BEE is bringing South Africa's economy to its knees
BEE is bringing South Africa's economy to its knees – new report
A report released on June 12 by the Solidarity Research Institute (SRI) and the Free Market Foundation (FMF) has sent shockwaves through South Africa's political and economic landscape.
The report delivers a scathing critique of the country's Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) policy, asserting that it is causing substantial damage to the South African economy while enriching only a small, politically connected elite.
BEE was initially introduced as a transformative policy aimed at redressing the economic imbalances of apartheid by promoting greater inclusion of black South Africans in the economy.
However, the latest findings paint a different picture, highlighting a policy that is now burdening economic growth, exacerbating inequality, and stalling job creation.
According to the report, the annual compliance costs for BEE range from R145-billion to R290-billion, which represents between 2% and 4% of South Africa's Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
This enormous economic burden has resulted in an annual reduction of GDP growth by between 1.5% and 3%, with a concomitant loss of between 96 000 and 192 000 jobs each year.
Over the years, this has accumulated to about 3.8 million lost job opportunities for South Africans.
'This huge economic cost is not simply the result of negligence or the mere poor implementation of a plan. It is a deliberate government policy that causes it,' said Theuns du Buisson, economic researcher at the SRI and co-author of the report.
'It is irrelevant when someone then says the policy was introduced with good intentions. Today it serves as a mechanism to enrich the elite at the expense of our country's economy and especially at the expense of its poorest citizens.'
The report further outlines that while there has been some progress in terms of black ownership and skills development, these gains are heavily overshadowed by the adverse effects of BEE.
Among these are increased inequality, elite capture of policy benefits, and widespread economic stagnation.
'The policy places a particularly heavy burden on critical sectors such as mining and finance,' the report reads, 'and it deters foreign investment, encourages capital flight, and stifles technological progress.'
South Africa's economic position on the global stage has deteriorated markedly, falling behind other middle-income countries with which it was once comparable.
The report critiques the lack of focus and effectiveness in the implementation of BEE policies, which contrasts with more successful affirmative action or empowerment programmes abroad.
Du Buisson pointed to countries such as Brazil and the United States, which have begun to phase out similar race-based economic policies.
'Moreover, in other countries, affirmative action policies are precisely there to prevent discrimination, while in South Africa, they in fact make discrimination compulsory,' he noted.
'South Africa must now follow the path of other countries and get rid of it. BEE has become an instrument that benefits a small, politically connected elite and has long ago stopped being a policy that could empower a disadvantaged society.'
Connie Mulder, head of the SRI, emphasised the urgency of the situation: 'South Africa cannot afford to continue down this path. The data is clear. BEE, in its current form, is damaging the economy and hurting those it was meant to help. We need policies that promote real economic participation and growth without racial quotas that cripple progress.'
The call to action from the writers of the report is for policymakers to immediately abolish the current BEE framework and replace it with a policy that fosters inclusive growth without impeding the economy.
'We need an economic environment where all South Africans, regardless of race, have the opportunity to contribute and prosper,' Du Buisson said.
– Access the full report here: https://soli.online/5nn
Do you have more information about the story?
Please send us an email to bennittb@rekord.co.za or phone us on 083 625 4114.
For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East
For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok.
At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Stay in the know. Download the Caxton Local News Network App
Stay in the know. Download the Caxton Local News Network App here
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
17 minutes ago
- TimesLIVE
Even if DA leaves, the GNU would never collapse: Fikile Mbalula
ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula has issued a stern warning to the DA, saying if it proceeds with a motion of no confidence against President Cyril Ramaphosa it will signal the end of their relationship in the government of national unity (GNU). DA leader John Steenhuisen threatened to table the motion, citing Ramaphosa's alleged failure to act against corruption and wrongdoing within the ANC. This comes after Ramaphosa's recent axing of the DA's former deputy minister Andrew Whitfield, who allegedly undertook an unauthorised trip to the US. Briefing the media on the sidelines of the third day of the OR Tambo Regional Conference in the Eastern Cape on Sunday, Mbalula dismissed the DA's threats. 'If they propose a motion of no confidence, it means they're out of the GNU,' Mbalula said. 'We're behind the president and we are not moved by any threats, including ultimatums. Government is not run by ultimatums. They must learn to speak to us properly, not through ultimatums. You can't give an ultimatum to a person when you serve in his executive.' He said the DA is free to leave the GNU if it feels it doesn't serve its interests. 'They have a choice to leave if they feel the GNU doesn't serve them. We also have a choice to work with everyone for the interest of South Africans. It's not good for the economy that the DA wants to hold government to ransom, and when there are differences, they threaten to walk away. It's blackmail. You can't run a relationship on the basis of blackmail. You need to respect your partner. We are not respected. Every time there's a point of difference, they threaten to go.' The DA had issued Ramaphosa with a 48-hour ultimatum to act against corruption in his own ranks. After the ultimatum expired, Steenhuisen announced his party's withdrawal from the national dialogue with immediate effect. The DA also plans to vote against upcoming departmental budget votes for departments headed by corruption-accused ANC ministers. Mbalula defended Ramaphosa's decision to dismiss Whitfield. He stressed the ANC would not tolerate disrespect towards the president by deputy ministers. 'We are not married to the DA. We are in a coalition. We formed the coalition not because we are at their mercy but because we respected the outcome of the elections. That is why we have characterised this as a strategic setback. 'It is not a permanent feature. The GNU is not a melting pot. We did say there are 10 political parties in the GNU and the DA did not want this. I see why they did not want this as they wanted to squeeze us and put us in a corner, but we turned the tables around and put them in our own trap. Now they are in a deeper trap.' Mbalula also expressed confidence that the GNU would survive without the DA. 'Even if the DA leaves, the GNU would never collapse. Others will come in. They're knocking hard on the door and want to get in.'
The Citizen
38 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Cape Town continues to lead national house price growth
The South African residential property market continues to gain momentum, with Stats SA's latest Residential Property Price Index (RPPI) revealing a national annual house price inflation of 5,2% in January 2025 – up from a revised 5,1% in December 2024. On a month-to-month basis, house prices rose by 0,4%, signalling a strong start to the new year. According to the RPPI, the City of Cape Town was the primary driver of annual metropolitan inflation, recording an impressive 8,5% year-on-year increase, contributing 3,1 percentage points to the overall metropolitan inflation rate. In contrast, the City of Johannesburg recorded a modest 2,3% annual increase, contributing 0,5 percentage points. 'Cape Town's sustained growth reflects high buyer demand, particularly in the upper price brackets and coastal lifestyle segments,' says Adrian Goslett, regional director and CEO of RE/MAX of Southern Africa. Looking at the trends, some notable outliers include areas like Hout Bay, which has experienced a 49% increase in average sales prices compared to the pre-pandemic market in 2019, going from R3m in 2019 to R4.47m in 2025. Llandudno was a significant outlier, growing by 135% since 2019, from an average of R11.5m to a staggering R27m in 2025. Apart from the suburbs that are outperforming the national averages, Goslett expressed his optimism following the release of the latest property inflation figures and encourages both buyers and sellers to take advantage of the current market dynamics. 'The latest figures reinforce that South African real estate market is strengthening and prices are starting to rise. This steady yet encouraging rise in property prices suggests that buyers still have a window of opportunity to enter the market while prices remain comparatively accessible, ahead of any potential sharper increases later in the year,' Goslett notes. Whether you're a first-time buyer, investor, or seller, understanding the nuances of regional property trends is crucial. 'Each suburb will have its own unique trends, which is why it is helpful to partner with a local real estate professional for tailored insights to help you navigate this dynamic environment,' Goslett concludes. Issued by: Kayla Ferguson
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Here's how to manage household electricity usage as municipal tariff increases kick in
More electricity hikes are coming after municipalities received approval to go ahead with increases of up to 14%. Newly approved electricity hikes will come into effect tomorrow and will have households scratching their heads as to how much more they can limit their usage. The National Energy Regulator of South Africa (Nersa) approved tariff increases between 4 to 5 times higher than latest inflation figures for over 100 municipalities in recent weeks, placing strain on consumers across the country. Alarm over the increases was illustrated by Nersa's comment that a record number of objections and submissions by affected customers were received from individual households. High tariff increases Nersa approved an 11.32% increase in Eskom's wholesale prices to municipalities earlier this year, but these municipalities made individual applications for increases for their own customers. Metropolitan municipalities covering Johannesburg, Cape Town, Bloemfontein, Gqeberha and East London will have their electricity increase between 12.4% and 12.8% from 1 July. The City of Tshwane customers escaped with a 10.2% increase, while those in Ekurhuleni were slapped with a 13.4% increase. 2025 municipal electricity tariff hikes Municipality Increase Buffalo City 12.74% City of Cape Town 12.8%* City of eThekwini 12.72% City of Tshwane 10.20% City Power (Johannesburg) 12.41% Ekurhuleni Metropolitan 13.40% Mangaung Municipality 12.40% Nelson Mandela Bay 12.80% * Cape Town's increase is based on Nersa's approved 2024/25 tariffs. The City implemented a 4.5% higher increase in 2024, which is currently the subject of ongoing legal proceedings. Among the reasons Nersa used to justify limiting even higher increases were poor financial performance, mounting municipal debt and high energy losses, essentially preventing the results of mismanagement being passed onto the consumer. Winter pressure on bills Electricity bills are naturally higher in winter and these added costs could plunge households headfirst into a billing abyss. Standard Bank's LookSee home efficiency platform has continued to keep customers at the forefront of their thinking, understanding the strife facing everyday South Africans. 'We keep having to deal with these above inflation increases for what is an essential service. It is painful not to have access to electricity, but at this stage it is becoming an affordability issue,' said LookSee Executive Head Marc Du Plessis. To propel its drive to create eco-conscious electricity customers that prioritise savings, LookSee has formulated a two-pronged solution to change and monitor behaviour. 'Behaviour is all about habits and habits can be changed. They may be hard to break but it is possible to make a shift that has a fundamental impact on your pocket,' advises Du Plessis. He notes that there are two variable municipal charges that households can do something about — electricity and water — and by evaluating the usage of those, increases can be absorbed or even offset. Household savings a sought-after destination LookSee's newly launched Smart Save journey is a tool to help households better understand their energy efficiency and plan ways to close any previously unseen gaps. Freely available on the LookSee platform, the Smart Save journey cross-references in-depth geographical, electricity consumption standards and municipal information with a household's unique specifications to enable users to make accurate energy decisions. 'The Smart Save journey is a commitment to not only helping households save, but to giving them reliable information and insights into what their comparable costs are,' states Du Plessis. Coupled with the Energy Efficiency Score that measures how efficiently a household consumes electricity, each home can build their own energy profile. 'We really believe that by empowering households with knowledge and insights, they can then do more in their own homes to manage their monthly costs and put money back into their budget,' he explains.
