Supreme Court rules for South Carolina over bid to defund Planned Parenthood
The court held in a 6-3 ruling on ideological lines with the conservative justices in the majority that the federal law in question does not allow people who are enrolled in the Medicaid program to file such claims.
The ruling authored by Justice Neil Gorsuch is a boost to the state's effort to prevented Planned Parenthood from receiving funding through Medicaid, a federal program for low-income people that is administered by the states, because it prevents individual patients to enforce their right to choose their preferred health care provider.
Federal funding for abortion is already banned, but conservatives have long targeted Planned Parenthood, which provides reproductive health services including abortions where allowed, for any funding it receives even it is for other health care-related services.
They argue that even non-abortion related funding that flows to Planned Parenthood would help it carry out its broader agenda that favors abortion rights.
The state's efforts to defund Planned Parenthood came before the Supreme Court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, overturned the landmark Roe v. Wade abortion rights ruling in 2022.
South Carolina now has a six-week abortion ban, meaning abortions are rare in the state.
Planned Parenthood has facilities in Charleston and Columbia that provide abortion care in compliance with the new law, as well as other health care services, including contraception, cancer screenings and pregnancy testing.
In 2018, Gov. Henry McMaster issued an executive order that prohibited Planned Parenthood of South Atlantic, the local affiliate of the national group, from providing family planning services under Medicaid.
Julie Edwards, a Medicaid-eligible patient who wants to use Planned Parenthood, joined a lawsuit filed by the group, saying that under federal civil rights law she could enforce her rights in court.
A federal judge ruled in her favor, and after lengthy litigation, the Supreme Court agreed to weigh in.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Charlamagne responds to Trump's comments on 'The Breakfast Club'
Lara Trump is the Republican National Committee co-chair and is married to the president's son, Eric Trump. Charlamagne tha God, whose real name is Lenard McKelvey, has become a key feature in pop culture and co-hosts the popular radio show. During the appearance on Saturday, Aug. 2, Lara Trump asked Charlamagne how he would rate Trump's second term so far. He responded: "I wouldn't give it a good rating, simply because the least of us are still being impacted by the worst." While admitting he's set to benefit from tax provisions in the president's tax-and-spending law, he said, "There's going to be so many people that's hurt by that bill." He added, "Anything that takes away Medicaid from people and will put people in a worse financial situation than they were previously in, I'm not for." The president later lashed out at Charlamagne in a Truth Social post on Sunday, Aug. 3. "He's a low-IQ individual, has no idea what words are coming out of his mouth and knows nothing about me or what I have done," wrote the president. 'I've never taken an IQ test': Charlamagne tha God responds to Trump Charlamagne spoke about the president's remarks on "The Breakfast Club" in his segment entitled "Donkey of the Day," shrugging off Trump's ire without much fuss. On Monday, Aug. 4, Charlamagne said, "I don't care. He called me a sleazebag. I looked up the definition of sleazebag, says it's 'a disgusting or despicable person.' Depending on who you ask, that may apply to me." He also said that the Trump administration is using an "authoritative strategy" against anyone who speaks out against it. He also went on to say, "With his reaction to what I said on Lara Trump shows how authoritarians will attempt to bully people into pushing false narratives. " He continued to make fun of the president's remarks, adding: "He said I'm 'a low-IQ individual.' I don't know, I've never taken an IQ test." As he closed out the segment, Charlamagne offered some advice to the commander-in-chief. Tips for Trump "I don't care who's in the White House," he said. "I want America to succeed. Believe it or not, I'm rooting for you, but I need you focused and right now, you're not focused. Ok?" "We need you focused on two things: the economy and Epstein. I need you to keep the promises of a great economy and the promises of transparency with the Epstein files." It is not out of the ordinary for him to criticize political figures, he told Lara Trump. When President Joe Biden was in office, he said he subjected the former president to "the same hell" when he disagreed with his actions. Michelle Del Rey is a trending news reporter at USA TODAY. Contact her at mdelrey@
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
US condemns Brazil supreme court judge for ordering house arrest of ex-president Jair Bolsonaro
In a move immediately condemned by the US, a Brazilian supreme court judge has ordered the house arrest of former president Jair Bolsonaro for breaching 'preventative measures' that were imposed ahead of his trial for an alleged coup attempt. According to the ruling on Monday by Justice Alexandre de Moraes, the far-right leader breached a ban on using social media which was imposed last month, when he was also ordered to wear an electronic ankle tag. Moraes wrote that as demonstrators took to the streets in several cities across the country on Sunday in support of the former president, Bolsonaro used the social media accounts of allies to share messages containing 'clear encouragement and incitement to attack the Supreme Federal Court, and overt support for foreign intervention in Brazil's judiciary'. 'There is no doubt the precautionary measure was breached,' Moraes wrote. The justice, who was sanctioned by the US last week over his role in the Bolsonaro case, ordered that Bolsonaro be placed under house arrest in the palm-lined compound where Bolsonaro rents a mansion in the south of the capital, Brasília, with visits restricted to close family members and lawyers. Federal police were instructed to collect all mobile phones available at the property. Visitors authorised to see the former president will not be allowed to use mobile phones, take photos or record videos. A press representative for Bolsonaro confirmed he was placed under house arrest on Monday evening at his Brasilia residence by police who seized his mobile phone. Bolsonaro's lawyers said in a statement they would appeal against the decision, arguing the former president had not violated any court order. The US state department, in a statement issued by its bureau of western hemisphere affairs on X, condemned the judge's ruling and said it would 'hold accountable all those aiding and abetting sanctioned conduct'. 'Justice Moraes, now a US-sanctioned human rights abuser, continues to use Brazil's institutions to silence opposition and threaten democracy,' the bureau said. 'Putting even more restrictions on Jair Bolsonaro's ability to defend himself in public is not a public service. Let Bolsonaro speak!' Moraes has said Trump's tariffs on Brazil and the 'spurious' sanctions targeting him and other supreme court justices were part of an 'illegal and immoral' ruse to obstruct justice that was being engineered by a group of Brazilian 'traitors' who had lobbied foreign authorities to carry out 'hostile acts' against the country's economy. In his ruling on Monday, Moraes noted that despite being banned from using social media, the far-right leader took part by phone in a pro-Bolsonaro demonstration on Copacabana beach in Rio de Janeiro on Sunday. During the rally, one of his politician sons, senator Flávio Bolsonaro, held a phone to the microphone so the crowd could hear the former president speak. The senator himself had posted a video on social media showing Bolsonaro addressing supporters by phone – but later deleted the footage. Moraes argued that the deletion was a 'blatant' attempt to conceal the breach of court-ordered restrictions. 'The flagrant disregard for the preventative measures was so obvious that – it bears repeating – the defendant's own son, senator Flávio Nantes Bolsonaro, decided to delete the post from his Instagram account in order to conceal the legal transgression,' Moraes wrote. The arrest order is part of an ongoing supreme court case in which Bolsonaro is accused of leading a plot to overturn the results of the last election, in which current president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva defeated the former army captain. The trial is expected to conclude later this year, with Bolsonaro facing a potential sentence of more than 40 years in prison. 'Bolsonaro is being arrested gradually,' said political commentator Fernando Gabeira on GloboNews. 'The supreme court, consciously or not, is leading him to prison in stages – to avoid a major shock.' In Brasilía, the political temperature has been rising in recent days, with thousands of Bolsonaro supporters on Sunday rallying outside the central bank to offer their support. Many of those protesters urged the US president Donald Trump – who recently hit Brazil with 50% tariffs in retribution for the alleged 'witch hunt' against Bolsonaro – to take further action to help save their embattled leader. 'I'd like to give Trump a hug and tell him: thank you for worrying about us,' said Álvaro Junior, 64, one Bolsonaro supporter who was carrying a sign that read: 'Thank you, Trump'. Metal barricades have been erected around the supreme court, foreign ministry and congress in anticipation of possible rightwing protests or violence. Trump further stoked the political flames last week by slapping sanctions on Moraes, who the US secretary of the treasury, Scott Bessent, accused of being 'responsible for an oppressive campaign of censorship, arbitrary detentions that violate human rights and politicized prosecutions – including against former president Jair Bolsonaro'. Lindovaldo Ribeiro Paulo, a 43-year-old in a red Maga cap, hailed the sanctions on Moraes, saying: 'We feel even more admiration and even love for the American people now.' In Monday's ruling, Moraes said Bolsonaro had 'repeated his unlawful conduct in an even more severe and defiant manner', continuing to 'urge and incite a foreign head of state to take measures aimed at unlawfully interfering with the normal course of judicial proceedings – in an attempt to generate social pressure on Brazilian authorities, in flagrant violation of national sovereignty'.
Sky News
4 hours ago
- Sky News
Brazil's former president placed under house arrest after social media post
Brazil's former president has been put under house arrest while he is on trial for allegedly plotting to stage a coup. On Monday, the country's Supreme Court ordered Jair Bolsonaro to remain at home and for police to seize all the mobile phones in his property after he broke legal restrictions that stop him using social media. Prosecutors accuse the right-wing politician of heading a criminal organisation that plotted to overturn the 2022 election and kill President Lula and a Supreme Court justice. He is also accused of using social media to encourage Donald Trump to interfere in his case. 'Flagrant disrespect' Under Monday's new restrictions, visitors authorised to see Bolsonaro will not be allowed to record the politician or post on his behalf. The ruling came after the 70-year-old used his sons' social media channels to speak to supporters during a rally in Rio de Janeiro on Sunday. Through his son's mobile phone, he told protesters: "Good afternoon, Copacabana, good afternoon my Brazil, a hug to everyone, this is for our freedom." "The flagrant disrespect to the precautionary measures was so obvious that the defendant's son, Senator Flavio Bolsonaro, decided to remove the posting in his Instagram profile, with the objective of hiding the legal transgression," the judge wrote in his Monday ruling. 'No limits!' Bolsonaro's lawyers say he will appeal the new restrictions and his words cannot "be regarded as ignoring precautionary measures or as a criminal act". Flavio Bolsonaro claimed on X that Brazil "is officially in a dictatorship" after his father's house arrest. "The persecution of de Moraes against Bolsonaro has no limits!" the senator wrote. Last week, Mr Trump used Bolsonaro's trial, which he describes as a "witch hunt", to justify imposing 50% tariffs on Brazil. 1:49 Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who is presiding over the trial, also had sanctions placed on him by the US for allegedly suppressing freedom of expression and the ongoing trial of Bolsonaro. On Sunday, tens of thousands of Bolsonaro supporters took to the streets to plead for the former president to be pardoned, along with hundreds of others who are on trial for destroying government buildings in Brasilia on 8 January 2023. On that day, Bolsonaro supporters stormed the buildings that symbolise Brazil's democracy, a week after Lula had taken office. They rejected his election victory and urged the military to overthrow him.
