logo
Trump gave the USOPC cover on its transgender athlete policy change. It could end up in court anyway

Trump gave the USOPC cover on its transgender athlete policy change. It could end up in court anyway

Fox Sports5 days ago
Associated Press
In its push to remove transgender athletes from Olympic sports, the Trump administration provided the U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee a detailed legal brief on how such a move would not conflict with the Ted Stevens Act, the landmark 1978 federal statute governing the Olympic movement.
That gave the USOPC the cover it needed to quietly change its policy, though the protection offers no guarantee the new policy won't be challenged in court.
Olympic legal expert Jill Pilgrim called the Trump guidance 'a well thought-out, well-reasoned set of arguments for people who want to look at it from that perspective.'
'But I'd be pretty shocked if this doesn't get challenged if there is, somewhere along the line, a trans athlete who's in contention for an Olympic team or world championship and gets excluded,' said Pilgrim, who has experience litigating eligibility rules for the Olympics and is a former general counsel for USA Track and Field.
The USOPC's update of its athlete safety policy orders its 54 national governing bodies to rewrite their participation rules to ensure they are in sync with the executive order Trump signed in February called 'Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports."
When the USOPC released the guidance, fewer than five had rules that would adhere to the new policy.
Among the first adopters was USA Fencing, which was pulled into a congressional hearing earlier this year about transgender women in sports when a woman refused to compete against a transgender opponent at a meet in Maryland.
One of the main concerns over the USOPC's change is that rewriting the rules could conflict with a clause in the Ted Stevens Act stating that an NGB cannot have eligibility criteria 'that are more restrictive than those of the appropriate international sports federation' that oversees its sport.
While some American federations such as USATF and USA Swimming follow rules set by their international counterparts, many others don't. International federations have wrestled with eligibility criteria surrounding transgender sports, and not all have guidelines as strict as what Trump's order calls for.
World Rowing, for example, has guidelines that call for specific medical conditions to be met for transgender athletes competing in the female category. Other federations, such as the one for skiing, are more vague.
White House lawyers provided the USOPC a seven-paragraph analysis that concluded that requiring 'men's participation in women's sports cannot be squared with the rest of the" Ted Stevens Act.
'And in any event, permitting male athletes to compete against only other fellow males is not a 'restriction' on participation or eligibility, it is instead, a neutral channeling rule," according to the analysis, a copy of which was obtained by The Associated Press.
Once the sports federations come into compliance, the question then becomes whether the new policy will be challenged, either by individual athletes or by states whose laws don't conform with what the NGBs adopt. The guidance impacts everyone from Olympic-level athletes to grassroots players whose clubs are affiliated with the NGBs.
Shannon Minter, the legal director at the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, said it will not be hard to find a transgender athlete who is being harmed by the USOPC change, and that the White House guidance 'will be challenged and is highly unlikely to succeed.'
'There are transgender women. There are some international sporting organizations that have policies that permit transgender women to compete if they meet certain medical conditions,' Minter said. 'Under the Ted Stevens Act, they can't override that. So, their response is just to, by brute force, pretend there's no such thing as a transgender woman. They can't just dictate that by sheer force of will.'
Traditionally, athletes on the Olympic pathway who have issues with eligibility rules must first try to resolve those through what's called a Section IX arbitration case before heading to the U.S. court system. Pilgrim spelled out one scenario in which an athlete wins an arbitration 'and then the USOPC has a problem.'
'Then, it's in the USOPC's court to deny that person the opportunity to compete, and then they'll be in court, no doubt about that,' she said.
All this comes against the backdrop of a 2020 law that passed that, in the wake of sex scandals in Olympic sports, gave Congress the power to dissolve the USOPC board.
That, combined with the upcoming Summer Games in Los Angeles and the president's consistent effort to place his stamp on issues surrounding sports, is widely viewed as driving the USOPC's traditionally cautious board toward making a decision that was being roundly criticized in some circles. The committee's new policy replaces one that called for reliance on 'real data and science-based evidence rather than ideology" to make decisions about transgender athletes in sports.
'As a federally chartered organization, we have an obligation to comply with federal expectations,' CEO Sarah Hirshland and board chair Gene Sykes wrote to Olympic stakeholders last week. 'The guidance we've received aligns with the Ted Stevens Act, reinforcing our mandated responsibility to promote athlete safety and competitive fairness.'
The USOPC didn't set a timeline on NGBs coming into compliance, though it's believed most will get there by the end of the year.
___
AP sports: https://apnews.com/sports in this topic
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

U.S. tariff: South Africa implements emergency measures to shield local exporters
U.S. tariff: South Africa implements emergency measures to shield local exporters

Business Insider

timea few seconds ago

  • Business Insider

U.S. tariff: South Africa implements emergency measures to shield local exporters

The government of South Africa has announced plans to draft emergency measures to support local exporters affected by the U.S. President Donald Trump's newly imposed 30% tariff; a policy shift expected to severely impact the country's automotive and agricultural sectors. The South African government announced emergency measures to support exporters affected by the US's newly imposed tariffs. These tariffs, set at 30%, target industries like automotive and agriculture, and are part of a US trade policy shift. Negotiations with the US are open, while efforts to finalize a support package for impacted sectors continue. The tariff, which was announced via an executive order on Thursday, is set to take effect within seven days and forms part of President Trump's broader push to reshape global trade in favour of the United States. In response, the country's Trade and Industry Minister, Parks Tau announced the launch of an 'Export Support Desk' to assist affected businesses and help them identify alternative international markets. The minister described the situation as 'a trying moment for South Africa,' underscoring the immediate risks to jobs and economic stability, a Reuters report confirmed. President Cyril Ramaphosa also addressed the development, revealed in a press release that his government is finalising a support package for vulnerable exporters, with further details expected in the coming day ' All channels of communication remain open to engage with the U.S., and our negotiators are ready pending invitation from the U.S., ' Ramaphosa said. The United States is South Africa's second-largest bilateral trading partner after China, importing a wide range of goods including automobiles, iron and steel, citrus fruits, and wine. However, rising diplomatic tensions, fueled by disagreements over South Africa's foreign policy positions and domestic affirmative action laws, which the Trump administration has openly criticised, have clouded the trade relationship. Trump unmoved by South Africa's tariff plea According to Reuters, South Africa had spent several months attempting to negotiate a trade compromise with Washington. Among its proposals were increasing purchases of U.S. liquefied natural gas and committing to investments in U.S. industries in exchange for tariff exemptions. However, U.S. officials reportedly remained unresponsive. The executive order signed Thursday imposes new duties on dozens of countries, many of them emerging markets, rekindling fears that African economies could become collateral damage in Washington's increasingly protectionist trade agenda. While the establishment of the Export Support Desk has been welcomed by some stakeholders, political opponents questioned its adequacy. South Africa's official opposition party, The Democratic Alliance,, dismissed the initiative as 'laughable.'

How to Watch Wyndham Championship, Final Round: Live Stream PGA Tour Golf, TV Channel
How to Watch Wyndham Championship, Final Round: Live Stream PGA Tour Golf, TV Channel

Newsweek

timea few seconds ago

  • Newsweek

How to Watch Wyndham Championship, Final Round: Live Stream PGA Tour Golf, TV Channel

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A very exciting final round at the Wyndham Championship will take place on Sunday, with American golfer Cameron Young tied at the top of the leaderboard at 20 under par. Cameron Young of the United States plays his shot from the 13th tee during the third round of the Wyndham Championship 2025 at Sedgefield Country Club on August 02, 2025 in Greensboro, North Carolina. Cameron Young of the United States plays his shot from the 13th tee during the third round of the Wyndham Championship 2025 at Sedgefield Country Club on August 02, 2025 in Greensboro, North Carolina. Photo by Jared C. Tilton/Getty Images How to Watch the Wyndham Championship Final Round Date: Sunday, July 13, 2025 Time: 1:00 p.m. ET Venue: Sedgefield CC Channel: CBS, The Golf Channel Stream: Fubo (TRY FOR FREE) Young has a fairly sizable lead heading into the final round, five strokes up on the second-place golfer, Colombia's Nicolas Echavarria, who is at 15 under par. Behind them, three golfers are tied for third place at 12 under par: England's Aaron Rai, American golfer Nicolas Echavarria and Mac Meissner. Young is 28 years old and has two wins on the Korn Ferry Tour in his career. Despite never winning a major, Young has fared pretty well at major tournaments in his career, finishing seventh at the 2023 Masters, third at the 2022 PGA Championship, fourth at the 2025 U.S. Open, and second at the 2022 Open Championship. For his efforts, Young was named PGA Tour Rookie of the Year for the 2021-22 season. Echavarria, meanwhile, is 30 years old and has two PGA Tour wins in his career, winning the 2023 Puerto Rico Open with a 21-under-par score, two strokes ahead of the second-place finisher. Echavarria also won the 2024 Zozo Championship with a 20-under-par score, one stroke ahead of the golfer who finished in second place. Can Young wrap up the tournament with his first PGA Tour win? Or can Echavarria make a comeback up the leaderboard on Sunday? Tune into The Golf Channel at 1:00 p.m. ET, followed by CBS at 3:00 p.m. ET, on Sunday afternoon to catch the final round of the Wyndham Championship. Live stream the Wyndham Championship final round for free on Fubo: Start your subscription now! Regional restrictions may apply. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store