Former Alberta justice minister Jonathan Denis appealing law society convictions and fines
Former Alberta justice minister Jonathan Denis is fighting his Law Society of Alberta (LSA) convictions, fines and the costs he was ordered to pay following the findings of guilt on two instances of professional misconduct.
Denis was found guilty of two violations in September 2024 and fined $5,000.
He was also ordered to pay $15,000 in legal fees on top of his fines.
Denis's lawyer Alain Hepner confirmed to CBC News that he is appealing.
According to Hepner, a panel of law society benchers will hear the appeal. A bencher is a lawyer elected by law society members to sit on disciplinary and other panels for the self-regulating society.
Denis, a former Progressive Conservative MLA for Calgary-Acadia, opened a law firm after losing his seat in the 2015 provincial election.
He was cited by the law society in 2023 on two sets of allegations.
In the first count, Denis was found to have acted in a conflict of interest when he represented two families of teenage girls — both the driver and passenger — who were involved in a car crash.
Denis ultimately dropped the driver as a client — after she'd provided a statement and sent her lawyer photos of the crash scene — in order to represent the passenger.
He then filed a lawsuit against the driver on behalf of the passenger.
Threatening emails
On the second citation, Denis was found to have threatened a woman's employment on behalf of a client who had dated her behind his wife's back.
After learning he was married, the woman contacted the wife of the man she'd been dating, to let her know about her husband's infidelity.
Denis then sent cease-and-desist emails to the woman, threatening to tell her employer she had violated its code of conduct.
The LSA found the emails "contain clear evidence that Mr. Denis twice made a threat."
In making its ruling, the committee said the Legal Profession Act clearly lays out that "if the complaint is justified, it should be made, not threatened."
Denis to pay $20k in fines, costs
In December, the LSA disciplinary panel accepted a joint submission from Denis's lawyer Hepner and Shanna Hunka, counsel for the law society, of a fine of $5,000 ($2,500 for each citation), finding the conduct was at "the lower range of seriousness."
The panel chair noted that while Denis has no prior record, he has persisted in his denial of wrongdoing.
Hunka argued Denis should pay $26,000 in legal costs on top of the fine, while Hepner argued no further financial penalties were necessary.
In the end, Denis was ordered to pay $15,000 in costs.
Hepner said Denis has paid the $5,000 in fines but has until April 30 to pay the legal costs.
A date for Denis's appeal arguments has not been set.
Hepner indicated he plans to appeal the findings of guilt on both citations, the sanctions imposed and the costs awarded.
Denis served as Alberta's justice minister for three years until he lost his seat in 2015.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
14 hours ago
Ontario, Michigan business groups jointly warn of 'crisis' if Canada, U.S. can't reach trade deal
Two groups representing businesses in Ontario and Michigan are urging Canada and the U.S. to get a trade deal done in order to avoid prolonged instability. Prolonged instability could have serious consequences for key sectors, from automotive and advanced manufacturing to agriculture and logistics, a joint statement Friday from the Ontario and Michigan chambers of commerce said. This is not just a trade story, it's a North American competitiveness crisis. The chambers are calling on both governments to return to the negotiating table. The statement comes after the two countries failed to come to some sort of agreement by an Aug. 1 deadline. U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order on Thursday boosting tariffs from 25 per cent to 35 per cent on Canadian goods that don't comply with the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA). Michigan and Ontario form one of the largest trade corridors between the two countries. The two jurisdictions are largely connected via the integrated auto sector. In addition to the 35 per cent tariffs on non-CUSMA compliant goods, Trump has also slapped a 25 per cent levy on the non-U.S. portion of assembled vehicles. The U.S. has also imposed 50 per cent tariffs on steel and aluminum imports from all countries. Enlarge image (new window) Tracking the trade war between the U.S. and Canada. Photo: CBC / Wendy Martinez, Graeme Bruce Prime Minister Mark Carney released a statement just past midnight on Friday saying Canada will continue to work toward a deal while focusing on providing supports for impacted industry and diversifying trade. Canada will be our own best customer, creating well-paying careers at home, as we strengthen and diversify our trading partnerships, the statement said. Trump's order cites Canada's lack of co-operation in stemming the flood of fentanyl and other illicit drugs across our northern border — even though Canada accounts for a small percentage of drug seizures entering the U.S. But a White House official gave CBC News a different explanation for the lack of an agreement with Canada, saying on background that Canada has repeatedly demonstrated a lack of seriousness in trade discussions as it relates to removing trade barriers. Trump gave Mexico, which accounts for the majority of drug seizures at the U.S. border, a 90-day extension of its current tariff regime with the goal of signing a new deal during that period. 'No deal better than a bad deal' Other Canadian business groups also expressed concerns about the lack of an agreement, but say it's better that Canada take its time rather than accept a bad deal. The Canadian Chamber of Commerce says it feels spending a little bit more time on crafting the right deal is well worth the wait because it will deliver lasting benefits. However, the group also feels businesses in Canada and the U.S. urgently need more certainty. Dan Kelly, the president and CEO of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB), blasted the U.S. administration for its tariff rationale. The hike in U.S. tariffs to 35 per cent will harm small businesses on both sides of the border. The fentanyl rationale is even more ridiculous than the decision itself, Kelly said in a statement. CFIB supports the view that no deal is better than a bad deal, but the lack of resolution means small firms will not be able to plan for the future or continue to put off difficult choices. WATCH | Scarcity of goods will force a trade deal by September, O'Toole says: Kelly's sentiment was echoed by the United Steelworkers union on Friday. While we're disappointed an agreement wasn't reached to end this trade war, the worst outcome would have been a deal that locked in permanent damage to our economy, national director Marty Warren said in a statement. Warren encouraged Ottawa to take retaliatory action if necessary. This fight is far from over. The federal government must remain steadfast to secure the right deal for the Canadian economy and Canadian workers and must not accept anything less. Premiers urge Ottawa to stand its ground Ontario Premier Doug Ford called the tariff increase concerning and said Ottawa should retaliate with 50 per cent tariffs on U.S. steel and aluminum. Canada shouldn't settle for anything less than the right deal, Ford said on X Thursday night. Now is not the time to roll over. We need to stand our ground. Quebec Premier François Legault called Trump's latest move disappointing and argued that it will hurt Americans. Recent events highlight the importance we must place on diversifying our markets and increasing our economic autonomy, Legault wrote on X in French. We are in contact with the federal government and other provinces regarding the next steps. Discussions with the American administration must continue. In any case, we will defend the interests of Quebecers. New Brunswick Premier Susan Holt said Canada should still push for a good deal. Canada has what the world wants, and we should not settle for anything less than the best deal for New Brunswickers, she wrote Friday on X. Canada is coming together like never before to support our local businesses, workers and build a strong and resilient economy. We have your back. Darren Major (new window) · CBC News · Senior writer Darren Major is a senior writer for CBC's parliamentary bureau in Ottawa. He previously worked as a digital reporter for CBC Ottawa and a producer for CBC's Power & Politics. He holds a master's degree in journalism and a bachelor's degree in public affairs and policy management, both from Carleton University. He also holds master's degree in arts from Queen's University. He can be reached at With files from Katie Simpson and The Canadian Press
18 hours ago
Canada 'disappointed' by Trump boosting tariffs to 35%, says Carney
Prime Minister Mark Carney released a statement (new window) just past midnight on Friday after U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order to increase a tariff on Canadian goods to 35 per cent. "While the Canadian government is disappointed by this action, we remain committed to [the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement (new window) ], which is the world's second-largest free trade agreement by trading volume," the statement read. The U.S. application of CUSMA means that the U.S. average tariff rate on Canadian goods remains one of its lowest for all of its trading partners. Other sectors of our economy — including lumber, steel, aluminum and automobiles — are, however, heavily impacted by U.S. duties and tariffs. He says the Canadian government will act to protect Canadian jobs, invest in industrial competitiveness, buy Canadian and diversify export markets. Even though the vast bulk of Canada's exports can still cross the border tariff-free, Trump's executive order (new window) increases the tariff rate, which had been set at 25 per cent since March (new window) , to 35 per cent (new window) starting Friday. WATCH | Trump speaks at the White House just hours before tariff deadline: The order cites Canada's lack of co-operation in stemming the flood of fentanyl and other illicit drugs across our northern border and the fact that Canada has retaliated against the United States for the president's actions. Border security improvements Carney's statement also outlined all the work Canada has been doing to crack down on fentanyl and increase border security. Canada accounts for only one per cent of U.S. fentanyl imports and has been working intensively to further reduce these volumes, he said. Canada's government is making historic investments in border security to arrest drug traffickers, take down transnational gangs and end migrant smuggling. Carney says they have hired thousands of new law enforcement and border security officers, implemented aerial surveillance and increased Canada's intelligence and security operations. Speaking to reporters at the White House, Trump was asked whether Carney's announcement that Canada plans to recognize a Palestinian state (new window) was a deal-breaker on trade. I didn't like what they said, but you know, that's their opinion, Trump said. Not a deal-breaker. But we haven't spoken to Canada today. He's called and we'll see. Negotiations ongoing Trump told NBC News Thursday evening that he was open to further discussions with Canada, adding that he may even speak with Carney later in the night. Carney's office would not confirm that a call was placed to the White House, and told CBC News it is not confirming any details about the ongoing negotiations. In a separate executive order on Thursday, Trump hit dozens of countries around the world with new across-the-board tariff rates ranging from 15 to 41 per cent (new window) . After speaking with Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum, Trump gave Mexico a 90-day extension (new window) of its current tariff regime, despite having previously threatened to raise the rate effective Friday. Canada's trade negotiating team is in Washington, but officials were tight-lipped Thursday about who they were meeting with — if anyone. WATCH | Canadians' boycott of U.S. booze draws attention south of the border: Tariffs remain 'unjustified,' says Poilievre Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre took to social media Thursday evening, calling the tariffs unjustified and saying his party continues to hold out hope for a deal to end all tariffs. That means zero tariffs on our steel, aluminum, softwood, autos, energy, agriculture and everything else, he wrote on the social media platform X. That is the deal Canada had before and the prime minister should accept nothing short of that. Earlier, Ontario Premier Doug Ford called the tariff increase concerning and said Ottawa should retaliate with 50 per cent tariffs on U.S. steel and aluminum. Canada shouldn't settle for anything less than the right deal, Ford said on X. Now is not the time to roll over. We need to stand our ground. Enlarge image (new window) Note: Trade deals are preliminary. Photo: CBC Union wants to see action Unifor national president Lana Payne said she agrees with Ford. This is the fight of our lives, said Payne, whose union represents some 40,000 autoparts and assembly workers in Canada. And we need to use all our leverage to fight for Canadian workers and their jobs. The stakes are high but we can do this Canada! For more than a week, Carney and other Canadian officials have been downplaying the likelihood (new window) of getting a deal by the deadline. They've also cast doubt on the urgency, given the exemption that allows roughly 90 per cent of Canadian exports to enter the U.S. tariff-free. David Paterson, Ontario's representative in Washington, told CBC's Power & Politics guest host David Common that Canadians should not be overreacting to the lack of a deal right now. WATCH | The latest from Washington, D.C. : The sun will shine in the morning and we will carry on, Paterson said Thursday from his office in Canada's embassy in Washington. We really support the prime minister's approach. When the time is right for that agreement to come together, it will. Comments from U.S. officials White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt suggested earlier Thursday the threatened tariff increases would kick in unless Trump reached last-minute deals with trading partners. Those countries that either do not have a deal or have a letter, they will be hearing from this administration by the midnight deadline tonight, Leavitt told reporters in a briefing. Trump's Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick criticized Canada for being one of the only countries to retaliate against Trump's tariffs. I just don't see the president stepping off the gas, Lutnick said in an interview on Fox Business Network. Trump issued similar ultimatums with the same Aug. 1 deadline to 17 major trading partners across the globe, including the European Union, Japan and Taiwan. Each contained threats of tariffs in the range of 30 per cent. Last week, Trump announced deals with the EU and Japan (new window) with across-the-board tariffs of 15 per cent, as well as vague commitments for hundreds of billions of dollars of investment in the U.S. A pending legal challenge Separately, Trump has imposed a 50 per cent tariff on steel and aluminum imports (new window) from around the world. Canada is the top supplier of both products to the U.S. For the 35 per cent tariff that specifically targets Canada, Trump used a law that allows the U.S. president to take emergency economic measures to deal with any unusual and extraordinary threat to national security. He cited the supposed flow of fentanyl across the country's northern border as that threat. That tariff is facing a legal challenge (new window) that has now reached a federal appeals court, putting it further along in the U.S. court system than any other tariff lawsuit. Mike Crawley (new window) · CBC News · Senior reporter Mike Crawley has covered Ontario politics for CBC News since 2009. He began his career as a newspaper reporter in B.C., spent six years as a freelance journalist in various parts of Africa, then joined the CBC in 2005. Mike was born and raised in Saint John, N.B. Follow Mike Crawley on Twitter (new window) With files from CBC News
CBC
21 hours ago
- CBC
A Calgary woman was unable to complete a breathalyzer test. Now, she can't drive
A Calgary woman says she had her driver's licence suspended after being unable to complete a breathalyzer test — and some experts say the situation is more common than you might think. Pam Lacusta, 58, was driving on Stoney Trail in April when she was pulled over by Calgary police, who administered a breathalyzer test. Lacusta attempted the test 30 times and couldn't complete it. The officer handed her an administrative penalty for failing to provide a proper breath sample — a penalty that carries the same consequences as driving while impaired. Now, Lacusta must complete a driver's education course and install an interlock device in her car before she can drive again. Her prior insurance now refuses to cover her. "I feel like I'm being punished for something that I never did," said Lacusta, who said she doesn't drink for religious reasons. Later on the day she was ticketed, Lacusta took a urine test at a private clinic at her own expense to prove she wasn't drinking. She sent CBC News a copy of the negative results. Edmonton-based paralegal Sandra Weber said she hears of situations like Lacusta's fairly regularly. Weber said people may struggle to complete a roadside test due to medical conditions like lung cancer or asthma, compounded by the stress of completing a test in front of an officer. Once someone has received a penalty for failing to complete a breathalyzer, she said, it can be difficult to fight. "It's up to the recipient … to prove that there was something wrong with the machine or something that the police had done wrong," said Weber, who works with Moreau Law. "It's a very challenging situation and without any medical evidence it's very difficult to overcome these types of tickets." Lacusta did appeal her penalty with a provincial adjudicator, who turned her down. Lacusta said her difficulty with the test may have been due to a recent Botox injection that kept her from making a proper seal with her mouth. She also later learned that she had two suspected rib fractures, but not in time to include that information in her appeal. 'Not enough puff' Recent research out of the University of Sheffield in the U.K. suggests there may be people without severe lung or breathing problems who nevertheless struggle to complete breathalyzer tests. "There is a small, but significant, subset of people who just don't have enough puff to be able to operate the machine successfully," said lead researcher Galen Ives, who noted that older people, short people and women are more likely to struggle. Ives said police should be more willing to offer blood or urine tests as an alternative to people who try and fail to complete breathalyzer tests, though he acknowledged there would be practical hurdles to testing at a second location. A spokesperson for the Calgary Police Service said she couldn't comment on Lacusta's situation, but said anyone who believes they are medically unable to complete a breathalyzer test should tell the officer at the scene. A spokesperson for the provincial minister of justice said if people can't provide breath samples they may be asked to provide blood or urine samples "where certain legal requirements are met." Lacusta said blood and urine tests were not offered in her situation, and she believes they should be more widely available to people who can't provide a breath sample. For now, she's relying on her friends and her bicycle to get around the city, but still hopes to fight her penalty and have her clean driving record restored.
