she's saying, "Auntie, tell them everything. Don't forget anything".' Williams is next set to appear in court on July 28. She was assigned a public defender.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Sean 'Diddy' Combs jury passing notes to judge 'could be a good sign' for rapper
The jury in Sean 'Diddy' Combs' sex trafficking trial have asked two questions to the judge, as they begin their deliberations in the high-profile case The fact the jury deliberating in the Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial sent two notes to the judge could be a good sign for the embattled rapper, it's been claimed. The music mogul, 55, is currently awaiting his fate at the hands of 12 jurors as his sex-trafficking trial comes to a conclusion. Jury deliberations commenced on Monday, but things took an unexpected turn when two notes were handed over to the presiding judge from the jury. The first note revealed concerns from a juror about their ability to comprehend the extensive 61-page instructions delivered by the judge right before deliberations got underway. Despite this, Judge Arun Subramanian was adamant that jurors should strictly adhere to his directions, even if it meant the deliberative process would be prolonged. Hours later, the second note sought further explanation concerning the section on drug distribution within the instructions—a key point in Combs' racketeering conspiracy charge. This request was addressed, and deliberations proceeded, with speculation that a verdict might come down by this afternoon (UK time). Combs finds himself facing serious allegations including two counts of sex trafficking, two counts of transportation to engage in prostitution, and one count of racketeering—all charges he vehemently denies. The music industry titan could be sentenced to life imprisonment if found guilty. But Combs may be heartened by the jury's note-passing. Mitch Epner, a New York-based lawyer and former prosecutor, argues that the notes may turn out to be good sign for Combs. "First, it is unusual for the jurors to send a note to the judge this early, other than asking for logistical help. Second, this note indicates that there may already be a breakdown in the deliberative process," he tells the BBC. A conviction requires the full agreement of the jury panel. The reasons behind the unease concerning juror number 25, and their struggle to adhere to the judge's guidance remain unrevealed. Epner highlighted that while a juror can be dismissed for not engaging in deliberations, they cannot be ousted solely for "having come to a fixed conclusion about the proper verdict". In the final arguments last week, both federal prosecutors and Combs' defence team made their concluding attempts to sway the jury towards conviction or acquittal. Assistant US Attorney Christy Slavik argued: "The defendant used power, violence and fear to get what he wanted. He thought that his fame, wealth and power put him above the law." She accused him of relying on a "close inner circle and a small army of personal staff, who made it their mission to meet the defendant's every desire, promote his power and protect his reputation at all costs." However, Combs' defence attorney Marc Agnifilo countered these claims, stating: "This isn't about crime. It's about money." He pointed out that one of the accusers had also filed a civil lawsuit against Combs. Agnifilo defended his client, saying: "He is not a racketeer. He is not a conspirator to commit racketeering. He is none of these things. He is innocent. He sits there innocent. Return him to his family, who have been waiting for him," as he addressed the jury.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
My boy, 14, thought he was innocently flirting with a girl on TikTok – 35-minutes later he was dead
WHEN Morgan Moore got a call from her son's dad, she wasn't expecting her world to fall apart instantly. Her son, Caleb, who was just 14 years old, had taken a gun and shot himself. 5 5 5 Like most teenagers, Caleb had spent the evening on social media and had found a girl online with whom he began innocently flirting, or so he thought. Caleb and the '14-year-old girl' had met on TikTok, but soon moved their conversation over to Snapchat where she allegedly sent him compromising photos of herself. The mum-of-five says Caleb then sent over similar photos in return. But Caleb had been conned, the 'girl' wasn't who he thought and was instead a sextortion scammer who threatened to release Caleb's photos unless he sent money. The online exchange lasted just 35-minutes and tragically ended Caleb's life when he took a gun from the home. In that moment, Morgan, 33, believes her son felt like he had nowhere to turn and shot himself. Now, the brave mum has shared her son's story to raise awareness and keep others safe. Morgan, from El Dorado, Kansas, US, said: "I want his death to have as much meaning as his life did, which was a lot. He is very, very missed and very loved. "I never thought this would happen to him or us. I found out about it right after Caleb had fired the gun because his dad called me. The mum rushed over to the house as soon as she got the call, and while Caleb was still alive, she was unable to be with him in his last moments. Inside INTERPOL's largest-ever operation against human trafficking and migrant smuggling "When I got there, Caleb was still alive and breathing but they were unable to resuscitate him so they stopped trying as nothing was working," she explains. "He passed away in the house and it was very difficult because I wanted to be with him but they wouldn't let me go inside as they didn't want me to see anything. "I was hysterical and screaming and begging them to not give up on my boy and let me go to him. I was inconsolable. "It was the worst moment of my life. At this point, we didn't know why Caleb had shot himself. It didn't make sense. "It was probably the next day when the police called and wanted to show me something on his phone. They made him feel like his life was over as he had made this mistake. Morgan Moore "That is when they had gone through his TikTok messages and showed me the progression. It had stolen my boy's happiness and hope in a 35-minute span. "It was someone posing as a girl his age and they started flirting and she sent him photos and then 'she' asked him to send pictures. "He sent the photos and these were of a compromising nature. As soon as he sent them, the conversation switched. "This person began demanding money and making threats that if he didn't send over the money they were going to expose his photos and his family and friends would be ashamed of him. "They made him feel like his life was over as he had made this mistake." What is Sextortion? 'Sextortion' is a type of online blackmail. It's when criminals threaten to share sexual pictures, videos, or information about you unless you pay money or do something else you don't want to. Anyone can be a victim of sextortion. However, young people aged between 15 to 17, and adults aged under 30, are often most at risk. Criminals often target people through dating apps, social media, webcams, or pornography sites. They may use a fake identity to befriend you online. If a person you've just met online chats to you in a sexual way, or asks for sexual images, it might be an attempt at sextortion. You should be wary if someone you've met online: is trying to start a relationship with you very quickly (they may even send you a sexual image first) chats to you in a sexual way, or asks for sexual images, soon after you've met them. has sent friend requests to lots of people, not just you repeatedly asks you to do sexual things that you're not comfortable with tells you they've hacked your account or have access to your contacts Sextortion attempts can happen very quickly, or they can happen over a long time. You should never share sexual images or information about yourself if you are not comfortable. You can still be a victim of sextortion if you haven't shared sexual images or information. Criminals may have hacked one of your accounts, or created edited or fake images or videos, like deepfakes, of you that appear real. Even if blackmail isn't involved, sharing or threatening to share intimate photos or videos of you without your permission is illegal. This is called ' revenge porn' or intimate image abuse. From the Met Police website Morgan says her son had been using TikTok for about a year and says they had had open conversations about internet safety. Before shooting himself, she claims Caleb even sent a photo of the gun to the TikTok user to try and stop the threats but it didn't help. Morgan said: "These people intentionally manipulate what a 14-year-old boy would be vulnerable about - their sexuality, the family's wellbeing and social status. "I don't think Caleb thought that we wouldn't help him, I think he felt like we wouldn't be able to help him or fix it and it was going to be his fault and none of these things are true. He had even sent a photo of the gun to them and they still didn't stop and so he did use it. Morgan Moore "The most devastating loss I can imagine is losing one of your kids and now I'm in that situation and it was all so avoidable. "I know Caleb had pleaded with the person to not send the pictures out. He had even sent a photo of the gun to them and they still didn't stop and so he did use it. "It's so heartless and anonymous. The police are doing what they can but the reality of them tracking down the individual is really low. "It's incredibly overwhelming because even though Caleb was the most loved kid and happy, funny and responsible on these platforms and this still happened to him. "I don't have any idea how these people found my son and I'm guessing TikTok doesn't either. "I think there should be more accountability or monitoring [on TikTok]. There has to be something that they can do." Caleb's funeral took place on June 16 and Morgan says around 300 people turned up to celebrate his life. She is now using her son's tragic death to urge other children to tell a responsible adult if they feel they are in danger online. Morgan said: "Caleb was a pretty popular kid, really funny and goofy and made people laugh a lot. "He was mild-mannered so got along with everybody. He loves sports and played football, basketball and was really good at wrestling. 5 "I don't know how to stress enough to children to tell someone, your parents, about it or another trusted adult. "You just have to tell someone because they purposely make it seem like they have so much more power than they do. "You need to battle the false communication between the scammer and your child with open conversation with you and your child." El Dorado Police Department confirmed that the conversation began on TikTok before moving to another platform on which the images were sent. It is unclear if Caleb had used his correct age to access the platform. Snapchat said they offer 'strong safety settings' for Snapchat users aged between 13-17 and have a Family Safety Hub on their website designed to help families navigate Snapchat safely and confidently. TikTok says they are deeply committed to making their platform a safe and positive experience for teens. The social media platform claims that teens using TikTok who are aged 16 do not have access to direct messaging. Adults using the platform are also unable to send message requests to teens and no one in the US can send off-platform imagery in DMs. The platform said that when people receive a message from someone for the first time, they are prompted to mark the conversation as safe or report the sender. Messaging on TikTok is not end-to-end encrypted, which the social media giant claims makes its platform undesirable for those who would attempt to share illegal material. Snapchat said on their website page how they offer extra protection to teens to help prevent unwanted contact from strangers. This includes strong safety settings for Snapchat users aged between 13-17, which means their accounts are private by default that also includes their friends lists. Due to this, they state that users of this age can only communicate with mutually accepted friends or those whose numbers they have already saved to their contacts. Snapchat also has a Family Safety Hub on their website which is intentionally designed to help families navigate Snapchat safely and confidently. An El Dorado Police Department spokesman said: "Our thoughts and prayers go out to the Moore family during this difficult time. "We are amazed at the incredible strength and courage that this family has shown through the tragedy that they have suffered. "We strongly support the fact that the family has made it a priority to share this story with others in an effort to protect the lives of other children and we intend to support this family in every way possible." Following his death, a GoFundMe page was set up to help support Caleb's family at this difficult time. After funeral costs his parents are going to use the extra funds to set up a scholarship fund for the local athletics team. YOU'RE NOT ALONE EVERY 90 minutes in the UK a life is lost to suicide. It doesn't discriminate, touching the lives of people in every corner of society - from the homeless and unemployed to builders and doctors, reality stars and footballers. It's the biggest killer of people under the age of 35, more deadly than cancer and car crashes. And men are three times more likely to take their own life than women. Yet it's rarely spoken of, a taboo that threatens to continue its deadly rampage unless we all stop and take notice, now. That is why The Sun launched the You're Not Alone campaign. The aim is that by sharing practical advice, raising awareness and breaking down the barriers people face when talking about their mental health, we can all do our bit to help save lives. Let's all vow to ask for help when we need it, and listen out for others... You're Not Alone. If you, or anyone you know, needs help dealing with mental health problems, the following organizations provide support: CALM, 0800 585 858 Heads Together, Mind, 0300 123 3393 Papyrus, 0800 068 41 41 Samaritans, 116 123 Movember,
