Pup fatally struck by speeding e-bike – and grieving NYC owner can't get justice thanks to legal loophole: ‘Just heartbreaking'
A tiny pooch was fatally struck by an e-bike in a sidewalk hit-run on the Upper East Side on Memorial Day – but the dog's grieving owner says she can't get justice for the pup because of a loophole in state law.
6 Little Fennel was tragically struck and killed by an e-bike in a sidewalk hit-and-run in Manhattan over Memorial Day weekend.
Local resident Sarah Grant's 18-month-old shih tzu-poodle mix Fennel – who Grant rescued in December – was out with a dog walker when she was struck on the sidewalk by an e-bike rider on East 96th Street near Third Avenue in Manhattan just before 6 p.m. that Monday, her owner said.
Advertisement
'She was not very responsive,' Grant told The Post, recalling the moment her dog walker rushed Fennel back to her nearby apartment building. 'Her eyes rolled back into her head, and she was barely moving. It was just heartbreaking.'
Fennel sustained a traumatic brain injury and severe skull fracture and was euthanized hours later.
But when her owner attempted to file a police report with the NYPD, she was told she couldn't, as the incident wasn't a criminal matter — because dogs are only considered property under the law.
Advertisement
6 The 18-month-old pop was struck by a speeding e-bike rider on the sidewalk on East 96th Street near Third Avenue.
Google Maps
'I pushed back. If dogs are property, then this is a property crime,' Grant said. 'And they [still] said, 'No, you cannot submit a report.' ' Grant said.
She said she was told only her dog walker — who was also injured in the incident — could file a report.
'This is a wake-up call for me,' Grant said. 'I've always had pets, and it's an oversight that there is no legal recourse.
Advertisement
'Setting a car on fire is considered to be a worse felony than setting a dog on fire.'
The legal loophole is already the subject of a state bill introduced in January by Assemblywoman Linda Rosenthal (D-Manhattan). The bill seeks to swap the 'property' classification of such animals to 'sentient beings' and establish that they can be a victim of a crime. The bill has remained in committee since its introduction.
A 'sentient being is one who perceives or responds to sensations of whatever kind—sight, hearing, touch, taste, or smell,' according to Merriam-Webster's dictionary.
6 State Assemblywoman Linda Rosenthal (D-Manhattan) is pushing to reclassify animals under the law and establish that they can be a victim of a crime.
AP
Advertisement
The Mayor's Office of Animal Welfare told The Post it is looking into the matter in conjunction with other city agencies.
'We are heartbroken to hear about Fennel and are in touch with her family,' a rep for the office told The Post.
6 Upper East Side resident Sarah Grant says she just wants justice for her pup Fennel.
In addition to championing Rosenthal's bill to reclassify animals as 'sentient beings' under the law, Grant is calling for more enforcement for pedestrians safety on Gotham's sidewalks, where any form of biking is illegal for riders over the age of 12.
'Whether that's for humans or pets, it needs to be a bigger priority,' Grant said of the issue. 'An e-bike at that speed is deadly. I think people need to have a license and prove they have an understanding of traffic law in order to drive them.'
Janet Schroeder, director and co-founder of the NYC E-Vehicle Safety Alliance, which has called for the registration and licensing of e-bikes, told The Post that Fennel's passing is 'incredibly sad' and 'infuriating' — but not surprising.
'The fact that the e-biker fled is also expected,' she said. 'The rider flees the crash scene the majority of the time and therefore the rider can't be held accountable because they can't be identified.'
6 Fennel was out with a dog walker when he was killed.
Advertisement
Schroeder said Fennel's untimely death is yet another reason city legislators must pass the proposed Priscilla's Law, a 'common-sense solution' requiring license plates on e-vehicles 'so that egregious riding can be identified by enforcement cameras and riders held accountable to following the basic rules of the road which will change egregious riding behavior.'
In 104 e-bike-related crashes that Schroeder's group recorded, only four riders remained at the scene, according to the coalition — and in only six cases were crashes logged by the NYPD.
'This is a public-health crisis, and there is blood on the hands of any legislator who continues to do nothing but talk,' Schroeder added.
6 The pooch was adopted as a rescue dog in December.
Advertisement
Fennel's tragic passing comes just weeks after the mauling of chihuahua pup Penny on the Upper West Side by a pair of pitbulls sparked public outcry over how the city and state handle animal-related crimes.
As dogs are considered property under state law, police often don't get involved unless a human is attacked or a human owner participates in crimes against dogs — and justice for Penny has yet to be served as well, animal advocates say.
'[From] East Harlem to Brooklyn, there are people who … have the same concern: Somebody has dogs who attack other dogs, and nobody does anything about it,' city Council Member Gale Brewer told The Post this month.
'The agencies try, but they operate in a silo. We need to have everyone working together.'
Advertisement
Grant said, 'I think if people knew and understood the ramifications of [the law], it would help galvanize action.
'I don't want any money out of this — I just want accountability, I want the laws to change,' she said.
'I don't want any other people to have to go through what I'm going through.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
NYC Pride parade fills streets with glitter and glee — as NYPD wannabe marchers protest uniform ban
More than a million people filled Manhattan on Sunday for the largest annual Pride parade in North America — while LGBTQ cops turned out in droves to protest from the sidelines. As revelers dressed in glitter, drag and other festive attire packed the streets surrounding the downtown parade route, the officers were furious that they are still barred from marching in their NYPD uniforms. 'It takes a tremendous amount on courage to be out. It takes an even more tremendous amount of courage to be out in uniform,' said NYPD Detective Brian Downey, president of the Gay Officers Action League. Advertisement 5 More than a million people pack the streets of downtown Manhattan for this year's Pride parade. Michael Nigro But the party remained uninterrupted for the throngs of sanctioned participants as the parade snaked through Madison Square Park, down Fifth Avenue, through Greenwich Village and up Seventh Avenue — with rainbow flags and smiles flying from start to finish. 'I'm out here making sure our voices are loud and proud and heard. It's more important now than ever,' said 30-year-old Audacity Mansfield, who wore a 'Mr. Gay New Jersey' sash won at a pageant earlier this month. Advertisement 5 NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch (third from left) joins queer officers protesting after they were barred from marching in uniform. DANIEL WILLIAM MCKNIGHT 'If we don't have pride, then we don't really have anything,' Mansfield said. 'If we can't be proud of who we are or if we can't be proud of our community, what are we out here for?' This year's parade fell on the 10th anniversary of the legalization of gay marriage in the US and also commemorated the 1969 Stonewall riots — which helped spark the country's gay-rights movement — with the theme 'Rise Up: Pride in Protest.' But one part of the queer community that was left out of the festivities for the fifth year in a row were uniformed LGBTQ NYPD officers who were told by organizers they couldn't march in their blues. Advertisement 'We will not be erased,' read signs carried by cops watching from the sidelines, along with others reading, 'Let gay cops back into march,' and, 'Our uniform is our protest.' 5 Despite the NYPD controversy, the parade is filled with joy and smiles as people turn out in droves to celebrate. Stephen Yang NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch turned out to support the officers, calling the decision to bar them 'unbelievable.' 'It is an absolute disgrace,' Tisch said, saying it was ironic that a parade about inclusivity is keeping people out. 'These officers standing behind me who have been pillars of reform in the community for decades have been excluded and told they are not welcome to walk in the uniforms they wear.' Advertisement The ban was put in place in 2021 over ongoing anti-cop sentiment from the George Floyd protests the summer before. 5 This year's Pride parade was filled with the usual fare of glamour, glitter and colorful costumes. Michael Nigro Parade organizer Heritage Pride claims it doesn't want parade-marching officers carrying weapons, which they have to have on them as part of their uniform requirements. Scores of on-duty armed cops protect the parade-goers. Tisch called organizers' excuse 'nonsense' and characterized it as a 'publicity stunt.' 'Heritage of Pride knows full well that when officers wear their uniforms, those uniforms can be magnets,' she said. 'It is about personal safety for our officers and public safety that officers don their uniforms and carry their service weapons with them.' Downey said it was 'painful' to have to protest the parade — and that queer officers are among the most courageous members of the community. 'It's been painful for four years now,' he said. 'Telling folks that they can show up not as they are is not in the spirit of pride.' Advertisement 5 The parade marched down Fifth Avenue, cut across Greenwich village and then moved up Seventh Avenue. Getty Images 'Everyone standing behind me protests every day by going into the system that has historically was not for them. They go in and force change upon that system. They force that system to deal with that,' Downey added. Downey — echoing others — also said it was outrageous that the parade would ask the NYPD to keep the parade safe but wouldn't let officers march in uniform. Mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani stopped by the protest and greeted Tisch and some protesting cops — but was snubbed by at least two officers. Advertisement Mayor Eric Adams — who previously voiced support for GOAL's push to let officers march in uniform — joined the parade but was booed at times and given the middle finger as he walked. 'Eric Adams doesn't care about gay people!' a woman yelled, while others called him a 'Trump lover' and screamed, 'Mamdani for mayor.' Despite the controversy, Sunday's parade was the festive and positive celebration many wait all year and travel from across the world to attend. 'I'm just proud of the energy,' said paradegoer Paul Mcgrorety. 'I love seeing smiles and just the pridefulness of everyone here. It's awesome to be here.'
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
More NYC dogs mauled by other pooches without consequence as state bill to close legal loophole stalls: ‘Should not be happening'
City dogs continue to be mauled by other pooches without consequence because a state bill prompted by the horrific Penny the Chihuahua attack has stalled, animal activists say. Upper West Side resident Jennifer Busse told The Post a pit bull who was illegally off his leash mauled her tiny 13-year-old shih tzu-chihuahua mix Forrest in Riverside Park earlier this month — and that the NYPD said there are still no avenues in the criminal-justice system to punish the four-legged attacker's careless owner. 'Something needs to change,' Busse fumed. 4 Chihuahua mix Forrest was attacked by a vicious dog in Riverside Park on June 6 — but current laws prevent police from taking criminal action, owner Jennifer Busse told The Post. Courtesy of Jennifer Busse She said Forrest was sleeping in the grass at the Manhattan park June 6 when he was suddenly pounced on by the pit bull in front of her screaming terrified children, ages 6 and 8. Busse said her poor pooch lost vision in his right eye while being left with more than a dozen puncture wounds from the attack. Yet cops said their hands were tied, according to Busse. 4 Joe Columbus' pit bulls are accused of mauling Penny. Obtained by NY Post 4 Penny recovers at her owner's apartment after being attacked by two dogs on the Upper West Side last month. Gabriella Bass 'Due to current laws, harm or death to an animal caused by another animal is not a criminal matter,' an NYPD rep confirmed to The Post. The attack occurred just weeks after a similar incident involving Penny the Chihuahua on the Upper West Side made national headlines. The 16-pound Chihuahua was mauled by a pair of pit bulls near Columbus Avenue on May 3. The case prompted state Assemblywoman Jennifer Rajkumar last month to introduce a bill that seeks to allow owners to be potentially criminally charged for pet-on-pet injuries, as opposed to only facing a possible civil lawsuit. 'Pets are not property, they are family,' Rajkumar said at the time. But the legislation remains stalled in the Assembly's Agriculture Committee, although it's unclear exactly why. 4 Assemblywoman Jennifer Rajkumar proposed 'Penny's Law' in the state legislature last month. Stephen Yang The bill would make it possible to levy charges against careless owners, including 'cruelty to animals through negligent handling of a dog' and 'leaving the scene of an animal attack.' It would also impose harsher penalties for those who repeatedly violate city leash laws. The bill is named after Penny. 'This lack of accountability has permitted numerous dog owners to allow their pets to attack other dogs,' Rajkumar said last month. 'The same owners will allow the behavior repeatedly, often dismissing it as 'playing' or 'a dog being a dog.' ' Busse said, 'I totally understand that people who are homeless have [some of] these animals for companionship for protection. 'But at a certain point, this kind of situation is so unsafe for the community.'
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
Illegal NYC car meetups feature strippers, drugs and ear-splitting speaker systems driving residents nuts
They've heard just about enough of this. Ear-splitting, high-decibel street parties fueled by cars with booming sound systems are making life hell for residents from the Bronx to Brooklyn — as the massive automotive meetups are becoming an ever-more frequent nuisance. The unregulated revelries are often louder than planes landing at LaGuardia and feature drugs, booze, strippers and wet t-shirt contests, all within earshot of neighborhoods such as Maspeth in Queens, Greenpoint in Brooklyn and Throggs Neck in the Bronx, residents said. Advertisement 6 NYPD officers approaching a vehicle equipped with speakers in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. Alicia Vaichunas 'It sounds like a missile being launched at your home from all directions,' said Astoria resident Jay Cane, 40. 'You know it will be a long night when the windows are vibrating. Advertisement 'You shut your windows and turn on air conditioners and fans to drown out the noise, even in the winter,' the frustrated local said. The events, which got their start during the COVID-19 pandemic, often last all hours of the night, as sounds blast from gigantic car-mounted speakers referred to as 'kitipo' systems. Residents tormented by the noise of the illicit meetups — which can feature dozens of cars paying to participate — said the city and cops are having little luck cracking down on them. 'There's a sense we're being forgotten by the city because we have exhausted all the options it has provided, and we're losing hope,' Cane said. Advertisement 6 A Honda car in Maspeth, Queens with a speaker attached to the roof for a car meetup Ben Tifa John DiMario, co-owner of Village Chapels funeral home in Middle Village, said the ruckus could wake the dead. 'It booms off every surface in my house,' said DiMario, who lives in Maspeth. 'It's been going on for so long, and lately, it's starting earlier.' Alfredo Centola, co-founder of the nonprofit We Love Whitestone, said he and his family deal several times a week with intrusive noise from unlawful rendezvous in Willets Point and World's Fair Marina in Queens, as well as Ferry Point in The Bronx. Advertisement 'It's a constant and consistent boom, boom, boom overnight,' said Centola, 54. 'It's the most frustrating experience in the world.' 6 Fireworks getting set off at a car meetup in Ozone Park, Queens earlier this year. Instagram/shottbyzay._ Locals said the events' organizers assemble in Industrial Business Zones and 'mixed-use' areas that are abandoned at night. There have been large-scale meetups outside of Vaughn College in East Elmhurst, Queens, and Maspeth's UPS Customer Center, as well as on Randall's Island — within walking distance of NYPD parking. The gatherings also feature the illegal sale of 'nutcrackers,' a street cocktail made of alcohol and fruit punch, and 'endless pot smoking,' neighbors claim. In one case, there have been reports of roughly 10 cars equipped with roaring stereos, synchronized by Bluetooth, routinely gathering in Greenpoint underneath the Kosciuszko Bridge. 'There is noise three or four times a week when there aren't events in 'Under The K Bridge Park,' ' said Natalia Rzeszutek, 23, of eastern Greenpoint. 'It's mostly on weekends, but you have Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday nights where this has been a big issue,' too. In The Bronx, Friends of Ferry Point Park President Dorothea Poggi said these intolerable meetups frequently invade areas around the park, creating 'a hot spot for crime' where things sometimes turn violent. Advertisement 'People are making big money using the park and the streets as a venue; they aren't paying the overhead to host a party, but they charge hundreds of people admission,' Poggi said. 'There are drugs and alcohol; they've had strippers and wet t-shirt contests; there was even sex going on – it's crazy.' An upcoming expected epic meetup – touted as an 'outdoor music car show battle' – is planned for July 13 from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. in Jamaica, Queens. An online ticket-seller lists general admission as $25, while the cost for vendors is more than $535. 6 A fire set at a car meetup in Brooklyn. Instagram/shottbyzay._ Centola, Poggi and Rzeszutek are all members of the Facebook group 'That Annoying Bass Sound Throughout NYC,' which Cane created to share tips about the illegal noise compromising their comfort. Advertisement When meetups occur, page members request that people place 311 calls in the hope that their reports will be prioritized. 'The group was formed by fed-up residents who want to end the underground meetups,' Cane said. 'We're all waiting for legislation to address these illegal speakers.' 6 A car seen doing donuts at a Queens car meetup. Instagram/shottbyzay._ Alicia Vaichunas, deputy chief of staff for city Councilman Robert Holden and a candidate for city council herself, lives near a regular nuisance in Maspeth and is active in the Facebook group. She said a Maspeth woman who tried to confront the source of the noise was threatened with a baseball bat. Advertisement 'This happens at three or four Maspeth locations alone,' Vaichunas said. 'If the police chase them, they'll switch locations, and then we have to get the cops back out there again.' In March 2024, Holden introduced a bill that would have increased civil penalties for unreasonable noise from personal audio devices. He said there has been success in curbing parties in some parks but adds that the NYPD needs more power to mute the meetups. 6 An NYPD vehicle getting attacked at a Ozone Park meetup this year. Instagram/ksoostayoutside 'What we've been doing on the local level is trying to get the police to confiscate,' Holden said. 'I told police Commissioner Tisch that the local precincts cannot handle this; we need a special task force.' Advertisement The NYPD did not return Post requests for comment. Councilwoman Vickie Paladino, a member of Holden's Common-Sense Caucus, said a new law is needed to prevent illegal car stereos from hitting the streets. 'We proposed to make it illegal to operate a vehicle in New York State with a non-factory sound system installed which utilizes an external power supply,' Paladino said. 'This would make these cars impossible to register and inspect and subject them to impoundment if found in use.' Residents and officials hope that the NYPD's new Quality of Life Division, which launched Labor Day weekend, will help muffle the noise-causing car-speaker showdowns. 'I'd like to see the Quality of Life units roll out in Queens and The Bronx first to address illegal parties,' Cane said. 'Right now, it's a constant headache.'
