Lawsuit centers on power struggle over elections in Arizona's most populous county
County Recorder Justin Heap filed a lawsuit Thursday in state court with the backing of America First Legal, a conservative public interest group founded by Stephen Miller, who is now the White House deputy chief of staff.
Heap, a former GOP state lawmaker who has questioned election administration in Arizona's most populous county, has been at odds with the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors for months over an agreement that would divide election operations between the two offices.
After taking office in January, Heap terminated a previous agreement that was reached between his predecessor and the board. He claimed in his lawsuit it would have restrained his power to run elections by reducing funding and IT resources for the recorder's office.
Last year's agreement also gave the board authority over early ballot processing, which drew criticism from Heap in his lawsuit.
Heap is asking the court to undo what the lawsuit calls 'unlawful' actions by the board and to issue an order requiring the board to fund expenses he deems necessary.
'Despite their repeated misinformation and gaslighting of the public on these issues, defending the civil right to free, fair and honest elections for every Maricopa County voter isn't simply my job as county recorder, it's the right thing to do and a mission I'm fully committed to achieving,' Heap said in a statement Thursday.
The board's chair and vice chair have called the legal challenge frivolous, saying Heap is wasting taxpayer money by going to court.
Negotiations between the offices have been ongoing since the beginning of the year, and the board said in a statement that it appeared things were going well after a meeting in April. It was only weeks later, the board said, that Heap came back with what he called a final offer that included dozens of changes.
Heap claims in the lawsuit that the board rejected his proposed agreement in late May. In a statement, America First Legal says the board separately voted on a tentative budget that shifts Heap's key duties and underfunds the recorder's office.
'From day one, Recorder Heap has been making promises that the law doesn't allow him to keep," Board Chairman Thomas Galvin said. "Arizona election statutes delineate election administration between county boards of supervisors and recorders to ensure there are checks and balances, and Recorder Heap clearly doesn't understand the responsibilities of his position.'
Following President Donald Trump's 2020 loss, Maricopa County became an epicenter for election conspiracy theories. Heap has stopped short of saying the 2020 and 2022 elections were stolen, but he has said the state's practices for handling early ballots are insecure and has questioned how ballots are transported, handled and stored after they are submitted. Last year, Heap proposed an unsuccessful bill to remove Arizona from a multistate effort to maintain voter lists.
Heap's predecessor, Stephen Richer, was rebuked in some GOP circles for defending the legitimacy of the 2020 and 2022 elections, in which Democrats including former President Joe Biden and Gov. Katie Hobbs won by razor-thin margins. Trump won Arizona in 2024, along with the other battleground states.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
MS-13 leader sentenced to 68 years in federal case involving 8 Long Island murders
The leader of an MS-13 clique in New York City's suburbs was sentenced Wednesday to 68 years in prison in a federal racketeering case involving eight Long Island murders, including the 2016 killings of two high school girls that focused the nation's attention on the violent Central American street gang. Alexi Saenz pleaded guilty last year for his role in ordering and approving the killings as well as other crimes during a rash of bloody violence that prompted President Donald Trump to make several visits to Long Island and call for the death penalty for Saenz and other gang members during his first term in the White House. Saenz's lawyers sought a sentence of 45 years behind bars, but prosecutors wanted the judge to impose the maximum sentence of 70 years. Prosecutors, who previously withdrew their intent to seek the death penalty, said Saenz deserves to live out his days in prison for his 'senseless' and 'sadistic' crimes. 5 AP Judge Gary Brown, in handing down the sentence, said the reduction of two years from the maximum recognized Saenz's role in pleading guilty and avoiding a painful and costly trial, as well as his efforts in convincing his younger brother, the gang's second-in-command, to do the same. 'This small adjustment is more than what was afforded to his victims,' the judge said, 'none of whom will ever enjoy another day on this planet.' Saenz, addressing the court, asked for forgiveness from God, his family and the relatives of the victims. 'I know my apology will not repair the harm and the pain that I have caused,' the now 30-year-old said in Spanish through a translator. 'I know many of you do not accept my apology, but I want to say from the bottom of my heart that these words are sincere.' 5 Mother of Nisa Mickens an alleged victim of High-ranking MS-13 gang member Alexi Saenz, speaks outside of Central Islip Federal Court after a hearing and possible plea deal for her daughters alleged killer. Dennis A. Clark Saenz's lawyers said he suffers from intellectual disabilities and lasting trauma from a difficult upbringing in his native El Salvador that allowed him to be recruited and unwittingly 'groomed' into MS-13. But Saenz said he did not want to use his 'hard life' as an excuse. 'I do not recognize the person who committed these crimes,' he said in court. Prosecutor Paul Scotti rejected Saenz's comments as 'self-serving' and 'not sincere.' He argued that Saenz remains committed to MS-13, citing his 'extensive disciplinary record' while in custody at a federal lockup in New York City. 5 George Johnson, whose son, Michael, was viciously beaten by MS-13 gangsters, speaks outside of Federal Court in Central Islip, NY. Dennis A. Clark Prosecutors have cited photos of him posing with other gang members behind bars and displaying gang signs and gang paraphernalia. They also said Saenz was disciplined for assaulting other inmates, refusing staff orders and possessing sharpened metal shanks, cellphones and other contraband. 'Actions speak, louder than words,' Scotti said in court. Saenz, also known as 'Blasty' and 'Big Homie,' was the leader of an MS-13 clique operating in Brentwood and Central Islip known as Sailors Locos Salvatruchas Westside. 5 Prosecutors have cited photos of him posing with other gang members behind bars and displaying gang signs and gang paraphernalia. Calabro, Peter B. (NY) (FBI) He admitted last July that he'd authorized the eight killings and three other attempted killings of perceived rivals and others who had disrespected or feuded with the clique. Among the killings were those of Kayla Cuevas, 16, and Nisa Mickens, 15, lifelong friends and classmates at Brentwood High School who were slain with a machete and a baseball bat. Authorities said there had been a dispute weeks earlier between one of the girls and gang members. Other victims included Javier Castillo, 15, of Central Islip, who was befriended by gang members only to be cut down with a machete in an isolated marsh. 5 Mother of High-ranking MS-13 gang member Alexi Saenz, leaves court after a hearing and possible plea deal for her son. Dennis A. Clark Another victim, Oscar Acosta, 19, was found dead in a wooded area near railroad tracks nearly five months after he left his Brentwood home to play soccer. Saenz also admitted to arson, firearms offenses and drug trafficking — the proceeds of which went toward buying firearms, more drugs and providing contributions to the wider MS-13 gang. MS-13, or Mara Salvatrucha, is a transnational criminal organization believed to have been founded as a neighborhood street gang in Los Angeles in the mid-1980s by people fleeing civil war in El Salvador.
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Judge ends order blocking deportation of family of man charged in Boulder firebomb attack
DENVER (AP) — A federal judge on Wednesday ended an order blocking the deportation of the family of the man charged in the fatal firebomb attack in Boulder, Colorado, noting government lawyers say the man's relatives are not being rushed out of the country as the White House originally stated. Hayam El Gamal and her five children were detained by immigration agents on June 3, two days after her husband Mohamed Sabry Soliman was accused of throwing two Molotov cocktails at people demonstrating for awareness of Israeli hostages in Gaza. Prosecutors announced Monday that an 82-year-old woman who was injured in the attack had died. U.S. District Judge Orlando L. Garica dismissed the family's lawsuit challenging their detention by immigration authorities. The ruling noted that El Gamal and her children ages 4 to 18 are not eligible for expedited deportations because they have been in the country for over two years, which he said lawyers for the Department of Homeland Security and Immigration and Customs Enforcement have acknowledged. Soliman is an Egyptian national who federal authorities say was living in the U.S. illegally. He is being prosecuted in both state and federal court for the attack, which prosecutors say injured a total of 13 people. Investigators say he planned the attack for a year and was driven by a desire 'to kill all Zionist people.' He has pleaded not guilty to federal hate crimes charges but hasn't been asked to enter a plea in the state case, which now includes a murder charge. On the day El Gamal and her children were arrested, the White House said in social media posts that they 'COULD BE DEPORTED AS EARLY AS TONIGHT' and that six one-way tickets had been purchased for them, with their 'final boarding call coming soon." Those statements led a federal judge in Colorado to issue an emergency order temporarily blocking the family's deportation, Garcia said. The case was later transferred to Texas, where the family is being held in an immigration detention center for families. Garcia is based in San Antonio. Because the family is in regular deportation proceedings, there is no longer any reason to block their deportation, Garcia said. Regular proceedings can take months or even years if decisions are appealed. He also turned down the family's request to be released from the detention center in the meantime, saying they can pursue release through the normal bond process in the immigration system. Lawyers for the family had challenged their detention as unconstitutional because they said it was intended to punish them for Soliman's actions. According to a court filing by El Gamal's lawyers, one of the immigration agents who arrested them told her, 'You have to pay for the consequences of what you did.' Garcia said immigration authorities have discretion in deciding who to detain and he did not have authority to review their decision to detain El Gamal and her children. Lawyers for the government said they are being lawfully held because they are accused of overstaying their visas. One of the family's attorneys, Niels Frenzen, said they hoped to get the family released from the detention center while the deportation proceedings continue.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
If she runs for Senate, Lara Trump would need to move back to NC by this fall
As Republicans now face an open race for their party's nomination for U.S. Senate next year, the one name that has shot to the top of the list is Lara Trump. The president's daughter-in-law co-chaired the Republican National Committee during Donald Trump's successful bid for the White House last year and currently hosts a weekly television show on Fox News. She is 'strongly considering' running for the seat that will be vacated by retiring Sen. Thom Tillis, NBC News reported Sunday. Her entry into the race could effectively end the GOP primary before it even begins. Her father-in-law had encouraged her to run for the U.S. Senate seat that opened with the retirement of Richard Burr in 2022, and when he was asked about the 2026 race on Tuesday, he said she would be his 'first choice.' Other prominent Republicans whose names have been floated as potential candidates have either taken themselves out of the running, like U.S. Rep. Richard Hudson, or have preemptively endorsed Trump's candidacy, should she decide to enter the race, as first-term congressman Pat Harrigan did. If Trump does move forward with a Senate bid, she'll need to take certain steps to ensure her eligibility, the most important of which would be to move back to North Carolina and register to vote here. A Wilmington native, Trump grew up in Wrightsville Beach and studied communications at N.C. State University before moving to New York, where she met her now-husband, Eric Trump, one of the president's sons. Lara Trump was registered to vote in Wake County while she attended college at N.C. State, and voted in the 2000, 2002 and 2004 general elections in North Carolina, according to the State Board of Elections. She has since been removed from the North Carolina voter list. Later, Trump lived in New York, where she reportedly voted in 2016 the first time her father-in-law won. Since September 2021, Trump has been a registered voter in Palm Beach County, Florida, according to the Florida Department of State. The N.C. State Board of Elections points to only three 'general candidate requirements' for running for U.S. Senate. Per federal law, candidates must be at least 30 years old, a U.S. citizen for at least nine years, and a resident of the state they are running from by the date of the general election. State law, however, requires candidates running in a party primary to be 'affiliated with that party for at least 90 days' as of the date that person officially files their notice of candidacy. Candidate filing for the 2026 primary election is currently scheduled to begin at noon on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025 and end at noon on Friday, Dec. 19, 2025. That means that if Trump decides to seek the Republican Party's nomination, she would need to move to North Carolina and register to vote here as a Republican by Sept. 20, 2025, at the latest. Other candidates for U.S. Senate who have gone on to win and represent North Carolina in Washington have grown up here, lived here, or have otherwise had ties here, but lived elsewhere at the time they began thinking about a campaign, and had to move back to the state to run. Former Sen. Elizabeth Dole, for example, took the first step towards running in the 2002 election when she registered to vote in her native Rowan County the previous August, declaring herself a legal resident of the state based in Salisbury, after spending more than three decades in Washington. At the time, Dole, a Republican, listed her residence as her childhood home on South Fulton Street, where her 100-year-old mother continued to live, according to a report in the Charlotte Observer, and turned in her registration form in person at the Rowan County administrative building.
