Advocates worry about message to survivors following Hockey Canada sex assault trial
A sexual assault expert in Waterloo Region is calling for more education following the Hockey Canada court verdict. CTV's Heather Senoran explains why.
Advocates in Waterloo Region are raising concerns following the conclusion of a high-profile sexual assault case.
On Thursday, Ontario Superior Court Justice Maria Carroccia acquitted all five former Hockey Canada players involved in a sexual assault trial.
Sara Casselman, executive director at the Sexual Assault Centre Waterloo Region (SASCWR), said the verdict only tells part of the story.
'I do think with the not guilty verdicts, we have to be very careful,' she said. 'That does not mean that someone is not guilty of causing harm. And in this case, harm definitely happened.'
SASCWR has been closely following the trial, and even has a wall of support for the woman at the centre of the case, who is only known as E.M. due to a publication order. E.M. claimed she had been sexually assaulted by the players in a London, Ont. hotel. The wall at SASCWR has 'We believe E.M.' written across the top in chalk with other messages of support underneath.
E.M. chalk board wall Sexual Assault Centre Waterloo Region (SASCWR)
A chalk board at the Sexual Assault Centre Waterloo Region (SASCWR) showed messages of support for E.M. on July 24, 2025. (Heather Senoran/CTV News)
'We, as survivor advocates, are taking this whole thing as a call to action because she stepped up, and so are we,' Casselman said.
Casselman told CTV News she is worried about how the outcome of the case could influence sexual assault survivors because many victims are too scared to come forward with their claims.
'With a 6 per cent reporting rate, and then about one in ten of those causes actually having a conviction, we know that the justice system doesn't often serve survivors well,' she said.
A key component of the case revolved around consent. E.M. said she was intoxicated during the events that transpired at the hotel. However, defence lawyers submitted video that they argued showed she wasn't showing signs of extreme intoxication.
'I think way more consent education is needed. Folks should learn very young if someone is inebriated, they can't consent to sexual activity,' Casselman said.
Casselman said she's heard about similar cases over the two decades she has been supporting survivors. She believes 'playful locker room banter' can turn into a toxic environment.
'We've seen that there is definitely a link between that toxic sport culture and sexual violence,' she said.
Last week, the Kitchener Rangers pledged $50,000 to help the SASCWR offer free training to young hockey players in the community, with a focus around healthy relationships and consent.
SASCWR also provides Ontario Hockey League-mandated OHL ONSIDE training to Rangers players and staff and has recently been asked by the league to take on an expanded role and facilitate the training for all of its 20 teams.
'Coaches, administrators and players who want to be allies and leaders in this work need to set a new bar in terms of expectations about how they treat women, about how they obtained consent, and about what it means to be a man,' Casselman said.
Casselman wants survivors to know there is still value in coming forward. She often hears survivors do it because they don't want it to happen to someone else. If needed, the SASCWR has a legal team that can help survivors through the entire process as it can be tough to navigate a sexual assault case in the legal system.
If you or someone you know is struggling with sexual assault or trauma, the following resources are available to support people in crisis:
If you are in immediate danger or fear for your safety, you should call 911.
A full list of sexual assault centres in Canada that offer information, advocacy and counselling can be found on the website for the Canadian Association of Sexual Assault Centres.
Helplines, legal services and locations that offer sexual assault kits in Alberta, B.C., Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Quebec, Ontario and Nova Scotia can be found here.
National Residential School Crisis Line: +1 866 925 4419
24-hour crisis line: 416 597 8808
Canadian Human Trafficking Hotline: +1 833 900 1010
Trans Lifeline: +1 877 330 6366
Sexual misconduct support for current or former members of the Armed Forces: +1 844 750 1648
Read about your rights as a victim here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
4 hours ago
- CBC
Troy Ryan confirmed as Canadian women's hockey head coach for 2026 Olympics
Troy Ryan has been tasked with coaching the Canadian women's hockey team to another Olympic gold medal in 2026 in Milan-Cortina, Italy. Ryan was behind the bench in Beijing in 2022 when the Canadian women reclaimed hockey gold from the United States in a 3-2 final. The U.S. had beaten Canada 3-2 in a shootout for the title in 2018 in Pyeongchang, South Korea, where Ryan was an assistant coach. Hockey Canada's announcement Thursday confirmed Ryan's return, although he'd signed an unprecedented four-year extension in 2022 that would make him the longest-tenured coach of the national women's team. Ryan navigated Canada to both an Olympic gold medal in Beijing and world championship wins in 2021, 2022 and 2024 after taking over midway through the 2019-20 season for Perry Pearn. Canada lost this year's world championship final 4-3 in overtime to the U.S. in Ceske Budejovice, Czechia. Korie Cheverie, former national team forward Caroline Ouellette and Britni Smith will be Ryan's assistant coaches in Italy, with Brad Kirkwood serving as goaltending consultant, Hockey Canada said in a statement. The coaches were chosen by women's team general manager Gina Kingsbury in consultation with Hockey Canada president and chief executive officer Katherine Henderson and senior vice-president of high performance and hockey operations Scott Salmond. Women's sports are booming. Why now? "It is always an honour and privilege to be in this leadership position as we set our expectations and goals for the Olympics," Ryan said. "We have a tremendous coaching staff that is committed to the vision and process, and I am excited for the journey ahead. We know our athletes are motivated to compete, and we are eager to begin the work towards achieving something extraordinary in seven months time." Canada won a silver medal in 1998 in Nagano, Japan, where women's hockey made its Olympic debut. Four straight gold medals followed in 2002, 2006, 2010 and 2014. Canada's preparation for Italy will be different than previous Olympic Games because of the Professional Women's Hockey League starting its third season. Hockey Canada will fit training blocks around the PWHL's schedule. Ryan is head coach of the PWHL's Toronto Sceptres. Cheverie is head coach and Ouellette an assistant coach of the Montreal Victoire. "We have made a conscious effort to create an environment for our athletes where consistency among our coaches creates trust and accountability in each other," Kingsbury said. "Our staff are experienced, detail-oriented and passionate as they give our team the confidence to grow, compete and meet the challenges of both short-term and long-term competition. We continue to build something special with our group and we are excited to see it all come together as we compete for a gold medal in Milan." Cheverie of New Glasgow, N.S., was Ryan's assistant in the 2022 Olympic Games and for every world championship since 2021. Montreal's Ouellette, a four-time Olympic and six-time world gold medallist, has been Ryan's assistant in four straight world championships. Smith of Port Perry, Ont., coached at Syracuse University for the past three seasons and was Ryan's assistant at this year's world championship. Calgary's Kirkwood has been the team's goaltending consultant for the last decade and works with Ryan and the Sceptres as a goaltending assistant coach.
Winnipeg Free Press
5 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Troy Ryan confirmed to return to Canadian women's hockey team's Olympic bench
CALGARY – Troy Ryan has been tasked with coaching the Canadian women's hockey team to another Olympic gold medal in 2026 in Milan-Cortina, Italy. Ryan was behind the bench in Beijing in 2022 when the Canadian women reclaimed hockey gold from the United States in a 3-2 final. The U.S. had beaten Canada 3-2 in a shootout for the title in 2018 in Pyeongchang, South Korea, where Ryan was an assistant coach. Hockey Canada's announcement Thursday confirmed Ryan's return, although he'd signed an unprecedented four-year extension in 2022 that would make him the longest-tenured coach of the national women's team. Ryan navigated Canada to both an Olympic gold medal in Beijing and world championship wins in 2021, 2022 and 2024 after taking over midway through the 2019-20 season for Perry Pearn. Canada lost this year's world championship final 4-3 in overtime to the U.S. in Ceske Budejovice, Czechia. Korie Cheverie, former national team forward Caroline Ouellette and Britni Smith will be Ryan's assistant coaches in Italy, with Brad Kirkwood serving as goaltending consultant, Hockey Canada said in a statement. The coaches were chosen by women's team general manager Gina Kingsbury in consultation with Hockey Canada president and chief executive officer Katherine Henderson and senior vice-president of high performance and hockey operations Scott Salmond. 'It is always an honour and privilege to be in this leadership position as we set our expectations and goals for the Olympics,' Ryan said. 'We have a tremendous coaching staff that is committed to the vision and process, and I am excited for the journey ahead. We know our athletes are motivated to compete, and we are eager to begin the work towards achieving something extraordinary in seven months time.' Canada won a silver medal in 1998 in Nagano, Japan, where women's hockey made its Olympic debut. Four straight gold medals followed in 2002, 2006, 2010 and 2014. Canada's preparation for Italy will be different than previous Olympic Games because of the Professional Women's Hockey League starting its third season. Hockey Canada will fit training blocks around the PWHL's schedule. Ryan is head coach of the PWHL's Toronto Sceptres. Cheverie is head coach and Ouellette an assistant coach of the Montreal Victoire. 'We have made a conscious effort to create an environment for our athletes where consistency among our coaches creates trust and accountability in each other,' Kingsbury said. 'Our staff are experienced, detail-oriented and passionate as they give our team the confidence to grow, compete and meet the challenges of both short-term and long-term competition. We continue to build something special with our group and we are excited to see it all come together as we compete for a gold medal in Milan.' Thursdays Keep up to date on sports with Mike McIntyre's weekly newsletter. Cheverie of New Glasgow, N.S., was Ryan's assistant in the 2022 Olympic Games and for every world championship since 2021. Montreal's Ouellette, a four-time Olympic and six-time world gold medallist, has been Ryan's assistant in four straight world championships. Smith of Port Perry, Ont., coached at Syracuse University for the past three seasons and was Ryan's assistant at this year's world championship. Calgary's Kirkwood has been the team's goaltending consultant for the last decade and works with Ryan and the Sceptres as a goaltending assistant coach. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 31, 2025.
Toronto Star
16 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Teaching boys to respect the opposite sex starts at home
After the Hockey Canada trial, here's what we need to teach our young men, June 25 The primary responsibility for teaching boys to respect women and girls starts at home with the parents and continues through school. This is the beginning of a journey that will lead to respecting the people who we will interact with for the rest of our lives. The outcome of the 'Hockey Canada Trial' — as it has come to be known — seems to indicate that just because a sexual activity may be legal should not necessarily mean that it is right or morally acceptable. When young adult men have become conditioned to be positive and respectful, it is highly unlikely they will deviate from this norm. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Robert Ariano, Scarborough How about teaching women to respect themselves? After the Hockey Canada trial, here's what we need to teach our young men, June 25 Teach women to respect themselves, is my response to Elizabeth Renzetti's article. Justice Maria Carroccia correctly stated it is not the function of the court to deal with the morality or the decency of those involved. While I don't condone the behaviour of the young men in this case, this young woman walked away with $3 million from a civil case and her identity protected while she destroyed the reputations of five other persons. She gets no sympathy from me. Francine D. McMullen, Etobicoke In Canada if you can score goals this sort of behaviour is OK So, the hockey players were found not guilty. Hmm. When I was younger, I never had a one-night stand/date, where afterwards I invited my team, buddies, co-workers over to have sex with her. I never went on a date where afterwards I had to collaborate with five or six other guys to get our stories straight. But it's Canada and if you can score goals, that kind of stuff is OK. Entitlement on one side. Victim blaming on the other. Mark Yates, Elmira, Ontario In Hockey Canada trial, silence was a strategy If the accused in the Hockey Canada trial walk free, this will be the reason why, July 23 Anne Bokma makes an excellent point that under Canada's legal system the complainant in a sexual assault trial is required to take the stand to testify and be cross-examined by defence whereas the defendants are allowed to be silent. How is this fair? ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW The defendant already has a significant advantage in a criminal trial as the Crown must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Is it not reasonable that the Crown be allowed to call the defendant to the stand and also be questioned under oath? While this likely would not have changed the findings of not guilty in this Hockey Canada case, it puts the trial on a more equal footing for the complainant. It's no wonder so few women who are sexually assaulted come forward. Robert D. Domoney, Richmond Hill Column twists professional integrity into moral betrayal Why would female lawyers represent men in sexual crimes? July 28 The piece opens with a perfunctory nod to the presumption of innocence, only to spend the rest of its length undermining that very principle. But the presumption of innocence is not a legal technicality — it is a pillar of justice in a democratic society. It guarantees that every person, regardless of the charge, has the right to a fair trial and to be defended against the full weight of the state. Without this, our justice system becomes mere performance, stripped of moral legitimacy. The author takes issue with female defence counsel for their roles in cases like Ghomeshi and more recently 'E.M.,' where the courts ultimately found the complainants to be unreliable. To frame these lawyers as betraying women is to fundamentally misunderstand their role and the value they bring to an adversarial system that — while far from perfect — requires accountability, fairness, and rigorous scrutiny on all sides. It is offensive — and telling — that the author suggests women are chosen to defend sexual assault cases for optics rather than ability. We categorically reject that notion. Our female colleagues are among the most capable, courageous, and respected advocates in the field. They bring invaluable perspective, strategic insight, and often a level of nuance that improves — not diminishes — how complainants are treated in court. This commentary didn't just take aim at individual lawyers. It reinforced a broader, corrosive narrative that women in criminal defence are somehow complicit in oppression simply for upholding the rule of law. That idea is dangerous. We cannot allow such thinking to take root — not in media, not in the profession, and not in public discourse. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW These women face challenges their male colleagues often don't — misogyny, moral judgment, and the constant burden of justifying their place in the courtroom. They should not be left to manage this climate of hostility alone. As male defence lawyers, we have a responsibility to push back when professional integrity is twisted into moral betrayal. This kind of discourse degrades the legal profession, undermines trust in the justice system, and disrespects the very people it claims to protect. Female defence lawyers don't need to be defended. They need to be backed up. And we're here to do just that. Mark Berry, Andrew Hindi, Allen Goldin, David Fai, Ervin Ariaee, Chris Johnson KC, Scott Wright, Philip Derksen, JB Emmons, Parm Taunk, Paul Doroshenko KC, Dale Marshall, Brian Coleman, KC, Rishi Gill, Robert Bellows, Andrew Cochrane, Bobby Movassaghi, Hovan Patey, Kevin Filkow, Patrick Johnston, Aasheesh Puri, Bill Jessop, Dave Ferguson, Ian Gauthier, Daman Mander, Jayse Reveley, Graeme Jose, Duncan Chiu, Robb Larmer, Larry Myers KC, Kyle Komarynsky, Paul Van Benthem, Cameron Johnson, Garen Arnet-Zargarian, Joshua Krueger, Jason Tarnow, Aman Jaswal, Brock Martland, Richard Neary, Eric Warren, Edison Heba, Wesley Solmon, Andrew Coulthard, Austin Nix, David Payn, Alexander Khamdamov, Greg Diamond, Declan McGovern, Sarab Atwal, Matthew Hauzar, Burnaby, BC Role models are important When I was on a very crowded shuttle bus on Bloor Street on Sunday morning, a preteen boy spontaneously gave up his seat to a mother and her very young daughter. The mother gave the seat to the daughter. (I was standing at the time.) Role models are important. In light of the behaviour of the five hockey players in London, it is good to see at least one young male is setting a good example for other males. Bruce Couchman, Toronto Opinion Headlines Newsletter Take a stand with this regular roundup of the best from our columnists. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. Please enter a valid email address. Sign Up Yes, I'd also like to receive customized content suggestions and promotional messages from the Star. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Opinion Headlines Newsletter You're signed up! You'll start getting Opinion Headlines in your inbox soon. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page.
