Cork crime: Northsiders get longer jail sentences than southsiders, 'Irish Examiner' study reveals
The analysis of more than 1,400 court reports published by The Irish Examiner and The Echo highlights a striking disparity between the city's northside and southside.
It raises fresh concerns about the ongoing inequality and the socioeconomic divide, despite decades of investment in disadvantaged areas.
This is one of the articles published in the 'Irish Examiner' in print and online here on Day 2 of the three-day Cork Crime series.
The breakdown of the 554 convictions between 2020-2024, shows:
360 had an address on the northside and 194 lived on the southside
The average jail sentence was longer on the northside (22.1 months) compared to 18 months on the southside
Some of the city's youngest offenders had an address on the northside;
Gurranabraher had the youngest average age of those jailed during the study period
The breakdown of the main crime categories shows an even greater disparity when it comes to sentencing.
The data shows:
Theft
127 jail terms in which theft was mentioned were imposed on people with an address on the northside. Average sentence – 11.8 months.
65 mentions of the same offence involving people with an address on the southside. Average sentence 8.7 months.
Burglary
54 jail sentences mentioning burglary involving someone with a northside address. Average jail term of 32 months.
12 mentions of the same offence involving someone living on the southside. Average sentence of 25 months.
Public order
53 jail sentences mentioning public order offences involving people with a northside address. Average sentence of 9.5 months.
31 sentences for the same offence involving someone living on the southside. Average sentence of 5.5 months.
Weapons and explosives offences
48 jail terms in which weapons and explosives offences were mentioned, involving someone with a northside address. Average sentence of 29.3 months.
23 involving someone living on the southside. Average sentence of 27 months.
Drugs for sale or supply
45 jail terms mentioning drugs for sale or supply involving some living on the northside, with an average sentence of 40.7 months.
23 mentions of the same offence involving someone with a southside address - average sentence of 29 months.
Assault
63 jail terms involving a person with a northside address. Average jail term of 26.2 months.
42 mentions of the same offence involving a person living on the southside. Average jail term of 27.6 months.
This was the only major crime category where sentences were harsher on the southside.
Of the top 10 jail-time suburbs, seven are in parts of the city classed as 'disadvantaged' or 'very disadvantaged' in the 2022 Pobal Deprivation Index, with higher rates of unemployment and lone parenting, and lower rates of school completion and third-level participation.
The average age of a person with a northside address at the time of sentencing was just under 33 years of age, with southsiders just over the age of 34.
The average sentence for a person with a northside address in that time was just over 22 months, but it was 18 months on the southside.
Previous convictions were mentioned almost equally across the city – in 65% of all the cases involving someone with a northside address and in 63% of cases involving someone with a southside address.
Addiction
However, the data shows that addiction does not respect any geographical boundaries and is a citywide problem.
Addiction was mentioned in 54% of cases involving northsiders, and in 52% of cases involving southsiders, with alcohol mentioned in 37% of cases both northside and southside, and drugs mentioned in 45% of cases both northside and southside.
Addiction, alcohol or drugs was mentioned in 72% of cases on the northside, and 74% of all cases in the southside.
The analysis also identified the most mentioned crime categories and the areas in which those convicted of the crimes were living at the time.
It shows that Gurranabraher accounted for the highest number of jail terms imposed over the five years, and it had the youngest average age in the city for someone jailed for an offence, at just under 29 years of age.
It was followed by Mayfield, Knocknaheeny, and Blackpool, all on the northside, and by Mahon in the southeast.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
9 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Effort to bypass help to buy scheme being examined, says housing regulator
Ireland's property regulator said it is examining a report that a potential home buyer was asked to pay €25,000 for flooring in order to bypass the cap on the help to buy scheme. The Property Services Regulatory Authority (PSRA), which licences and regulates auctioneers and estate agents, said it was not aware of such practices taking place, but encouraged any first-time buyers who were faced with such an incident to lodge a formal complaint. The Irish Times reported yesterday that a prospective home buyer contacted estate agents Sherry FitzGerald, asking if the developer of a new estate would consider selling a home for €500,000 so it would qualify for the help to buy scheme. The agent said it would not qualify for the scheme as it is priced at €525,000 and above the €500,000 cap. The agent subsequently contacted the buyer, saying the price of the home had been split so that it qualified for the scheme, with the house costing €500,000 and the flooring in the home costing €25,000. Reacting to the report, a spokesperson for the PSRA said it has the power to issue minor and major sanctions, including suspensions and fines. 'The PSRA was not aware of the practice of estate agents assisting developers circumvent the help to buy (HTB) scheme by asking first time buyers for the excess of €500,000, which is the limit under the HTB scheme, in cash,' they said. The PSRA would encourage first-time buyers who are approached by estate agents to enter into this practice to make a complaint to the PSRA [and] include all relevant evidence. Contacted by the Irish Examiner, Sherry Fitzgerald said it has launched an internal investigation. 'At this point, we believe that this is an isolated incident relating to a single property. Our client is not privy to any negotiations with any prospective buyer. 'Following the conclusion of our investigation, we will take whatever steps are necessary to ensure that such a situation cannot occur again.' Administered by the Revenue Commissioners, the scheme provides a refund on income tax of up to €30,000 to first-time buyers on new-build properties up to a value of €500,000. For a property to qualify under the scheme, it must be purchased or built as the first-time buyer's home and, if purchased, it must be purchased from a qualifying contractor. The tax refund is paid directly to the contractor. In the first four months of 2025, some 17,144 applications were received for the scheme — almost 5,000 more than in the same period in 2024. Contacted by the Irish Examiner, the Department of Housing referred questions to the Department of Finance, which referred the matter to Revenue. In a statement, Revenue said it could not comment on individual cases but said the €500,000 threshold includes all payments made in connection with the property. 'Splitting payments, omitting costs, or structuring arrangements to artificially remain below the threshold constitutes non-compliance,' Revenue said, adding that a range of sanctions could be imposed.
Irish Examiner
3 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Northside jail rates spark ministerial review as prison plans face local opposition
The Minister of State for rural and community development has asked officials in the department to examine the findings of a major Irish Examiner investigation into who is being jailed in Cork and why. Jerry Buttimer said it was 'disconcerting' to read how, despite decades of targeted government investment in areas of the city officially classed as 'disadvantaged,' these areas still account for the highest number of jail terms imposed — and that this needs to be examined. The analysis of almost 1,500 jail terms imposed in Cork courts over the last five years found that seven northside suburbs were in the top 10 for the number of jail terms imposed. These areas align closely with parts of the city classed as 'disadvantaged' or 'very disadvantaged' in the 2022 Pobal Deprivation Index. These areas have higher rates of unemployment and lone parenting, and lower rates of school completion and third-level participation. The Irish Examiner analysis also found that people living on the northside received, on average, longer jail terms than those with an address on the southside. It revealed that homeless people received almost a quarter of the jail sentences handed down in the city courts over five years, and that addiction or substance abuse was cited in almost three-quarters of the cases analysed. Theft, assault, public order, and drugs offences were the most frequently mentioned in the city courts, with men accounting for 87% of all jail terms. Men's sentences were, on average, twice as long as those imposed on women. Mr Buttimer congratulated the Irish Examiner for the investigation, describing it as 'an important piece of work.' Jerry Buttimer said it was 'disconcerting' to read how, despite decades of targeted government investment in areas of the city officially classed as 'disadvantaged,' these areas still account for the highest number of jail terms imposed. Picture: Daragh Mc Sweeney While he highlighted several positive examples of family and youth projects involving the Irish Prison Service, local resource centres, and the Cork ETB aimed at addressing recidivism, he acknowledged there is still a major problem. 'I've spoken to officials in my own department in community rural development on how we can ensure that there is, with Pobal, a piece of work done so that we can ensure that the investment we are putting in is paying dividends, in terms of people not being institutionalised in prison,' he said. 'We also have to work with different organisations to ensure there is a pathway to education, to safer streets, to rehabilitation from drug and alcohol misuse. 'But it is disconcerting to see that despite the vast sums of money spent by Government over generations, over decades, there is a map that illustrates a clear issue that we have to have a clear conversation on. 'I've asked people in my department to look at that as well.' The research comes as opposition grows on the city's northside to recent government plans to repurpose the old Cork Prison building to provide around 300 new prison spaces. Tánaiste Simon Harris said the government will engage with the local community on the plan, but stated that his 'high-level instinct' is that the State's prison capacity must be increased—and quickly. That increased capacity, he said, would provide the space for education and training programmes aimed at tackling the revolving door problem in the prison system. 'Providing adequate prison space, having it properly staffed and adequately resourced, provides that space or an environment within the prison where there can be a focus on ending the revolving door, by saying to people, how are you going to get your life back on track,' he said. 'Our population has grown and grown very significantly in recent years. 'We in the Oireachtas voted to increase the sentencing - that people who carry out heinous crimes should pay in terms of the time in prison, and that does require extra prison spaces. 'The minister for justice has an important role to do in bringing that extra space on track as quickly as possible. 'Having said that, any process has to engage with communities. 'Any process has to be conscious of the views of communities, and this government will absolutely engage with the community in relation to that. 'But we want to make sure our streets are safe, we want to make sure crime never pays, and one of the greatest deterrents to crime is people knowing there is enough prison capacity and if I commit a crime, I'm have a decent chance of going to prison." Read More From northside to southside: What your address means when the gavel falls in Cork
Irish Examiner
6 days ago
- Irish Examiner
'Irish Examiner' reporters win four prizes at Justice Media Awards
Three Irish Examiner journalists have won four prizes at this year's Law Society of Ireland Justice Media Awards. In the Print/Online Journalism (Daily) category, reporter Sean Murray was the overall winner for his reporting on the Stardust inquests. In awarding Mr Murray the prize, the judges said his work provided "detailed insights into the largest inquest in modern Irish history". They said his reports were "excellently written and showed compassion for all involved". Irish Examiner reporter Alison O'Reilly was awarded a merit certificate in the same category for reporting on surrogacy, IVF schemes, and the legal struggles facing people hoping to have families in Ireland. The judges described Ms O'Reilly's work as "strong, relevant, and timely reporting on a topic of increasing public interest in Irish society". In the Human Rights/Social Justice Reporting (Print/Online) category, Irish Examiner journalist Ann Murphy took home the top prize for her report: Why incarceration is not suitable for the mentally ill. The judges said, in highlighting the concerns of those with mental illness in the prison system, Ms Murphy had "reported on this very complex issue in an incredible way". "She was able to portray the daily horrors and injustices of those dealing with this on a daily basis," the judges said. Ms O'Reilly also took home a second merit certificate in the Court Reporting - Print/Online category for her reporting on the case of Aoife Johnston, who died at University Hospital Limerick in 2022. The judges said Alison's work shared "exclusive details of this tragic public interest story", and outlined "key court insights in a respectful way". Speaking at the awards ceremony, Law Society president Eamon Harrington said the Justice Media Awards have been a great source of pride for the Law Society for three decades but "they are only as strong as the quality, tenacity, and dedication of the journalists who apply each year and the stories they tell". "Over the past five years, entries to the awards have doubled, with a 20% increase this year from 2024. The record-breaking number of entries this year show that the standard of Irish legal journalism remains incredibly high," he said. Mr Harrington said that, at a time when journalists across the world continue to face threats, it is "more important than ever to recognise and support responsible journalism, and those who produce it, that educates, informs and keeps our State bodies accountable". Journalism that amplifies voices of survivors and shares stories for the benefit of the public needs be recognised and celebrated. Congratulating all of the winners and nominees, Mr Harrington said there was a "huge amount of talent and credibility among Ireland's legal journalists". "With new media forms being developed, there is talent emerging from all areas," he added. "From seasoned national and local reporters, podcasters, broadcasters, newcomers and students, there is every reason to be optimistic about the future of Irish legal journalism.' The winners were: Overall Winner - Aoife Kelleher, Farah Abushwesha and Rachel Lysaght (Underground Films and Rocliffe): Testimony; Print/Online Journalism (Daily) - Sean Murray, Irish Examiner; Print/Online Journalism (Sunday) - Killian Woods, Business Post; Post Print/Online Journalism (Feature) - Mark Tighe and Marie Crowe, Sunday Independent; Print/Online Journalism (Local) - Richard Canny, Roscommon Herald; Broadcast Journalism (Radio) - Frank Greaney, The Anton Savage Show, Newstalk; Broadcast Journalism (Radio-Local) - Sinéad Hubble and Will Faulkner, Midlands 103; Broadcast Journalism (Podcast) - Michael Doyle, Neil Cotter, Damien Lane, and Fiona Wynne ( The Irish Sun): The Stardust Tragedy; Broadcast Journalism (TV/Video) - Michael O'Farrell, Trevor Birney, Andrew Tully, Jim O'Hagan, Seán Mullan, and Michael Law (Fine Point Films LTD for RTÉ): Michael Lynn: The Fugitive; Court Reporting (Print/Online) - Mary Carolan, The Irish Times; Court Reporting (Broadcast) - Maura Fay, Today with Claire Byrne, RTÉ Radio One; Human Rights/Social Justice Reporting (Print/Online) - Ann Murphy, Irish Examiner ; Human Rights/Social Justice Reporting (Broadcast) - Aoife Kelleher, Farah Abushwesha and Rachel Lysaght (Underground Films and Rocliffe): Testimony; Environmental Law/Climate Justice Reporting - Niall Sargent, The Currency; International Justice Reporting - Marion McKeone, Business Post; Newcomer of the Year - Jessica Woodlock ( The Pat Kenny Show, Newstalk, Bauer Media Group); Student Journalism - Conor Healy, Trinity News
