Man whose hearing loss was not diagnosed or treated for 10 years sues the HSE
Padraig Byrne, who has Down Syndrome, only got his first hearing assessment when he was 17 months old, but while a hearing loss was recorded it was claimed ,it was not adequately recognised or followed up until he was five years of age.
Advertisement
His counsel Hugh O'Keeffe SC, instructed by Damien Tansey Solicitors told the court that the treatment of the boy was 'wholly inadequate.' It wasn't until the boy was ten years of age that hearing aids to amplify sound were appropriately fitted and verified.
Counsel said a ten year delay was conceded in what was a very complicated case. At one stage, he said the little boy was given hearing aids ' that were clearly going to fail.'
Padraig did not have access to the full spectrum of speech sounds between birth and almost five years of age, and even then, his hearing aids were not optimized until he was ten years old, meaning that he did not have access to the speech spectrum during the optimal period for language development.
Counsel said it was their case had Padraig's hearing loss been diagnosed earlier he would have been given a chance to have a degree of independent living and the delay has had ' a discernible effect on Padraig's future independence.'.
Advertisement
The HSE, he said, conceded an earlier diagnosis may have benefitted the boy but it did not accept it had an effect on Padraig's independence.
Padraig Byrne, now aged 20 years from Co Carlow, had, through his mother June Byrne, sued the HSE.
In the proceedings, it was claimed the delay had resulted in delayed access to optimum speech and language at a time critical for the boy's development of speech and language.
The standard of audiological care that the boy received until September 2014, it was contended fell significantly below that reasonably expected, and the boy had been denied the best possible access to sound.
Advertisement
Approving the settlement Mr Justice Paul Coffey said he was satisfied that the very best had been achieved for Padraig and the offer was fair and reasonable.
Ireland
Richard Satchwell told gardaí he kept 'bits and pi...
Read More
In a separate case, a boy who the court heard suffered a likely net four-year delay in the diagnosis and treatment of his hearing loss settled his action for €310,000.
Oisin Flanagan, now aged 8 years of Portarlington, Co Offaly, had, through his mother Fiona Flanagan, sued the HSE. A breach of duty was admitted in the case.
It was claimed there was a failure to assess the boy's hearing as requiring amplification, and he was allegedly deprived of the amplification required to access the speech spectrum of sound, which at that time was critical to his speech and language .
Approving the settlement Mr Justice Coffey said it was fair and reasonable.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
6 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
HSE chief admits waiting lists for assessments for children with disabilities will get worse
The head of the Health Service Executive (HSE) said on Tuesday that he was 'hugely' concerned at growing waiting lists for disabled children seeking vital health assessments and admitted the crisis will get worse. Bernard Gloster acknowledged a 'significant challenge' in tackling the crisis, with more than 15,000 children with serious disabilities waiting to access their legal right to assessments. Advertisement When asked if the crisis was 'going to get worse before it got better', Mr Gloster replied: 'Yes'. The HSE chief said: 'Until we get extra capacity and until we reform the legislation, we are going to be challenged.' 'It would be very wrong of me to say anything different to people across the country, it would be untruthful to do that,' he told reporters in Limerick. The HSE predicts that the children's assessment waiting lists will increase to beyond 25,000 by the end of this year. Advertisement After meeting Cara Daramody, a 14 year old campaigner for the rights of children with disabilities, Mr Gloster pledged that the HSE will advertise tenders for assessments to the private clinicians, to try and tackle the problem. Prior to the meeting, Ms Darmody, accompanied by her father Mark Darmody, called out the government via the HSE for breaching current legislation requiring it to provide health and education needs assessments for children with disabilities. Ms Darmody said children had been left to 'rot' on the waiting lists and urged Mr Gloster to act fast to rescue the waiting list backlog for the vital assessments. Ms Darmody, who led a 50-hour protest outside the Dáil last month highlighting the crisis, said she gave Mr Gloster 'crucial information that totally contradicts the myth that capacity has been reached in the system in relation to the number of psychologists available to assess autistic children'. Advertisement Ms Darmody said she also informed Mr Gloster that she is aware of 'private' clinicians who have sought to help reduce assessment waiting lists but who have been delayed in doing so by bureaucracy. Ms Darmody claimed she knows of at least one private clinician who could have 'eradicated' the AON waiting list in her home county of Tipperary over the last 12 months, by performing an additional 220 AONs, had they been given the opportunity. Ms Darmody said the clinician had applied for a HSE Assessment Tender last October, 'but only got confirmation a month ago' that they had been accepted. Ms Darmody questioned 'why in the middle of a national crisis did it take eight months', and she accused the government of not acting fast enough on the waiting lists. Advertisement Mr Gloster said this evening he was 'taken aback' at the details presented to him by Cara Darmody and Mark Darmody. Commenting on the alleged eight-month wait for the provision of the assessment tender, Mr Gloster said: 'I have to say, it can happen, we are a very big organisation and we have to have rules and systems, and they, by their nature, can become bureaucratic.' 'I'm the first to put my hands up and say, that's for us to do better.' 'I don't think that my own people are doing anything bad or wrong, but it is for us to better, we are paid public servants and Cara and her Dad are not.' Advertisement Mr Gloster said, going forward, he would try to 'tighten the timeline' on assessment tenders applications by the private sector. He acknowledged that 'in the short-term' the HSE required 'help' from the private system to help reduce the assessment waiting lists. 'In the next few weeks, we are going to redesign the specification of private sector provision to help us provide assessment of need,' Mr Gloster said. 'We are going to widely advertise and promote it, so that if there are suitably qualified clinicians who can conduct an assessment of need, and who are qualified and registered to do so, and are safe to do so, then there will be no issue with us using that additional capacity,' he said. 'Even if it possibly reduced the timeline for a couple of hundred (children), then it would be a really productive thing.' Mr Gloster said: 'If you apply for an assessment of need, you are entitled to it in law; you should be able to get it.' The Limerick health service boss said other 'challenges' existed beyond the assessments, including timelines over children's access to 'therapeutic support and intervention'. 'The amount of therapists we have in Ireland that are available to us is limited, but the government are making some really good interventions to increase the supply,' he said. Mr Gloster said that Cara and Mark Darmody's 'anecdotal evidence' of a possible reduction in the waiting lists may exist in the private system; their arguments to investigate it further were 'legitimate and appropriate'. Mr Gloster acknowledged that it had been 'a while' since the HSE had 'updated' its 'framework' of assessment providers, 'so, therefore, there is nothing to lose and everything to gain' by investigating potential capacity in the private system. 'If (it is) proven that there is capacity out there that isn't being used, we'll be delighted that more that can be done, because it means that we can immediately enter into arrangements with professionals to buy additional services to support our own (services),' Mr Gloster said. Ms Darmody described their meeting as 'extremely successful'. 'I got what I wanted from the meeting, which was for Mr Gloster to look into the issue and to start looking for solutions nationally, and in my own county, Tipperary, and possibly internationally,' Ms Darmody said.
BBC News
3 hours ago
- BBC News
Thinking Allowed The Irish in the UK
Laurie Taylor talks to Louise Ryan, Professor of Sociology at the London Metropolitan University, about her oral history of the Irish nurses who were the backbone of the NHS for many years. By the 1960s approximately 30,000 Irish-born nurses were working across the NHS, constituting around 12% of all nursing staff. From the rigours of training to the fun of dancehalls, she explores their life experiences as nurses and also as Irish migrants, including those times when they encountered anti Irish racism. They're joined by Bronwen Walter, Emerita Professor of Irish Diaspora Studies at Anglia Ruskin University, who discusses the way that Irish migration offers an unusual opportunity to explore wider questions about the experience of immigrants and how ethnic identities persist or change over time. Producer: Jayne Egerton
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
NHS earwax removal must be available to all
Your article about ear health (Get plugs and never remove wax at home, 24 June) didn't reflect the huge impact on some people's lives of the withdrawal of NHS earwax removal services in many areas. Cornwall is one of the areas of the country where you now have to pay privately to have earwax safely removed. The cost of this can be considerable for those on limited incomes, which causes some to undertake dangerous procedures themselves to clear their wax, or go to an unregulated and possibly dangerous practitioner, or simply live with reduced hearing. The double whammy is that you can't get an NHS hearing check – and thus NHS-funded hearing aids if you need them – or access to other treatment unless you have had your earwax removed at your own expense. RNID, the national hearing-loss charity, has published a report, Stop the Block, highlighting the issue. As your article rightly says, people need good hearing to stay socially connected. Without good-quality social interactions, people can become withdrawn, isolated, depressed and ill. The withdrawal in many areas of this apparently minor service to remove earwax is having a serious impact on some people's lives. The free NHS service must be reinstated for BlundyWest Cornwall HealthWatch Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
