‘Honest belief' of consent to sex may no longer be a defence in rape cases
victim
had consented to sex may no longer be a
legal defence
in rape cases if proposals being considered by the
Government
become law.
The
Department of Justice
and the Office of the
Attorney General
are currently considering the proposal to significantly modify the State's consent laws.
The planned reform is at advanced stage, has the backing of the Law Reform Commission and is a key part of the Government's plan to take action on consent laws.
Under the proposal, an accused person could not be acquitted of rape if a court found that their belief that the alleged victim had consented was not an objectively reasonable belief.
READ MORE
Case law in the State indicates that an accused person could defend themselves from a rape charge by testifying that they honestly believed their accuser had consented to sex, even if that belief is not reasonable or rational.
In 2016, the Supreme Court found, in the case of The People (DPP) v C O'R, that an 'honest, though unreasonable, mistake that the woman was consenting is a defence to rape'. It added that the belief must be 'genuinely held' by the accused.
In 2017, the attorney general asked the Law Reform Commission to examine the issue. The 'honest belief' defence came under scrutiny as the Oireachtas was passing a 2017 law that clarified the circumstances under which a person could not legally consent to sex. These included when they were asleep, unconscious, incapacitated by drugs or alcohol, or consenting under the threat or use of force.
The Law Reform Commission advised a change of the law to clarify that an accused person commits the crime of rape if he 'does not reasonably believe' the alleged victim was consenting.
The Department of Justice is now progressing the planned reform with the Office of the Attorney General.
It is one of a number of reforms of the way the criminal justice system handles rape and sexual assault allegations, which is a focus for Government officials in the wake of a scoping inquiry into historic abuse in schools.
Last week, the Government
announced a commission of inquiry
into the handling of historic sexual abuse allegations in schools. Officials from a number of Government departments, who were tasked with writing a report on the recommendations of the
scoping inquiry
published last year, noted that the majority of survivors who detailed their experiences with the scoping inquiry 'had a negative, and in some cases, retraumatising, experience with the legal system'.
[
Officials resist schools abuse redress scheme
Opens in new window
]
In a report published last week, the interdepartmental group added that a negative experience with the legal system 'may influence survivors' perspectives on participating in a future process such as a commission of investigation'.
Survivors had called on the State to 'make the legal system more accessible and appropriate for victims of sexual crimes'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
40 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Man who recorded himself murdering his wife said he killed her after ‘freaking out', court hears
A father of two who recorded the moment he stabbed his wife to death told emergency responders he killed her after he 'freaked out', a court has heard. Stephen Mooney (53) was on Monday sentenced at the Central Criminal Court to life imprisonment for the murder of his wife Anna Mooney, née Shuplikova. Mooney pleaded guilty to his wife's murder earlier this year after gardaí accessed the contents of his phone and discovered video footage of the build-up to the murder and an audio recording of the murder itself. Outlining the evidence, Det Sgt Basil Grimes told the court how Mooney called emergency services at 1.09am on June 15th, 2023. He reported that a person had been stabbed at his home on Kilbarrack Road, Kilbarrack, Dublin 5, and when asked who did it he replied: 'I did.' READ MORE A Dublin Fire Brigade officer was first on the scene and found Mooney kneeling over his wife's lifeless body, speaking to emergency services on the phone. She had a knife lodged in her chest. The defendant told the paramedic: 'I've killed her ... She's my wife. This has been going on for years. I'm really sorry. She's been having an affair.' A garda who arrived a short time later took a note of Mooney saying: 'She's having an affair. It got out of control, I tried to save her. Everyone's lives are ruined.' He also said: 'It's awful. I'm sorry to put you through this. I saw something on her phone about sex and everything else and freaked out.' He later said: 'There is no suspect. I am the guilty one. There's nothing worth this.' Det Gda Jeanette O'Neill found blood pooling on a couch and blood spatter on the wall immediately behind it. Ms Mooney was lying on the kitchen floor when paramedics arrived. Pathologist Dr Sallyanne Collis said the stab wound to Ms Mooney's chest tracked to 13.3cm and pierced the heart, diaphragm and abdominal cavity. There were further stab wounds to her back and her upper arm and incised wounds to her hand and arm. The pathologist said death was caused by multiple sharp force injuries. Det Sgt Grimes said that, weeks before Mooney was due to go on trial, gardaí accessed his phone using updated software that can access content protected by a password. Analysis of the phone uncovered a 90-minute video clip that included footage of the murder, he said. He said Mooney could be seen leaving the room where the murder happened and returning with the weapon. The moment when Ms Mooney died happened off-camera, he said, but the audio recorded 'all events leading to her death'. Det Sgt Grimes said the video went quiet before Mr Mooney could be seen returning to the kitchen where he drank three glasses of water and ran water over his hands while making the 999 call. The detective said it appeared that Mooney himself set the phone to record in an elevated position with a view of the kitchen table. Detectives believed Mooney set it up that way to record his wife entering her pin number into her own phone, so he could use it to find out who she was contacting. The detective confirmed Mooney had worked as an estate agent and had no previous convictions. Under cross-examination, he agreed with Michael Bowman SC, defending, that Ms Mooney moved to Ireland from Ukraine in 2004 and the pair married in 2005. They have two children together. Det Sgt Grimes agreed the investigation confirmed Ms Mooney was having a relationship with a man in Germany. Her brother, Anton Shuplikova, listened to the proceedings from Ukraine using a video-link and an interpreter. Following the detective's evidence, Mooney took the stand to apologise to his wife's family. 'I am truly sorry for what happened that night,' he said. 'It is the burden I go to bed with every night and wake up with every day.' He also said: 'I wish to apologise to my kids for the terrible suffering I have caused everybody. I hope one day everybody will be able to forgive me,' he said. Mr Justice Paul McDermott imposed life imprisonment. He said he had no discretion in sentencing and Mooney's future would be determined by a parole board.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Married farmer to serve almost 10 years in jail for rape of another man
A married farmer from County Cork was sentenced on Monday to a total of 19 years in jail for raping another man twice, but he will serve less than ten years for just one of the offences. Thomas 'Tossy' Nyhan (60), of Crookstown, Co Cork, was sentenced to 11.5 years with the final year suspended, for raping the man, in April 2019. Nyhan, who has four children, received a second sentence of 8.5 years for raping the man, in January 2011. The rapes occurred at a location in Limerick, the court heard. READ MORE As both sentences are to run concurrent to each other, Nyhan will only serve part of the total. The sentences were backdated to June 23rd last when Nyhan first entered custody. He has no previous convictions. Nyhan had contested two counts of anal rape of the victim, but he was unanimously convicted by a jury of both rapes, following an 11-day trial, held at the Central Criminal Court, sitting in Limerick, last May. Ms Justice Mary Ellen Ring had previously lifted reporting restrictions allowing Nyhan be named. The judge also directed that the victim was entitled to his anonymity and ordered that he not be identified. The victim told the trial that the rapes were so painful they were like 'barbed wire' inside him. 'He (Nyhan) raped me twice. This was not a moment of confusion,' the victim said in an impact statement. 'It was cold, calculated and violent – he knew what he was doing – and eight years later he did it again." He said he disclosed the second rape to his GP in 2019, because, he said, he 'could not hold the weight of his abuse any longer'. Later he told Gardaí he had also been raped by Nyhan in 2011. 'He (Nyhan) is a rapist and that will follow him for the rest of his life and it should,' the man said. When questioned by Gardaí in May 2019, Nyhan accepted sexual activity had occurred between him and the victim, yet he denied raping him. During the trial, and under cross-examination by Nyhan's barrister, senior counsel Mark Nicholas, the victim agreed that he had remained in regular contact with Nyhan following the first rape in 2011. The victim described as 'lies' unfounded claims by Nyhan that he had asked the farmer for money for sex and that he had grabbed Nyhan's 'crotch' a number of times and removed his own clothes to have sex with Nyhan. The victim told Mr Nicholas: 'I told him (Nyhan) to stop, I didn't like it.' DNA swabs taken by forensic gardaí of a stain at the scene of the 2019 rape matched Nyhan's DNA profile. Nyhan's wife, Mary Nyhan, supported her husband to court every day of his trial and throughout the criminal proceedings. In mitigation, the judge took into consideration Nyhan's age, no previous convictions, health difficulties and that he has been a hard-working family man.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Teenager killed after car collided with truck in Co Cork
Gardaí have issued an appeal for witnesses after a teenager died in a two-vehicle collision on the N71 in Co Cork this morning. The incident involving a car and a truck occurred at 7.15am on the N71 between Ballinhassig and Innishannon, south-west of Cork city. The male driver of the car, who was in his late teens, was pronounced dead at the scene. The road was closed on Monday afternoon to facilitate a technical examination by Garda Forensic Collision Investigators. Local diversions were in place. Gardaí are appealing to members of the public who may have witnessed the collision to contact them. Any road users with footage, including dash-cam footage, who were travelling in the area between 7am and 7.30am are asked to make this footage available to investigating officers. READ MORE Anyone with information is asked to contact Bandon Garda Station on (023) 8852200, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda Station. The death is the 93rd on Irish roads so far in 2025, and the 35th involving the driver of a car.
