
'Appalling' twist in methanol deaths of Melbourne teenagers - as their parents speak out
Bianca Jones and Holly Bowles, both 19, died after a night out in the party town of Vang Viang, a small village north of Laos' capital Vientiane in November last year.
The pair were staying at Nana Backpackers Hostel and accidentally consumed methanol after they drank free shots of vodka and whiskey that were handed out.
The teens, both from Beumaris in Melbourne 's southeast, were among six foreign tourists to die due to the mass methanol poisoning event.
Miss Jones and Miss Bowles were rushed to separate Thai hospitals after asking staff for help on November 13.
Miss Jones died in Udon Thani hospital the next day, while Miss Bowles died in nearby Bangkok Hospital two days later.
Four foreign tourists from Denmark, the UK and the US also died, while a further 14 tourists who had been drinking in the area developed methanol poisoning within days of each other.
Now, nearly six months later, up to 13 people connected to the deaths may finally face charges, according to a report by 60 Minutes.
The families were notified by email from the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) just 10 days ago that charges had been laid.
Local police reportedly recommended charges against 13 people from Nana's Hostel and the Tiger distillery.
The proposed charges include violation of food and health security, unlawful business operations and elimination of evidence.
Mrs Jones and Mrs Bowles criticised the recommended charges as weak
'Pretty appalling, I'd say pretty insulting,' Mrs Bowles told 60 Minutes.
Mrs Jones added: 'I think we're pretty furious about it … Food and beverage. You know, that's like? What is that? We don't even know.'
'We know that there's no murder or manslaughter charges, which we feel there should be.'
The mothers said they feel as though those allegedly involved would only get a 'slap on the wrist' in the form of a fine if they are found guilty.
They also slammed the Laos government, claiming authorities 'don't care' and that the lives of their daughters meant 'nothing'.
The government of Laos conveyed its 'deep condolences to the teenagers' family via the email sent to Mrs Jones and Mrs Bowles from DFAT.
The email it explains the Ambassador was informed prosecutors were compiling a case to present to the court and that an 'outcome was expected soon'.
However, DFAT was not provided with a timeframe of when the trial might occur.
'We do not have visibility as to whether the prosecutors will proceed with all the recommended charges,' the email read.
Staff at Nana Backpackers vehemently denied they added anything to the shots of Tiger Vodka that had been given away for free as part of the hostel's happy hour deal between 8pm and 10pm.
Nana Backpackers Hostel owner Duong Duc Toan, who was reportedly among 'a number of people' detained by police for questioning.
Mr Toan said his bar was not responsible for the mass poisoning and insisted alcohol was bought from legitimate sellers and even drank from a bottle to 'prove it was safe'.
Methanol is a colourless liquid that tastes similar to alcohol and is a byproduct of bootlegged liquor.
Nana Backpackers Hostel owner Duong Duc Toan (pictured) has vehemently denied the shots given to the girls during the bar's happy hour were responsible for their deaths
Consuming even a small amount can lead to blindness, multiple organ failure and death.
Miss Jones and Miss Bowles' families have since campaigned for methanol poisoning awareness and have raised money for a charity in their daughters' names.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Thailand returns two wounded Cambodian soldiers holds 18 of their comrades
Cambodia welcomed the repatriation of two wounded soldiers captured by the Thai army following five days of border combat over territorial disputes. Eighteen other Cambodian soldiers remain in Thai custody, with Cambodia demanding their immediate release under international humanitarian law, while Thailand states it is following legal procedures. Both nations offer conflicting accounts of the soldiers' capture and continue to accuse each other of breaching the laws of war, including targeting civilians. The recent fighting resulted in over three dozen deaths and displaced more than 260,000 people from their homes. Despite a ceasefire, military representatives are scheduled to meet next week to discuss avoiding further clashes, though the underlying territorial claims will not be addressed.


Reuters
2 days ago
- Reuters
Indonesian President Prabowo pardons political opponents
JAKARTA, Aug 1 (Reuters) - Indonesia's President Prabowo Subianto pardoned two political rivals, a former trade minister and a senior politician from an opposition party a few weeks after both were sentenced to jail, officials said. Prabowo granted amnesty to Hasto Kristiyanto, the secretary general of parliament's largest party, the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDIP), Law Minister Supratman Andi Agtas said late on Thursday in a news conference broadcast by local media, after meeting the House's deputy speaker. Hasto was sentenced to 3-1/2 years in prison last week for bribing an election official but the amnesty revokes his sentence though his conviction will still stand. The president also granted an abolition for Thomas Trikasih Lembong, a trade minister under President Joko Widodo who was sentenced to 3-1/2 years in prison for improperly granting sugar import permits, Supratman said in the news conference. The abolition means, Lembong, who was the campaign manager of Prabowo's rival candidate in last year's presidential election, is acquitted of the charges and his sentence. Prabowo granted the clemencies as the government sees the need to unite all political elements and as part of Indonesia's independence celebrations in August, said Supratman. "We need to build this nation together, with all the political elements ... And both have contributed to the republic," Supratman said. It is common for the Indonesian president to give pardons ahead of the national independence day on August 17. The amnesty for Hasto was among the pardons given to more than 1,100 other people, Supratman added. Lawyers for Hasto and Lembong did not immediately respond for Reuters' request for comments. Under Indonesian law, the president has the authority to give amnesty and abolition but it requires approval from the parliament, said Bivitri Susanti from Indonesia's Jentera School of Law. Still, she said the amnesty given to Hasto was rather "political" to gain support from the largest opposition party in the parliament while for Lembong, the government is responding to growing protests from the public over his sentence. Other observers were concerned the pardons undercut efforts by the judiciary to deal with corruption in a country where concerns about graft and government misconduct are high. "It shows that the government could intervene in law enforcement, make it as a political bargain," said Muhammad Isnur from rights group Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation.


The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Indonesia set to release hundreds of prisoners under president's clemency plan
Indonesia is set to begin releasing hundreds of convicts from its notoriously overcrowded prisons after parliament approved the first stage of President Prabowo Subianto's wide-ranging clemency plan. The first group of 1,116 will begin leaving prisons next week, and include prominent rivals of previous President Joko Widodo who were jailed during his term, as well as Papuan independence activists. The announcement was made late Thursday by the House of Representatives Deputy Speaker Sufmi Dasco Ahmad and Law Minister Supratman Andi Agtas after a consultation between the government and party factions in the legislature. Subianto surprised the nation barely two months after he took office in October when he said he planned to grant clemency to 44,000 inmates nationwide. Past Indonesian leaders have rarely used their amnesty powers, which require the approval of parliament. Agtas said the government is prioritizing prisoners with mental disorders, the elderly, critically ill and those convicted of blasphemy or insulting the country's leader. Among the convicts set to be released are several prominent opposition figures, including Hasto Kristiyanto, the Secretary General of the country's only formal opposition party, the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle. Kristiyanto, a former Widodo ally who turned to harshly criticize the former president and his family, was sentenced last week to 3.5 years in prison over bribery in a 2019 legislative seat appointment scheme. Agtas said parliament also approved an end to criminal proceedings against former Trade Minister Tom Lembong, a onetime Widodo ally who broke with him during the 2024 presidential election to support political rival Anies Baswedan. Lembong received a 4.5 year sentence and had been preparing to appeal it before Subianto proposed him for clemency. 'Both have demonstrated service to the nation, and our priority now is to strengthen the unity of the nation,' Agtas said. The group also includes six Papuan independence activists who are currently serving prison sentences for treason. Agtas said they were released the government considers their movement unarmed. Authorities are expected to submit a second list of 1,668 inmates to parliament in the near future, he added.