Hunter Valley bus crash driver's next move
Ten people died when a bus flipped on Wine Country Drive near Greta on the way back from a wedding reception on June 11, 2023.
Bus driver Brett Button had taken 'significantly more' than his prescribed dose of the opioid-based painkiller Tramadol on the day of the horrific crash.
He'd also been stood down by a previous employer just a year prior after a pain specialist found he was addicted to Tramadol — which he'd been taking since the 1990s — and he did not tell operator Linq Buslines he was using the painkiller. Ten people died in the Hunter Valley bus crash. NewsWire / Christian Gilles Credit: NCA NewsWire
Button initially faced 10 counts of manslaughter, however; they were ultimately dropped after prosecutors agreed to a plea deal, much to the anger of the victims' families.
He pleaded guilty to 10 counts of dangerous driving occasioning death and nine of dangerous driving occasioning grievous bodily harm.
Button was sentenced to 32 years behind bars with a non-parole period of 24 years last year.
However, he has since moved to fight the sentence, with the matter heard briefly in Sydney's Court of Criminal Appeal on Thursday morning.
The Crown prosecutor told the court that it was an 'unusual matter'.
'It is only a sentence appeal – I don't use the word only lightly,' she told the court.
'There are three grounds of appeal.
'It is an unusual matter.'
The grounds of appeal are expected to be released sometime on Thursday or Friday, registrar Peter Clayton told the court. Brett Button was jailed over the fatal crash. NewsWire / Damian Shaw Credit: NCA NewsWire He is fighting his sentence. NewsWire / Jeremy Piper Credit: News Corp Australia
She said there would be several victim impact statements in the 'fairly lengthy' Crown bundle.
'As I indicated, a number of victim impact statements, medical reports … quite a volume of documentary evidence,' she said.
She also indicated there'd be character references for Button.
Lawyers for Button didn't expect there to be re-sentencing materials put before the court at this stage.
He is set to front the court via a video link for a hearing on October 3.
Andrew Scott, 35, his wife Lynan Scott, 33, Nadene McBride, 52, her daughter Kyah McBride, 22, and her partner, Kane Symons, 21, Darcy Bulman, 30, Rebecca Mullen, 26, Zachary Bray, 29, Tori Cowburn, 29, and Angus Craig, 28, were killed in the crash.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
‘Virus': Sad claim at anti-Semitism hearing
An inquiry into anti-Semitism across Australia has been told the 'terrible virus' is spreading across the country. Last July the Federal Government appointed Australia's first Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism (ASECA), following a rise in apparent anti-Semitic attacks. Jillian Segal AO told a hearing at NSW parliament on Friday a spate of anti-Semitic acts in NSW over the past summer have contributed to 'anxiety and unease' in the Jewish community. 'Anti-Semitism is such a terrible virus that eats away at our fundamental Australian values,' she said. Anti Semitic attacks are on the rise across the country, a parliamentary hearing has been told. NewsWire / Simon Bullard. Credit: News Corp Australia Strike Force Pearl was formed following a spate of alleged anti-Semitic attacks across NSW. NewsWire Credit: NewsWire Since her appointment to the envoy nearly 12 months ago, Ms Segal told the parliamentary hearing she has met with many political and civil leaders across the country. Anti-Semitic acts that Ms Segal referenced included the caravan full of explosives found in Dural, NSW in January which appeared to target the Jewish community. 'The Dural caravan contained explosives and it deliberately targeted the Jewish community and created a sense of vulnerability among the Jewish community,' she said. Ms Segal said the assertion that the Dural caravan was 'merely a harmless hoax' and 'did not in fact terrorise the Jewish community' was false. 'Whether or not the caravan was ultimately intended to be used in a terror attack, it had the effect of causing a great deal of fear and anxiety in the Jewish community, which was already on edge following the succession of arson and graffiti attacks, as well as the terror attack on the Adass Israel synagogue in Melbourne,' she said. Ms Segal was asked about the impacts of a violent pro-Palestinian rally at the Sydney Opera House, on October 9, 2023, following Hamas attacks, and if those events 'set the tone for everything that has happened following that incident.' 'I think it was a terrible incident that did indicate to people who were underlying anti-Semitic that they could continue behaving that way,' she said. 'Anti-Semitism is a hatred and behaving that way in that community is shaped by leadership. 'Leadership is incredibly important and leader's condemning certain attitudes and behaviours sets the tone. Jillian Segal AO has spoken at a parliamentary hearing. . Supplied Credit: Supplied 'I don't think everything that has happened has been a result of that … but it was an opportunity for it to be stamped out.' Ms Segal said Jewish Australians should not have to live in fear. 'No Jewish person should be told it's not safe to visit the opera house, or to visit a NSW hospital. Or worry about the safety of their children at a Jewish school,' she said. Rising anti-Semitism is being seen 'everywhere', Ms Segal said, which requires a range of approaches. 'We need a whole host of responses not only individual leadership but we need legislation, condemnation and education,' she said. 'We need to make sure it doesn't in any way send the message that it is acceptable.' Deputy Commissioner David Hudson NSW Police Force told the hearing 33 per cent of reports of hate crimes to his team have been of an anti-Semitic nature. NSW Police have received a total of 1,121 reports of anti-Semitic acts so far in 2025, the inquiry was told. 'This type of behaviour and offending is not going away,' Mr Hudson said. Strike force Pearl formed to investigate anti-Semitic acts, has seen 14 incidents which were on the 'higher end of the spectrum' of offending, Mr Hudson said, which included attacks and firebombing of Jewish centres and synagogues. 'We certainly believe they were anti-Semitic in nature … the Jewish community was targeted, they were putting lives in danger and ultimately I don't think we would consider it anything but anti-Semitic in nature,' he said. Those 14 attacks were allegedly conducted by criminal networks, Mr Hudson said, with one 'individual of interest' seen as a catalyst for those incidents, who had allegedly made social media posts that were anti-Semitic in nature.
Perth Now
3 hours ago
- Perth Now
Dad's suspicion foils child sex plot
A young resort worker is behind bars after attempting to meet up with a young boy for sex which was only uncovered after the boy's father became suspicious. Luke Edward Reynolds, 29, was sentenced in the Brisbane District Court on Friday after pleading guilty to multiple child sex offences, including grooming and attempting to meet a 13-year-old boy. The former tour boat worker, who appeared in court wearing jeans, a jacket, and glasses, pleaded guilty to two counts of using electronic communication to procure a child under 16, three counts of indecent treatment of a child under 16 (expose), one count of indecent treatment of a child under 16, and one count of possessing child exploitation material. Luke Edward Reynolds, 29, was sentenced in the Brisbane District Court on Friday after pleading guilty to multiple child sex offences, including grooming and attempting to meet a 13-year-old boy. NewsWire/Tertius Pickard Credit: News Corp Australia The court was told that Reynolds, communicated with the 13-year-old initially through an online chat room before moving their conversations to Snapchat, where the exchanges became sexual in nature. Both exchanged nude photos with each other. The Crown Prosecutor said Reynolds' acts were 'persistent, predatory and premeditated', noting the 'significant age gap' between him and the boy. He said the conversations were 'heavily sexual in nature,' and Reynolds would also send the boy pictures found online. On one occasion, Reynolds sent a photo of a cooler bag containing two bottles of lubricant and condoms. The court was told Reynolds first arranged to meet the boy at Cannon Hill, but the boy became nervous and left on his pushbike without going through with it. Reynolds messaged the boy again later that day to arrange another meeting and continued to send explicit messages. The court was told that Reynolds, communicated with the 13-year-old initially through an online chat room before moving their conversations to Snapchat, where the exchanges became sexual in nature. Both exchanged nude photos with each other. NewsWire/Tertius Pickard Credit: News Corp Australia When the boy returned home, his father became suspicious and demanded to check his phone. After discovering the messages, he immediately contacted police. Officers took over the boy's account and continued the conversation with Reynolds, who sent nude images and arranged another meeting. During the second planned meet-up, police moved in and arrested him. At the time of his arrest, he had lubricant and condoms and a towel in a cooler bag. Police also found two images of naked children on his phone. The judge noted that Reynolds 'at all times ... believed [the boy] was under 16'. Reynolds' barrister told the court his client was remorseful and had suffered significant consequences as a result of the offending. He noted the case had attracted widespread media attention and said Reynolds lost his job at a resort following his arrest, effectively being 'driven out of that industry.' Since then, he had struggled to find new employment. When the boy returned home, his father became suspicious and demanded to check his phone. After discovering the messages, he immediately contacted police. NewsWire/Tertius Pickard Credit: News Corp Australia The court was also told Reynolds' mental health had 'plummeted' since the incident. A psychological report described him as 'sexually naïve' and suffering from depression. It also revealed he had a lonely upbringing, was 'a bit of a loner,' and had never been in a relationship or had any previous sexual experiences. The report stated he did not fit the criteria for someone with paedophilia. While Reynolds initially had the support of his family, the court was told his father had 'severed all contact' after learning of the offending. The defence submitted that Reynolds had 'good prospects' of rehabilitation, pointing to his minimal criminal history, willingness to seek help, and completion of relevant courses since his arrest. However, Judge Brad Farr SC described Reynolds' actions as 'demonstrably serious' and 'abhorrent' to society. Judge Farr noted that although the boy initially said he was 14, Reynolds told him he looked younger than 13 when they met. Reynolds was sentenced to two years' imprisonment, suspended after six months, followed by a probation period with strict conditions, including a special order for psychiatric treatment. NewsWire/Tertius Pickard Credit: News Corp Australia The judge described Reynolds' actions as 'quite calculated' and highlighted his persistence, even after the boy became frightened following the first attempted meeting. While accepting Reynolds' remorse as genuine, the judge also considered his early guilty plea and lack of relevant criminal history. He sentenced Reynolds to two years' imprisonment, suspended after six months, followed by a probation period with strict conditions, including a special order for psychiatric treatment. Reynolds was taken into custody immediately after sentencing.
Perth Now
6 hours ago
- Perth Now
Kindy cop vow after childcare charges
Education Minister Jason Clare has vowed new laws to allow on-the-spot compliance checks at childcare centres after childcare worker Joshua Brown was charged with dozens of child sex offences. Mr Brown, 26, was charged with 70 offences after he allegedly abused eight children at a Point Cook childcare centre in Melbourne. It is alleged some children were as young as five months, and the charges have resulted in 1200 children being asked to undergo infectious disease testing. Conceding that 'not enough has been done, and not fast enough' to keep children safe, Mr Clare said legislation would be introduced within the first sitting fortnight once parliament resumes on July 22. Once passed, the new laws would allow fraud investigators to conduct random, unannounced visits at childcare centres without a warrant, and without the need to be accompanied by police. Jason Clare said the new laws would be introduced within the first fortnight once parliament resumes sitting on July 22. NewsWire/ Nikki Short Credit: News Corp Australia Separate laws will also allow the federal government, which currently provides $16bn of annual funding to centres, to scrap payments to places which do not meet standards. 'One of the big weapons that the Commonwealth has, probably the biggest, is the funding that we provide to childcare centres, something like $16 billion a year,' he told Sky on Friday. 'Centers run based on that funding. If they don't get it, they can't operate. And what I'm saying is, if they're not meeting those standards that we expect, then we should have the power to pull that funding off them. So the Bill will do that. 'The bill will also make sure that centres that aren't meeting those minimum standards can't expand and open another centre.' Mr Clare said there were about 150 staff in the investigate team, with the government also able to draw in investigators from state based regulators. He noted that while the initiative will cost money, it would ultimately help the budget bottom line by reducing fraudulent claims. 'The investment of about an extra $200 million over the last few years has clawed back more than that in money we've saved from the fraud investigations,' he said. The proposed laws come after a Melbourne man and alleged pedophile was hit with more than 70 charges including child sexual assault. Picture Supplied., Credit: Supplied Mr Clare said joint federal and state education ministers will consider how CCTV cameras could be used as a deterrent against unscrupulous behaviour but said they had to 'be in the right places if deterrence is going to work'. 'How you set them up is just as critical as whether you've got them there at all,' he said. There could also be stronger laws in relation to real-time updates on working-with-children checks when Attorney-General Michelle Rowland convenes a meeting with state attorney generals in August. The long called-for changes were an initial recommendation made in the 2015 Royal Commission into Institutionalised Responses to Child Sexual Abuse. Attorneys-General will consider how states and territories can better share information across borders and look at strategies to 'improve criminal record checks and the criminal record check system'. However Mr Clare warned these solutions were not a 'silver bullet'. 'I'm not going to comment specifically on the case in Victoria, because it will be before the court, but in other examples, we've found people who have been convicted of assaulting children in child care centres where they had a criminal record check. Why? Because they didn't have a criminal record and so they got through the system,' he said. Joshua Brown has been hit with 70 charges. Supplied Credit: Supplied 'The truth is here there's no silver bullet. There's a whole bunch of things that we need to do. And this work will never end. 'There are always going to be more things that we need to do here, because there's always going to be people who are going to try and break through the net to try to do the dastardly things that we've seen other people do.' Bravehearts chief executive Alison Geale welcomed the proposed changes but hoped the 'vigour and rigour extends beyond this news cycle because these cases are happening almost weekly'. 'I think that any measure that's taken in isolation isn't the one answer. There is systemic reform, societal reform that needs to happen,' she told Sky. The proposed changes after Mr Brown, a 26-year-old former childcare worker, was hit with 70 offences including sexual assault, and the possession of child pornography. Victorian authorities have since confirmed he worked at 20 childcare centres between January 2017 and May 2025. About 2600 families have been contacted, with 1200 children being urged to undergo testing for infectious disease as a precaution. He will appear at Melbourne Magistrate's Court on September 15.
