Work and pensions secretary tells MPs controversial disability benefit reforms will go ahead next year
More than 100 Labour MPs are thought to have concerns about the plans to cut nearly £5bn from the welfare bill by restricting personal independence payments (PIP) and the health top-up to Universal Credit.
Charities say the changes will have a "catastrophic" effect on vulnerable people.
3:06
The chair of the Commons' Work and Pensions Committee wrote to the secretary of state, Liz Kendall, last month, calling on the government to delay the changes until a full assessment is carried out of the impact on employment, poverty and health.
Labour MP Debbie Abrahams wrote that while there was a case for reform to disability benefits, "the evidence indicated [these changes] might not improve outcomes for most claimants, but instead push many into poverty and further away from the labour market".
But Ms Kendall has written back, in a letter made public on Wednesday, to reject the idea because the bill needs final approval from parliament in November in order for the changes to take effect in 2026.
She wrote: "We need urgent action to help people who can work, into work. With one in eight young people now not in education, employment or training and nearly 2.8 million people out of work due to long-term sickness, and spending on health and disability benefits set to rise by an additional £18bn, we must change course.
"We have consistently been clear that we are not consulting on every proposal.
"Instead, parliament will have the opportunity to fully debate, propose amendments to, and vote on areas where we have announced urgent reforms that are not subject to consultation.
"With PIP caseload and costs forecast to continue rising, reforms are needed now to make the system sustainable, while supporting those people with the greatest needs."
3:38
What is the government's plan?
The government says the PIP caseload has more than doubled from 15,000 new claims per month in 2019 to 34,000. PIP is a benefit to help disabled people with the increased costs of day-to-day living.
It is proposed that claimants will need to achieve four points out of eight in their assessment to qualify for the benefit, and the government says some 370,000 existing claimants will lose out when reassessed.
Ms Kendall says the growth in claims means the PIP caseload will still increase by the end of the parliament.
The government will also tackle what Ms Kendall called the "perverse incentive" to claim the health top-up for Universal Credit by freezing it at £97 a week for existing claimants, and slashing the rate to £50 a week for new claimants. The average loss of benefits will be £1,700 a year for some three million people.
Claimants with the most serious conditions, who have been assessed as never able to work, will not be subject to reassessment, ministers say, allowing them to have peace of mind.
The government will provide £1bn for targeted support schemes to help disabled people into work. But it's estimated these will help only some 70,000 people find employment.
1:23
Ms Kendall said a minister in her department is engaging with disabled people and organisations about the PIP assessment process, but said: "The PIP assessment review will rightly take time and require extensive engagement, and we cannot wait for its conclusion to make the urgently needed changes to the PIP eligibility criteria."
'Deeply disappointing news'
The first minister of Wales, Eluned Morgan, who is gearing up for elections next year, told Sky News she had spoken to Ms Kendall about her concerns last week.
She said: "This is going to be really challenging for a lot of people in Wales. We know more people in Wales will be affected by PIP than in any other part of the country.
"We do think there needs to be reform of welfare because we believe people can work should work, but in Wales we have examples of where we hold people's hands, stand by them, we help them into work, and we think that's more of a productive approach."
Labour MP Richard Burgon, who has vowed to vote against the reforms, said: "This will be deeply disappointing news for all the MPs who've been urging the government to delay this decision. Instead of allowing time for proper scrutiny and meaningful dialogue with disabled people, the government has brushed aside MPs' genuine concerns.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
35 minutes ago
- The Independent
Ministers ‘have to work harder' to bring down small boat numbers
Ministers are going to 'have to work harder' to bring down small boat crossings, a member of Sir Keir Starmer's Cabinet has said amid record numbers in the first half of this year. Pat McFadden told LBC 'everyone in Government knows it's a big challenge', as the tally for 2025 nears 20,000, but he declined to give an assurance that the figures would be down by this time next year. The Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster said: 'We are going to have to work harder to bring the numbers down. 'Everyone in Government knows it's a big challenge, and as a team we are determined to meet it.' Pressed specifically on whether the numbers would be down by this time next year, Mr McFadden said: 'I'm not going to make a prediction.' Asked again for an assurance that the numbers will reduce, he added: 'I can give you an assurance that the numbers at the moment are too high. We are working together to tackle this.' Figures released on Tuesday confirmed a record number of crossings for the first half of the year. Some 19,982 migrants had arrived in the UK after making the dangerous crossing by the end of June, latest Home Office figures show. The total is 48% higher than the figure for the first six months of 2024, which was 13,489, and 75% above the equivalent figure for 2023, which was 11,433. Some 879 migrants made the journey in 13 boats on Monday, the third highest number of arrivals on a single day so far this year. Data collection on the Channel crossings began in 2018. The figures also come as the UK's borders watchdog David Bolt said in June he did not feel 'very optimistic about the ability to smash the gangs', adding that with organised crime 'the best thing you can do is deflect it to something else you're less concerned about rather than expect to eradicate it'.
The Independent
35 minutes ago
- The Independent
Chief executive of miscarriage of justice review body resigns
The chief executive of a miscarriage of justice review body has resigned amid attempts to rebuild public confidence in the organisation. Karen Kneller, who had held the position since 2013, has left her job at the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), it was announced on Wednesday. Last month former victims Commissioner Dame Vera Baird became the interim chairwoman of the CCRC, having been asked by the Lord Chancellor to carry out a review of the organisation. The CCRC had been heavily criticised for its handling of the Andrew Malkinson case, one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British legal history. Ms Kneller's resignation came after former chairwoman Helen Pitcher resigned in January, but claimed she had been scapegoated over the Malkinson case. Dame Vera said: 'The CCRC has a vital role to play in the criminal justice system, but confidence in the organisation has been badly damaged. Confidence in our work must be restored. 'I thank Karen for her work at the CCRC over many years.' Amanda Pearce, who is CCRC casework operations director, has been appointed interim chief executive. Mr Malkinson served 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit, and was knocked back twice by the CCRC until his legal team carried out crucial DNA testing that was then repeated by the commission and led to his release. A review found that he could have been released 10 years earlier if the CCRC had obtained new DNA evidence as early as 2009, and thousands of cases are being reviewed in the wake of the bungled handling of the case. In May, the Commons Justice Committee also warned that the position of the current chief executive of the CCRC, Karen Kneller, was no longer tenable. MPs said in a report it followed 'unpersuasive' evidence from her on the CCRC's challenges and response to public criticisms in April, and concerns on the performance of the review body.
BBC News
36 minutes ago
- BBC News
Labour won't break tax pledges after welfare climbdown, minister says
A senior minister has insisted Labour will keep its election tax promises, after a major climbdown over welfare changes left a hole in the government's spending night, ministers offered rebel Labour MPs last-minute concessions to pass a welfare bill that was originally intended to make £5bn a year in benefits savings by concessions mean the savings will now be delayed or lost entirely, which puts pressure on Chancellor Rachel Reeves ahead of the autumn minister Pat McFadden told the BBC there would be "financial consequences" to the decision to water down planned cuts to disability and health-related benefits. But the minister ruled out increases in income tax, National Insurance or VAT in response to the government's decisions on welfare."I'm not going to speculate on the Budget," McFadden said."We will keep to the tax promises that we made in our manifesto when we fought the election last year."Helen Miller, incoming director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies think tank, said the government had moved from a position of saving £5bn to nothing by said: "Come autumn, given the government has not been able to put through the cuts it wanted, and given that the growth might get worse rather than better, it's looking increasingly likely that, if the government needs to do something, it's going to turn to tax rises."In its election manifesto, Labour said it would not raise taxes on "working people", specifically income tax, national insurance or has committed to meeting so-called fiscal rules, which most governments in wealthy nations have in place to try to maintain credibility with financial two main rules are not to borrow to fund day-to-day public spending; and to get debt falling as a share of the UK economic output by 2029/ Reeves's determination to stick to these rules has led to speculation that she will raise taxes or announce spending cuts in her autumn Budget. The Labour government's expensive policy reversals on welfare and the winter fuel allowance for pensioners have made that task more on ITV's Lorraine programme, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner said welfare reform was "always difficult", and said the government has to "flatten that curve a bit" of welfare spending said: "Rachel [Reeves] will have to look at those challenges" in the Labour rebellion over the welfare changes undermines the authority of the chancellor and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, and raises questions about their ability to enact key parts of their policy about the challenge to the government from its own backbenchers, Rayner said "to be fair to colleagues many of them have been raising them [concerns] privately", adding that "the process can look aggy but that's the way you get to consensus".The biggest savings in the welfare bill would have come from restricting eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip), the main disability benefit in England, Wales and Northern in a late concession on Tuesday evening, ministers shelved those plans and said any Pip changes would happen after a review of the the end, MPs gave the government's Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill their initial approval, by 335 votes to it was not enough to stop 49 Labour MPs voting against the legislation, the largest revolt of Sir Keir 's Rachael Maskell had proposed an amendment designed to halt the legislation, which was backed by a total of 44 Labour York Central MP said she had seen the bill "disintegrating before our eyes".Maskell said she was glad there had been a public debate about the issue and "now disabled people should feel empowered to have their voice at long last in an ableist parliament".Labour MP Chris Curtis, who supported the welfare changes, said the government needed to focus on economic growth to put the finances on a stable footing."I hope this government is going to go further and faster, and be bolder and more radical on unlocking growth in this country," he said."The most important thing for financial stability is to ensure we get the economy growing again."
