The 16 Best Restaurants on Martha's Vineyard

Eater

3 days ago

Skip to main content Current eater city: Boston
16 essential stops around the island Jul 2, 2025, 5:17 PM UTC Celina Colby is a Boston-based writer and editor on a perpetual search for the perfect empanada. She has more than ten years of experience covering food, travel, and culture, with a particular emphasis on marginalized communities.
Martha's Vineyard is a 20-mile-long island off the coast of Massachusetts with six towns, a fascinating history, and a very different vibe from its island neighbor, Nantucket. The island may be small, but there's a lot to eat in between beach days and bike rides.
At these essential Vineyard restaurants, you can sink your teeth into Peruvian-inspired sandwiches, fresh-off-the-boat lobster, late-night donuts, and more.
16 essential stops around the island Jul 2, 2025, 5:17 PM UTC Celina Colby is a Boston-based writer and editor on a perpetual search for the perfect empanada. She has more than ten years of experience covering food, travel, and culture, with a particular emphasis on marginalized communities.
Martha's Vineyard is a 20-mile-long island off the coast of Massachusetts with six towns, a fascinating history, and a very different vibe from its island neighbor, Nantucket. The island may be small, but there's a lot to eat in between beach days and bike rides.
At these essential Vineyard restaurants, you can sink your teeth into Peruvian-inspired sandwiches, fresh-off-the-boat lobster, late-night donuts, and more.
For a little bit of nightlife, head to the Ritz, a lively dive bar in Oak Bluffs. They host live music and DJs most nights while slinging cocktails and beers from behind the bar. Order bar food classics like wings, burgers, and pretzels. On Sundays, Pocket Dogs pops up with $6.50 gourmet hot dogs from 1 to 6 p.m. 4 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
[phone]‬
[phone]‬ Visit Website
This eclectic restaurant serves up a rotating cast of shareable plates depending on what ingredients are in season and what the chef feels like cooking that day. The restaurant is best known for its crispy fried Brussels sprouts doused in preserved lemon and parmesan, but diners can also try dishes like garlic noodles with lump crab served in a Chinese takeout box and pan-roasted monkfish paired with a sweet corn risotto. The bar menu offers a spectrum of craft cocktails, including 375ml takeout bottles of their clarified cocktails. 6 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
This popular Oak Bluffs coffee shop is the perfect place to get a shot of espresso or a bottle of natural wine (whatever the vacation moment calls for). The Mediterranean-inspired breakfast and lunch menu offers ful medames (a fava bean and chickpea stew) alongside Cape Cod bagels and eggs. This spot is also a hub for local culinary incubators, often hosting pop-ups and trial concepts from island chefs. 16 Kennebec Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
Tigerhawk is a Peruvian fusion takeaway spot that simultaneously serves giant sandwiches, fried chicken, and poke bowls. Somehow it works. Grab a breakfast sandwich with hash browns, cheddar, pork belly, and eggs, or order off an extensive menu of plant-based sandwiches, salads, and bowls. Everything pairs well with the house-made chicha morada, a traditional Andean purple corn drink blended with pineapple and green apple juice. 12B Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
It's not all seafood on this island. The Attic is an acclaimed Vineyard Haven spot known for its robust burgers and wide whiskey selection. The moody, upstairs space is perfect for sipping a cocktail and chatting with visitors and locals alike. The burger menu has seven different options, including everything from a classic smash burger to the Mr. Bowen with balsamic onion jam, baby spinach, melted brie cheese, braised short rib, and red wine gravy. 82 Main St, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
In 1969, the Black Dog Tavern opened as the first year-round restaurant on Martha's Vineyard. Although the dining scene has diversified significantly since then, the Black Dog still holds a place in local eaters' hearts (and stomachs). Though the restaurant serves food all day, it's most popular for breakfast, when you can eat plate-sized blueberry pancakes while looking out onto the Vineyard Haven harbor. 20 Beach St, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
The Net Result is a casual seafood market and takeout spot that serves up a daily catch fresh from the ocean. At the takeout counter, order a classic lobster roll, clam chowder, or a selection of local sushi to eat on picnic tables outside. Or order fresh quahogs, oysters, salmon, and squid, pulled from Vineyard or regional waters, to cook up later at home. 79 Beach Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
This local brewery makes ales, lagers, stouts, and other beers inspired by the surrounding landscape. Their classic Martha's Vineyard ale is brewed using island grape leaves, English malt, and American hops for a unique local flavor. At their Edgartown brewpub, you can sample the beers or a selection of housemade hard seltzers while snacking on charcuterie boards and pizza. 270 Upper Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
Order local Vineyard oysters by the dozen at this trendy oyster bar in Edgartown. Serving lunch and dinner with a split focus on steak and seafood, 19 Raw offers everything from a hefty, dry-aged Tomahawk steak to a lobster slider served on a Hawaiian roll and slathered with caviar. They don't take reservations, so arrive early or go for lunch for a better shot at getting in. 19 Church St, Edgartown, MA 02539
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
It's worth a trip to the ATM to visit this cash-only ice cream shop in Edgartown. Order flavors like black sesame and Chilmark Coffee cold brew soft serve, or choose from homemade hard ice cream flavors like Southern peach, sea salt caramel truffle, and pistachio. Of course, there's nothing wrong with a classic chocolate or vanilla scoop, too. Be sure to order one of their homemade waffle cones. 56 Main St (at S Summer St), Edgartown, MA 02539
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
Tucked behind Edgartown Books, you'll find this all-day cafe serving fresh croissants and other pastries for breakfast, flavorful salads for lunch, and a seafood-heavy dinner menu complete with a raw bar. Or follow in the footsteps of beloved authors and have a liquid meal at the Hemingway Bar. Everything is served in a private outdoor space covered by shaded trees and twinkle lights. 46 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
Founded by a Culinary Institute of America-trained chef turned farmer, 7a Foods transforms ingredients from local farms into gourmet sandwiches perfect for a road trip around the island. The breakfast and lunch spot also offers baked goods, salads, a daily frittata, and a few curated local products. While you're there, pop into Alley's General Store for a classic small-town New England shopping experience. 1045 State Rd, West Tisbury, MA 02575
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
There's almost nothing better than picking up a lobster roll stuffed with fresh-off-the-boat meat and eating it on the beach while watching the sunset. Larsen's is a popular market in the small fishing village of Menemsha, just down the road from the beach. Since 1969, they've been serving up ready-to-eat lobster rolls, chowder, and clams as well as fresh fish, shellfish, and whole lobsters caught by local fishermen. 56 Basin Rd, Chilmark, MA 02535
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website
For an upscale meal meant to impress, it's hard to beat Outermost Inn, a stylish prix-fixe restaurant in the rural community of Aquinnah. Here, you're just as likely to enjoy a three-course menu of wagyu beef and local lobster as you are spellbinding sunsets that can only be found on the western side of the island. 81 Lighthouse Rd, Town of Aquinnah, MA 02535
[phone]
[phone] Visit Website